BattleTech - The Board Game of Armored Combat

BattleTech Player Boards => Fan Articles => Topic started by: Dakkagor on 31 August 2017, 17:21:07

Title: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Dakkagor on 31 August 2017, 17:21:07
So, the mighty Devastator . . .

(http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/warhammer40k/images/a/a6/Devastator_Squad.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20160404115540)

No, not that one.

(https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/8c/42/c5/8c42c51af7902e8328b99145e12f5725.jpg)

Not that one either!

(https://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/transformers/images/0/0e/G1-devastator-ongoing.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/310?cb=20161205230508)

I mean, he's cool but he's not who we are after either. . .

(http://orig04.deviantart.net/1b80/f/2010/316/e/b/mech_warrior___devastator_by_shimmering_sword-d32q1rr.jpg)

Yeah, that's the ticket. . .

Picture the scene:  Terra burns, Amaris and his Rim World Republican Guard are fighting for survival against a vengeful Star League, and from out of the smoke of the battlefield, titans of war stride, the ultimate assault lance.

At their head, a solid wedge of armour bearing two AC-20 Autocannons, designed to slay opposing mechs as quickly as possible.  The indomitable King Crab shoulders through the enemies heaviest fire and guts mechs in one massive salvo.  Following behind, standing tall and shrouded in smoke like a pair of grim reapers, come the Atlas II’s.  Any mech opened up by the King Crab gets shredded by missiles, LBX-pellets and burned down by lasers.  Finally, standing on the ridge line behind, laying down a hail of murderous long range gauss and PPC fire, the Devastator stands watch.  Four hundred tons of fusion powered death machine, all designed by or designed for Aleksandr Kerensky.

Its just a damn shame it probably never happened.  The Devastator, the last of Kerensky’s trifecta of Assault Mechs, only saw a desperate limited production run in the lead up to the assault on Terra, with six being produced and deployed.  After that, the design is lost to the Inner Sphere until the Fed Suns trip over its schematics on Hoff in 3023.  A low-tech monkey copy was produced and put into production in 3036 after being prototyped by NAIS, and it would take a further twelve years for the full DVS-2 to return to the fields of the Inner Sphere in the arsenal of the Fed-com alliance, and it would soldier on in both the Davion and Lyran halves of the Alliance, and Republic Space, right into the Dark Ages.

The Devastator is a simple, murderous machine.  A hundred tons, it uses a Vlar 300 XL to propel it to the blistering speeds of 54 KM/H.  The engine supports 14 double heat sinks, and its Star League XT frame carries 18.5 tons of Durallex heavy armour, near maximum for frame.  Every forward location takes at least two gauss rifle hits to claw open barring the head, its legs take two AC20s to strip and the centre torso takes that and a large laser to inflict your first critical chance.  Its rear locations are well protected, with protection enough to keep out an AC-10 or IS PPC on each rear torso, with a shred of armour left on the rear centre torso.

Weapons wise, the DVS-2 uses a pair of Poland Main Model A Gauss Rifles, one to each arm.  Each gun has a dedicated bin feeding it in the arm, and a cross-fed bin in each side torso for decent ammunition endurance.  This is combined with a pair of Donal PPCs in each torso, and four intek medium lasers, one in the head, one in each torso location (the centre one points backwards, pointlessly.)  This weapon arrangement helps protect the vulnerable XL engine, keeping Gauss explosions somewhat contained, so if some lucky devil crits out the gauss rifles, its unlikely to kill the mech.  Thanks to the locations of the PPC’s and heat sinks that extrude out of the engine, the XL engine is well packed against criticals.
This variant is about as optimally designed for an Inner Sphere assault mech as you can get.  The only flaw seems to be the range brackets of the PPC’s not quite matching up with the Gauss Rifles.  ER PPC’s would make it easier to use, improving the designs overall range, but screw with the heat curve, which is currently gloriously easy to manage.  A Stalker this ain’t.

The DVS-1D is the monkey tech variant pushed out in 3036.  With a standard engine, it has to save a lot of weight.  It strips out the heavy weapons and replaces them with a pair of AC10 and a pair of large lasers.  This is a vicious combo for a Succession War era assault machine.  It gains an extra heat sink, but its a single, so its heat curve is ruined.  It also only loses a half ton of armour over the original variant. 
With its matched up range brackets, and solid secondary battery, this mech has only a single flaw: Heat!  A standing ranged strike with the four big hitters generates a six point heat spike.  You have to drop the large lasers every other salvo to keep the heat under control, or pick your moments for an alpha very carefully.  This variant completely disappears from Davion space by 3060, surviving only in the Taurian Concordat. 

The DVS-3 is pretty much a standardized field refit for the DVS-2.  It strips medium lasers for armour and more gauss rifle ammo.  Apparently it is intended for long term operations, and gains an additional two tons of gauss ammo and a half ton of armour.  The only secondary weapons remaining are a rear facing small laser and a rear facing medium, both in the centre torso.  No, I don’t know why either.

We have an experimental tech variant debuting in 3075, the Devastator MUSE EARTH.  This is jammed with experimental gubbins.  Built on endo-composite frame and with a compact gyro, the engine has been upgraded to a 400 XXL engine, combined with MASC and a super charger, allowing this 100 ton machine it to nearly hit 100 KM/H, which is nuts.  For weapons its packs a pair of medium Variable Speed Pulse lasers, and for long range poke it carries a pair of Heavy PPC’s, each mated to a PPC capacitor, allowing it to dish out serious hurt at medium range if you are willing to risk a big heat spike.   Finally, the entire mech is coated in 19.5 tons of reactive armour, which provides superb protection against missiles, artillery and mortars, as well as screwing with AC armour piercing rounds, mech tasers and tandem charge rounds.  Seeing this thing accelerate towards you faster than most cavalry mechs, exploding under fire and not giving a single flip, is probably a pant wetting experience for most pilots.

Finally, a production model of the MUSE EARTH, the DVS-10 uses an XL engine and a suite of re-engineered lasers.  This variant is found in readout 3150, and doesn’t yet have a control sheet printed as far as I can tell.

The Devastator is easy to use in most configurations: find your range, find some good cover, and lay down the pain.  The MUSE EARTH and its production model are different, providing horrid speed and blistering take down power, which on a 100 ton frame is exceptional.  Of the three mainline variants, the base is undoubtedly my favourite, followed by the Succession War era DVS-1D, which is just a nasty bit of kit for period and would require very little tinkering to make usable in the modern era.   

Fighting one is not easy: Shoot it till it dies.  All of them apart from the DVS-1D have zombie characteristics, with no explosive criticals apart from the Gauss Rifles, but they all mount an XL engine in a pair of (relatively) thinly armoured side torso bays.  If you can rip open a side torso a salvo of missiles or cluster rounds can put one down for the count and leave you some premium salvage.  The MUSE EARTH is a different kettle of fish, you will need to use lasers or PPC’s to chew through its armour, as it can shrug of long range barrages of missiles.  Thankfully, its probably going to charge right at you to get optimum range for its PPC’s, so you should get a turn or two of close range fire as it closes to kill.   The reactive armour and XXL engine makes it very vulnerable to criticals, so if you can dig past its fancy armour you can hope to get lucky and watch the armour fall of in a chain reaction.

