BattleTech - The Board Game of Armored Combat

Catalyst Game Labs => BattleTech Game Errata => Topic started by: Xotl on 19 June 2020, 14:24:08

Title: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Xotl on 19 June 2020, 14:24:08
This thread is for all issues and problems with all volumes in the Recognition Guide: IlClan series.

Product Links:
https://store.catalystgamelabs.com/pages/search-results-page?q=recognition%20guide

There is no compiled errata for these products at this time.

Please remember to follow the errata report template (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,2412.msg171290.html#msg171290) when reporting issues.  In addition, be sure to specify which volume you are reporting the error for.  Thanks.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 19 June 2020, 14:30:47
Volume 1
Page 5, along with the Griffin GRF-3N Record Sheet.

Error: The written layout for the variant and the record sheet have conflicting locations for the placements of four of the jump jets (side torsos vs legs).

Correction: Place the jump jets in the side torsos on the record sheet.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 19 June 2020, 14:57:46
Volume 1
Page 4, Griffin readout, second column, second paragraph

"...the C is not as sturdy XXX most of its..."
missing the word "as"

- - -

Volume 1
Grasshopper Record Sheet

'Mech role is missing.

- - -

Volume 1
Loki J Record Sheet
--Place Streak SRM/4 ammo below both ER Medium lasers.

- - -

Volume 1
Loki T Record Sheet
--Place ATM ammo (both slots) between the AP Gauss ammo and AMS ammo crits.

- - -

Volume 1
Goliath C Record Sheet
--Place Gauss Rifle ammo below the Micro Pulse Laser.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Adrian Gideon on 03 July 2020, 13:46:14
Volume 2

Page 10, “In an act of sheer cheek, Jaime Wolf snuck a Stone Rhino into his Dragoons when they departed for the Inner Sphere, knowing full well it would stand out.”

This is 100% wrong and somehow slipped through without required changes. Will post corrected text and upload a new PDF when able.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 03 July 2020, 14:08:32
Volume 2

Page 31: Behemoth (Stone Rhino) record sheet is missing the Small Pulse Laser that should be mounted in the head.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Hussar2 on 03 July 2020, 14:38:26
Volume 2

Page 14 Urbanmech record sheet change R93 to R96 (The R93 is the version from XTRO:Republic vol II)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 03 July 2020, 15:48:05
Volume 2
Zeus write-up on page 13 and Zeus record sheet.

Write-up claims: "...mating  the  Sphere-made  Artemis  FCS  onto  the  ClanTech launcher..."
Record sheet shows a Clan-made Artemis system.

Fix: Correct one or the other. Tonnage is the same either way, it's just important for campaign stuff.

- - -

Volume 2
Zeus Record Sheet
--Change all LRM ammo slots to "Ammo (LRM 15 Artemis-capable) 8"

- - -

Volume 2
Behemoth (Stone Rhino 5) Record Sheet
--Change LB-X ammo in slot 6 of both side torsos to "Ammo (LB 5-X Cluster) 20"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Bishop Steiner on 03 July 2020, 18:08:04
Volume 2

Also the TRO Entry itself for the Stone Rhino/Behemoth in Recognition Guide: ilClan vol 2, pg 11*(with the illustration), shows the 2 tons of Gauss Ammo that should be in the RT (and are correctly shown on the RS) as being in the CT.  Since it already has a Jump Jet in the CT, this clearly cannot be so.

Fix: Change Location of Gauss Ammo from CT to RT, on page 11 of TRO.

Source
*Recognition Guide: ilClan vol 2, pg 11
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Wrangler on 03 July 2020, 19:02:32
Volume 2

page 15

Errant: Ostscout's 7K variant record sheet has the Succession Wars era symbol. MUL indicates that the 7K is Clan Invasion era unit.

Fix: Change symbol to Clan Invasion era symbol.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Bishop Steiner on 03 July 2020, 19:19:45
Volume 2

possible fluff error with dates in the "Notable Pilots" Section for the Ostscout, pg 6 under Lem Pureliff*.

Reads that the repairs to his Ostscout served him well in the FedCom Civil War, but then immediately follows that he retired from Stinging Barflies in 3063.  While the 10th Lyran Regulars did declare for Victor in that year, there were no opposing military forces on Cavenaugh II at that time.

So it seems unlikely he would have seen any action to make use of his repaired sensors before his retirement in 3063**.  It seems more likely he would have retired at a later date, especially since having declared for Victor he would have been viewed as a traitor to the FedCom if he left the relative protection of the 10th Guard before the Civil War ended.

Fix: Change date of retirement to later year, probably 3067.

Sources:
*Recognition Guide: ilClan vol 2, pg 6.
**FedCom Civil War (sourcebook), pp. 84, 144
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Hussar2 on 04 July 2020, 05:44:11
Volume 2:

Page 7 under notable pilots Kelvin Howe. The first sentence reads "The latest in his family to serve in the Davion Light Guards"  The last sentence reads
"Howe's attitude is unsurprisingly not a good fit for the First"

It is unclear if he has served with the Light Guards or the 1st Guards (or both)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 04 July 2020, 10:17:12
Volume 2:

Record sheet for Wolf's Dragoons' downgraded Behemoth is missing. Reference: https://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=69931.msg1627225#msg1627225
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Xotl on 17 July 2020, 17:19:30
Volume 3:

Page 12, Notable MechWarrior Evgeniy:
"Evgeniy is one of three warriors to graduate from the
first sibko raised from the genes of Phelan Kell."

Per Bred for War, Phelan resolved to wait to create sibkos with his DNA until Ranna was eligible (by earning a bloodname, which she did before her death back in 3077).  The idea that for some reason the exile Wolves (including Phelan, who only died decades later) waited until the Dark Ages to start a sibko featuring the DNA of his dead beloved is not impossible, but does not seem to hold.  Unless the Evgeniy entry is set in an older period, but that would be odd since the TRO is modern.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 17 July 2020, 17:57:16
Volume 3:

Page 9, entry for BattleMaster C 3
Armor factor is listed as 248. Replace with 232.

Page 9, entry for BattleMaster C 3
Under Weapons and Ammo, two of the ER Medium Lasers are listed as rear-mounted.
The Record Sheet for the 'Mech does not reflect this. Change two ER Medium Lasers to be rear facing.

- - -

Volume 3
Hierofalcon B Record Sheet
--Move all three Partial Wing criticals in both left and right torso so they sit directly beneath the XL engine criticals.

- - -

Volume 3
Hierofalcon D Record Sheet
--Replace Left Torso ATM ammo in block 4-6, slot 3 with "Ammo (ATM 6 HE) 10"
--Replace Right Torso ATM ammo in block 4-6, slot 3 with "Ammo (ATM 6 ER) 10"

- - -

Volume 3
Shadow Cat III B Record Sheet
--Replace Left Torso ATM ammo in block 1-3, slot 4 with "Ammo (ATM 6 HE) 10"
--Replace Right Torso ATM ammo in block 1-3, slot 4 with "Ammo (ATM 6 ER) 10"

- - -

Volume 3
Shadow Cat III C Record Sheet
--Replace LB-X ammo in slot 6 with "Ammo (LB-20X Cluster) 5"

- - -

Volume 3
BattleMaster 6G Record Sheet
--Swap placement of "ER Small Laser (R)" and "Ammo (Streak SRM 6) 15" in Left Torso
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Adrian Gideon on 17 July 2020, 20:55:52
Volume 3:

Page 12, Notable MechWarrior Evgeniy:
"Evgeniy is one of three warriors to graduate from the
first sibko raised from the genes of Phelan Kell."

Per Bred for War, Phelan resolved to wait to create sibkos with his DNA until Ranna was eligible (by earning a bloodname, which she did before her death back in 3077).  The idea that for some reason the exile Wolves (including Phelan, who only died decades later) waited until the Dark Ages to start a sibko featuring the DNA of his dead beloved is not impossible, but does not seem to hold.  Unless the Evgeniy entry is set in an older period, but that would be odd since the TRO is modern.
This was debated in development. It's odd, and there's a story there eventually, but this is not errata.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Wrangler on 18 July 2020, 05:41:11
Volume 3

Page 5 entry for Hierofalcon
Errant - Prime Weapon Configuration - entry for the TAG is messed up, rows of stats is pushed to the left.

Correction - Fix positioning of the stats so it lines up.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 18 July 2020, 09:35:06
If we're doing formatting,

Volume 2
Page 9, Sojourner entry
Gyro tonnage (3) is in wrong column.

The words "Actuator enhancement system" takes up too much space and displaces "RA", recommend replacing with "AES"


Volume 3
Page 5, Heirofalcon entry
Gyro tonnage (3) is in wrong column.

Page 7, Shadow Cat III entry
Gyro tonnage (3) is in wrong column.

Page 13, Thor entry, configuration J
The words "Improved Heavy Medium Lasers" take up too much space and displace the other columns, replace with "Imp. Heavy Medium Lasers"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Caturix on 21 July 2020, 12:41:54
Volume 3

I think a clarification may be needed about the Hierofalcon battle history, page 4:

"The capture of Rigil Kentarus at the end of 3150
brought the Jade Falcons closer to mother Terra than
any Clan of Kerensky has ever been
. Both the Republic
defenders and Clan Wolf forces already on-planet..."
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 31 July 2020, 14:22:46
Volume 4
Page 4, Wasp entry.

Quote
...and expendable design. (Claims that the SLDF classified the Wasp as a “unit of ammunition” rather than a BattleMech in its logistics systems are, however, wholly untrue).

Either the period after "design" needs to be removed, or else the period after the closing bracket needs to be within the bracket.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 31 July 2020, 15:03:43
Volume 4
Page 5, Wasp C, and Record Sheet, Wasp C

Error: SSRM-2(OS) is mounted on the left leg in the readout, and the right leg on the record sheet.
Fix: Move the SSRM-2(OS) onto the left leg on the record sheet.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 31 July 2020, 15:35:00
Volume 4
Page 7, notable pilot Leftenant Caesar Davion-Green

Unsure if errata, but there have been multiple references to a "Green-Davion" family throughout many sources; could the two names have been accidentally reversed?
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 31 July 2020, 16:59:44
Volume 4
Page 7, Ol' Deke entry

Error: "...city-states of that Periphery World"
Fix: There is no need for World to be capitalized.

- - -

Page 9, Thresher II entry

Error: Location of Jump Jets are not listed under Weapons and Ammo
Fix: Put two in LT, two in RT, one in CT

- - -

Page 12, Star Captain Kaylee
Error: "...while her father was freeborn Exiled Wolf warrior"
Fix: Missing the word "a" in between "was" and "freeborn"

- - -

Page 12, Star Captain Kaylee
Error: Guerrette has one too many r's in it.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 31 July 2020, 17:43:23
Volume 4
Page 13, Blackjack entry

"...to carry quadruple light PPCs"
FIX: Incorrect use of quadruple, replace with "four"


Volume 4
Page 13, Blackjack entry

"...helping update Canopian tactics..."
FIX: Add "to" between "helping" and "update"

Volume 4
Page 13, Awesome entry
"...and breaking with a lance..."
FIX: Add the word "out" between "breaking" and "with"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 04 August 2020, 16:59:16
Volume 1

Problem: On the Critical Table, the Left Rear Leg is labeled "Right Rear Leg".

Solution: Change label to "Left Rear Leg".

S.gage
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: 3rdCrucisLancers on 06 August 2020, 17:35:58
Volume 4
Page 7, notable pilot Leftenant Caesar Davion-Green

Unsure if errata, but there have been multiple references to a "Green-Davion" family throughout many sources; could the two names have been accidentally reversed?

Yes, it was intended to be Green-Davion. Mea culpa.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MarauderD on 07 August 2020, 16:42:15
Volume 1

Record Sheet, Griffin C:

Problem: On the Critical Table, the Right Arm is missing the Hand Actuator.

Solution: Add Hand Actuator to Right Arm.

Source:  Checked by posting in Ask the Writers.

https://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=70528.msg1639964#new

Cheers,

Mad
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MarauderD on 14 August 2020, 15:11:36
Volume 5

PG 11:

Problem: Lieutenant Colonel Justin Morning  (There is no such rank in the AFFS)

Solution:  Change to "Leftenant Colonel Justin Morning"

Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 14 August 2020, 16:26:56
Volume 5
Page 12, Timber Wolf Configuration W

ERROR: UAC/20 erroneously listed as having 13 criticals and weighing 17 tons. Streak (SRM) ammo listed as having 30 shots, and weighing 12 tons. "ER Medium Lasers" missing a leading number.

FIX: UAC/20 should be listed as having 8 criticals and weighing 12 tons. Streak (SRM) should be listed as having 15 shots, and should weigh 1 ton. Put "2" before "ER Medium Lasers".

- - -

Volume 5
King Crab record sheet
--Replace LB 20-X ammo in slot 12 of the Right Torso, along with the ammo in slot 6 of the Left and Right Leg, with "Ammo (LB 20-X Cluster) 5"

- - -

Volume 5
Marauder II MAD-5A record sheet
--Replace LB 10-X ammo in slot 12 of the Right Torso with "Ammo (LB 10-X Cluster) 10"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Hussar2 on 14 August 2020, 16:39:10
Volume 5

Page 8 states the battle of Palmyra took place in 3145. This should be changed to 3143 according to FM3145 page 70 (or 3144 according to FM3145 page 21)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: BaldDen on 16 August 2020, 07:40:01
Volume 1

pg. 5
GRIFFIN C's weapon and ammo table
wrong amount of critical slot on ER PPC (clan) 3 instead 2
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Wrangler on 22 August 2020, 16:43:06
Recognition Guide: ilClan vol 01 - Page 8 -Dominator Battle History

Errant Summary: Conflicting Histories - Which Republic unit fought XI Principes Guards or XI Triarii Protectors

Errant:  Essentially wrong 11th was used in the battle. Shattered Fortress notes the invasion of Alula Australis by Clan Wolf in October 3150, was fought trial of possession against Republic regiment  XI Principes Guards.  However, in RecGuide 1 - Dominator's history notes that it was the XI (11th) Triarii Protectors. 

