As revenge for the Dragoons betraying the Clans.
Eminently reasonable. That'll teach the descendants of the descendants of the original Clan mission not to arrange Tukayyid, splinter Clan Wolf, and cripple Clan Jade--oh wait.
Clan Wolf seeking 100-year-later vengeance is irrational. And irrational people are why we created stories about geese laying gilded eggs. Alaric Wolf being a dipshit is always an x-factor; this universe wouldn't turn if folks didn't make stupid decisions.
Because like every other human endeavor, the Trial has hypocrisy built in? If you read the Shrapnel story, the Clan warrior winning was expected though the Solaris warrior was not going to roll over.
Some X are Y. That does not mean all X are Y. If every Clan challenger issued a batchall and then dropped with overwhelming force--regardless of the defender's declared opposing forces--then a Trial of Possession just becomes a "raid." My impression of the Dark Age is that Inner Sphere and Clan mechwarriors alike still engage in honor duels so some form of honor and equitable fighting has to be around, save for individual warrior skill.
Without the equity promised by the pretenses of the Clan honor system, why would a kidnapped Solaris VII mechwarrior be any better than a WWI conscript?
Alternatively, who would even want a warrior you had to cheat to beat? "I can't take this warrior in a fair fight; I can't wait until we're fighting back-to-back. They love me." If they needed warm bodies, aren't there a ****** of Trueborn washouts with actual 'mech training
Also, a one-on-one duel can only be
so unfair in a universe with gauss rifles, blazers, and Clan PPCs.
Canon's gonna do what canon do, but when strained for troops, kidnapping charismatic winners from a heavily armed planet of opportunistic lucre-warriors...well BrianDavion said it in detail, but there's a reason even the elites of a society have to maintain the pretenses of the social mores they hold the populace to. When they get sloppy with their corruption--and maybe this is just conjecture--the populace takes that as a cue and the whole social fabric disintegrates.