The Devastator is a great machine, and arguably stands at the apogee of what can be achieved with Star League technology: maximum damage and direct fire range mated to the toughest chassis available.   I've used them in a few games as I have a terrible weakness for assault mechs, and I've always found them to be a demanding presence that cannot be ignored.

You can find a selection of excellently painted Devastators on Camospecs:
http://camospecs.com/Search/Index?Term=devastator (http://camospecs.com/Search/Index?Term=devastator) 

And further information on its deployment and availability on the MUL:

http://masterunitlist.info/Unit/Filter?Name=Devastator (http://masterunitlist.info/Unit/Filter?Name=Devastator)     
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Kidd on 31 August 2017, 18:35:27
Excellent writeup of an excellent machine. The Devastator truly lives up to its name and never fails to be an MVP when deployed in any of my games. Pilot motto: Stand and Deliver!
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: THUD on 31 August 2017, 18:55:08
IMHO one of the best darn mechs in the whole game.

In the last game I used one it took a clan ppc to the head in round 1.  I lost a few turns later. :-\
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 31 August 2017, 20:28:05
I love this thing.  I wish the Taurian Concordat was able shoe horn double heat sinks into the 1D model since i love the idea of a AC/10 packing variant.

Hope we won't be waiting a while to get record sheets for 3150's new tech section. I'd like see what else the 10D has.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Demon55 on 31 August 2017, 20:51:13
IMHO one of the best darn mechs in the whole game.

In the last game I used one it took a clan ppc to the head in round 1.  I lost a few turns later. :-\

Some times Murphy comes. 

2 Gauss Rifles, 2 PPCs and 4 medium lasers is a great set of weapons.  I generally do not like IS XL engines but they have their place.

The Devastator is a beast and so is the Pillager.  Although I would rather have the Pillager since it has jump jets. 
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Mattlov on 31 August 2017, 21:39:39
A great 'Mech, another of the Gauss monsters from 3058 (Nightstar, Pillager, and Thunder Hawk), this is one I don't field often.  When they show up in my games, they have TERRIBLE luck, and that stains my view of them.  The long range punch is solid, the best of the 4, on paper it should be a 'Mech I love.

But that bad luck streak has been around for a long time, and I don't trust them.  :)
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 31 August 2017, 23:41:08
I always wanted to run one for campaign reasons, especially like Wendy Sylvester in the Guards during Operation Bulldog.  IMO its the ideal Clan fighter for when they can slug it out understanding you are giving up some range with regular PPCs and slower.  Wonder if it got much action in Op Sovereign Justice or the SIC conquest from FedCom units, because facing Pillagers or Liao stealth designs would be different.

I would have liked to see the latest Davion Devastator using the Clan ER lasers they put on the Black Knights, maybe REs for in close?

I have not played with one often, or maybe even not at all.  I also wonder how the mini is?
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: William J. Pennington on 31 August 2017, 23:53:22
Glorious. You just have to love it. A cornerstone for my Crucis Lancer assault units.  I even enjoy the extra ammo version. I have yet to play with the Muse version, but I should get around to it. Other 3150 updates would be nice, but its one of those Mechs you can understand they look at and say  "leave well enough alone."
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Dakkagor on 01 September 2017, 08:16:03
A great 'Mech, another of the Gauss monsters from 3058 (Nightstar, Pillager, and Thunder Hawk), this is one I don't field often.  When they show up in my games, they have TERRIBLE luck, and that stains my view of them.  The long range punch is solid, the best of the 4, on paper it should be a 'Mech I love.

But that bad luck streak has been around for a long time, and I don't trust them.  :)

I've had much the same experience, one of the first times I used the thing my opponent TAc'ed the gyro and it fell down a hill and refused to get up for the rest of the game. . .

I have not played with one often, or maybe even not at all.  I also wonder how the mini is?

The mini is. . . .fine.  Its ok to put together and paint, but the pose looks like its just tripped on a rock and is about to fall over.  I get that its meant to be running full pelt, but on a 100 ton assault it just looks wrong.  But for the muse, I suppose the mini is quite fitting. . .
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Getz on 01 September 2017, 08:29:56
You can't argue with the effectiveness of this one.  Personally I'd prefer a Nightstar or - if one was going for style points - a King Crab 001, but I wouldn't pretend for a second that the Devastator wasn't objectively better than either of them.

To me, one of the nice things about the Devastator is that, optimised as it is, you can still think of ways to make it better so it doesn't feel as uber-muchy as something like a Hellstar.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: mbear on 01 September 2017, 08:59:03
Quote
The DVS-1D is the monkey tech variant pushed out in 3036.  With a standard engine, it has to save a lot of weight.  It strips out the heavy weapons and replaces them with a pair of AC10 and a pair of large lasers.  This is a vicious combo for a Succession War era assault machine.  It gains an extra heat sink, but its a single, so its heat curve is ruined.  It also only loses a half ton of armour over the original variant.
With its matched up range brackets, and solid secondary battery, this mech has only a single flaw: Heat!  A standing ranged strike with the four big hitters generates a six point heat spike.  You have to drop the large lasers every other salvo to keep the heat under control, or pick your moments for an alpha very carefully.  This variant completely disappears from Davion space by 3060, surviving only in the Taurian Concordat.

Fun Fan Fact: The DVS-1D is actually two Enforcers welded together! ;)

I'm kind of surprised that the AFFS didn't turn that heat flaw into a benefit by installing TSM. The four big hitters give you six heat points, and a single Medium Laser gives you the three you need to activate it. Then you're moving at 4/6.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Iron Mongoose on 01 September 2017, 11:23:36
3058 was a good year for gauss rifles, wasn't it?

The Devistator has long been my pick of the class from that year.  The Thunder Hawk is great on paper, but I dislike the feel of it, the unballanced GRs, and it does feel a bit more Hellstar-ish (plus I've had bad experiances with two engine crits and SHS, which is really just unforgivable on a 100 ton XLed three GR monster).  I love jets, but on a mech with the Pillager's range I generally like to just stay  on the groun and snipe, even if it is a decent brawler with it's lasers and GRs (a-la Michael Searcy), but giving up six tons to jets just is too much to be competitive with the Devistator and T-Hawk.  And the Nightstar...if it were five tons heavier, I'd like it more even if it made no other changes.  Lot's of irrationality in this, but I accept that.

As to the Devistator itself, asside from that it's a good mech there's little to say.  It's slow, with good range, a forgiving heat curve and good armor.  It's hard to fight a sniper dual with unless you've got a Warhawk or Supernova, since slow as it is it's still generally pretty easy to get the PPCs into range (and few mechs have the power to just trade blows with twin GRs anyway) and with a bevy of MLs it's not entirely safe to try and close to get under the minimums of it's big guns, since in the first place the big guns may just rip you appart before you get there, and in the second a mech fast enough to get there safely can't usually stand up to the MLs and a 20 point kick. 

Really, the only sure fire stratigy is to either just curcumvent it, in which case perhaps it's won anyway, or just hit it so hard there's no hope of recovery, in which case hopefully there was enough cash to spare for solid lance mates for the thing.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 01 September 2017, 13:21:41
3058 was a good year for gauss rifles, wasn't it?
Funny, I kept thinking Cerberus was in the book, not 3055.
That and the Gunslinger made up that book's Gauss Rifle mafia. 