EDIT - Double Checking the Field Manual: 3145, it looks like RecGuide v1 is in the wrong.  Colonel Abasi was named in fighting, he was commander of the XI (11th) Principes Guards.

Correction: Change 11th Triarii Protectors to Principes Guards.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Caesar Steiner for Archon on 23 August 2020, 13:52:55
Vol 3, P. 5 - BattleMaster notable pilots:

Error: Angela Franks is listed as a Lieutenant-Colonel.

Solution: The correct LCAF rank is "Leutnant-Colonel"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Sartris on 28 August 2020, 16:46:02
Vol 6, pg 5

Problem The Cricket's equipment block lists the RL jump jet twice, giving the illusion of seven JJs. This is not possible due to the BR armor crit.

Solution: Delete the duplicated line
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vol 6, pg 20

Problem: the Cataphract 5L's small VSP lasers have a listed damage of zero on the record sheet

Solution: replace with the correct value

Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 28 August 2020, 17:56:50
RG6, pg 26 and 28
Problem: MAD-7C and 7R record sheets have erroneous side torso armor allocation, with right rear having 7 points and right front having 25 points. Judging by pg 7 stat block, right side armor allocation should be 24/8 just like the left torso.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Dies Irae on 28 August 2020, 19:55:25
Vol 6, Pg 11

Problem: Marauder IIC entry mounts a 270 Standard Engine.
Solution: Change Marauder IIC entry to 340 Standard Engine
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mbear on 31 August 2020, 08:51:39
Volume 6, page 20 Cataphract record sheet:

Problem:
Small VSP damage is listed as '0' in stat block.

Correction:
Add correct damage to both Small VSP entries.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Maelwys on 01 September 2020, 14:41:34
Vol. 5
p. 9

MAD-8K Marauder II BV is listed as 2,894. Record sheet (p. 30) shows 2849. Should be 2849
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Diplominator on 11 September 2020, 19:15:29
Volume 3:

Page 20, Hierofalcon fluff text, "...is poised to compliment or even
supersede..."

Solution: Replace "compliment" with "complement."
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Adrian Gideon on 19 September 2020, 23:05:36
[Developer edit]
Volume 5:
Page 13, the Crab MechWarrior should be named "James Kushelainn"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: BaldDen on 01 October 2020, 14:35:15
Vol 01
pg12
Weapons Configuration T --> Alternate Configuration T
3 ER Medium Lasers crits 3 instead 6


vol 02
pg5
Ostscout -8J` Equipment table
Mass of Gyro (Compact): 1.5 instead 4.5

Ostscout -12K` Equipment table
Mass of Gyro: 1.5 instead 3

vol 03
pg9
Battlemaster C 3` Armor factor

Error: 248 points

Correction: 232 points

vol 06
pg 11
Engine raiting 340 instead 270
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 13 October 2020, 14:09:28
Volume 5:
Page 4, Hammerhead entry, "Capabilities" section
Replace "vibrobomb" with "vibrabomb"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jymset on 17 October 2020, 16:53:35
[Developer edit]
Volume 4:
Page 8-9 and RS p. 28, change all references of the "Thresher II" to the "Thresher Mk II"

edit: additionally, the same change applies to the mention on p. 8 of RecGuide vol. 1
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 02 December 2020, 13:10:02
Volume 5, Catapult CPLT-K6 record sheet
-Change tech level from Standard to Advanced

Volume 5, Catapult CPLT-K6 record sheet
-Move AES critical slots below ELRM/15 critical slots

Volume 5, Marauder II MAD-10D record sheet
-Change tech level from Standard to Advanced

Volume 5, p.9 Marauder II MAD-8K record sheet
-Add (Advanced) next to "Technology Base: Inner Sphere"
-Change tech level on record sheet from Standard to Advanced

Volume 6, p.12 and Linebacker I record sheet
-Change BV to 1853

Volume 6, Marauder MAD-7R record sheet
-Change Right Torso armor to 24 (removing one pip), and increase Right Torso Rear armor to 8 (adding one pip)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 03 December 2020, 18:27:51
Dev Level Errata (from jymset)

Volume 5

Timber Wolf M record sheet: change era icon to Jihad.
Timber Wolf N record sheet: change era icon to Clan Invasion.

- - -

Volume 7

Stormcrow P record sheet: change era icon to Clan Invasion.

- - -

Volume 7
War Crow C record sheet
--Replace Left Arm ATM ammo in block 4-6, slot 1 with "Ammo (ATM 9 HE) 7"
--Replace Right Arm ATM ammo in block 4-6, slot 1 with "Ammo (ATM 9 ER) 7"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 04 December 2020, 21:31:30
RecGuide 8, Fire Moth R

Change BV from 1161 to 1160.

 - - -

RecGuide 9, Valkyrie introduction

"the Valkyrie changed its appearance and “ultimately even served Davion’s enemies."
Remove the quotation mark.

 - - -

RecGuide 9, CaptainThomas Michael Haase

Change the year of his raid from 3145 to 3146 (New Avalon fell in 3146, so him having the 'Mech in 3145 doesn't work).
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jymset on 14 December 2020, 17:08:29
RecGuide 5, MAD-8K, p. 9

Change "Technology Base: Inner Sphere" to "Technology Base: Inner Sphere (Advanced)"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Starbuck on 15 December 2020, 13:07:13
Volume 3:
Page 9, entry for BattleMaster C 3
Under Weapons and Ammo, two of the ER Medium Lasers are listed as rear-mounted.
The Record Sheet for the 'Mech does not reflect this. Either the entry on page 9 or the Record Sheet should be changed.

in addition:
because of the different facings of the lasers BV differs in TRO Section (p. 9) and RecSheet (2,532 vs 2,579)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Scotty on 18 December 2020, 16:30:14
Volume 10, Crucible 2 record sheet, pg 36.

There are two errors on this page.

1) there is no ammo for the LRM-15s on the record sheet.
2) the design is a whopping eight tons underweight.

Fix: unclear due to scope.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 18 December 2020, 17:01:23
DEV-LEVEL ERRATA (from jymset)

Volume 10

CRUCIBLE 2 Record Sheet
-Left + Right arms, block 4-6, slots 3-4: add "Artemis V FCS"
-Left + Right arms, block 4-6, slots 5-6: add four slots of "Ammo (LRM 15 Artemis V-capable) 8"
-Center Torso, block 4-6, slot 6: add "Coolant Pod"
-Change BV to 3598.

HIGHLANDER HGN-740
-Right arm, block 4-6, slot 4: add "PPC Capacitor"
-Right arm, block 4-6, slot 6: add "Light Ferro-Fibrous"
-Left torso, block 4-6, slot 5: add "CASE II"
-Left torso, block 4-6, slot 6: add "Light Ferro-Fibrous"
-Change BV to 2237.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Scotty on 18 December 2020, 17:20:53
One more error that needs to be corrected, based on that dev-level errata:

BV on the record sheet is 3104.  Should be 3598.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 18 December 2020, 17:23:59
One more error that needs to be corrected, based on that dev-level errata:

BV on the record sheet is 3104.  Should be 3598.

Yes, thank you.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: IronLichRich31 on 18 December 2020, 17:55:39
Volume 10 page 34. Highlander HGN-740 record sheet.

After adding the capacitor, the design is still one ton under weight.

Fix: Add Inner Sphere CASE II to the left torso as mentioned on page 13.


Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 18 December 2020, 19:43:06
VOLUME 10

Centurion CN10-D Record Sheet
--Replace BV with 1260.

- - - - -

VOLUME 10

Archer C Record Sheet
--Move two Heat Sinks from the Side Torsos to the Legs (reference Tuk:Supp for correct sheet)

- - - - -

VOLUME 1

Goliath C entry, p. 11, and corresponding record sheet
--Change BV to 2222.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 26 December 2020, 18:26:33
Volume 10, Hermit Crab, p. 5

Judging by the artwork, the "No Torso Twist" Design Quirk should be added.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kojak on 15 January 2021, 15:29:25
Volume 11

Phoenix Hawk, pg. 9

Large X-Pulse Laser RA 2 7
Medium Laser RA 1 1
Light Machine Gun RA 1 .5
Ammo (Light MG) 100 CT 1 .5
CASE II CT 1 1
Medium Laser LA 1 1
Light Machine Gun Shimafukuro LA 1 .5
4 Improved Jump Jets RT 8 4
4 Improved Jump Jets LT 8 4


Extraneous word appears to have been transposed in the middle of the second light machine gun, should be deleted.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kojak on 15 January 2021, 15:31:06
Volume 11

Horned Owl, pg. 6

"Strafing the encampment from the darkness Kerensky smiled on her when she hit an ammunition pallet, disabling half of the pirates’ ’Mechs."

There should be a comma after 'darkness'.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kojak on 15 January 2021, 15:32:29
Volume 11

Horned Owl, pg. 6

"A freeborn Rasalhagian Chloe Robertson gave up her surname for the chance to become a MechWarrior. More determined than skilled Chloe somehow managed to pass her Trial of Position and was assigned to the Fourteenth PGC. Placed in a vintage Horned Owl it was hoped the pulse lasers would enable her to hit something."

There should be commas after 'Rasalhagian', 'skilled' and 'Owl'.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 15 January 2021, 15:57:43
Volume 11

Record Sheet, Kit Fox J

Problem: Stats for Kit Fox J on page 12 reports 2 tons of UAC/5 ammo in the RA. Record Sheet only has 20 ammo points, only displays 1 critical slot for UAC/5 ammo.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 15 January 2021, 16:03:28
Volume 11

Record Sheet, Horned Owl (Peregrine) 6

Problem: The record sheet is 1 ton under mass. The armor on the record sheet is identical to that of the Horned Owl (Peregrine) (Standard). According to "Horned Owl (Peregrine)", "Variants" (p. 6), "Based on an ancient prototype which drops the jump jets for armor and a targeting computer..."

Solution: The Horned Owl (Peregrine) 7 has 1 ton more armor than the Horned Owl (Peregrine) (Standard). Replace the armor of the Horned Owl (Peregrine) 6 with that of the Horned Owl (Peregrine) 7.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 15 January 2021, 16:52:04
Volume 11

Kit Fox (Uller), p. 12

Misspelling: "Battle History", 1st Paragraph, 2nd Sentence: "Swift-moving scout Stars anchored by Kit Foxs were able to quickly isolate and annihilate the Davion forces."
Solution: Replace Foxs with Foxes or Foxes (depending upon italicization conventions for plural BattleMech names).
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 15 January 2021, 17:31:22
Volume 11

Ion Sparrow record sheets (all), pp. 14-18, "Weapon and Equipment Inventory" block

error:
Partial wing is assigned only to left torso
"1 Partial Wing LT — [E] — — — —"

correction:
Assign to left torso/right torso
"1 Partial Wing LT/RT — [E] — — — —"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Hussar2 on 15 January 2021, 20:48:06
Volume 11

Horned Owl write-up
Change Kapako to Kakapo (The flightless bird)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 16 January 2021, 14:59:10
Volume 11
Uller (Kit Fox) T, J, and V record sheets
--Change CT armor distribution to 9 points on the front Center Torso, 4 points on rear Center Torso.

- - -

Volume 11
Phoenix Hawk C 2 record sheet
--Add "Striker" role to record sheet
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 16 January 2021, 18:28:16
Volume 11

Uller (Kit Fox) T, J, and V record sheets
--Change "Battlemech Record Sheet" to "Omnimech Record Sheet."
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 17 January 2021, 00:48:54
Volume 11

Horned Owl (Peregrine) 7 "Shimafukuro" record sheet

-- Heat dissipation does not account for extra dissipation from Partial Wing.  Change Heat dissipation from 10 (20) to 10 (23)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Wrangler on 23 January 2021, 21:49:05
Volume 3:

Page 4 entry for Hierofalcon
Errant - CJF Factory Zone 4 planet is incorrect, Factory Hierofalcon entry says Alyina.  Planet shown in TRO: 3075 for the Jupiter & Objectives: Clans as being on Erewhon.

Correction - Change planet to Erewhon or add to fluff factory was moved.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kojak on 29 January 2021, 14:31:42
Volume 12, Shadow Hawk entry:

THE ERROR: "The joint Magistracy-Rim Commonwealth -7H carries on this tradition, marrying the best traits of the original SHD-2H with powerful new systems."

THE FIX: "The joint Magistracy-Rim Commonality -7H carries on this tradition, marrying the best traits of the original SHD-2H with powerful new systems."
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 29 January 2021, 15:20:08
Volume 12, Black Knight Record Sheet
Page 34

Error: Active Probe (Beagle) has a long range value of 3

Fix: Change Active Probe's long range value to 4
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 29 January 2021, 17:15:22
RG12
P4

Carrion Crow
In the Upper Right the box with the picture.
It misidentifies the Carrion Crow as a Light ‘Mech. It should say Medium ‘Mech based on its 40t weight
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 29 January 2021, 23:21:44
Volume 12

Record Sheet, Viper (Black Python)

Problem: As printed, the record sheet is 1 ton too light. The record sheet lists 12 Double Heat Sinks, while published versions of the Viper (Black Python) as far back as TRO:3055, p. 127 (FASA) have 13 Double Heat Sinks

Solution: Increase Double Heat Sinks to 13, adding 1 ton and bringing the total mass to 75 tons.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 30 January 2021, 08:25:06
Volume 12
Record Sheet: Shadow Hawk C

Problem: Battle Value indicates (Clan) CASE is installed, but record sheet does not show this. CASEless BV would be 1309 per SSW 0.7.5.

Solution: ??? One thing needs to be updated but not sure which.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jymset on 30 January 2021, 09:47:20
It does not have CASE, the BV needs fixing.

