Author Topic: (Answered) Combat Within Buildings and Rooftops  (Read 844 times)

Static

  • Private
  • *
  • Posts: 26
  • Armed entirely with rear-mounted medium lasers.
(Answered) Combat Within Buildings and Rooftops
« on: 06 September 2023, 18:08:43 »
Per BMM, page 73, "Combat Within Buildings":
Quote
A 'Mech on a building's roof is not considered within a building, and so if it fires on a 'Mech in a building it uses the rules given above under Attacking 'Mechs Inside Buildings.

This is contradicted by the example text, where a BattleMaster on Level 0 of a 4-level building is unable to cannot attack the Wolverine on level 4 (the rooftop), because
Quote
More than two hexes and/or levels of intervening building between attacker and target means line of sight is not valid

This reasoning shouldn't apply, because the Wolverine is not considered within the building. Instead, the rules from "Attacking 'Mechs Inside Buildings" should be used:

Quote
An attacker must have line of sight to a building hex, as well as to the target 'Mech. Building hexes block LOS, but the building hex a 'Mech is in does not count (since it is not intervening terrain).

This creates another strange situation, because by these rules the Wolverine on the rooftop should be able to see and fire on the BattleMaster on level 0, and vice versa, since there's no intervening terrain. If this is the correct interpretation, than the consequence is that line of sight between the BattleMaster on level 0 and another 'Mech on level 3 of the same building hex would be blocked by the presence of 2 intervening levels, but LOS between the BattleMaster and the Wolverine on the rooftop at level 4 would be open. Is that the intent of the rules/am I understanding things correctly?
« Last Edit: 07 September 2023, 02:22:04 by Xotl »

Xotl

  • Dominus Erratorum
  • Moderator
  • Lieutenant Colonel
  • *
  • Posts: 11710
  • Professor of Errata
Re: Combat Within Buildings and Rooftops
« Reply #1 on: 07 September 2023, 02:21:55 »
Combat Within Buildings:

Change the second bullet point to read:

Apply an automatic +1 Target Number modifier if the target ’Mech is inside a building hex (i.e. not on a roof), and another +1 for each intervening building hex and/or level.

And then at the end of the section replace the last para with the following:

   Rooftops: A ’Mech on a building’s roof is not considered inside a building. Nonetheless, if a ’Mech inside a building is firing at another ’Mech on the same building’s roof (or vice versa), use the line of sight and Target Number modifiers given in the bullet points above.
   Attacks by a ’Mech on a roof against a ’Mech inside another building use the rules for Attacking ’Mechs Inside Buildings.
   
Hopefully that covers it, presuming that the reader understands what "same building" vs. "another building" means (it's defined at the top of the section).  The example should then function without any need for changes.
3028-3057 Random Assignment Tables -
Also contains faction deployment & rarity info.

http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=1219.0