I remember the CBT Novel Flashpoint where the Devastator faced off with the Cerberus at the HPG.

Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: SD501st on 01 September 2017, 13:23:56
A very nice article on a Mech I never really warmed up to... it feels weirdly generic to me, or maybe "simple" is the better word. The MUSE EARTH on the other hand oozes character, even though the combination of an XXL engine with armor that has the nasty habit of coming off all at once if someone gets a lucky TAC in, doesn't leave me with warm and fuzzy feelings.  #P

By the way, I am intrigued by this "Gauss Armour" idea of yours that is supposedly found on the DVS-3. How exactly does this special armour work?  ;D
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: sadlerbw on 01 September 2017, 13:57:57
This is one of those mechs where the original is probably still my favorite variant. It really does feel like a solid clan-fighter and makes the smart choice as a slow assault mech to make sure it has big, long-ranged guns to keep it in the fight. Honestly, you don't even really want to close with it, because even at hugging distance, the to-hit mods on the PPC's and Gauss Rifles really aren't that bad. Plus, you have to give up one point of that penalty if you don't want to stand within kicking/punching range.

As much as I love some of the classic big-gun Assaults like the Atlas and King Crab, this has got to be one of the best 100T Inner Sphere mechs there is. It piles on the armor. It carries big guns, and lots of them. It doesn't have way more weaponry than heat capacity to use it. It isn't totally reliant on ammo or one type of weapon. This thing is just plain good.

The art isn't the most interesting or inspiring I've ever seen, but it isn't bad and does give the feeling of a pretty large and beefy mech. The cockpit is probably my least favorite detail. I think the artist was maybe going for using a small 'head' to make the rest of the mech seem larger, but that isn't what it ended up looking like to me. It just looks like the head is too small. Other than that, it's really a decent design.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Dakkagor on 01 September 2017, 16:22:56
By the way, I am intrigued by this "Gauss Armour" idea of yours that is supposedly found on the DVS-3. How exactly does this special armour work?  ;D

I have no idea what you are talking about.   :P
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: glitterboy2098 on 01 September 2017, 21:33:49
i'm surprised we didn't see a 'field upgrade' version of the DVS-1D used in the war of 3039.. double strength heatsinks (that are hard to maintain but can be combined with SHS), would have gone a long way to fixing some of the type's issues, and those AC10's just beg for prototype LB10X's.


Edit: playing round with megamek lab, you could do it easily.. remove the AC10's, their ammo, and the 3 external SHS, and put in Prototype LB10X's, move the 4 tons of ammo (split between slug and cluster) to the side torso's, then fit in 4 DHS prototypes (2 per side torso), and CASE in both side torso's. the primary arsenal (the AC's and LL's) becomes heat neutral aside from movement, and heat management becomes much easier. would also put the ammo behind not only more armor, but better crit padding.
would probably need to be a factory refit, but would make for a nasty surprise.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 01 September 2017, 21:57:40
Also could have made it AC/5s & PPCs . . . would fit in with all the other Davion AC/5s.

I never really got to look at my War of 3039 SB before it was water damaged (mom's window AC unit got it & several other books) how often did the -1D or prototype models enter into play?
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: marauder648 on 02 September 2017, 03:22:05
Ahh the Devastator, one of TRO 3058's wonderfully potent series of assaults like the Nightstar or Pillager.  Its a great Clan fighter and fighter all round with firepower at all ranges whilst being a darn tough nut to crack. The placement of the Gauss' in the arms just makes more sense so it won't kill itself with an exploding gauss rifle unlike the Pillager. 

The MUSE EARTH sounds utterly bonkers, but in the best possible way :)  And I didn't know about the low tech Monkey version, which as was pointed out, is two Enforces slapped together with duct tape and string :D

When i've used them i've had a mixbag of luck. One Dev pilot couldn't hit ANYTHING with his guns save his medium lasers.  Another one headcapped a Dire Wolf at long range with its first shot.  Six of one, half a dozen of the other :)
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Kidd on 02 September 2017, 03:42:51
Fun Fan Fact: The DVS-1D is actually two Enforcers welded together! ;)

I'm kind of surprised that the AFFS didn't turn that heat flaw into a benefit by installing TSM. The four big hitters give you six heat points, and a single Medium Laser gives you the three you need to activate it. Then you're moving at 4/6.
The DVS-2 on the other hand is functionally two FALCONERS welded together, in terms of firepower at least.

Playing the heat curve like that is not worth the potential negatives to THNs, IMHO.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: glitterboy2098 on 02 September 2017, 11:19:55
When the 1D came out, they didn't have that type of TSM, and by the time they did, the 1D was probably considered obsolete, since the 2's had supplanted them in production.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 02 September 2017, 21:06:04
Anyone else feel like the DVS-2 is a souped-up Warhammer?  It even looks kinda like one, with the arms and the searchlight.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: SteelRaven on 02 September 2017, 21:39:25
I used to call the Devastator a Warhammer on PCP
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: misterpants on 02 September 2017, 22:23:30
Anyone else feel like the DVS-2 is a souped-up Warhammer?  It even looks kinda like one, with the arms and the searchlight.

Now it does  ;D (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=891.msg1348825#msg1348825)
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: misterpants on 02 September 2017, 22:30:25
The Devastator is emblematic of my feelings of assault gunboats: I love the simplistic, efficient, and brutal payload, yet I feel uninspired when I run it or any of its compatriots. That may be more of an indictment of my lack of skills than the mech itself though.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Firesprocket on 02 September 2017, 23:20:00
I used to call the Devastator a Warhammer on PCP
It was the Warhammer on Steroids for me.  The photo from the MAC with the search light nailed it home for me (http://www.sarna.net/wiki/File:Devastator_MACp55.png (http://www.sarna.net/wiki/File:Devastator_MACp55.png)).
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Demon55 on 03 September 2017, 12:18:46
The Devastator is one of the few mechs that could be called Clan-busterish. 
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: gyedid on 05 September 2017, 04:17:50
The Devastator is one of the few mechs that could be called Clan-busterish.

But DOES the Devastator consistently give a good accouting of itself against opponents like Dire Wolves, Turkinas, and Hellstars?

cheers,

Gabe
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: THUD on 05 September 2017, 10:10:37
But DOES the Devastator consistently give a good accouting of itself against opponents like Dire Wolves, Turkinas, and Hellstars?

cheers,

Gabe

IMHO yes. It's one of the few IS mechs that can throw 50 points of damage long range for little to no heat every turn. (I know that people don't consider the PPC long range any more, but I still do) At least until the bins run dry.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Iron Mongoose on 05 September 2017, 11:49:02
That's the key. If you can fight at 16-18 hexes, the Devastator is comparable to a good Clan assault until the armor is breached (IS XL engine can't be ignored). Plenty of terrain situations can create this. 

But, Devastator still gives up speed to Warhawks and Executioners and Blood Asps and things, making it harder to hold that sweet spot without really optimal terrain or lots if other mechs, or maybe mines. And while many Clan assaults aren't nearly as slickly designed, putting the Devastator up against the few that are is still a mismatch.