Thank you. :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 07 February 2021, 12:11:05
RecGuide 12
P.11

--Change "Ammo (AP Gauss) 40" location from LT to LA.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Known Glitch on 14 February 2021, 22:11:02
Volume 12, pg.8.

Shadow Hawk, Notable Mechs and Mechwarriors, Colonel Lori Kalmar-Carlyle

"Kalmar remains indelibly associated with Boss Lady.
This Shadow Hawk, captured by Kalmar on Verthandi
in 3025..."


Problem: The Shadow Hawk was actually a former Carlyle's Commandos mech that was captured and used by Grayson Carlyle on Trellwan in Decision at Thunder Rift and Verthandi in Mercenary's Star. It was given to Lori by Grayson after Verthandi to replace her destroyed Locust.

Solution:  Edit the quoted sentence to more accurately reflect Kalmar-Carlyle's acquisition of the mech.

Sources: Keith, Decision at Thunder Rift. Keith, Mercenary's Star. Keith, The Gray Death Legion pp. 10-11.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Maelwys on 24 April 2021, 11:54:02
Vol 13 pg 30

Dire Wolf (Daishi) X has an extra heat sink in RL. Remove it. Design is fine otherwise.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Dragon41673 on 24 April 2021, 20:03:25
Volume 14, Page 12 & 24

ERROR: Listed unit is Nova [Black Hawk] T...this is a completely different variant than the Black Hawk "Nova" T as listed in Record Sheets 3145 New Tech New Upgrades (RS218).

FIX: Rename one of the units to a different model designation.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Scotty on 24 April 2021, 20:11:21
Volume 14, Page 12 & 24

ERROR: Listed unit is Nova [Black Hawk] T...this is a completely different variant than the Black Hawk "Nova" T as listed in Record Sheets 3145 New Tech New Upgrades (RS218).

FIX: Rename one of the units to a different model designation.

Previously handled. (https://bg.battletech.com/forums/errata/record-sheets-3145/msg1628621/#msg1628621)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MarauderD on 25 April 2021, 13:59:36
Volume 14 Page 7:

OTL-8E Gyro should 4.5 tons as it is a Compact Gyro.  1.5 tons as listed would be XL Gyro, which it is not.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 06 May 2021, 23:30:18
Volume 2, Page 30

Error: ZEU-11S Active Probe (Beagle) is listed as having a long range of -

Correction: change long range value to 4.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 08 May 2021, 01:52:37
Volume 15
Page 14

Fire Falcon T does not have Supercharger listed in the Weapons and Equipment Inventory
Correction: Add Supercharger with location Center Torso to list

Volume 15
Page 16

Fire Falcon G  does not have Supercharger listed in the Weapons and Equipment Inventory
Correction: Add Supercharger with location Center Torso to list

Volume 15
Page 24

Black Lanner J does not have Supercharger listed in the Weapons and Equipment Inventory
Correction: Add Supercharger with location Left Torso to list
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Hussar2 on 08 May 2021, 10:24:29
Page 7
TDR-12R technology base should be mixed Inner Sphere (advanced)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 12 May 2021, 12:51:37
Volume 13, p. 12, Dire Wolf, 1st paragraph:

Quote: "Introduced in 3019..."

Problem: This appears to be a typo, as MUL and TRO:3050U, p. 144, state the Dire Wolf was introduced in 3010. The later date may also pose problems with Natasha Kerensky's discussion with Phelan re: piloting a Dire Wolf against the Jade Falcons in the "Blood of Keresnky" trilogy (I can not remember the page number), and if I remember correctly, there are several references to the introduction of the Dire Wolf in published biographies of Ulric Kerensky.

Solution: change 3019 to 3010.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 12 May 2021, 19:17:46
Volume 14, p. 6, Ostsol, Variants, 2nd paragraph:

Quote: "Another refit added triple-strength myomer. This variant, badged the -8E3, puts the ’Mech’s notable heat deficit to good use."

Problem: Typo, should read, "...puts the 'Mech's notable heat deficiency to good use."
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jymset on 15 May 2021, 18:37:01
Heads-up for an upcoming change in vol. 12's notable Shadow Hawk pilots.

MechWarrior Mordred, p. 8, will be removed when the PDF is corrected, and replaced with Sandusky Sorrell.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 21 May 2021, 15:02:58
Volume 15
P. 13 - Black Lanner F
--Change BV to 2,154.

- - -

Volume 16

Locust C record sheet: change era to Succession Wars

- - -

p.4, Battle History
...lance of rundown Marian Locusts...
...the lance’s surviving MechWarriors...

--Replace both instances of "lance" with "century"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Turaglas on 22 May 2021, 10:08:57
Volume 16

Locust C record sheet: change era to Succession Wars

- - -

p.4, Battle History
...lance of rundown Marian Locusts...
...the lance’s surviving MechWarriors...

--Replace both instances of "lance" with "century"

Adding to p4 battle history:

I think the century's surviving MechWarriors were posted to the Cohors Morituri for their failure would make more sense than the lance’s surviving MechWarriors were sold into slavery for their failure.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Starbuck on 22 May 2021, 10:30:53
Rec Guide 16

p. 9
Locust IIC

Internal Structure Endo Steel
Mass should be 1.5
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 04 June 2021, 16:31:02
Volume 17, p. 6
Crusader Notable 'Mechs and MechWarriors

error: Tai-i Harimander Singh

correction: Tai-i Harimandir Singh
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Karasu on 04 June 2021, 18:04:23
Volume 17, p. 32
Crusader 7M2 Record Sheet

error: Lacks a Role

correction:  Role: Brawler [I admit this is an informed guess].
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Baldur Mekorig on 05 June 2021, 12:36:00
Volume 17, p. 10
Bane (Kraken) entry

error: "10 Tpe 25 Ultra Autocannon/2"

correction:  "10 Type 25 Ultra Autocannon/2"


Volume 17, p. 12
CROSSBOW entry

error: "64 kph cruising"

correction:  "54 kph cruising"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mbear on 07 June 2021, 07:53:57
Multiple text formatting and spelling issues from multiple volumes.

Volume 1, 1st printing, p. 13, Pack Hunter entry.
Italicize Hermes in first sentence.

Volume 8, 1st printing, p. 8 Rifleman entry, Variants section, third paragraph, first sentence: Rifleman  in Rifleman C needs to be italicized.

Volume 9, 1st printing, p. 4 Valkyrie entry, second full paragraph has an opening quotation mark before the word ultimately. This should be removed.

Volume 9, 1st printing, p. 10 Inferno entry, Battle History section, second paragraph, second sentence. Infernos needs to be italicized.

Volume 9, 1st printing, p. 11 Inferno entry. Above Alternate Configuration C configuration, the "Weapons and Ammo", "Location", "Critical", "Tonnage" headings are repeated. Should probably be removed.

Volume 9, 1st printing, p. 13 Executioner entry, first paragraph, last word: "Touman" needs to be italicized and lowercase.

Volume 9, 1st printing, p. 13 Executioner entry, Battle History section, first paragraph, last sentence
Quote
...from the Eighteenth Battle Cluster that held the breech from...
"Breech" is incorrect. Should be "breach"
Quote
...from the Eighteenth Battle Cluster that held the breach from...

Volume 10, 1st printing, p. 6, Battle History, paragraph 2, last sentence:

Quote
Star Captain Mark Radick was glad to claim such a brave warrior as his bondsman.

"Mark" should not be italicized.

Volume 10, 1st printing, p. 10, Crucible entry, Notable 'Mechs and MechWarriors, Star Commander Dimitri Kerensky
Quote
...Kerensky and his Crucible detered several ...
"Detered" is misspelled. Should read "deterred".
Quote
...Kerensky and his Crucible deterred several ...
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Deadborder on 07 June 2021, 18:35:11
Volume 17, pg 4

"Bander’s attempts to emulate a clawed Crusader from Solaris resulted in the finely-tuned CRD-9BR, a speed demon with an XXL engine."

Assuming that this is meant to be a reference to the Crusader Crael, then it's from Antallos, not Solaris. "Crusading" Crael's biography on the next page mentions "He resurfaced, now sporting an eyepatch, on Solaris VII as a color commentator in 3059. Crael could no longer pilot a ’Mech"

Fix: Change "Solaris" to "Antallos"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 18 June 2021, 18:02:47
RG 18, page 8
Error: Under Variants, first paragraph. "The -7R..." should be -7K as discussed earlier in the paragraph.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 18 June 2021, 20:52:03
vol. 18, p. 10

Captain Cassandra Belmont

Should be Cassandra Balmont (https://characters.battletech.com/canon-characters/cassandra-balmont)?
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jasonf on 22 June 2021, 21:06:41
RG 18, page 8
RG 18, page 8
Error: Under Variants, first paragraph. "The -7R..." should be -7K as discussed earlier in the paragraph.

In addition to above, factory on Marduk should be Victory Industries, not Kallon. Also, it is not clear what the phrase in italics is meant to convey:
Quote
The -7K was so spectacularly successful that subsequent variants were developed even after the Victory [Industries] factory on Marduk was upgraded to Project Phoenix standards.

1. Is it meant to imply that the WVR-7K remained in production even as the WVR-8K and WVR-8C Phoenix upgrades were produced on Marduk?
--If so, then italics should read something like "it remained in production even after"
2. Or is it meant to imply that the WVR-8C is was a high-priority upgrade of the WVR-7K because of the latter's success?
--If so, then italics could read something like "a subsequent variant was developed from it when" or "it was a top priority for an upgrade when"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 24 June 2021, 17:30:59
vol. 16, p. 10

Star Commander Oryan Winters

Should be Oryan Winter (https://characters.battletech.com/canon-characters/oryan-winter)? (no 's')



vol. 15, p. 8

MechWarrior Johnny Tessel

Should be Johny Tessel (https://characters.battletech.com/canon-characters/johny-tessel)? (one 'n')
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 24 June 2021, 18:36:16
vol. 16, p. 10

Star Commander Oryan Winters

Should be Oryan Winter (https://characters.battletech.com/canon-characters/oryan-winter)? (no 's')

Can't speak for the other name issues, but this change was necessary to give the Clan character an actual extant Bloodname.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kojak on 10 August 2021, 13:52:18
Volume 5, pg. 4:

"She has already once challenged Star Colonel Isis Bekker-Florala for command of the Fifth Bear Guards"

Isis Bekker-Florala is a Galaxy Commander, not a Star Colonel, and has been in all prior sources. This is confirmed in the ilClan sourcebook (pg. 125), which postdates RG5 in-universe.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 28 August 2021, 20:57:22
Volume 5, p.10

Replace "Jace Kartwright" with "Jayce Kartwright"

- - -

Volume 5, p.10

Replace "Miles Conz" with "Myles Conz"

- - -

Volume 10, p.10

Replace "Edward "Joe" Brevan" with "Edward "Joe" Bevan"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 30 August 2021, 09:26:13
Volume 17, p.12

Replace "64 kph cruising" with "54 kph cruising"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 30 August 2021, 15:06:30
Volume 14, p. 10

Replace "Sebastian Franke" with "Sergej Kharpov"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mbear on 01 September 2021, 06:11:59
Volume 17, first printing, page 10. Last sentence of first paragraph

Quote
...allows the Bane to compete with OmniMechs of similarly mass.

Similarly should be replaced by "similar"


Quote
...allows the Bane to compete with OmniMechs of similar mass.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: NeonWolf on 08 September 2021, 12:51:47
Vol. 17 pg.12 & pg.16

Crossbow T Variant illegal build
Weight listed for both sets of the 7x SRM 2(I-OS) is 1.75 tons when should be 3.5 tons for each, making this variant 3.5 tons over weight.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 08 September 2021, 13:26:39
Vol. 17 pg.12 & pg.16

Crossbow T Variant illegal build
Weight listed for both sets of the 7x SRM 2(I-OS) is 1.75 tons when should be 3.5 tons for each, making this variant 3.5 tons over weight.
Not errata, Clan iOS SRM-2s weight .25 tons each, so total of 3.5 tons is correct and it is not overweight. (If you used SSW, it hasn't been updated with correct launcher masses.)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: NeonWolf on 08 September 2021, 14:44:08
Not errata, Clan iOS SRM-2s weight .25 tons each, so total of 3.5 tons is correct and it is not overweight. (If you used SSW, it hasn't been updated with correct launcher masses.)

My mistake, thanks.  I was indeed using SSW and thought I had the latest data file
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Ruger on 15 October 2021, 19:25:40
Recognition Guide 19
Page 4, Notable ‘Mechs and MechWarriors section; Star Captain Theron entry states “The two Horse ‘Mechs used their speed…”.

The bolded section should be replaced with “Bear”.

Ruger
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Wrangler on 15 October 2021, 19:46:39
Recognition Guide 19
Page 19
Issue: Record sheet on top says BattleMech Record Sheet for the Courgar G, while the rest of entries for this machine say OmniMech
Correction: Unless found to be a Standard BattleMech, the Record Sheet name should read OmniMech Record Sheet.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Scotty on 15 October 2021, 20:36:02
Recognition Guide Vol 19
Page 7

Issue: SCP-2N Scorpion readout describes the maximum speed as "97 kph, 129 kph with MASC".  There is not MASC on this design, it has a Supercharger instead.

Correction: Replace mention of MASC with Supercharger.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Ask Eklund on 16 October 2021, 01:40:29
Recognition Guide Vol. 19

Pg. 22 and continuing through all Record Sheets for the Rime Otter.

Are the arm actuators correct on all configurations? If nothing else the artwork does not depict hands on the Rime Otter Prime.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 18 October 2021, 13:43:23
Recognition Guide Vol. 19

Pg. 22 and continuing through all Record Sheets for the Rime Otter.

Are the arm actuators correct on all configurations? If nothing else the artwork does not depict hands on the Rime Otter Prime.

Dev-level Errata:

Rime Otter Prime record sheet
--Remove lower arm and hand actuators from both the left and right arms.

