Author Topic: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao  (Read 6921 times)

Grey

  • Warrant Officer
  • *
  • Posts: 534
Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« on: 18 May 2015, 13:01:12 »
Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
Who: Sun-Tzu Liao
What: Chancellor of the Capellan Confederation
   First Lord of the Star League
   Celestial Wisdom
When: 3031 - 3113
Weapon of Choice: Politics
         Intelligence
         Intrigue
         EMP-6A Emperor

The third Capellan Chancellor prominent in fiction, the longest featured in fiction, Sun-Tzu is certainly the most influential Chancellor since the Star League, if not ever. His accomplishments, his impact in the Battletech universe, are going to reverberate for a long time.

As a Chancellor Sun-Tzu breaks the mould we’re used to. Though still a dictator, as all the Successor Lords ultimately are, he is not as great a terror to his own people as he is those of enemy states, though his initial public moves were misleading.

Now all but forgotten is that early in his reign Sun-Tzu Liao fostered the image that he was incompetent so as to get others to underestimate him. This lasted until his first grand moves to retake the Sarna March.

As a Liao Sun-Tzu upholds the traditional form of being cunning and ruthless, he is as intelligent as his grandfather and as capricious as either of his predecessors, showing a profound flexibility in his planning. Furthermore he is not overtly insane, the trait all Liaos are tarred and feathered with thanks to the majority of fiction feature Chancellor Liaos.

By his own admission he is slightly paranoid, though given the environment he was raised in this is less a mental illness and more of a survival trait. Nonetheless it sticks with him and he copies his mother’s tactics of putting allies within his own government at subtle odds against each other as a hedge against potential betrayal.

Sun-Tzu is also rather obsessive. Again this may not be a mental illness in the strictest sense, as the object of his obsession is the desire to re-establish the Capellan Confederation as a strong nation, beholden to no one, and reclaiming its former borders.

That last one is a bit tricky, Sun-Tzu focuses on what was lost in the Fourth Succession War, which principally means the Chaos March and St Ives Compact, leading to a two front war. When told, quite sensibly, by then fiancé Isis Marek that he should consolidate and focus his forces on one objective at a time he snaps, berates her, reveals quite a bit of his personal motivation and then breaks off their very long running engagement.

This would probably only have been the proverbial straw breaking the camel’s back, the engagement by that point was ridiculous, any gains from marrying Isis were long gone and largely limited to giving Hanse Davion a heart attack and far more limited assistance in assaulting the Sarna March than Sun-Tzu would have liked. But that was Isis.

Naomi Centrella, his eventual wife, was a different story. Though from a Periphery nation she shared a similar outlook to that of Sun-Tzu and was far more a partner. This shows up principally in how the Trinity Alliance plays out, the Taurians are cannon fodder, the Canopians are far more equal, even allowed to withdraw with little animosity at one point causing the Taurians to further commit themselves on Capellan fronts.

Did Sun-Tzu love either woman? Doubtful. He certainly considered both useful, but only Naomi did he respect. Love is not something Sun-Tzu would allow himself. This is another key difference between himself and his predecessors. Max was all about Max, Romano was self-indulgent in her games and manipulations, Sun-Tzu is largely anhedonic. Small pleasures he allows himself, yes, but everything is working towards those goals.

Remember when I said re-establishing the Confederation’s former borders was interesting? While the pre-Fourth Succession War boundaries were the immediate goal, and never achieved thanks to the Chaos March, the Blake Protectorate, the Jihad and the Republic of the Sphere, had he managed to achieve those it’s worth considering if he would have gone further. Sun-Tzu was never one to hold back, and the nation would be riding high on a string of military victories, and it feeds into the obsession. Alas we have no real indications, though it would have revealed much about his character.

For one thing it would have fed into his role as an antagonist to, well, pretty much everyone. Sun-Tzu entered into only useful alliances and discarded them once they had served his purposes. The Canopian alliance is the only long term one because, as his marriage shows, there was a strong partnership and mutual respect at play. Everyone was to be used or fought.

This is also the traditional role of Capellan Chancellors, if not Liaos in general. Cunning, ruthless, manipulative, all with goals of conquest, they make perfect antagonists.

Of course as mentioned Sun-Tzu’s goals of conquest aren’t simply those of a warmonger or wannabe First Lord.

Funnily enough he was the First Lord, and used that position for all it was worth to the betterment of the Confederation, creating a military and political situation that gave him casus belli for going to war with St Ives.