But, for an IS mech, it's as good as can be asked for.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Darkwing on 06 September 2017, 09:05:39
But DOES the Devastator consistently give a good accouting of itself against opponents like Dire Wolves, Turkinas, and Hellstars?

cheers,

Gabe


Yeah it does, even more so when you take into account the inner Sphere views war as a team sport. A Devastator in the back, with practically anything else running interference and you have a good chance. You are never going to get a 1:1 against a 100 ton Clan Machine, but the Devastator is probably as close as you can get given the tech curve. I am surprised, given its backstory as a mech designed by the Great Father, I thought we would see this as IIC. I suppose for damage potential a Hellstar is a Devastator IIC.....
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Sabelkatten on 06 September 2017, 11:04:15
If you really want to go up against clantech you'd do better to drop the MLs for more heatsinks and upgrade to ERPPCs, but it's still decently optimized.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Generalstoner on 08 September 2017, 09:21:01
I've always loved the Devastator.  If I were a mechwarrior in the BattleTech universe, from the inner sphere, the Devastator or the Nightstar would be the mechs I would want.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: garhkal on 08 September 2017, 14:47:59
Excellent writeup of an excellent machine. The Devastator truly lives up to its name and never fails to be an MVP when deployed in any of my games. Pilot motto: Stand and Deliver!

It certainly has been a beast in games i've ran against them.  Never played with one on my side of the field though.

Anyone else feel like the DVS-2 is a souped-up Warhammer?  It even looks kinda like one, with the arms and the searchlight.

The first time i saw it, i did think it looked like a heavier warhammer..  And in practicality it works like one too..

If you really want to go up against clantech you'd do better to drop the MLs for more heatsinks and upgrade to ERPPCs, but it's still decently optimized.

That is true.  Even just dropping 2 of the MLs for 2 more heat sinks but making them all doubles, while upping the peepers to ER models, gives a boost in range..
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: gyedid on 09 September 2017, 11:59:23

Picture the scene:  Terra burns, Amaris and his Rim World Republican Guard are fighting for survival against a vengeful Star League, and from out of the smoke of the battlefield, titans of war stride, the ultimate assault lance.

At their head, a solid wedge of armour bearing two AC-20 Autocannons, designed to slay opposing mechs as quickly as possible.  The indomitable King Crab shoulders through the enemies heaviest fire and guts mechs in one massive salvo.  Following behind, standing tall and shrouded in smoke like a pair of grim reapers, come the Atlas II’s.  Any mech opened up by the King Crab gets shredded by missiles, LBX-pellets and burned down by lasers.  Finally, standing on the ridge line behind, laying down a hail of murderous long range gauss and PPC fire, the Devastator stands watch.  Four hundred tons of fusion powered death machine, all designed by or designed for Aleksandr Kerensky.
   

Wouldn't the fourth of that quartet actually be the original Titan?

cheers,

Gabe
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Stormlion1 on 09 September 2017, 15:20:25
Devastator, my go-to Mech.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: gyedid on 11 September 2017, 10:47:36
Wouldn't the fourth of that quartet actually be the original Titan?

cheers,

Gabe

Actually, if memory serves, doesn't the original TRO:3058 fluff mention something about the Devastator being derived from the Titan in some way?  They're both 100 tons and sport a standard PPC in each side torso, but the similarities pretty much end there, since the Titan is a rather low-tech affair that concentrates on a short-range barrage, in contrast to the Devastator, with its advanced tech and clearly ranged fighting paradigm.

cheers,

Gabe
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Minemech on 11 September 2017, 11:07:49
The 1D may be one of the best flavor additions to the Davion roster.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 11 September 2017, 13:54:45
Actually, if memory serves, doesn't the original TRO:3058 fluff mention something about the Devastator being derived from the Titan in some way?  They're both 100 tons and sport a standard PPC in each side torso, but the similarities pretty much end there, since the Titan is a rather low-tech affair that concentrates on a short-range barrage, in contrast to the Devastator, with its advanced tech and clearly ranged fighting paradigm.

cheers,

Gabe
Grand Titan is variant of Titan, as well is Titan II is later variant of the Titan.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Firesprocket on 11 September 2017, 21:35:57
Actually, if memory serves, doesn't the original TRO:3058 fluff mention something about the Devastator being derived from the Titan in some way? 
Kerensky designed the Devastator to make up for the flaws of the Titan.  What those flaws might have been, who knows.  I find the Titan to be a pretty decent design aside from mixing in that SRM-6.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: glitterboy2098 on 11 September 2017, 21:53:24
damage at long range would be my guess. the original SLDF titan had 2 PPC's for long range, but that was about it. the rest was (an impressive amount of) medium lasers and SRM's. so beyond 9 hexes, the original Titan would have been less than impressive for its size.

the SLDF Devestator cranked the long range up to 11 with the twin gauss and the 2 PPC's.

ultimately they'd be complimentary designs.. the Titan does best up close where it's 4 ML's, and 22 SRM's can put a lot of hurt on an enemy, while the Devastator is a nightmare at long range, but has limited close range firepower thanks to minimum ranges on its big guns, and only having 3 forward lasers for close range.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 11 September 2017, 22:01:39
Yeah . . . honestly the original Titan is a fat Battlemaster, it would be good in a SLDF Assault lance where the other 3 mechs were . . . Thunderhawk, Devastator and Emperor 6A . . . 2 long range BFG sets, a mid range critseeker or can opener and then up close light show that pitches missiles.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: gyedid on 13 September 2017, 10:30:33
damage at long range would be my guess. the original SLDF titan had 2 PPC's for long range, but that was about it. the rest was (an impressive amount of) medium lasers and SRM's. so beyond 9 hexes, the original Titan would have been less than impressive for its size.

the SLDF Devestator cranked the long range up to 11 with the twin gauss and the 2 PPC's.

ultimately they'd be complimentary designs.. the Titan does best up close where it's 4 ML's, and 22 SRM's can put a lot of hurt on an enemy, while the Devastator is a nightmare at long range, but has limited close range firepower thanks to minimum ranges on its big guns, and only having 3 forward lasers for close range.

In (retconned) context, the Titan is also the kind of machine the SLDF would be forced to cobble together during the years when they were without access to the major factories and main supply bases in the Amaris-controlled Hegemony.  The Titan could be built by a member-state factory that didn't have access to all of the top-tier military tech, while the Devastator is a Cadillac machine that would almost certainly have needed a Hegemony-grade facility to build.

cheers,

Gabe
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Firesprocket on 14 September 2017, 00:18:03
The Titan could be built by a member-state factory that didn't have access to all of the top-tier military tech, while the Devastator is a Cadillac machine that would almost certainly have needed a Hegemony-grade facility to build.

That is a fairly good point.  My personal sadness is that they didn't adapt the other versions of the Btechnology Titan into canon.  The 3145 versions are close enough, but not identical to the other high tech versions found in that publication.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 14 September 2017, 05:39:27
Kerensky designed the Devastator to make up for the flaws of the Titan.  What those flaws might have been, who knows.  I find the Titan to be a pretty decent design aside from mixing in that SRM-6.
If that's the case, then the Devastator's flaws is close-in Combat. The medium lasers aren't enough if someone get's close a personal with the Mech. It's firepower may fair somewhat well until someone comes in to it's minimum ranges.  I've seen this happened with the Devastator and it's spiritual SLDF Gauss Rifle flinging cousin, the Thunderhawk.  Both get into trouble when someone close-in with the Mech.