All other configurations have the correct actuators.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mordel on 22 October 2021, 22:01:34
Recognition Guide Vol 19 (pg. 15)

Issue: Spider SDR-9M record sheet is listed as Standard. However, VSP lasers never became standard, ad remained advanced.

Correction: Change Rules Level from Standard to Advanced
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jymset on 23 October 2021, 17:33:59
Recognition Guide Vol 19 (pg. 15)

Issue: Spider SDR-9M record sheet is listed as Standard. However, VSP lasers never became standard, ad remained advanced.

Correction: Change Rules Level from Standard to Advanced

Sorry, mordel...

Errata for VSPL's tech advancement to TL. (https://bg.battletech.com/forums/errata/technical-readout-prototypes/msg1286712/#msg1286712)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Xotl on 25 October 2021, 21:44:30
Volume 14, page 6 (Ostsol):

observers were surprised to see that Clan Sea
Fox recently returned to this classic, after acquired plans
from Kong Interstellar in exchange for

Should be "acquiring"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kojak on 29 October 2021, 19:38:01
RecGuide Vol. 20, pg. 10

"Many within his Cluster disparage his lack Rasalhagian roots, and constant trials eventually overcame his fragile Viper."

There should be an "of" between "lack" and "Rasalhagian"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 09 November 2021, 22:16:11
RecGuide 17, p. 8, Amarok entry.
Variants subsection.

Replace "...along with twelve additional tons..." with "...along with nine and a half additional tons..."
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mbear on 10 November 2021, 08:50:53
RecGuide Volume 20, 1st printing, p. 11, Mastodon alternate configuration D
Left Arm LRM ammo is listed as Ammo (LRM) 8.

Fix:
Change to
Ammo (LRM 15) 8 to match right arm ammo.



RecGuide 20, 1st printing, p. 12.

"The Hellion is a fearsome..."

Hellion needs to be italicized.



Recognition Guide 19, first printing, p 9, Star Commander Adam:
"...Adam was given his own Scorpion and..."

Scorpion needs to be italicized.

Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kojak on 13 November 2021, 03:56:58
RecGuide 21, pg. 8

Notable Pilots, John Sandison Entry

'the mad Alisendar Gryn"

Should be Gyrn, not Gryn
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Wrangler on 14 November 2021, 14:56:39
RecGuide 21, pg. 2

Illustrations: Aaron Harris, Harri Kallio, Chris Lowry, Anthony
Scroggins

Should be Chris Lowrey
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 15 November 2021, 10:20:10
Recognition Guide 17

Crusader CRD-9BR
--Change BV from 1615 to 1653.

- - -

Recognition Guide 21

Kontio
--Change BV from 1875 to 1912.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Chinless on 30 November 2021, 10:19:26
Dev Level Errata:

Rec Guide 13, p10.

Manufacturer is listed as Wolf Empire and Primary Factory as Kallon Industries (Thermopolis)

Manufacturer should be Kallon Industries, while the Primary Factory should be Thermopolis.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Ruger on 03 December 2021, 17:57:38
Recognition Guide 22, page 5

Issue: Stat block for the Doom Courser ("Weight and Space Allocation" section) says the quad turret is in the left torso, but all configurations and Fixed Equipment section indicate it is in the right torso.

Solution: Adjust the Weight and Space section to match the rest of the stats.

Ruger

Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 04 December 2021, 13:56:51
Recognition Guide 22, Jade Phoenix Prime record sheet

Change Rules Level from "Standard" to "Advanced".
Change Role from "Advanced" to "Sniper"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 24 December 2021, 16:43:13
Recognition Guide 24, Alpha Wolf A record sheet.

-Remove instances of CASE II in the Left and Right Torso.
-Add a Coolant Pod in Block 4-6, Slot 2 of the Left Torso.
-Change BV to 3435, both on record sheet and in entry on p.7
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 24 December 2021, 19:00:14
Rec Guide 24.

Pg 12

Notable pilot Jorge: if he was defending against the bears why would the HH trial for him from the bears?
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 25 December 2021, 11:15:52
Rec Guide 23

Record Sheets, GRN-D-01-X Grand Crusader appears to be 1 ton too massive, assuming Artemis IV is also placed in the turret. Please check my math, and correct me if Artemis is not in the turret.

S.gage
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Baldur Mekorig on 25 December 2021, 11:41:02
Recognition Guide 23, RJN-301-F FUJIN (RAIJIN) entry

Add "2" to the "Lord’s Light" Extended-Range PPC.


Quote
"For firepower, Independence kept the -101-C’s triple-mount of ER medium lasers, while two SRM-6 launchers"
Record sheet shows only one SRM-6 launcher.

Recognition Guide 23, STAR CRUSADER (GRAND CRUSADER)

Remove "with CASE II" from
Quote
Armor: Forging SE09B Ferro-Fibrous with CASE II
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Hammer on 26 December 2021, 15:28:51
RecGuide 24 - Flashman RS (pg 25)

Left torso has gap at position 4-6 slot 3, Reflective should be moved up I believe.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GoldBishop on 27 December 2021, 17:51:07
submitting per request (found here: https://bg.battletech.com/forums/errata/errata-discussion-thread/msg1792438/#msg1792438 )

RecGuide Vol 24, Elemental III p.14-16 "Record Sheets with Inconsistent BV between Points"

With each variant - AP Gauss, Flamer, and MicroPulse - the Battle Values appear to be "jumbled" and inconsistent with each other on their own respective pages.  Upon further investigation, these values appear to coincide with "Randomly Rolled Skills" and are not representative of the base equipment BV for these units.

recommend the following corrections to BV by page/variant
p.14  [AP Gauss]:  532/76  (Points 1-5)
p.15  [Flamer]: 359/51  (Points 1,2,3,5)
p.16  [MicroPulse]: 435/62 (Points 1-5)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 27 December 2021, 18:07:34
Rec Guide 23

Record Sheets, GRN-D-01-X Grand Crusader appears to be 1 ton too massive, assuming Artemis IV is also placed in the turret. Please check my math, and correct me if Artemis is not in the turret.

S.gage

Developer-level Errata

Recognition Guide 23, Grand Crusader GRN-D-01-X record sheet.
--Delete head-mounted Medium Laser.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 02 January 2022, 03:15:14
Rec Guide 24

Record Sheet AS8-KE

Error: Record Sheet lists Tech Base as Mixed.  Record Sheet does not show any Clan components on mech.
Solution: Change Tech Base to Inner Sphere
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Maelwys on 02 January 2022, 11:55:02
Rec Guide 23

Star Python TRO and RS don't match. TRO has two iHML and 1 ERML, RS has 1 iHML and 2 ERML
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 02 January 2022, 12:07:42
Rec Guide 23

Star Python TRO and RS don't match. TRO has two iHML and 1 ERML, RS has 1 iHML and 2 ERML

Dev-level fix: the TR entry is correct. Replace Right Arm ER Medium Laser with an Improved Heavy Medium Laser.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Maelwys on 05 January 2022, 18:44:35
Way back...

Vol 2 - Stone Rhino (Behemoth) 6. In 3055Uu, it has 3 FF critical slots in the RA, 4 in the LA. In Vol 2 RGiC it has 4 in the RA, 3 in the LA. Is this intentional, or needs to be reported?
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Maelwys on 05 January 2022, 18:50:36
Volume 1
Page 5, along with the Griffin GRF-3N Record Sheet.

Error: The written layout for the variant and the record sheet have conflicting locations for the placements of four of the jump jets (side torsos vs legs).

Correction: Place the jump jets in the side torsos on the record sheet.

Is this an official fix? And how is it done? I suggest placing 1 ES and FF crit in each leg from the torsos, and slip the jump jets in at the top and push everything down.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 05 January 2022, 19:14:10
Is this an official fix? And how is it done? I suggest placing 1 ES and FF crit in each leg from the torsos, and slip the jump jets in at the top and push everything down.

This is official, yes. One endo, one ferro.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Zeruel on 06 January 2022, 11:31:04
Rec Guide 19
p.4

Error:
"The two Horse ’Mechs used their speed to duck in and out of cover"

Fix:
"The two Bear ’Mechs used their speed to duck in and out of cover"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: ShroudedSciuridae on 13 January 2022, 23:22:57
RG 21, p. 10

Regent showing "Durallex Heavy Special" Armor, likely intended to be the ubiquitous "Durallex Special Heavy."
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 03 February 2022, 01:02:50
RG 19, pages 11 and 33

Page 11 shows Iron Cheetah Prime BV as 2866, record sheet on page 33 shows it as 3155 (as does the MUL).  Solution: check BV for Iron Cheetah Prime, replace the value that is in error.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 21 April 2022, 18:16:58
RecGuide 24
Page 34: Record Sheet Atlas: AS-7S3-DC
Error: Mech is listed as having a Command Console but does not have the added table for the Commander.
Correction: Add Commander table below Pilot table
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mindw on 28 May 2022, 08:17:31
VERSION: RecGuide 11 - 1st Printing
LOCATION: GARGOYLE (MAN O’ WAR) configuration F at Page 13 and RS at page 40
THE ERROR: The variant is under weight by 0.5 tons. It is likely caused by the Heavy Flamer errata in the 5th BM printing which reduced the Clan Heavy Flamer from 1.5 tone to 1.0.
THE CORRECTION: Add an ER Small Laser or a Light TAG to fill up the spare 0.5 ton?



Gargoyle (Man O' War)

Mass: 80 tons
Tech Base: Clan
Chassis Config: Biped Omnimech
Rules Level: Tournament Legal
Era: Succession Wars
Tech Rating/Era Availability: F/X-E-E-D
Production Year: 2945
Dry Cost: 24,127,500 C-Bills
Total Cost: 24,127,500 C-Bills
Battle Value: 1,026

Chassis: Unknown Standard
Power Plant: Unknown 400 Fusion XL Engine
Walking Speed: 54.0 km/h
Maximum Speed: 86.4 km/h
Jump Jets: None
    Jump Capacity: 0 meters
Armor: Unknown Ferro-Fibrous
Armament:
    21.5 tons of pod space.

================================================================================
Equipment           Type                         Rating                   Mass 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Internal Structure: Standard                     122 points                8.00
Engine:             XL Fusion Engine             400                      26.50
    Walking MP: 5
    Running MP: 8
    Jumping MP: 0
Heat Sinks:         Double Heat Sink             16(32)                    6.00
Gyro:               Standard                                               4.00
Cockpit:            Standard                                               3.00
    Actuators:      L: SH+UA    R: SH+UA
Armor:              Ferro-Fibrous                AV - 211                 11.00
    Armor Locations: 1 HD, 2 LT, 2 RT, 1 LL, 1 RL

                                                      Internal       Armor     
                                                      Structure      Factor     
                                                Head     3            9         
                                        Center Torso     25           30       
                                 Center Torso (rear)                  10       
                                           L/R Torso     17           24       
                                    L/R Torso (rear)                  10       
                                             L/R Arm     13           23       
                                             L/R Leg     17           24       



================================================================================
Loadout Name: F                                              Cost: 26,167,063
Tech Rating/Era Availability: F/X-X-F-E                       BV2: 1,894

Equipment           Type                         Rating                   Mass 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    CASE Locations: CT, LA, RA                                             0.00
    Actuators:      L: SH+UA    R: SH+UA

Equipment                                 Location    Heat    Critical    Mass 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Imp. Hvy Large Laser                         RA        18        3         4.00
2 ATM-3s                                     RA        4         4         3.00
Rotary AC/2                                  LA        1         4         8.00
Heavy Flamer                                 CT        5         1         1.00
@ATM-3 (40)                                  RA        -         2         2.00
@Rotary AC/2 (90)                            LA        -         2         2.00
@Heavy Flamer (10)                           CT        -         1         1.00
                                            Free Critical Slots: 23

Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mordel on 28 May 2022, 11:50:01
VERSION: RecGuide 11 - 1st Printing
LOCATION: GARGOYLE (MAN O’ WAR) configuration F at Page 13 and RS at page 40
THE ERROR: The variant is under weight by 0.5 tons. It is likely caused by the Heavy Flamer errata in the 5th BM printing which reduced the Clan Heavy Flamer from 1.5 tone to 1.0.
THE CORRECTION: Add an ER Small Laser or a Light TAG to fill up the spare 0.5 ton?

The errata document reduces the ER Flamer (not the Heavy Flamer) from 1.5 to 1.0 tons. The Heavy Flamer has always been listed as 1 ton in BMM, but that does not match up with the TO:AUE, which still says 1.5 tons and no errata mentioning it needs to be updated. So I'm thinking the 1 ton in BMM is the actual errata, and should be changed to 1.5.


Xotl: Correct, and fixed in the next BMM printing.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: ShroudedSciuridae on 03 July 2022, 16:02:48
Recognition Guide: ilClan, vol. 11, p. 4

"Elements of Gyrfalcon Eyrie deployed with the Ion Sparrow during Delta Galaxy’s assault on Coventry in 3148. Following the carnage at Whitting, the Lyrans code-named it Butcherbird for its various configurations’ abilities to skewer infantry."

Issue: Gyrfalcon Eyrie hasn't existed on deployment tables since 3085 (FM 3085, p. 126), and it was already established this was a Trinary from the First Falcon Striker Cluster and elements of Ninth Falcon Talon (Shattered Fortress p. 50 & The Anvil, ch. 4).

Correction: Change Gyrfalcon Eyrie to Ninth Falcon Talon, in keeping with their Mongol leanings versus the First Falcon Striker.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: ShroudedSciuridae on 01 August 2022, 16:33:41
Volume 16

Page 7, Peter Knopf
"His actions would have set him on the fast track for promotion had his own regiment not chosen to betray the Commonwealth a few months later."