He cared nothing for the position beyond what use it could be, but it is the pinnacle of his political skills and far from his only political move, this sort of thing further marks him as an antagonist in the Battletech setting.

This is further cemented by the few times he attempts actual military action in person. While minimally trained in the military arts, thanks to his mother’s paranoia about her heir, he shows outright incompetence on Outreach while training with other up and coming nobles, self-sabotaging all attempts to reach out to him, further isolating himself and the Confederation, reinforcing the perception that the Confederation was a weak, self-destructive nation. His first in fiction political move.

At that time he piloted a stereotypical Capellan machine, a Cataphract, and later ejected from a perfectly serviceable Dire Wolf in a rare miscalculation to make cousin Kai Allard-Liao look bad.

During actual military action Sun-Tzu pilots an Emperor, gold plated of course. As one of the most powerful assault designs that could be called Capellan at the time it was perfect for him. Though in actuality given the name he could never pilot anything else. And in this he proves to be at least competent, though he would on occasion have a Death Commando pilot in his stead because Sun-Tzu is not stupid and knows full well what his falling in battle would represent.

Nonetheless that is what he chooses in the end, precisely because of what it represents at that point, the elevation of himself from a mere Chancellor with a cult following into a legend that would power the Capellan people for generations.

I won’t delve further into his death, it’s a rich source of debate and conspiracy theory, and that’s just how Sun-Tzu would have wanted it. And from a writing point of view it makes sense as it furthers the legend, ambiguity always serves that purpose.

The fact is as far as anyone can prove Chancellor Sun-Tzu Liao died in combat fighting a foe holding traditional Capellan worlds, ostensibly rising to heaven because there was no body.

And that is his legacy, as much as the Capellan people have been revitalised and empowered by his efforts Sun-Tzu is a legend on par with Shiro Kurita, Aleksandr Kerensky or Jerome Blake.

It’s an interesting fate because the cult of personality that formed around him was a side effect of his efforts, not a deliberate act. For you see Sun-Tzu was not infallible, Operation Guerrero proves that, he utterly miscalculated how far Thomas Marik would go in prosecuting his part in the war, did not foresee the Chaos March develop, and was later foiled by his own obsession as mentioned earlier.

Daoshen may yet be considered another. While their relationship devolved in a manner similar to Takashi and Theodore Kurita in that both relationships were coloured by successor paranoia it’s clear that Daoshen is a return to the self-centred Liao stereotype that Sun-Tzu knew nearly brought the nation down, even while his son was competent and absorbed Sun-Tzu’s dedication to the nation.

All things considered it’s hard to call these miscalculations in the strictest sense but still represents something that isn’t in Sun-Tzu’s control.

Likewise the Black May attacks, though in all fairness not even God knows what Kali Liao is going to do at any given time.

These are probably his greatest set back, they are a terrorist attack on such a scale that he knows it courts retribution beyond that of St Ives and it’s currently dubious ally the Federated Commonwealth.

He reprioritises military assets, cooperates with former foes and gives up his sister to avoid annihilation since no decent nation can let him get away with gassing what he claims are his own people.

It barely works out well because Kali is so obviously mind bogglingly insane and out of control, and he is thankful for it, even though it turns his war with St Ives into a quagmire.

This means that he is at the mercy of events, something more frequently associated with protagonists, which he is for two novels. This muddies Sun-Tzu’s overall role, and humanises him considerably, and the Confederation by extension.

While far from a perfect protagonist we can no longer see him as just another villainous Capellan out to take whatever he can, and this characterisation carries over into the Jihad era. Remember, though the Confederation pulls out of the Star League first Sun-Tzu makes no aggressive actions until George Hasek acts first.

Thus, while he starts out as a stereotypical continuation of a theme and winds up a legend Sun-Tzu is the first fully realised and fleshed out Chancellor of the Capellan Confederation, providing a traditionally antagonistic faction with a hero and an icon counter to what has come before, enriching the faction and indeed the setting as a whole.

Giovanni Blasini

  • Lieutenant Colonel
  • *
  • Posts: 7164
  • And I think it's gonna be a long, long time...
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #1 on: 18 May 2015, 17:03:48 »
Wait, I thought they made him a popsicle after he died and he was put on public display a la Lenin.
"Does anyone know where the love of God goes / When the waves turn the minutes to hours?"
-- Gordon Lightfoot, "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald"

iamfanboy

  • Captain
  • *
  • Posts: 1980
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #2 on: 18 May 2015, 17:49:55 »
Your statement that Sun-Tzu really is almost a protagonist, rather than antagonist, is true in my eyes - he's probably one of Stackpole's least, uhh... well, Stackpole does have a habit of making characters either completely noble or completely evil, but Sun-Tzu is the character which breaks that mold.