That be said, no mech suppose to be perfect.  That's why you have lancemates or designated body guards such as Shootist or some other close-in fighter to cover your weak spots.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Iron Mongoose on 14 September 2017, 11:59:02
I've seen it too, but not many mechs can pull it off, or it can't be done in too many terrain types.  Sure, you can get a really tough fast mech in close, and if it's a really high end mech (Clan especially, like a Stormcrow B or Gargoyle C) it might have enough power to hack into the side torsos before either the Devastator or it's lance mates bring the fool down, which needs to be damn fast because the first turn the Devastator wins int it just walks back three hexes and fires the big guns at short range with no mods. 

In tight terrain, you can get a King Crab or Sagitire or Kodiak or Turkina D in close, with the power to just blow the damn thing to hell free and clear.  It's easier for the jumpers, of course, and an ultra high end Clan mech like a Dire Wolf C can just shoot it's way in close, but for a King Crab or Hunchback you need just the right terrain, and if one takes a Devastator into terrain where that can take place, then they deserve what they get.

Honestly, I think the minimum ranges on PPCs and GRs are more dangerous to opponents than to the mechs that wield them.  I've killed more mechs with Awesomes who thought they could get in and exploit my minimums, than with foes who thought they could stand back and slug it out (though granted no one imagines they can just slug it out with an Awesome).
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 14 September 2017, 14:56:38
To be honest, the Devastator isn't that vulnerable close up.  It's looking at a maximum of +2 to hit with the GRs and +3 with the PPCs.  That's easily doable with a good gunner (and it's not like you'd typically assign a novice to one).
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Kidd on 14 September 2017, 18:52:15
Yeah, but on the flipside, if you are fighting a Devastator, you would know that, and make sure to send an equally-skilled pilot(s) to take out such a key enemy piece.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: mbear on 15 September 2017, 05:35:17
To be honest, the Devastator isn't that vulnerable close up.  It's looking at a maximum of +2 to hit with the GRs and +3 with the PPCs.  That's easily doable with a good gunner (and it's not like you'd typically assign a novice to one).

If close in attacks are a problem, I could see swapping a PPC for a Large Pulse Laser. After the Jihad, maybe a Snub nose ppc?
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 15 September 2017, 06:18:32
If close in attacks are a problem, I could see swapping a PPC for a Large Pulse Laser. After the Jihad, maybe a Snub nose ppc?

I like that idea.  You won't be giving up too much firepower in exchange for better means of close range attacks.  I will have to play with it seem if you can both the standards and the snubbies on with the gausses.

I hope the DVS-10 doesn't cut remove the PPCs for the RE-Lasers. It be almost a setback to be coming a DVS-1Dr than a newer model. ReEngineering Lasers i think could be useful, but i don't think they'd be good if it was main weaponry for a Mech like the Devastator.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Sjhernan3060 on 11 November 2017, 20:30:50
Excellent writeup of an excellent machine. The Devastator truly lives up to its name and never fails to be an MVP when deployed in any of my games. Pilot motto: Stand and Deliver!

Did the clans ever produce this?
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 11 November 2017, 20:50:03
No, the Clans never produced the Devastator.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: jklantern on 11 November 2017, 21:04:32
No, the Clans never produced the Devastator.

Not to the best of our knowledge.  But they DID bring some along during the Exodus, and they DID use them during Operation Klondike.  So it's not impossible for one to be stuck in some Brian Cache somewhere, solahma forces, yada yada.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hellraiser on 11 November 2017, 21:50:50
I don't see those minimum ranges as an issue.
4 ML might not seem much but it matches the firepower of the 2 PPC while a 20 point kick more than matches a Gauss.
Tangle with that at your peril.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: William J. Pennington on 11 November 2017, 22:31:23
Yep, charge up close..into the increasingly more accurate fire form the heravy weapons..then enter the short range of the Ml's..then maybe get a kick in the process. And the Devastator can be multitasking and shifting Gauss fire to another target  Or just shoots you anyway--after all, if he can hit a target at medium range he can hit someone up close as well). Dropping the PPC's out of the circuit every other round, and he doesnt even break a sweat. Heck, hes keeping the beer cold.

If you want to dance up close, you need to be a mobile jumper, making sure you keep out of that kick arc, preferably out of the front arc completely. Make him dance, or move to protect himself and thus take his firepower off the rest of your force. Expecting a slow slugger assault to bully his way up to a Devastator is just going to get you one dead slugger.

My Devastator usually hans with some other long range bruises, but theres always an element wth short range capability in case someone feels froggy. A Stalker 7D often fills this roll. 4 medium pulses and a TC makes even an agile light jumper sweat getting close in. And for those far away, it supports the Devastator with very accurate TC guided ER PPC fire.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hellraiser on 12 November 2017, 12:12:47
A Stalker 7D often fills this roll. 4 medium pulses and a TC makes even an agile light jumper sweat getting close in. And for those far away, it supports the Devastator with very accurate TC guided ER PPC fire.
I also find things with old school AC's loaded w/ Precision Ammo to be VERY effective at keeping backstabbers away.
Victor-9B,  Rifleman-3C,  Demolisher,  Saladins.
You don't even need every bin, just enough for a few rounds & its normally quite effective as a deterrent to those flankers.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 12 November 2017, 14:43:45
I also find things with old school AC's loaded w/ Precision Ammo to be VERY effective at keeping backstabbers away.
Victor-9B,  Rifleman-3C,  Demolisher,  Saladins.
You don't even need every bin, just enough for a few rounds & its normally quite effective as a deterrent to those flankers.
This partially why I wish the 1D variant was canonically refitted by the Taurians for Dark Age use. 
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hellraiser on 18 November 2017, 14:30:37
This partially why I wish the 1D variant was canonically refitted by the Taurians for Dark Age use.

My GM used to have a great set up as a "GoalKeeper" for a Breakthrough scenario.

Level-1 Annihilator with all Precision Ammo.

Sure, its only 5 Shots per Gun.

But after the enemy has run the gauntlet against your own mobile forces,  to have to get past that thing with the near equivalent of 4 Clan LPL's was just enough to stop many of the mechs from getting off the end of the board as that 10 point hit will de-leg a lot of fast light mechs  >:D
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: anastrace on 22 December 2017, 20:50:54
I've lost a couple devastators (that name is incredibly accurate as well) in close combat, primarily because of jumpy backstabbers getting lucky on rear torso crits. There was one incident involving a hidden SRM Carrier that was...unfortunate. Of course, I've also kicked enough mechs and vehicles attempting it into scrap. The to hit mods aren't god awful at point blank either even inside the minimums.

If I ever modded one, it'd be for capacitor modded snub nose particle cannons, or scrap a medium or two for some rockets for point blank defense. It's one of the few mechs where I've never really had to tinker with it, as it works pretty dang great as it is.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 04 August 2020, 15:09:13
We finally got a Clan based Devastator that people have been looking for . . .