Issue: Ambiguity.  The initial action was June 3147 (Shattered Fortress pp. 42-44) and then a stalemate settled in until January 3148 (Shattered Fortress pp. 47-48).  The "a few months later" seems to point to Jan 3148 when it instead points to June 3148 defection to Timbuktu Collective (Shatter Fortress p. 48 sidebar)

Correction: Change "a few months later" to "a year later"

------------------
Volume 13, page 13

"When Huntsman Stables offered to fund a heist of Zellbrigen Stables’s hangars, Johnson was desperate enough to accept."

Issue: Huntsmen Stables

Correction: Change to Huntsmen
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jymset on 12 October 2022, 08:47:43
[Developer edit]
Volume 14:
Griffin, p. 4 (and, as it happens, p. 5)

Cut the notable pilot Felton Kel entirely. The entry will appear unchanged with a different 'Mech.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Wrangler on 28 October 2022, 15:56:43
Volume 25

Page 24 entry for Demolisher Heavy Tank (Reinforced)
Errant - No indications other than it's name of the variant what type armor is on the vehicle

Correction - Add Reinforced Armor on record sheet.  Players can dispute it has it or not unless looking a the RecGuide or future sources fluff.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 28 October 2022, 15:57:02
Recognition Guide 25, page 9

CLN-8V Chameleon stat block:

Issue: Cruising Speed is listed as 75 kph, Maximum Speed is listed as 118 kph.

Correction: Chane Cruising speed to 64 kph and Maximum Speed to 97 kph to match its 6/9/6 movement.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MarauderD on 28 October 2022, 17:07:02
Recognition Guide, Volume 25.

Page 14:  Pegasus Scout Hover Tank Record Sheet

Description says it has 2 tons of ammo for the MML for "long and short range options" but the record sheet has only LRM ammo listed.

Correction:  List SRM and LRM Ammo for the MML 3 launchers
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 30 October 2022, 00:39:42
Recognition Guide, Vol 25, Record Sheet for CLN-9V Chameleon

Problem: The Critical Table for the CLN-9V Chameleon includes "Reinforced" on critical 4 of the Head internal structure in light font.

Solution: Though not having any effect on game play, Reinforced structure does not require criticals, and this block should read "Roll Again" in light font.

S.gage
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: tassa_kay on 11 November 2022, 17:50:10
Recognition Guide, Vol 26, Page 10 (Naga II entry)

Problem: In the Notable Mechs and MechWarriors entry for Luthor Johns, the final word on the page ("remembrances") should be capitalized, as it is a proper noun in Clan nomenclature.

Solution: Capitalize "Remembrances".
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 12 November 2022, 00:03:47
Recognition Guide Volume 26, STY-4C Starslayer Record Sheet:

Problem: The STY- is listed with a lower arm actuator on the Right Arm. All previous record sheets for the chassis lack lower arm actuators in the right arm. Technical Readout artwork for the STC- appears to show a 'Mech with no lower arm actuators in the right arm, too.

Solutions:

1. There is no problem! The STC-4C diverges from the previous Starslayers and it has a lower arm actuator on the Right Arm.
2. Remove the lower arm actuator to make the record sheet consistent with the apparent art and earlier variants of the chassis.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 13 November 2022, 10:32:03
RecGuide 26

Condor (LAC) record sheet.
-Replace XL engine with a standard engine.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Ruger on 15 November 2022, 06:56:35
RecGuide 26. Page 4 Condor Ultra stat block lists engine as 165 Fuel Cell with a cruising speed of 86 kph and a Maximum Speed of 129 kph.

Issue: page 5 lists engine type as 215 Fuel Cell, with a Cruising Speed of 9 (97.2 kph) and a Maximum Speed of 14 (151.2 kph).

Solution: correct stat block on page 4 to match page 5 and record sheet.

Ruger
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 16 November 2022, 14:12:18
RecGuide 26

p.11, Naga II Space Allocation table
--Move Endo Steel critical allocated to the Head location to the Center Torso.
--Change Spaces Remaining in both the Head and the Center Torso to 1.

Naga II C and W record sheets
--Move Endo Steel critical in the Head to the Center Torso location.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: ShroudedSciuridae on 19 November 2022, 13:41:29
RG16, p. 8 Locust IIC

"an overconfident Locust IIC MechWarrior in Clan Wolf’s Beta Galaxy led his combined-arms recon Star too far ahead and blundered into a lightning company of the First Royal Guards."
Issue:  These two units fought in different engagements, separated by the snarl of Seth Marsden Ave.
Correction: Either replace Beta Galaxy with Alpha Galaxy, or replace First Royal Guards with a unit in Tharkad City like Second Royal Guards.

"Calibos now seeks a long-lost Brian Cache in the Chainelane Isles"
Issue: Brian Cache's are a distinctly SLDF-in-exile creation not present outside the Homeworlds.
Correction:  Replace with Castle Brian or Star League-cache

"After Loremaster Kalara Yeh was killed along with Calibos’s Trinary commander in the overwhelming Hansa assault, he took command of the stunned Fifth"
Issue: Contradicted by OTP: Hanseatic Crusade pp. 12, 21, 31 which states Star Colonel Qelli Kirov assumed command. Keshik and Galaxy formations typically have a Star Colonel Aide position which doesn't command their own Cluster, though it is unclear if the assumption of command following a fatality would pass to the Aide or a Cluster commander. Unknown if Qelli Kirov was the Seeker Keshik Aide or a Cluster commander.  Also appears to contradict Spotlight On: Schmidt's Petraries pp. 9-10 which places only Seeker Keshik on scene, not 5th Seeker.
Correction: Replace with "he took temporary command" or "took command of the stunned Trinary" depending on the organizational level a presumptive-Star Commander would assume command of.  Possibly replace 5th Seeker with Seeker Keshik
Correction #2: Replace  "Calibos’s" with  "Calibos’"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Wrangler on 25 November 2022, 16:17:20
Volume 27

Page 13,43 entry for Gunslinger GUN-3ERD
Errant - Fluff for unit indicates it is fitted with a Clan XL Fusion Engine, which is a sticking point of the entry for the 3ERD. However, Record Sheet does not indicate the unit has Clan Engine or Clan Heat Sinks (in engine).  Additionally, uncertain if -102 unallocated armor points (using MegaMekLab) issue.  Armor is Ballistic-Reinforced Armor type, but armor protection is same as the original 1ERD.

Correction - Note Clan XL Fusion Engine or XL Fusion Engine (C) on record sheet and Add missing Ballistic-Reinforced Armor on record sheet. 
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 26 November 2022, 00:18:47
Volume 27

Pg 7

In the weapons and ammo section the Galleon has TAG listed as 0.5 tons. Either swap to light tag or correct the tonnage. Not sure which is correct

If it is supposed to be light TAG the record sheet needs to be adjusted too.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 26 November 2022, 08:27:25
Volume 27

Pg 7

In the weapons and ammo section the Galleon has TAG listed as 0.5 tons. Either swap to light tag or correct the tonnage. Not sure which is correct

If it is supposed to be light TAG the record sheet needs to be adjusted too.

Errata:
Change TAG tonnage to 1 ton.
Change armor tonnage to 7 tons (point value remains the same).

No other errata required. Unit remains legal as-is.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 26 November 2022, 08:34:06
Volume 27

Page 13,43 entry for Gunslinger GUN-3ERD
Errant - Fluff for unit indicates it is fitted with a Clan XL Fusion Engine, which is a sticking point of the entry for the 3ERD. However, Record Sheet does not indicate the unit has Clan Engine or Clan Heat Sinks (in engine).  Additionally, uncertain if -102 unallocated armor points (using MegaMekLab) issue.  Armor is Ballistic-Reinforced Armor type, but armor protection is same as the original 1ERD.

Correction - Note Clan XL Fusion Engine or XL Fusion Engine (C) on record sheet and Add missing Ballistic-Reinforced Armor on record sheet.

No errata required. The Clan XL engine is indicated through the number of criticals on the record sheet.
I'm also what you mean by -102 unallocated armor points. Armor protection appears correct to me; the unit carries 20.5 tons of B-R armor, giving it 246 points of protection (two fewer points than the -1ERD, with both shaved from the rear center torso location).

Feel free to take this point to the errata discussion thread if I seem to have overlooked something.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GreekFire on 26 November 2022, 09:29:12
RG25

Vindicator Record Sheet
--Move 2 jump jets (one from each leg) to the Center Torso.
--Move CT Heavy Ferro-Fibrous critical to the Right Leg.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: ShroudedSciuridae on 26 November 2022, 12:11:48
Volume 7, p. 12

"Alula Australis...defending Eleventh Triarii"
Issue:  Wrong Eleventh, this was the Eleventh Principes Guards under Colonel Randolph Abasi (Shattered Fortress, pp. 91 & 144).  This same error was spotted by Wrangler for the Dominator ( https://bg.battletech.com/forums/errata/recognition-guide-ilclan-all-volumes/msg1645878/#msg1645878 )
Correction:  Change to Eleventh Principes Guards.  Alternatively, change Shattered Fortress &  RG10 p. 6 to the Eleventh Triarii Protectors under Colonel Jens Scholz if the recurring nature means this is a retcon.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 26 November 2022, 22:04:54
Volume 27, Page 6, GAL-106 GALLEON LIGHT TANK entry

Error: Under Armor, it lists Riese-675 Hardened with CASE.  The tank does not have CASE listed on page 7 or in its record sheet on page 19, nor does it possess any explosive equipment that could make use of CASE.

Suggested Correction: remove "with CASE" from the armor listing.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 27 November 2022, 04:37:45
RG 27

Pg11/32

Patton (XL)

Page 11 lists Artemis IV attached to the MML5
Page 32 does not list the MML5 as having an attached Artemis module (while the Axel IICs both have their Artemis listed)

I wouldn’t have noticed unless the ammo was listed as Artemis compatible
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 27 November 2022, 20:05:06
RG25
Page 4
Bulldog Medium Tank (ERLL)
NOTABLE VEHICLES AND CREW

Error: Major Dan Sose

Correction: According to the canon character list, this should be Don Sose. (Confirmed by GreekFire)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: ShroudedSciuridae on 03 December 2022, 13:14:56
vol 3, p. 10

Force Commander Gerald Cameron-Jones
Issue: Force Commanders command battalions. He commanded the 1st Regulan Hussars regiment prior to retiring as a Colonel (FM:FWL p. 106, FM3145FWL p. 28)
Correction: Replace Force Commander with Colonel
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Baldur Mekorig on 10 December 2022, 18:00:52
vol 28, p. 6

LT-MOB-25F MOBILE LONG TOM ARTILLERY
Issue: Unit stats mention "Armor: StarSlab/1 Ferro-Fibrous", but the stats block shows CASE
Correction: Add "with CASE" to the "Armor: StarSlab/1 Ferro-Fibrous" part.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: BlackLanner05 on 14 December 2022, 01:32:27
Vol. 27 pg. 10 typo: "The two tanks became strong sellers whose performance outweighed complaints about the use expensive fusion reactors in vehicles"

Correction: Add the word "of" after the word use
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Sartris on 24 December 2022, 00:34:14
PDF, pg 29

Problem: SturmFeur (Steiner) does not list Artemis IV for the MML-9s

Solution: Add a pair of Artemis IV FCS to the turret.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: hf22 on 01 January 2023, 19:45:34
RG27
Page 6
GAL-106 Galleon Light Tank
BATTLE HISTORY

Error: Refers to "Duchess Humphreys herself publicly implored her people to return to civility" during the 3140 Great Galleon War within the Duchy of Andurien.

Correction: As at 3140, the reference should either to be Duke Humphreys (as Ari Humphreys was Duke as at 3140), or Duchess Centrella (if his wife Ilsa Centrella is intended).
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: pokefan548 on 06 January 2023, 15:13:04
Vol. 29 — Dragoon Battle Armor (WD) Record Sheet

The WD Star is listed as a Taurian/Calderon Maniple. Change "Maniple" to "Star".

For future I.S. armors organized into Clan Stars, note that in your MegaMek dev environment you should modify "megameklab/megameklab/src/megameklab/printing/PrintBattleArmor.java/", line 167.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Baldur Mekorig on 06 January 2023, 18:51:41
RG29
Pages 4 and 5
The Fusion Engine Rating should be "155" instead of "130".
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Baldur Mekorig on 07 January 2023, 09:08:18
RG29
Dervish entry, page 13
Second paragraph, 8th line, it should say "Huesos Dentados" instead of "Hueso Dentados". "Dentados" is the plural of "dentado".
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mordel on 07 January 2023, 15:48:25
RG28
Page 34
Cicada CDA-4A

Issue: Listed as Standard, but Re-engineered Lasers were Advanced in IO and never became standard
Correction: Change to Advanced
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jasonf on 14 January 2023, 20:46:18
RG29
Pp. 25-27 (record sheets)

Issue: Mismatch between Eulus' omni configurations' unit roles on the record sheets and the roles listed in the writeup. Writeup looks correct.
Corrections (for record sheets):
Eurus MBT Prime -- Role should be Sniper (not Brawler)
Eurus MBT A -- Role should be Skirmisher (not Brawler)
Eurus MBT B -- Role should be Brawler (not Sniper)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 16 January 2023, 17:09:29
ilClan Recognition Guide 01, updated

Record Sheet, GRF-6R

Problem: Tech Base is listed as "Mixed". There appear to be no Clan components on the GRF-6R.

Solution: 1. Change Tech Base to "Inner Sphere"
2. Exchange the ER small laser (IS) with an ER small laser (Clan), updating range and damage. This will change the BV as well.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 16 January 2023, 17:59:32
ilClan Recognition Guide 01, original and updated

Goliath C

Problem (?): Solaris Skunk Werks reports the BV 2.0 for the Goliath C is 2,227. Both sources have the BV 2.0 at 2,222.

