A couple things (though I have similar concerns):
- Do we know that the 3250 league is the one Alaric is trying to found right now? Is it referenced as the third Star league or as just the Star league.
- we don’t know that all of the currently opposing clans submitted.
But overall, the 3250 blurbs are, as presented, a spectacular mistake. A storytelling albatross that needs to be thrown out. There is not a single positive aspect to their existence. They don’t add tension, don’t add a sense a “how could we get from A to B?” They add a sense of “oh, the smug POS Mary Sue in HotW keeps winning.”
The only way they aren’t a detriment to the setting is if they are a long play misdirection so we are surprised when the Alaric fails, and we are left wondering who the next ilClan could be.
But, if we throw out the 3250 blurbs, the current story has a bunch of potential.
The following quote is a snippet taken from the 3250 blurb in TRO: Dark Age.
In our modern context, the saying most often used to describe the so-called "Dark Age" era, the six or seven decades between the end of the Blakist Jihad and and the rise of the ilClan.
The speaker not only references
the ilClan, but Alaric's ilClan. However, others have pointed out that we do not know if Clan Wolf stills heads up the ilClan in 3250. I think that's a valid argument and I will address those comments individually in the post.
In regard to opposing Clans, no, we don't know which factions have submitted. However, we do have this following quote. Also, taken from TRO: Dark Age.
Conversely, the effects of the Blackout did not magically disappear with the rise of the ilClan, and lingered for several years after the Last Annihilation.
The speaker talks of the Last Annihilation. This can be interpreted in many ways. It could be the last in a series of annihilations over a specific time period. Or it could mean the last annihilation of a single faction in the Inner Sphere before the practice is outlawed by the ilClan/Third Star League. Regardless at least one faction is completely destroyed, and this doesn't just potentially include Clans, but also the Great Houses as well.
CGL has stated that they are not throwing out the 3250 blurbs and have claimed that the blurbs don't provide the whole picture, they only did so after they received pushback. There may be changes or elaborations in the future, but as of right now, this is what CGL decided to give us.
What if you had a Star League and nobody showed up?
I have to admit that this question got me excited. It's ringed of self-awareness. Then I actually thought about it. What if you had a Star League and nobody showed up? Then you
make them show up. Why, because we already know there will be a Third Star League, making the question a moot point.
What if you had a Star League and nobody showed up... at first?
Well.... The 3250 bits mostly mention Jade Falcon bloodnames for top leaders. And seem to have a recurring thread of venerating Elias Crichell as the greatest leader of the invasion era clans.
Main reason I'm engaged with this topic at all is that if it is to be good then IMO The devs need to be aware of what they are going and how material is recieved. If they've completely lost touch with wider fan reception (the small loud minority doesn't really matter) then odds of the Ilclan era being good drops SHARPLY.
IMO at least. Popular doesn't automatically mean good, but working in an echo chamber tends to be worse.
And I want very badly for BT storylines to be good and popular (Popular means it's more profitable and we can get more of it after all) both
The 3250 blurbs only mention the Roshak bloodname, held by Loremaster Stephan Roshak. No other currently living Clan character is mentioned. However, that doesn't rule out the possibility that the Jade Falcons could have supplanted Clan Wolf.
I would argue that it doesn't matter which Clan is ilClan by 3250, the foundation of the Third Star League as it stands right now is very shaky.
Thank you for your egagement, I'm hoping CGL staff noticed the discussion in this thread as well.
There's always an easy explanation to the 3250 blurbs: whoever wrote it was a sycophant. I'm sure there are tons of letters written during the Succession Wars to the "First Lord" about a campaign to "subdue the rebels"
Anyway, I think the popularity of Star League stuff can be chalked up to this being the second time they offered similar stuff. I've already got the stuff for the faction I actually play, so I grabbed a patch for the army my boys in the 2nd were briefly a part of in 3059.
I'm drawing a blank on the lore. Will you elaborate of which First Lord during the Succession Wars and what rebels?
Other than that, let's say that you are right. Stephan Roshak is a sycophant, keeping in mind that a sycophant is not the same as a liar. How much of what Roshak says can we trust?
We know that the Gunslinger program is real. It's the framing for the entire Battle of Tukayyid sourcebook. We know that there's a Sortek and Marik part of the Gunsligners, meaning there's participation in the Third Star League from the House Marik and the Federated Suns.
Then there's the Auditor Clusters:
...It is for this very reason that our Auditor Clusters exist, after all, tasked with scouring the League and the Periphery for signs of unauthorized heavy industry, and they must remain ever vigilant in these efforts.
Let's say that there are no Auditor Clusters, what is CGL trying to convey to us? What is the point of going so in-depth on information should not be considered reliable? How are we supposed to look at this?
Unless I've missed something, none of the 3250 blurbs spell out the fate of Alaric or of the Wolves in particular.
That being said, I've pointed this out before and I don't get the sense that my viewpoint is catching on. So I'm forced to conclude that on balance, the 3250 blurbs are bad for Battletech. There's only so long you can get away with teasing your own fans and then admonishing them for not getting the joke, even if you are technically correct.
Whichever Clan reaches and conquers Terra, shall be the ilClan for all time. All ilKhans of the ilClan thereafter will arise from that Clan till the end of time. This is Nicholas Kerensky's decree.
For the day will come and our kin will stand
On Terra's firm soil, ready to rebuild
The Star League with their hearts and hands.
But who shall lead? Upon whose shoulders
Will the burden lie? The answer is the test;
The test is the journey. Whichever Clan
Carves its way through the barbarians
To reach that fabled cradle of us all
Shall be the vehicle of the League's rebirth. Upon
The Star League throne shall sit that Clan's
Wisest Khan. So should it be -- So shall it be.
-- The Remembrance, Passage 72, Verse 22, Lines 14-24
It should be noted that there's the possiblilty that Alaric could go against this and open the ilKhanship to other Clans. That begs the question, if Nicholas Kerensky's beliefs of conquering Terra and forming a new Star League hold so much value to Clans, why would the abandon the one Clan for ilClan, forever rule.
Thank you. People take those blurbs way to literally, when unreliable narrators have been a trope for more than a century at this point.
Perhaps, but two sourcebooks and four technical readouts over the course of six years? That seems a little excessive for an attempt at misdirection. You would think after the poor reception of the Jihad plotbooks, CGL would be weary of the unreliable narrator trope.
I don’t know where anyone could’ve gotten that idea to begin with, because the writers certainly never sent that message in the writing. I thought it was quite obvious that the Wolves taking Terra and becoming ilClan was just the first step of the process, and we’d see a loooooooooot of conflict (i.e., the bread and butter of this franchise) to get to the state of things in 3250.
So far, no one has expressed that idea in this thread.