A handful of DVS-2 were built for Operation Klondike using improved Gauss Rifles so that they were able to carry 2 more tons of ammo, another ton of armor and a single med laser.  With the six prototypes the SLDF took with them, it offers a max of 11 IMO for the Clans to use . . . I would expect the Jaguars, Coyotes, and Adders to be the Clans most expected to have used them.  After Klondike, the Enhanced ERPPC were incorporated into the design along with Clan DHS to increase the sinking capacity- and unlike Omnis TPTB put the DHS in the feet to let it alpha if it was standing in a puddle.  We get the RS for this post-Klondike model, which seems to have removed the additional ammo and 3 medium lasers removed while the last 2 become ER.

The thing about the DVS-2-EC?  You get 4 chances to to get a headcap for 16 turns . . . if you are standing in that puddle, it can be putting out 68 points of damage in 15/12/7 point chunks.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 04 August 2020, 15:24:46
I didn't like the EC usage. But that's how it is.  Thing still nasty.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 04 August 2020, 15:44:43
You talking about putting the tag 'EC' on the end of those designs or 'some were for Klondike and then retrofit later' use?
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 04 August 2020, 18:41:08
You talking about putting the tag 'EC' on the end of those designs or 'some were for Klondike and then retrofit later' use?
Yes.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Empyrus on 04 August 2020, 18:46:11
I would assume the Clans didn't actually give them real designations and were in process of calling everything just by its proper names (like how no fully Clan-tech design has designation), and the EC is essentially a tag added by historians in-universe for sake of clarification.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hellraiser on 06 August 2020, 00:35:32
EC?

Early Clan?

Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: mbear on 06 August 2020, 06:33:54
EC?

Early Clan?

Yes
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 06 August 2020, 06:34:57
EC?

Early Clan?
Yes. Its on all the refits of Star League units. I think makes no sense since early Clan engineers/desigers would have given the Mechs a new designation based on its old one. Like Devastator has DVS-2. It would be in universe DVS-2B or DVS-2r or something.  EC thing not in universe something people at the time be calling these machines.

Well other than "BLOOD OF KERSENSKY! THAT THING TOOK OUT TOMMY!".
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Rince Wind on 06 August 2020, 06:51:33
Oh no, not Tommy!

And he was due to retire next week as well!
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 06 August 2020, 10:12:05
And the family photos he was always showing were so adorable.

But really, I think EC makes as much sense as the IIC designation, which is also something that appears to be used exclusively by the Inner Sphere and not by the Clans themselves.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Vonshroom on 06 August 2020, 14:11:49
My favorite Assault Mech and favorite post 3050 mech as well. Awesome design, art, and "feel". Reading the Flashpoint novel was awesome. This would be my ideal ride if I had to pilot a mech and I was blessed enough to have one. I actually greatly prefer the standard PPC's for heat management / simplicity and the damage is the same as the ER's so no big loss. The mech has no weaknesses, haha perfect design. 
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 06 August 2020, 14:35:42
I actually greatly prefer the standard PPC's for heat management / simplicity and the damage is the same as the ER's so no big loss.

No, the damage is not the same- the listed 'final' Dev EC has Enchanced ERPPCs which is the step between IS & Clan ERPPCs.  They do 12 points of damage, which is why I said the mech has 4 head capper chances that it can safely fire off for 16 turns.

The final EC design overheats slowly- like I said if you stand in a puddle you are going to be cool.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Stormlion1 on 08 August 2020, 15:28:44
Looking at the timeframe I doubt many were built before Klondike and the fact it didnt even get a IIc version in 3050 makes me think it actually wasnt a popular choice among the Clans in the Golden Century. Perhaps they were mostly used by Wolverines, Widowmakers, and Mongoose pushed the design into Dezgra territory.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 08 August 2020, 19:48:58
Like I said, taking handful literally you have at most 11 . . . Wolverines prob not b/c the way it talks about the Enhanced ERPPC being mounted later, the Mongoose were speedster mechs (not Hellion level nuts) but I do not see them with a 3/5.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Stormlion1 on 09 August 2020, 07:47:24
Just coming up with a theory why the design faded away. Being in the forces of three Clans that no longer exist would be a good reason.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: SteelRaven on 09 August 2020, 09:51:06
Just coming up with a theory why the design faded away. Being in the forces of three Clans that no longer exist would be a good reason.

Clans resources shifted to Omnis very fast, fluff for allot of the more common Clan standard mechs made it sound like each design was on the brink of being discontinued until the invasion made it clear they needed simpler designs that could be turned out in a hurry. 
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Stormlion1 on 09 August 2020, 13:36:17
Clans resources shifted to Omnis very fast, fluff for allot of the more common Clan standard mechs made it sound like each design was on the brink of being discontinued until the invasion made it clear they needed simpler designs that could be turned out in a hurry.

That's understandable if every Clan was rescources rich and they all moved to Omnimechs over the decades but we know many Clans were rescource poor and used Star League era mechs even up to the Invasion. Clans like the Blood Spirits would have continued using mechs like the Devastator because they wouldnt have a choice. Even the Ghost Bears fielded ancient designs like the Atlas II all the way into the invasion.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Maingunnery on 09 August 2020, 13:39:57
That's understandable if every Clan was rescources rich and they all moved to Omnimechs over the decades but we know many Clans were rescource poor and used Star League era mechs even up to the Invasion. Clans like the Blood Spirits would have continued using mechs like the Devastator because they wouldnt have a choice. Even the Ghost Bears fielded ancient designs like the Atlas II all the way into the invasion.
Sure but all Clans would evaluate which designs to keep in production, most designs would have to fall out of production and slowly become rarer or even extinct in the Clans.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: SteelRaven on 09 August 2020, 13:56:46
Even the Ghost Bears fielded ancient designs like the Atlas II all the way into the invasion.

They probably had more Atlas IIs than Devastators (It was the Founders mech after all) The Clans did have Brian Caches of old SLDF mechs but we don't know in what numbers so we can only guess what survived the Golden Age and what became scrap after so many trails. A Jade Falcon mechwarrior forgot the NightStar was originally a SLDF design when the IS began to deploy them for themselves as non survived in Clan space the Golden Age. Likewise, the newer Woodsman was phased out during the production of T-Wolves and Gargoyles, seemingly non survived to serve in Operation Revival.   
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 09 August 2020, 14:01:01
That's understandable if every Clan was rescources rich and they all moved to Omnimechs over the decades but we know many Clans were rescource poor and used Star League era mechs even up to the Invasion. Clans like the Blood Spirits would have continued using mechs like the Devastator because they wouldnt have a choice. Even the Ghost Bears fielded ancient designs like the Atlas II all the way into the invasion.

They had at most 6 of the prototypes to refit, and when they say they built a handful to me it implies they built at most 5 based off a prototype or plans they had on hand.  I would actually say they were hand built rather than ever really produced.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 09 August 2020, 21:04:30
A friend of mine was using a fictionally captured Devastator that was refitted with Clan tech.   Clan ER PPCs, Gauss Rifles, lasers as well. Essentially it was murder machine but it wasn't too op, but had the Clans had put the Devastator into production while fitting them out with mature Clan Tech (aka the normal stuff), it would be force to be reckoned with.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hotpoint on 10 August 2020, 06:16:45
Like I said, taking handful literally you have at most 11 . . . Wolverines prob not b/c the way it talks about the Enhanced ERPPC being mounted later,

Looking at Golden Century it says: "After Klondike, Wolverine engineers installed two Enhanced ER PPCs, updated the torso medium lasers and upgraded the heat sinks to help cope with the tremendous heat produced by the new weapons" so presumably it must have been just before the Annihilation.