Solution: I may have missed something. Alternatively, although it is accurate most of the time, SSW is not perfect. Here is the BV calculation:

Code: [Select]
Mech Name:   Goliath C                                 Tonnage:    80
Rules Level: Experimental Tech (has not been updated)  Total Cost: 9,626,500
Tech Base:   Mixed                                     Total BV:   2,227

Item                                            DefBV     OffBV             Cost
Internal Structure - Standard                  195         0           32,000.00
Engine - Fusion Engine                           0         0        1,280,000.00
Gyro - Compact Gyro                             40         0        1,800,000.00
Cockpit - Standard                               0         0          410,000.00
Heat Sinks - Double Heat Sink                    0         0           66,000.00
Musculature - Standard                           0        80          160,000.00
Actuators                                        0         0          112,000.00
Armor - Standard Armor                         580         0          145,000.00

B-Pod                                               2         0         2,500.00
B-Pod                                               2         0         2,500.00
B-Pod                                               2         0         2,500.00
B-Pod                                               2         0         2,500.00
(T) Gauss Rifle                                     0       320       300,000.00
@ Gauss Rifle                                       0        40        20,000.00
@ Gauss Rifle                                       0        40        20,000.00
ATM-9                                               0       147       225,000.00
@ ATM-9                                             0        36        75,000.00
@ ATM-9                                             0        36        75,000.00
(T) ER Large Laser                                  0       248       200,000.00
(T) Micro Pulse Laser                               0        12        12,500.00
ER Medium Laser                                     0       108        80,000.00
Targeting Computer                                  0         0        40,000.00
Turret                                              0         0        20,000.00
CASE II                                             0         0       175,000.00
CASE II                                             0         0       175,000.00

Cost Multiplier                                                            1.800
Dry Cost                                                               9,436,500
Total Cost                                                             9,626,500


Defensive BV Calculation Breakdown
(Note: BV Calculations include defensive BV for armored components.)
________________________________________________________________________________
Total Armor Factor (232) * Armor Type Modifier (1.0) * 2.5                580.00
Total Structure Points (130) * Structure Type Modifier (1.0)
    * Engine Type Modifier (1.0) * 1.5                                    195.00
Mech Tonnage (80) * Gyro Type Modifer (0.5)                                40.00
Total Defensive BV of all Equipment                                         8.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Explosive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Explosive Item Penalty                                                      0.00
Subtotal                                                                  823.00
Defensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Maximum Ground Movement Modifier: 1.20
    Maximum Jump Movement Modifier:   0.00
    Defensive Speed Factor Bonus from Equipment: 0.00
    Minimum Defensive Speed Factor:   0.00
    (Max of Run or Jump) + DSF Bonus = 1.20
Total DBV (Subtotal * Defensive Speed Factor (1.20))                      987.60


Offensive BV Calculation Breakdown
________________________________________________________________________________
Heat Efficiency (6 + 22 (Dissipation) - 2 (Movement Heat)) = 26.0
Adjusted Weapon BV Total WBV                                            1,007.00
    -> (T) Gauss Rifle                                                    400.00
    -> ATM-9                                                              147.00
    -> (T) ER Large Laser                                                 310.00
    -> (T) Micro Pulse Laser                                               15.00
    -> ER Medium Laser                                                    135.00
Non-Heat Equipment Total NHBV                                             152.00
    -> B-Pod                                                                0.00
    -> B-Pod                                                                0.00
    -> B-Pod                                                                0.00
    -> B-Pod                                                                0.00
    -> @ Gauss Rifle                                                       40.00
    -> @ Gauss Rifle                                                       40.00
    -> @ ATM-9                                                             36.00
    -> @ ATM-9                                                             36.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Mech Tonnage Bonus                                                         80.00
Subtotal (WBV + NHBV - Excessive Ammo + Tonnage Bonus)                  1,239.00
Offensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Adjusted Running MP (5) + ( Adjusted Jumping MP (0) / 2 ) - 5 = 0.00
    0.00 / 10 + 1 = 1.000
    1.00 ^ 1.2 = 1.0 (rounded off to two digits)
Total OBV (Subtotal * Offensive Speed Factor (1.0))                     1,239.00


Total Battle Value (DBV + OBV, round off)                                  2,227
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Xotl on 16 January 2023, 18:18:30
RG 6 (Updated) p. 4: Cricket, Variants section:

"The Since the Cricket’s debut,"
Change to:
"Since the Cricket’s debut,"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mordel on 16 January 2023, 21:20:27
SSW is not accounting for B-Pods being explosive, hence the difference.

ilClan Recognition Guide 01, original and updated

Goliath C

Problem (?): Solaris Skunk Werks reports the BV 2.0 for the Goliath C is 2,227. Both sources have the BV 2.0 at 2,222.

Solution: I may have missed something. Alternatively, although it is accurate most of the time, SSW is not perfect. Here is the BV calculation:
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 16 January 2023, 21:24:10
RG 11 (2022 Update) pp. 8 & 11

Plog's Phoenix Hawk artwork in the TRO section was replaced with Scroggins' earlier work that no longer matches the miniature (cockpit), while the record sheets artwork was changed from Scroggins' version to Plog's. (For reference, the Kit Fox and Horned Owl artwork in the record sheets was changed to match the TRO artwork.)

Change pp. 8 & 11 artwork back to Plog's version.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Cache on 16 January 2023, 21:30:56
RG 1 (2022 Update) p. 3, Credits

Harri Kallio was removed from the "Illustrations" credits but his Pack Hunter artwork was added to p. 13 in the update.

Change: Add Harri Kallio back to the "Illustrations" credits.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 19 January 2023, 23:43:02
...
Volume 6, p.12 and Linebacker I record sheet
-Change BV to 1853
...

ilClan Rec Guide Vol 06, Record Sheet for Linebacker I:

Problem: The record sheet reports the Linebacker I's BV (2.0) = 1804. GreekFire posted it should be 1853, which is also the value according to SSW 0.7.6

Solution: Change the BV (2.0) to 1853 if the calculation is correct

Code: [Select]
Mech Name:   Linebacker                                Tonnage:    65
Rules Level: Experimental Tech                         Total Cost: 27,997,875
Tech Base:   Clan                                      Total BV:   1,853

Item                                            DefBV     OffBV             Cost
Internal Structure - Endo Steel                117         0          104,000.00
Engine - XL Fusion Engine                        0         0        6,760,000.00
Gyro - Gyro                                     33         0        1,200,000.00
Cockpit - Standard                               0         0          380,000.00
Heat Sinks - Double Heat Sink                    0         0           84,000.00
Musculature - Standard                           0        65          130,000.00
Actuators                                        0         0           58,500.00
Armor - Ferro-Fibrous                          480         0          200,000.00

MG Array (4 MG)                                     0        33        21,250.00
Active Probe                                       12         0       200,000.00
MG Array (4 MG)                                     0        33        21,250.00
MG Array (3 MG)                                     0        25        16,250.00
MG Array (3 MG)                                     0        25        16,250.00
MG Array (3 MG)                                     0        25        16,250.00
MG Array (3 MG)                                     0        25        16,250.00
ER Large Pulse Laser                                0       272       400,000.00
@ MG (1/2)                                          0         1           500.00
@ MG                                                0         1         1,000.00
Supercharger                                        0         0     3,900,000.00

Cost Multiplier                                                            2.063
Dry Cost                                                              27,996,375
Total Cost                                                            27,997,875


Defensive BV Calculation Breakdown
(Note: BV Calculations include defensive BV for armored components.)
________________________________________________________________________________
Total Armor Factor (192) * Armor Type Modifier (1.0) * 2.5                480.00
Total Structure Points (104) * Structure Type Modifier (1.0)
    * Engine Type Modifier (0.75) * 1.5                                   117.00
Mech Tonnage (65) * Gyro Type Modifer (0.5)                                32.50
Total Defensive BV of all Equipment                                        12.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Explosive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Explosive Item Penalty                                                      0.00
Subtotal                                                                  641.50
Defensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Maximum Ground Movement Modifier: 1.40
    Maximum Jump Movement Modifier:   0.00
    Defensive Speed Factor Bonus from Equipment: 0.00
    Minimum Defensive Speed Factor:   0.00
    (Max of Run or Jump) + DSF Bonus = 1.40
Total DBV (Subtotal * Defensive Speed Factor (1.40))                      898.10


Offensive BV Calculation Breakdown
________________________________________________________________________________
Heat Efficiency (6 + 28 (Dissipation) - 2 (Movement Heat)) = 32.0
Adjusted Weapon BV Total WBV                                              439.00
    -> MG Array (4 MG)                                                     33.40
    -> MG Array (4 MG)                                                     33.40
    -> MG Array (3 MG)                                                     25.05
    -> MG Array (3 MG)                                                     25.05
    -> MG Array (3 MG)                                                     25.05
    -> MG Array (3 MG)                                                     25.05
    -> ER Large Pulse Laser                                               272.00
Non-Heat Equipment Total NHBV                                               1.50
    -> Active Probe                                                         0.00
    -> @ MG (1/2)                                                           0.50
    -> @ MG                                                                 1.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Mech Tonnage Bonus                                                         65.00
Subtotal (WBV + NHBV - Excessive Ammo + Tonnage Bonus)                    505.50
Offensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Adjusted Running MP (12) + ( Adjusted Jumping MP (0) / 2 ) - 5 = 7.00
    7.00 / 10 + 1 = 1.700
    1.70 ^ 1.2 = 1.89 (rounded off to two digits)
Total OBV (Subtotal * Offensive Speed Factor (1.89))                      955.40


Total Battle Value (DBV + OBV, round off)                                  1,853
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Sartris on 20 January 2023, 00:31:32
i went to change it had already been taken care of with no record in the changelog. spooky.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 20 January 2023, 22:29:47
Grizzly 3 has a ‘Reinforced’ crit in the head.

Pg13. Fluff for Hoplite; dispossessed is capitalized in the 4th line
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 21 January 2023, 00:31:11
Recognition Guide 18 (second printing)

Error: Record Sheet for Kingfisher T is included twice.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Sartris on 21 January 2023, 00:45:02
Recognition Guide 18 (second printing)

Error: Record Sheet for Kingfisher T is included twice.

The second Kingfisher T has also bodysnatched the X config
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Doc Swift on 21 January 2023, 02:38:00
Pg13. Fluff for Hoplite; dispossessed is capitalized in the 4th line

It's supposed to be capitalized.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Starbuck on 21 January 2023, 07:23:15
Rec Guide Vol 30

stat block for Hellcat (Hellhound II), page 9

mass of extra heat sinks is incorrect,
should be 4 tons not 3
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 21 January 2023, 19:02:55
ilClan Rec Guide Vol 30

Record Sheet for Conjurer (Hellhound) 6

Problem: The Rules Level for the record sheet is listed as Standard. Since the Conjurer 6 mounts an ER Medium Pulse Laser, and was introduced in the 3060s, the tech level should be experimental upon introduction (and Advanced by 3082 according to TRO: Prototypes, p. 207).

Solution: Change the Rules Level to Experimental.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 22 January 2023, 18:43:01
ilClan Recognition Guide 11 Updated:

Ion Sparrow (Butcherbird) A Record Sheet.

Problem: BV (2.0) for the Ion Sparrow A is listed as 477. The original printing of ilClan Rec Guide 11, MUL, as well as Solaris Skunk Werks 0.7.6 reports the Ion Sparrow A should be BV (2.0) = 501.

Solution: 1. There is no problem, 477 is correct
2. change BV (2.0) back to 501.

For reference, here is the BV (2.0) calculation.

Code: [Select]
Mech Name:   Ion Sparrow (Butcherbird)                 Tonnage:    20
Rules Level: Experimental Tech                         Total Cost: 3,820,750
Tech Base:   Mixed                                     Total BV:   501

Item                                            DefBV     OffBV             Cost
Internal Structure - Endo Steel                 37         0           32,000.00
Engine - XL Fusion Engine                        0         0          853,333.33
Gyro - Gyro                                     10         0          600,000.00
Cockpit - Small                                  0         0          265,000.00
Heat Sinks - Double Heat Sink                    0         0           60,000.00
Musculature - Standard                           0        20           40,000.00
Actuators                                        0         0           18,000.00
Jump Jets - Standard Jump Jet                    0         0          256,000.00
Armor - Ferro-Fibrous                          143         0           60,000.00

MG Array (4 MG)                                     0        33        21,250.00
MG Array (4 MG)                                     0        33        21,250.00
@ MG (1/2)                                          0         1           500.00
Active Probe                                       12         0       200,000.00
Partial Wing                                        0         0        70,000.00

Cost Multiplier                                                            1.500
Dry Cost                                                               3,820,250
Total Cost                                                             3,820,750


Defensive BV Calculation Breakdown
(Note: BV Calculations include defensive BV for armored components.)
________________________________________________________________________________
Total Armor Factor (57) * Armor Type Modifier (1.0) * 2.5                 142.50
Total Structure Points (33) * Structure Type Modifier (1.0)
    * Engine Type Modifier (0.75) * 1.5                                    37.13
Mech Tonnage (20) * Gyro Type Modifer (0.5)                                10.00
Total Defensive BV of all Equipment                                        12.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Explosive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Explosive Item Penalty                                                      0.00
Subtotal                                                                  201.63
Defensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Maximum Ground Movement Modifier: 1.40
    Maximum Jump Movement Modifier:   1.50
    Defensive Speed Factor Bonus from Equipment: 0.00
    Minimum Defensive Speed Factor:   0.00
    (Max of Run or Jump) + DSF Bonus = 1.50
Total DBV (Subtotal * Defensive Speed Factor (1.50))                      302.44


Offensive BV Calculation Breakdown
________________________________________________________________________________
Heat Efficiency (6 + 23 (Dissipation) - 8 (Movement Heat)) = 21.0
Adjusted Weapon BV Total WBV                                               66.80
    -> MG Array (4 MG)                                                     33.40
    -> MG Array (4 MG)                                                     33.40
Non-Heat Equipment Total NHBV                                               0.50
    -> @ MG (1/2)                                                           0.50
    -> Active Probe                                                         0.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Mech Tonnage Bonus                                                         20.00
Subtotal (WBV + NHBV - Excessive Ammo + Tonnage Bonus)                     87.30
Offensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Adjusted Running MP (12) + ( Adjusted Jumping MP (10) / 2 ) - 5 = 12.00
    12.00 / 10 + 1 = 2.200
    2.20 ^ 1.2 = 2.58 (rounded off to two digits)
Total OBV (Subtotal * Offensive Speed Factor (2.58))                      225.23


Small Cockpit modifier                                                      0.95
Total Battle Value ((DBV + OBV) * cockpit modifier, round off)               501

EDIT: Forgot to mention the MUL still lists the Ion Sparrow A at BV (2.0) = 501
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 23 January 2023, 06:45:51
RG26, page 19
Maxim Heavy Hover Tank record sheet does not have ferro-fibrous armor marked even though it must have that in order to fit all the equipment (and it seems to share its armor layout and type with the Maxim 3052 upgrade model).
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Richard S. on 24 January 2023, 05:00:23
RG30, page 26

The SRM Carrier shouldn't qualify for the Missile Boat role since it can't deliver indirect damage.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mbear on 24 January 2023, 14:33:14
Vol 2 (January 2023 update) p 13, UrbanMech, Notable Pilot section, UrbanMech needs to be italicized.
Quote
...keeping his own UrbanMech-"Frickle"-...

