I find myself in agreement with him too. Maybe the Minekaze or Kamikaze R might reload their torpedoes fast enough but yeah I wouldn't want to take a Fubuki, Mutsuki or Hatsuharu into the current operation. Farragut is a bit iffy as it is too frail. Nicholas might actually be a better choice because it is tougher. I've also tried Gaede and it's 150mm guns proved reasonably effective.
But if I had to pick ships that would absolutely dominate the current operation I would have to say it is the UK Cruisers. Emerald, Leander, and Perth with their built in smoke screens and heals mean they can just hang in there longer.
Worst ship I've taken though is actually the Graf Spee. It's guns are just too slow, few, and inaccurate for how many enemies show up.
I only have my Argpeggio BBs to take in but they might do well thanks to their speed more than anything else.
CV I think you can actually get away with strike load outs even for the US CVs. Depends on what kind of agility and AA your team has.