Given that this was also when they were ramping up production of the Mercury II, Stag and Pulverizer I doubt they were making more Devastators too (they were just hanging their new toy on things they already had).

Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hellraiser on 19 August 2020, 10:42:27
Well given that only 6 prototypes were created before the exodus, IIRC......   I don't think we'd have very many on hand for the Wolverines to use if someone wasn't cranking out some new ones.

It seems like an odd mech to get a variant of actually given it was so new & rare.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 19 August 2020, 10:44:59
Hand built . . . but they started developing their own mechs, looking forward rather than back, to make the Pulverizer.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hellraiser on 19 August 2020, 10:52:15
It would be in universe DVS-2B or DVS-2r or something. 
Or, based on what we got from similar refits at Tukayyid......  DVS-2 (c)

Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: SteelRaven on 19 August 2020, 12:19:52
They may have skipped a new designation at first and was later added on EC for context.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 03 February 2024, 02:22:09
Bringing this thread back up to discuss the DVS-10 and DVS-11.

Showing up in TRO 3150 and finally getting a record sheet in Record Sheets 3150 a considerable amount of time later, the DVS-10 is an extremely specialized mech.  Like the MUSE EARTH, it moves at 4/6(10) thanks to a 400XL engine combined with MASC and an armored Supercharger.  Endo-Composite structure and FF armor save weight and very nearly provide the same level of protection (it has 1 less point in the center torso rear) while a Compact Gyro (also armored) reclaims some internal space.  For weaponry, it mounts two Re-engineered Large Lasers, one in each arm, and two Re-engineered Medium Lasers in the Center Torso, kept frosty by 18 double heatsinks (giving it 36 dissipation compared to a maximum of 32 heat on a running alpha strike).  That's honestly quite anemic firepower for a 100 ton mech and isn't great unless you're expecting to face opponents with Hardened or Reflective armor- though given the mech is used by the FedSuns it's got some use against the Combine.  Armor on the Hips and Shoulders also means that this mech is very resistant to having limbs blown off by lucky crits.

The DVS-11 returns to something closer to the original.  The Gauss Rifles are back in the arms, but the torso PPCs are now Snub Noses and the lasers are now Clanspec, with an ER Medium in each side torso and an ER small in the head and center torso (the CT one being rear-facing).  The MASC, Supercharger, and Compact Gyro are retained from the 10, but the component armor is gone and the engine has been downgraded back to a standard 300XL for a 3/5(8) movement pattern.  Heat is handled by 12 double heatsinks, all contained in the engine.  You can't freely mash the Alpha Strike button, but it does handily cover the main armament while running.  Endo-Composite provides some weight-saving.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 04 February 2024, 00:47:18
I'd go with DVS-11 anyday over 10.   400XL wicked expensive to repair/replace in a campaign unless doing generic chaos campaign / warchest system.   RE-Lasers is just not that great of a trade to me, I know the Clan tech DVS-11 is technically more expensive because tech itself.  DVS-10 has potential for pickup game, but it lack hitting firepower to me, unless you're facing a lot specialty Harden armored units from Kurita.

I find this little funny that my predictions/concerns back in September 2017 of the DVS-10/11 was nearly dead on what we got as far variants go. 
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 04 February 2024, 02:54:49
One hilarious thing about the 10 is that if you're up against an enemy with Reflective Armor, you're better off making a 9 hex charge if you can set it up than using the lasers.  The 10's weapon array is positively anemic- I'm not sure what other 100 tonners have such low firepower.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: BrianDavion on 04 February 2024, 02:57:48
One hilarious thing about the 10 is that if you're up against an enemy with Reflective Armor, you're better off making a 9 hex charge if you can set it up than using the lasers.  The 10's weapon array is positively anemic- I'm not sure what other 100 tonners have such low firepower.

I thought RE lasers ignored the bonuses of reflective armor?
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 04 February 2024, 03:05:47
They do.  But Reflective Armor also takes double damage from physical attacks, so a 100 ton mech charging from 9 hexes?  That's a lot of damage.  A lot more than two 9 point and two 6 point hits.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Wrangler on 04 February 2024, 10:38:11
They do.  But Reflective Armor also takes double damage from physical attacks, so a 100 ton mech charging from 9 hexes?  That's a lot of damage.  A lot more than two 9 point and two 6 point hits.
Yep, that bane of being able reflect energy damage.  While its still normal arm against regular attacks. Once things get physical, your hosed.

Then again, aside from Thunderhawk being super stay at long range specialist, Devastator is able move reasonably fast for a Assault, as long you  generally keep at medium/long range for the enemy and not close in with them.  Gauss Rifles are still brutal hammers when your firing volleys of two or more at a target.   
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: BATTLEMASTER on 07 February 2024, 10:46:46
I don't think we can talk about the Devastator's RecGuide variants without the new art  :cool:

(https://i.ibb.co/k0yHwd6/devastator-rg.png)
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Minemech on 07 February 2024, 10:53:12
I don't think we can talk about the Devastator's RecGuide variants without the new art  :cool:

(https://i.ibb.co/k0yHwd6/devastator-rg.png)
Interestingly enough, with some work you could model a Battle Armor suit off of it.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Starfury on 10 February 2024, 23:49:54
I prefer the DVS 2 and the 3 over the other variants, but I see what Davion is aiming for with the newer variants. I'm sad to see we didn't get a full up Clan version at some point, but such is life. The new art and in service date in 3048 makes me a happy Lyran though
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 11 February 2024, 01:40:02
A full-up Clan version would basically just be a Behemoth.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 11 February 2024, 02:06:31
Maybe not since it would probably be based off the EC- so ERPPCs still instead of pulse lasers.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 11 February 2024, 11:44:54
Hmm, I just feel like that wouldn't really be doing anything that dozens of other Clan assault mechs already do.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 11 February 2024, 12:55:28
Hmm, I just feel like that wouldn't really be doing anything that dozens of other Clan assault mechs already do.

Not really disagreeing- ERPPC or LPL w/ Gauss has been done.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: BATTLEMASTER on 11 February 2024, 13:23:26
Not really disagreeing- ERPPC or LPL w/ Gauss has been done.

According to MegaMek, only the Crucible 2 is configured with dual Clan Gauss and dual Clan ER PPC.  It's not an alpha baby either.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Tyler Jorgensson on 11 February 2024, 13:29:34
I prefer the DVS 2 and the 3 over the other variants, but I see what Davion is aiming for with the newer variants. I'm sad to see we didn't get a full up Clan version at some point, but such is life. The new art and in service date in 3048 makes me a happy Lyran though

To be fair everyone on the forums has made a Devastator IIC in the fan-made forums. Simple solution in swap to Clan tech weapons, frame, DHS, armor etc.

It would be nice of course but Omni-mechs became a thing and any particular Omni with enough pod space can replicate it.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: BATTLEMASTER on 11 February 2024, 13:38:10
It would be nice of course but Omni-mechs became a thing and any particular Omni with enough pod space can replicate it.

It was a pretty popular Dire Wolf configuration in MechWarrior Online.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Colt Ward on 11 February 2024, 13:38:36
According to MegaMek, only the Crucible 2 is configured with dual Clan Gauss and dual Clan ER PPC.  It's not an alpha baby either.

