I'm going to buck the trend on the scoring the surfaces. At least for CAs
Yes, scratching up the surfaces does create more surface to which the glue can bind, but it also create peaks and valleys. Unless the peaks in one part line up REALLY well with the valleys in the other part, you are actually
reducing the contact area.
Superglue works best when there is a thin film between two smooth pieces. Yes, the glue will fill the voids but most of the work will be done by the tiny bits of CA on the tops of the peaks that are touching other peaks.
I will however second washing all the parts and maybe a new bottle of glue. The new glue is a bit iffy but it's a cheap option, and you'll need more glue eventually. I suppose super glue can go bad but the only age related issue I've ever ha....heard of is gluing the cap on. Yes, superglue does stick to the inside of the bottle. Don't ask me how I know this.