Compare him to his three 'contemporary' character protagonists (Victor Steiner-Davion, Kai Allard-Liao, and Phelan Kell/Ward), and you see that he has valid arcs, goals, obstacles, and ultimately succeeds over them. If one were inclined, one could take all the snippets from the various novels about him and combine it into a single novel covering his life and it would be highly entertaining - might require some bridgework, but it would be decent by BT standards.

mikecj

  • Major
  • *
  • Posts: 3261
  • Veteran of Galahad 3028
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #3 on: 18 May 2015, 20:45:25 »
Great article, thanks
There are no fish in my pond.
"First, one brief announcement. I just want to mention, for those who have asked, that absolutely nothing what so ever happened today in sector 83x9x12. I repeat, nothing happened. Please remain calm." Susan Ivanova
"Solve a man's problems with violence, help him for a day. Teach a man to solve his problems with violence, help him for a lifetime." - Belkar Bitterleaf
Romo Lampkin could have gotten Stefan Amaris off with a warning.

JadedFalcon

  • Lieutenant
  • *
  • Posts: 868
  • Wins at Battleteching
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #4 on: 18 May 2015, 23:30:10 »
Your statement that Sun-Tzu really is almost a protagonist, rather than antagonist, is true in my eyes - he's probably one of Stackpole's least, uhh... well, Stackpole does have a habit of making characters either completely noble or completely evil, but Sun-Tzu is the character which breaks that mold.

Compare him to his three 'contemporary' character protagonists (Victor Steiner-Davion, Kai Allard-Liao, and Phelan Kell/Ward), and you see that he has valid arcs, goals, obstacles, and ultimately succeeds over them. If one were inclined, one could take all the snippets from the various novels about him and combine it into a single novel covering his life and it would be highly entertaining - might require some bridgework, but it would be decent by BT standards.

You bring up a good point of Sun-Tzu being closer to an antihero archetype than his contemporary protagonists. He wasn't trying to save the Inner Sphere, just the Capellan Confederation. Even at the expense (or maybe especially at the expense) of other nations. He used the 2nd Star League to strengthen his own realm instead of anything overly-idealistic. When he got engaged to Isis, he didn't tour the FWL and set up shop in Atreus, to paint himself more Mariky with the aim of becoming Chancellor-General of the Free Words Confederation. He stuck to making the Capellan Confederation better than when he started. Too bad he didn't make progress on the Chesterton worlds, though.  ;)

[...] any gains from marrying Isis were long gone and largely limited to giving Hanse Davion a heart attack and far more limited assistance in assaulting the Sarna March than Sun-Tzu would have liked. But that was Isis.

His decade-long engagement did bring about strong economic ties to the FWL, seeing a lot of technology entering the Confederation, not to mention an effective cease-fire. With one enemy distracted by the Clan invasion and the other sending military hardware as sales instead of raids, it was a good time to rebuild. If nothing else, the whole affair was good business for both Sun-Tzu and Not-Thomas, and didn't start to unravel until the mid-3060s.

It could also be argued that Hanse dying set the stage for the destruction of the FedCom alliance, and it fits with Sun-Tzu's style to see one of his most effective weapons be a wedding announcement letter. And there wasn't anything more than canon-rumor that Hanse was Sun-Tzu's biological father, or was that proven? I seem to remember something from Jihad Secrets or Conspiracies.

This recent series has been an interesting read. Thanks for writing, Grey.

jklantern

  • LAM of Shame
  • Major
  • *
  • Posts: 3409
  • Designated Snack Officer of the Diamond Khanate
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #5 on: 18 May 2015, 23:39:36 »
I think it was the novel "Double Blind" which has his first meetings with Naomi Centrella.  Those were actually some of the most interesting parts of the novel for me.  While we do see his PoV during conversations with her, and he is plotting and scheming as he is talking to her, he is not plotting and scheming ABOUT her.  As I recall, it doesn't even occur to him that, "This woman who is politically important is being friendly with me, how can I use that to my advantage?"  Granted, I'm not an expert in the character of STL, despite him being one of my favorite Successor Lords, but this might be the closest thing to a friendly human relationship that he has, and when I read "Double Blind" it felt very "Pet the Dog."
I'm not sure how long you've been around on the forums, though you have a thousand posts. Never take anything JKlantern says seriously unless it's about food.