Sure but you have . . .

Dire Wolf A- GR & 3 LPL
Dire Wolf H- 2 GR & 2 HLL
Dire Wolf Widowmaker- if you just look at the ranged damage, matches DVS profile
Supernova 3- same was DW Widowmaker
Tomahawk Prime- matches DVS
Deimos A- flip dmg profiles, 2 ERPPC, 2 LB-10X
Jupiter 2- same as Deimos

After a quick look at basic rules designs.

To be fair everyone on the forums has made a Devastator IIC in the fan-made forums. Simple solution in swap to Clan tech weapons, frame, DHS, armor etc.

It would be nice of course but Omni-mechs became a thing and any particular Omni with enough pod space can replicate it.

Which is why 5 of those I cited are Omnis.  I mean the Dire Wolf is a pretty basic frame for duplicating any of the Star League 3/5 assaults and getting just a bit more.  It is when you start talking those that are faster or like the Liao update of the Pillager to Stealth armor that you have to start reaching.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: BATTLEMASTER on 11 February 2024, 14:02:13
Sure but you have . . .

Dire Wolf A- GR & 3 LPL
Dire Wolf H- 2 GR & 2 HLL
Dire Wolf Widowmaker- if you just look at the ranged damage, matches DVS profile
Supernova 3- same was DW Widowmaker
Tomahawk Prime- matches DVS
Deimos A- flip dmg profiles, 2 ERPPC, 2 LB-10X
Jupiter 2- same as Deimos

After a quick look at basic rules designs.

Agreed - I was thinking of four headcappers.  The Dire Wolf A only has one  :wink:
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Luciora on 11 February 2024, 15:01:50
But they look like thier parent designs, not a Devastator.  :cool:

Hmm, I just feel like that wouldn't really be doing anything that dozens of other Clan assault mechs already do.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: BrianDavion on 12 February 2024, 20:43:29
regarding clantech upgrades for the DVS, one intreasting idea might be 2 silverbulelt gausses and 2 clan tech ERPPCs. open holes with the PPCs and then buckshot the crap outta the enemy mech
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: SteelRaven on 12 February 2024, 21:04:22
I like the Silver Bullet Gauss idea as we don't see enough of that weapon imo.

It's kinda hard to beat the DVS 2 without deviating away from range, then you still have to compete with similar overlapping designs. A duel RAC+Snubs would be a brutal urban combat build but would be similar to the King Crab KGC-007.   
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: spotH3D on 27 March 2024, 10:39:55
Brian Davion,

double SB Gauss double cERPPC with a few lasers is nasty nasty.  I'm going to do that up in MegaMek.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: 17thRecon on 27 March 2024, 19:20:47
Brian Davion,

double SB Gauss double cERPPC with a few lasers is nasty nasty.  I'm going to do that up in MegaMek.

Even all IS tech; double Silver Bullet Gauss and double ER PPC would be vicious. Similar to a Carronade. The Devastator is symmetrical, otherwise I’d say 1 SB Gauss, 1 regular Gauss, and 2 ER PPC’s would be cool/ cover both ranged hole punching and crit seeking, but 2 SB and 2 PPC covers that in spades and stays symmetrical and in line with the art.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: BrianDavion on 27 March 2024, 20:09:13
I mean the SB GR is a straight up swap for the standard IS GR yeah? so you could refit the basic DVS-2 to those specs
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: spotH3D on 28 March 2024, 12:17:36
In later ages I'm not a fan of Devastator but faster. 

So a Dark Age/ IlClan version with 2 cERPPCs and 2 SB Gauss sounds Deliciously nasty, and plan hasn't been done at all yet.

In addition to punching holes and filling them with SB Gauss flechettes, nasty as hell to VTOLs, aerospace, and combat vehicles, just searching for crits/motive hits.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MarauderD on 28 March 2024, 12:41:29
Even all IS tech; double Silver Bullet Gauss and double ER PPC would be vicious. Similar to a Carronade. The Devastator is symmetrical, otherwise I’d say 1 SB Gauss, 1 regular Gauss, and 2 ER PPC’s would be cool/ cover both ranged hole punching and crit seeking, but 2 SB and 2 PPC covers that in spades and stays symmetrical and in line with the art.

I didn't take the time to post--but you nailed my thought on the head. Two Clan-grade ER PPC (produced in FedSuns already for the new Marauder lines) backed up by one regular IS Gauss Rifle and one SB Gauss would be just sick.  The extra heat would be slightly problematic, but I doubt anyone would complain about the extra firepower.  Perhaps drop a medium laser for an extra HS.  I don't want to derail thread, so I'll go ahead and say the DVS-11 is back on track. 
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: 17thRecon on 28 March 2024, 19:42:14
I didn't take the time to post--but you nailed my thought on the head. Two Clan-grade ER PPC (produced in FedSuns already for the new Marauder lines) backed up by one regular IS Gauss Rifle and one SB Gauss would be just sick.  The extra heat would be slightly problematic, but I doubt anyone would complain about the extra firepower.  Perhaps drop a medium laser for an extra HS.  I don't want to derail thread, so I'll go ahead and say the DVS-11 is back on track.

Hey, not bad for a dude who’s actually never designed a Mech and is still trying to figure out the construction rules! 😆 (My current fantasy project is doing “3025 Now”, redesigning all the original 3025 stock Mechs but using all off the Ilkhan era tech available, like the stock was would have something like a light PPC, and MML 3, reflective armor, and maybe advance structure, improve jump nets, partial wing, etc. Take all that with a grain of salt, though,  because, like I said, I’ve got the ideas, but no idea what I’m doing 😆).

Back on the Devastator: I was saying IS ER PPCs, not even going as nasty as the Clan ER PPCs.
To steer further back on topic, I love the new art and plastic sculpt of the Devastator, too, and can’t wait until mine arrive.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hellraiser on 03 April 2024, 00:09:44
I'm sort of ok w/ keeping the Gauss as in on the Devastator, its a mech designed to punch big holes, I don't need it to Crit hunt too at the same time.
That is what I have other mechs for.  (Insert Longbow Here as Lancemate)

Now, that said, there is a Jager that has Twin-Gauss & given the Jagermech's entire job is ADA, well that seems like a fun place to use some SB-Gauss.

While I'm at it, I'm sure a Partisan would make a good home for them too.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 03 April 2024, 00:41:37
I'm sort of ok w/ keeping the Gauss as in on the Devastator, its a mech designed to punch big holes, I don't need it to Crit hunt too at the same time.
That is what I have other mechs for.  (Insert Longbow Here as Lancemate)

Now, that said, there is a Jager that has Twin-Gauss & given the Jagermech's entire job is ADA, well that seems like a fun place to use some SB-Gauss.

While I'm at it, I'm sure a Partisan would make a good home for them too.

There's a dual SB Gauss Rifleman in Rec Guide 8.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: Hellraiser on 03 April 2024, 00:43:56
There's a dual SB Gauss Rifleman in Rec Guide 8.
I have not seen that but dang, at 60 tons that's got to be thin skinned or using LOTS of weight saving techs.
Title: Re: Mech of the Week: DVS- Devastator
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 03 April 2024, 00:54:39
Both.