I'm going to be honest here. I never liked her to begin with in her original run. That the series then spent the entirety of Martha and Donna's run as companions basically talking them down while pointing out that she was a far more wonderful human being than they could ever be was maddening, and going out of their way to bring her back at every opportunity was even worse. She's one of the reasons i gave up on New Who.
Just saying
I totally get where you coming from. I think Rose is cool and pretty BA. BUT I just have a problem with the Doctor falling in love with anyone. I grew up watching stories from the classic Who and I can't see any of those Doctors falling in love with a human (or anyone else for that matter). The Eighth Doctor...maybe but then again he was written by committee, so...
Also the way the Doctor treated Martha was actually pretty horrible. "Yes I know you are falling for me, but I'm just going to ignore that and continue to pine away for the last girl."
What is it with the companion always has to fall in love with the Doctor now anyway? Rose, Martha (Donna thankfully escaped this), Amy, Clara seems to have escaped this as well. I certainly hope that the next one won't. :P