Vol 8 (January 2023 update) p. 6, second column, last sentence before Capabilities: Touman needs to be in lowercase and italicized.
Quote
...welcome addition to the Snow Raven touman and...

Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Doc Swift on 24 January 2023, 16:38:07
Vol 8 (January 2023 update) p. 6, second column, last sentence before Capabilities: Touman needs to be in lowercase and italicized.

Incorrect. "Snow Raven Touman" (capitalized, non-italics) is correct.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 26 January 2023, 14:03:48
ilClan Rec Guide Vol 12 (updated only)

Record Sheet, Huntsman (Nobori-Nin) G:

Problem: Tech Base is listed as "Mixed". It appears the only piece of equipment listed as Inner Sphere is the Retractable Blade, but this equipment is considered both Inner Sphere and Clan, according to TechManual, p. 237.

Solution: Change the Tech Base for the Huntsman (Nobori-Nin) G to Clan
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 26 January 2023, 14:26:59
ilClan Rec Guides 12 and 12 updated:

Record Sheet, Shadow Hawk C:

Problem: Record sheets for the Shadow Hawk C in both the original and updated ilClan Rec Guide 12 have a "Clan Invasion" icon. MUL indicates the Shadow Hawk C dates to the Early Succession Wars, 2826.

Solution: Change the icon on the record sheet to "Succession Wars" icon.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 26 January 2023, 14:47:54
Cosmetic observation for ilClan Rec Guides 13 and 13 updated

Record sheets for STG-5G Stinger

Problem: If it is preferred to place Double Heat Sinks above weapons, the right arm Light PPC + Capacitor is above the right arm DHS.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mordel on 28 January 2023, 10:49:25
Problem: If it is preferred to place Double Heat Sinks above weapons, the right arm Light PPC + Capacitor is above the right arm DHS.

"Preferred" by who?
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 28 January 2023, 19:43:28
"Preferred" by who?

I just saw the trend in recent the Rec Guides, so I figured I would bring it to your attention. I’m sorry if “preferred” is the wrong word. You’re doing an awesome job!

S.gage
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 29 January 2023, 09:31:36
RG vol 28, page 6.
The Long Tom's battle history erroneously states that the Second MAC artillery attacked Julian Davion's forces in 3147. Judging by Shattered Fortress page 57, this actually happened in 3148.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 30 January 2023, 16:51:21
ilClan Recognition Guide 14

Record Sheet, Ostsol C

Problem: While it has no effect on gameplay (and construction is still legal), there are only 5 designated criticals for Clan Reflec armor. TO, p. 280, Clan laser reflective armor should have 7 criticals.

Solution: Add 2 Reflec criticals to locations with open criticals, for instance 1 each to the arms or side torsos.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 30 January 2023, 20:05:06
ilClan Rec Guide 15 updated:

Record Sheet, Fire Falcon F:

Problem: The reported BV (2.0) = 1,430 for the Fire Falcon F. Using Solaris Skunk Werks, the calculated BV (2.0) = 1,135. This matches the original published version of ilClan Rec Guide 15, as well as the MUL.

Solutions: 1. There is no problem, SSW is wrong (maybe MG arrays are not calculated correctly, etc.). 1,430 is the correct BV.
2. The BV is not 1,430, and needs to be corrected.

Here is the report on BV value:

Code: [Select]
Mech Name:   Fire Falcon                               Tonnage:    25
Rules Level: Tournament Legal                          Total Cost: 4,721,052
Tech Base:   Clan                                      Total BV:   1,135

Item                                            DefBV     OffBV             Cost
Internal Structure - Endo Steel                 48         0           40,000.00
Engine - XL Fusion Engine                        0         0        1,333,333.33
Gyro - Gyro                                     13         0          600,000.00
Cockpit - Standard                               0         0          300,000.00
Heat Sinks - Double Heat Sink                    0         0           60,000.00
Musculature - Standard                           0        25           50,000.00
Actuators                                        0         0           22,500.00
Armor - Ferro-Fibrous                          190         0           80,000.00

Active Probe                                       12         0       200,000.00
ER Large Laser                                      0       248       200,000.00
ER Small Laser                                      0        31        11,250.00
ER Micro Laser                                      0         7        10,000.00
ER Small Laser                                      0        31        11,250.00
ER Micro Laser                                      0         7        10,000.00
MG Array (4 MG)                                     0        33        21,250.00
MG Array (4 MG)                                     0        33        21,250.00
@ MG                                                0         1         1,000.00

Cost Multiplier                                                            1.563
Dry Cost                                                               4,720,052
Total Cost                                                             4,721,052


Defensive BV Calculation Breakdown
________________________________________________________________________________
Total Armor Factor (76) * Armor Type Modifier (1.0) * 2.5                 190.00
Total Structure Points (43) * Structure Type Modifier (1.0)
    * Engine Type Modifier (0.75) * 1.5                                    48.38
Mech Tonnage (25) * Gyro Type Modifer (0.5)                                12.50
Total Defensive BV of all Equipment                                        12.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Explosive Ammunition Penalty                                              -15.00
Explosive Item Penalty                                                      0.00
Subtotal                                                                  247.88
Defensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Maximum Ground Movement Modifier: 1.40
    Maximum Jump Movement Modifier:   0.00
    Defensive Speed Factor Bonus from Equipment: 0.00
    Minimum Defensive Speed Factor:   0.00
    (Max of Run or Jump) + DSF Bonus = 1.40
Total DBV (Subtotal * Defensive Speed Factor (1.40))                      347.03


Offensive BV Calculation Breakdown
________________________________________________________________________________
Heat Efficiency (6 + 20 (Dissipation) - 2 (Movement Heat)) = 24.0
Adjusted Weapon BV Total WBV                                              390.80
    -> ER Large Laser                                                     248.00
    -> ER Small Laser                                                      31.00
    -> ER Micro Laser                                                       7.00
    -> ER Small Laser                                                      31.00
    -> ER Micro Laser                                                       7.00
    -> MG Array (4 MG)                                                     33.40
    -> MG Array (4 MG)                                                     33.40
Non-Heat Equipment Total NHBV                                               1.00
    -> Active Probe                                                         0.00
    -> @ MG                                                                 1.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Mech Tonnage Bonus                                                         25.00
Subtotal (WBV + NHBV - Excessive Ammo + Tonnage Bonus)                    416.80
Offensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Adjusted Running MP (12) + ( Adjusted Jumping MP (0) / 2 ) - 5 = 7.00
    7.00 / 10 + 1 = 1.700
    1.70 ^ 1.2 = 1.89 (rounded off to two digits)
Total OBV (Subtotal * Offensive Speed Factor (1.89))                      787.75


Total Battle Value (DBV + OBV, round off)                                  1,135
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 03 February 2023, 16:06:55
RG31, page 30 Behemoth (Refit) record sheet
Issues:
-has wrong era icon (should be Civil War probably judging by unit description)
-lacks MG ammo completely, probable amount half a ton (100 shots) in order to fit everything else.
-SAW and MML both report BV as 1246 with half a ton of machine gun ammo.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 03 February 2023, 16:10:45
RG31, page 29 Behemoth (Laio) record sheet

Issue:
Record sheet lacks ammunition for the Gauss Rifle.

Solution: Add Gauss Ammo
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Sartris on 03 February 2023, 16:12:42
-SAW reports BV as 1246 but i'm uncertain about that.

Please copy and paste the BV report so we can take a look to see if/where SAW (or, inversely, MML) is goofing up the calcs
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 03 February 2023, 16:23:14
Hey in Rec Guide 29 page 13 the Charger C blurb says

‘A fully clan tech version of the mech’ (or something to that effect)

While the record sheet later shows it using a IS 400XL (3 crits per torso)

Either the description or the record sheet needs to change. (Also if the record sheet changes you’ll have to get the MUL team on a new card, the card reflects the IS engine)

Might have put this in the wrong spot.

Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 03 February 2023, 16:36:57
Please copy and paste the BV report so we can take a look to see if/where SAW (or, inversely, MML) is goofing up the calcs
MML report:
Code: [Select]
Battle Value Calculations For
-----------------------------
Behemoth Heavy Tank
--------------------
Defensive Battle Rating Calculation:
   Total Armor FR (46) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          46.0
   Total Armor RS (38) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          38.0
   Total Armor LS (38) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          38.0
   Total Armor RR (40) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          40.0
   Total Armor TU (46) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          46.0
   Total modified armor BV x 2.5                                           = 520.0
   Total I.S. Points x 1.5 x Blue Shield Multipler   50 x 1.5 x 1.0         = 75.0
                                                                         ---------
   Defensive Equipment                                                           
                                                                             = 0.0
   x Body Type Modifier                              x 0.9                       
   x Target Movement modifier                        x 1.1                       
                                                                         ---------
                                                                             589.1
   Weapons                                                                       
   LRM 5                                             45.0 Front               45.0
   LRM 5                                             45.0 Front               45.0
   LRM 5                                             45.0 Front               45.0
   LRM 5                                             45.0 Front               45.0
   Machine Gun                                       5.0 Front                 5.0
   Machine Gun                                       5.0 Front                 5.0
   SRM 2                                             21.0 Front               21.0
   SRM 2                                             21.0 Front               21.0
   Machine Gun                                       5.0 Side/Turret           5.0
   SRM 2                                             21.0 Side/Turret         21.0
   Machine Gun                                       5.0 Side/Turret           5.0
   SRM 2                                             21.0 Side/Turret         21.0
   SRM 6                                             59.0 Side/Turret         59.0
   SRM 6                                             59.0 Side/Turret         59.0
   LB 10-X AC                                        148.0 Side/Turret       148.0
   LB 10-X AC                                        148.0 Side/Turret       148.0
                                                                           = 698.0
   Ammo BV                                                                       
   LRM 5 Ammo                                                              BV: 6.0
   LRM 5 Ammo                                                              BV: 6.0
   SRM 6 Ammo                                                              BV: 7.0
   SRM 6 Ammo                                                              BV: 7.0
   SRM 2 Ammo                                                              BV: 3.0
   Half Machine Gun Ammo                                                   BV: 0.5
   LB 10-X AC Ammo                                                        BV: 19.0
   LB 10-X AC Ammo                                                        BV: 19.0
   LB 10-X Cluster Ammo                                                   BV: 19.0
   LB 10-X Cluster Ammo                                                   BV: 19.0
                                                                           = 105.5
   Offensive Equipment                                                           
   CASE                                              0.0                         
                                                                             = 0.0
                                                                         ---------
   + weight / 2                                      100.0 / 2              = 50.0
   + weapons bv * speed factor                       853.5 * 0.77          = 657.2
                                                                         ---------
   Final BV                                                                1,246.2
                                                                         ---------
   Final Adjusted BV                                                     = 1,246.0
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 03 February 2023, 18:16:39
MML report:
Code: [Select]
Battle Value Calculations For
-----------------------------
Behemoth Heavy Tank
--------------------
Defensive Battle Rating Calculation:
   Total Armor FR (46) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          46.0
   Total Armor RS (38) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          38.0
   Total Armor LS (38) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          38.0
   Total Armor RR (40) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          40.0
   Total Armor TU (46) x 1.0 x 10/10                                          46.0
   Total modified armor BV x 2.5                                           = 520.0
   Total I.S. Points x 1.5 x Blue Shield Multipler   50 x 1.5 x 1.0         = 75.0
                                                                         ---------
   Defensive Equipment                                                           
                                                                             = 0.0
   x Body Type Modifier                              x 0.9                       
   x Target Movement modifier                        x 1.1                       
                                                                         ---------
                                                                             589.1
   Weapons                                                                       
   LRM 5                                             45.0 Front               45.0
   LRM 5                                             45.0 Front               45.0
   LRM 5                                             45.0 Front               45.0
   LRM 5                                             45.0 Front               45.0
   Machine Gun                                       5.0 Front                 5.0
   Machine Gun                                       5.0 Front                 5.0
   SRM 2                                             21.0 Front               21.0
   SRM 2                                             21.0 Front               21.0
   Machine Gun                                       5.0 Side/Turret           5.0
   SRM 2                                             21.0 Side/Turret         21.0
   Machine Gun                                       5.0 Side/Turret           5.0
   SRM 2                                             21.0 Side/Turret         21.0
   SRM 6                                             59.0 Side/Turret         59.0
   SRM 6                                             59.0 Side/Turret         59.0
   LB 10-X AC                                        148.0 Side/Turret       148.0
   LB 10-X AC                                        148.0 Side/Turret       148.0
                                                                           = 698.0
   Ammo BV                                                                       
   LRM 5 Ammo                                                              BV: 6.0
   LRM 5 Ammo                                                              BV: 6.0
   SRM 6 Ammo                                                              BV: 7.0
   SRM 6 Ammo                                                              BV: 7.0
   SRM 2 Ammo                                                              BV: 3.0
   Half Machine Gun Ammo                                                   BV: 0.5
   LB 10-X AC Ammo                                                        BV: 19.0
   LB 10-X AC Ammo                                                        BV: 19.0
   LB 10-X Cluster Ammo                                                   BV: 19.0
   LB 10-X Cluster Ammo                                                   BV: 19.0
                                                                           = 105.5
   Offensive Equipment                                                           
   CASE                                              0.0                         
                                                                             = 0.0
                                                                         ---------
   + weight / 2                                      100.0 / 2              = 50.0
   + weapons bv * speed factor                       853.5 * 0.77          = 657.2
                                                                         ---------
   Final BV                                                                1,246.2
                                                                         ---------
   Final Adjusted BV                                                     = 1,246.0

I also had problems with the Behemoth Heavy Tank (Refit). The BV (2.0) matched the published value with the CASE installed, 1266, and the mass is already 100 tons without MG ammo.