Kidd

  • Major
  • *
  • Posts: 3535
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #6 on: 19 May 2015, 02:25:54 »
The Method to the Madness. I like that, and wish Daoshen was better (or better fleshed out at any rate). Still prefer the Draconis Combine though; the CC is quite clearly the Commies while the DC represents the remaining Asians (Japanese, Arabs and INdians).

Frabby

  • Major
  • *
  • Posts: 4252
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #7 on: 19 May 2015, 03:51:57 »
Good writeup Gray.

As you may have gathered by now, I also like to look at the meta-plot and game developer side of major characters. And Sun-Tzu Liao is one of the more interesting characters from that perspective.

House Liao played no role in the Clan Invasion era, still being the curbstomped ruin of a state from the previous era and not being in the invasion corridor. (Sidenote: Why they introduced the FRR just before the Clan Invasion only to kill it off once the invasion started is another development curiosity... rumor has it the Clans were initially supposed to invade from the Kurita/Davion border via the Outworlds Alliance.) Stackpole paraded the next generation of BT characters before the reader in Lethal Heritage and Sun Tzu, the Liao heir, had no particular role because he was not slated to become a character in the trilogy. So, in the tradition of ridiculing House Liao, he was portrayed as an incompetent idiot to make Kai Allard-Liao shine.

It was apparently much later that House Liao was "reactivated" by the writers, if only in conjunction with the equally neglected House Marik to serve as a foil for Victor Steiner-Davion. The Joshua gambit is one of the less brilliant moments in BT history but it was the catalyst for the breakup of the FedCom, precipitating the FedCom Civil War and creating the Chaos March which even got its own sourcebook and was apparently planned to become the writers' sandbox - which then wasn't used. (You could also ask what the Chaos March was needed for, storytelling wise, when you already had the chaotic Free Worlds League. But I digress.)

With Houses Liao and Marik recuperating and the Star League lordship somehow falling on Sun Tzu's shoulders, he naturally couldn't be the clueless fop he'd been portrayed as. So it was apparently retconned as a clever disguise; I seriously doubt that Stackpole had anything else in mind for Sun Tzu than exactly how he wrote him initially.
And then Xin Sheng happened. Meta-plot wise, this turned the CapCon around from everybody's punching ball to an up-and-coming superpower that players could (and would) root for. It's a bit like the early evolution of House Kurita: Initially described as aliend-minded xenophobic mass murderers, they get real depth from the Charette novels to the point where they former bad guys had become fan favorites. That initially left only House Liao as antagonists, though more in a black comic relief style and not the "killing you on principle" hostility of the Draconis Combine. Now, with Xin Sheng, Sun Tzu and all the new toys, suddenly the CapCon became en vogue with the fans. The black hat was passed on to the Word of Blake.

In summary, Sun Tzu evolved from a superflous fifth wheel among the next generation characters into a deus-ex-machina tool to explain the CapCon's phenomenal recovery. And in a way he even overshot the target, by actually becoming First Lord of a reformed Star League, and then all his grandfather and mother had ever wanted really only played second fiddle to reinvigorating the CapCon - in achieving their goal, Sun Tzu also proved that they had in fact pursued the wrong goal all along.

As a character, or even a protagonist, Sun Tzu comes across as painfully intelligent and insightful but emotionally bland. He's like a super computer more than a person. Perhaps something like Asperger's Syndrome.
Just look at the end of Highlander Gambit where he elects to let Loren Jaffray live... not because he sympathizes with the untenable position he himself has put him into, but because Jaffray's failure to carry out his orders to the end was actually a calculated course of events on Sun Tzu's behalf and because he had served his purpose. Sun Tzu let him live because he couldn't be bothered to have him killed - it wouldn't have furthered his goals so wasn't worth the bullet.
Sarna.net BattleTechWiki Admin
Author of the BattleCorps stories Feather vs. Mountain, Rise and Shine, Proprietary, Trial of Faith & scenario Twins

Grey

  • Warrant Officer
  • *
  • Posts: 534
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #8 on: 19 May 2015, 05:14:44 »
I think Sun-Tzu the protagonist is less a doing of Stackpole's and more of Coleman, where he is most fully fleshed out.

In all fairness Stackpole did start it, during the Blood of Kerensky Trilogy he had Sun-Tzu acting the fool and revealing his actual intelligence, and other authors have built on that since.

But I think the Capellan Solutions series presents Sun-Tzu in a fairly favourable light, or at least a very well balanced one. At any rate making him much more developed than most characters.

That's some good insight Frabby, the Clan Invasion had the side effect of rendering the Mariks and Liaos as somewhat irrelevant to the major events of the time since they were on the opposite side of space from the big, new, exciting action. Sun-Tzu became a means for making the Confederation one of the more relevant powers in catalysing events for the next century.

iamfanboy

  • Captain
  • *
  • Posts: 1980
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #9 on: 19 May 2015, 13:08:00 »
Credit where credit is due, guys: There are at least three scenes at least in Blood of Kerensky where STL show's he's sharp. Where Romano gloats over assassinating Candace and Justin (and STL tries to figure how Hanse will take his vengeance on their already-wrecked nation), where Candace talks to STL after killing Romano, and the final one, where it's implied that Hanse's fatal heart attack was caused by STL's private message announcing his engagement to Isis. Isn't there another one, where he's sitting at Justin's old desk in the Maskirovka?

I know it's hard to give Stackpole credit sometimes, but seriously fellas, he did establish STL. It's possible that he was given STL's character as a meta order leading to the second Star League, but all the books set in the series really set up the Civil War; the Refusal War and Operation Guerrero is very sudden shift.

nerd

  • Captain
  • *
  • Posts: 2321
  • Nunc Partus-Ready Now
    • Traveller Adventures
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #10 on: 19 May 2015, 16:19:53 »
Sun-Tzu was a well written character.

He played the child of Romano role perfectly at Outreach getting Hohiro and Victor to actually work together, but starting in Lost Destiny when we had scenes from his POV, he became a much more dangerous character. He was a sane man in a dangerous court, and was able to run the best surprise strategy of a 'known factor' since Aramis, while keeping his throne. He was an example of what a Successor Lord should be, an excellent player of the Great Game. The only problem I have is my main issue with most of the 3050's Lords save Theodore and Thomas: not having a ready heir until relatively late in life.

Was it a problem he was only a fair MechWarrior? No. While being one is part and parcel of Inner Sphere Nobility, it does show where his true talents lay.

He does tend to steal the scene when he has the chance.
M. T. Thompson
Don of the Starslayer Mafia
Member of the AFFS High Command

Intermittent_Coherence

  • Lieutenant
  • *
  • Posts: 1165
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #11 on: 21 May 2015, 04:28:25 »
IIRC he was elected Chancellor because he was perceived to be the least harm in that role compared to the other House Lords. Him being the ruler of a gutted ruin of a state that he was.

Also he had a paranoid fear of going as bugnuts insane as his grandfather, mother and sister. A valid paranoid fear IMHO.

Grey

  • Warrant Officer
  • *
  • Posts: 534
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #12 on: 21 May 2015, 17:57:56 »
If you mean First Lord, he was a compromise candidate for a number of reasons, including as you point out his perceived harmlessness.

Victor and Katherine were too polarising, none of the minor states had strong enough candidates at the time (Christian Mansdottor's election was another compromise coupled with a lack of viable alternatives), Thomas was seen as too close to the Word of Blake and while that wasn't damning at the time it made people uncomfortable and I think Theodore was sidelined due to Katherine's political machinations.

Sun-Tzu seemed like the safe option for a largely ceremonial position in what was probably the last time anyone underestimated Sun-Tzu's intelligence. He still outsmarted most people but that was because he was cunning and unpredictable, not because no one thought he was a soft idiot.

And yes, considering the family leading up to Sun-Tzu, descending from Sun-Tzu and standing next to Sun-Tzu I don't think anyone had a more legitimate fear.

Psyckosama

  • Warrant Officer
  • *
  • Posts: 545
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #13 on: 16 June 2015, 10:33:13 »
He's my least favorite character in all of Battletech.

Jackmc

  • Captain
  • *
  • Posts: 2681
    • How I pay the bills
Re: Character Study of the Week: Sun-Tzu Liao
« Reply #14 on: 22 June 2015, 01:48:45 »
To me, the only real difference between him and the typical Chancellor is that rather than being batshit insane, he's fleshed out to the point that you have no doubt that he's a sociopath who lucked into a position of power.  That actually lowers him in my book.  A batshit crazy villain is enjoyable as a buffoon, where as sociopaths tend to just come across as ******.

-Jackmc