Solutions to the problem: 1. Replace armor, ammo, or weapons for MG ammo.
2 (my preferred solution). In order to add 1/2 ton of MG ammo, I removed the case. The BV is unchanged, 1266. Here is the cost breakdown:

Code: [Select]
Vehicle Name:   Behemoth Heavy Tank (Refit)               Tonnage:    100
Rules Level: Tournament Legal                          Total Cost:    3,752,167
Tech Base:   Inner Sphere                                Total BV:    1,266

Item                                            DefBV     OffBV             Cost
Internal Structure - Standard                   75         0          100,000.00
Controls                                         0         0           50,000.00
Lift Equipment                                   0         0                0.00
Engine - I.C.E. Engine                           0         0          333,333.33
Heat Sinks - Single Heat Sink                    0         0                0.00
Power Amplifiers                                 0         0                0.00
Armor - Standard Armor                         540         0          135,000.00
Turret                                           0         0           15,000.00

LRM-5                                               0        45        30,000.00
LRM-5                                               0        45        30,000.00
LRM-5                                               0        45        30,000.00
LRM-5                                               0        45        30,000.00
Machine Gun                                         0         5         5,000.00
Machine Gun                                         0         5         5,000.00
SRM-2                                               0        21        10,000.00
SRM-2                                               0        21        10,000.00
SRM-2                                               0        21        10,000.00
Machine Gun                                         0         5         5,000.00
SRM-2                                               0        21        10,000.00
Machine Gun                                         0         5         5,000.00
LB 10-X AC                                          0       148       400,000.00
LB 10-X AC                                          0       148       400,000.00
SRM-6                                               0        59        80,000.00
SRM-6                                               0        59        80,000.00
@ LB 10-X (Cluster)                                 0        19        20,000.00
@ LB 10-X (Cluster)                                 0        19        20,000.00
@ LB 10-X (Slug)                                    0        19        12,000.00
@ LB 10-X (Slug)                                    0        19        12,000.00
@ LRM-5                                             0         6        30,000.00
@ LRM-5                                             0         6        30,000.00
@ SRM-2                                             0         3        27,000.00
@ SRM-6                                             0         7        27,000.00
@ SRM-6                                             0         7        27,000.00
@ MG (1/2)                                          0         1           500.00

Cost Multiplier                                                            1.000
Chassis Modifier                                                           2.000
Dry Cost                                                               3,546,667
Total Cost                                                             3,752,167


Defensive BV Calculation Breakdown
________________________________________________________________________________
Total Armor Factor (216) * Armor Type Modifier (1.0) * 2.5                540.00
Total Structure Points (50) * Structure Type Modifier (1.0)
    * 1.5                                                                  75.00
Total Defensive BV of all Equipment                                         0.00
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Subtotal                                                                  615.00
Vehicle Type Modifier                                                       0.90
Total DBV (Subtotal * Vehicle Type Modifier * Defensive Factor (1.10))    608.85


Offensive BV Calculation Breakdown
________________________________________________________________________________
Weapon BV Total WBV                                                       698.00
    -> LRM-5                                                               45.00
    -> LRM-5                                                               45.00
    -> LRM-5                                                               45.00
    -> LRM-5                                                               45.00
    -> Machine Gun                                                          5.00
    -> Machine Gun                                                          5.00
    -> SRM-2                                                               21.00
    -> SRM-2                                                               21.00
    -> SRM-2                                                               21.00
    -> Machine Gun                                                          5.00
    -> SRM-2                                                               21.00
    -> Machine Gun                                                          5.00
    -> LB 10-X AC                                                         148.00
    -> LB 10-X AC                                                         148.00
    -> SRM-6                                                               59.00
    -> SRM-6                                                               59.00
Non-Heat Equipment Total NHBV                                             105.50
    -> @ LB 10-X (Cluster)                                                 19.00
    -> @ LB 10-X (Cluster)                                                 19.00
    -> @ LB 10-X (Slug)                                                    19.00
    -> @ LB 10-X (Slug)                                                    19.00
    -> @ LRM-5                                                              6.00
    -> @ LRM-5                                                              6.00
    -> @ SRM-2                                                              3.00
    -> @ SRM-6                                                              7.00
    -> @ SRM-6                                                              7.00
    -> @ MG (1/2)                                                           0.50
Excessive Ammunition Penalty                                                0.00
Vehicle Tonnage Bonus                                                      50.00
Subtotal (WBV + NHBV + Tonnage Bonus)                                     853.50
Offensive Speed Factor Breakdown:
    Adjusted Flank MP (3) + ( Adjusted Jumping MP (0) / 2 ) - 5 = -2.00
    -2.00 / 10 + 1 = 0.800
    0.80 ^ 1.2 = 0.77 (rounded off to two digits)
Total OBV (Subtotal * Offensive Speed Factor (0.77))                      657.20


Total Battle Value (DBV + OBV, round off)                                  1,266

EDIT: My reply was written as a response, and was a bit unclear. Now it is written with more clarification, and potential alternate fixes.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jymset on 04 February 2023, 08:18:52
Dev errata:

#31, p. 3, Credits

Writing - delete Edward McEneely
also add following line:
Additional Writing: John Haward, Agustín Sieiro Barja

Apologies for the inconvenience.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Hammer on 04 February 2023, 18:26:13
Dev Level Errata:

Rec Guide #31

Behemoth Heavy Tank (Refit)

Replace armor with following values.
Front: 46
R/L Side: 38
Rear: 40
Turret: 46

Add half ton of Machine gun ammo - (Machine Gun) 100

BV will change to 1246

Era Icon should be Clan Invasion.

Behemoth Heavy Tank (Liao)

Reduce MML Ammo to (MML 5/LRM) 72, (MML 5/SRM) 60

add (Gauss) 16

BV will change to 1324
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Jellico on 09 February 2023, 00:14:12
RecGuide 19 and 20.
The Rime Otter and Mastodon use RUFM engines. Should be RFMU like the Grizzly.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 12 February 2023, 16:09:01
VERSION: Updated Recognition Guide volume 1

LOCATION: Griffin 3N (pg20) and Griffin C (pg23) record sheets

THE ERROR: The record sheets are missing right hand actuators.
Considering the Griffin C originally had this issue and it was noted to be an error here (https://bg.battletech.com/forums/ask-the-writers/griffin-c-no-right-hand-actuator/msg1639950/#msg1639950), it seems the error has multiplied.

THE CORRECTION: Add right hand actuator to both sheets.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Karasu on 15 February 2023, 09:07:36
RG Vol 29

Dragoon Battle Armour Pg 11 says
"Swarm/Leg Attack/Mechanized/AP: Yes/Yes/Yes/No"

The record sheets from page 14 onwards all have the AP box ticked.

I believe that the boxes should be unticked.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 17 February 2023, 15:37:32
ilClan Recognition Guide Volume 32

PROBLEM: There are two copies of Drillson Heavy Hover Tank C. Both appear identical.

SOLUTION: Remove one of the two copies.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: ShroudedSciuridae on 19 February 2023, 12:25:40
RG32, Record Sheet for Viper VP-7, VP-8, and VP-9

Critical Hit locations specify Active Probe as Clan, Weapons & Equipment Inventory box does not.
Solution: Tack on a (C)

Pages 12-13
Not sure if this is an error, but it is a discrepancy. Armaments & Weapons and Ammo sections uses Binary Laser Cannon while all instances on Record Sheets use Binary Laser (Blazer) Cannon.
Solution: Add (Blazer) if required.

PS Thank you for the Viper!
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 22 February 2023, 17:45:59
ilClan Rec Guide Vol 32

PROBLEM: The MUL refers to a "Schrek AC Carrier" in addition to the "Schrek AC Carrier (Lothian)". The link is here:

http://masterunitlist.info/Unit/Details/2822/schrek-ac-carrier

This record sheet was not included with the volume.

SOLUTION: add the record sheet back in any subsequent re-release.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Sartris on 22 February 2023, 21:56:21
Vol 32

Problem: The record sheet for the Drillson (MML) lacks a role:

Solution: set role to Striker
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: ShroudedSciuridae on 23 February 2023, 13:06:40
Volume 4, Updated
Page 10, Warhammer IIC

"Kalasa worked closely with the Exarch over the next week until Labov could resume command"
Issue: RG24 p. 11 states Labrov was out of action for "several weeks." Even after Labrov returned to command she "functioned more as an observer" until the final clash for the capital. Per Era Digest: Dark Age p. 6, this final battle took place "nearly a month" after the battle began.
Solution: Resolve the discrepancy in whichever source. I'm inclined lean towards "several weeks."
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 13 March 2023, 14:56:53
ilClan Recognition Guide Volume 19 (original and updated)

Record Sheet, Rime Otter D

Problem: The Rime Otter D mounts a Narc Missile Beacon Laucher. The SRM-6 ammunition contained in the right arm is standard SRM-6 ammunition. While the Rime Otter D does not have to mount Narc-capable SRM ammunition, other 'Mechs with Narc launcher (for instance, the ARC-5S Archer from Volume 10) have customarily used Narc-capable ammunition.

Solution: Replace "Ammo (SRM 6)" with "Ammo (SRM 6 Narc-capable)"
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 13 March 2023, 16:03:35
ilClan Recognition Guide, Volume 19 (original and updated)

Record Sheet for Iron Cheetah B:

Problem?: It is unclear if this is a problem. But a few observations led me to suspect an issue.

In the updated version of the pdfs, the Iron Cheetah B has a lower arm actuator on the left arm, but only has an upper arm actuator on the right arm.
In the original pdf version, the Iron Cheetah B has lower arm actuators on both arms.
In both versions, all other configurations of the Iron Cheetah lack arm actuators, and most are able to flip their arms. Additionally, as this is designed by Clan Smoke Jaguar, it feels strange to have the extra arm actuator.

I can not check the 1993 FASA Update at the moment to see if the actuator configurations were specified.

Solutions: 1) There is no problem, the Iron Cheetah B was supposed to have a lower arm actuator on the left arm.
2) There is a problem, we did not intend to change the lower arm actuator configurations from the original pdf.
3) There is a problem, neither were supposed to have any lower arm actuators.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 13 March 2023, 21:35:33
ilClan Recognition Guide Volume 21

Record Sheet for OSR-6R Ostroc:

Cosmetic Problem: In the right torso, the order of the weapons are (Cl) ER Large Laser, Streak SRM 4, and (Cl) ER Medium Laser.

Cosmetic Solution: Reorder the weapons in the right torso (Cl) ER Large Laser, (Cl) ER Medium Laser, Streak SRM 4.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 16 March 2023, 10:23:12
ilClan Recognition Guide Volume 24, updated (original is correct)

Record Sheet, AS8-S Atlas

Problem: The updated record sheet specifies the three CASE II systems are Clan-spec. However, the original (with IS-spec CASE II) was balanced. Therefore, making the 3 CASE II Clan-spec leaves the AS8-S 1.5 tons undermass.
I looked for something else added to utilize the extra 1.5 tons, but I could not find anything, and confirmed this by noting the BV (2.0) is unchanged at 2,789.

Solution: 1) revert to the original record sheet, making the CASE II systems IS-spec.
2) there is sufficient left over space to add 1.5 tons of equipment.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: S.gage on 16 March 2023, 10:51:26
ilClan Recognition Guide Volume 24

Record Sheet, Atlas C (updated and original):

Problem: As a mixed-tech BattleMech, weapon systems (4x IS Medium Lasers, 1x Cl Ultra AC/20, 1x Cl LRM-20, 1x Cl Streak SRM 6) should identify the tech base on the critical diagram.

Solution: Label the criticals with tech labels for Clan equipment "[Clan]"

============================================================

Problem: According to MUL, the Atlas C debuted in the Early Succession Wars (2830). Mixed technology base units are "Advanced" (TRO: 3145, p. 218) or "Experimental" (TRO:Prototypes, p. 208) until ~3082.
The record sheet from the original Rec Guide pdf has the Rules Level as "Experimental".
The record sheet from the updated Rec Guide pdf has the Rules Level as "Standard".

Solution for the original record sheet: Change the Rules Level of the Atlas C to "Advanced" if the Rules Level should be revised after the publication of TRO:3145. Otherwise, no change is required.

Solution for the updated record sheet: Even when using the revised Rules Levels from TRO:3145, units debuting before ~3082 should not be "Standard" rules. Therefore, change the Rules Level to either "Experimental" (TRO:Prototypes) or "Advanced" (TRO:3145).

============================================================

Cosmetic Problem: In both the original and updated record sheets, the ammunition criticals in the left torso are order

Ammo (LRM 20)
Ammo (Streak SRM 6)
Ammo (LRM 20)

Solution: While it has little impact on game play or the value of the unit, the ammunition criticals could be reordered

Ammo (LRM 20)
Ammo (LRM 20)
Ammo (Streak SRM 6)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: BaldDen on 19 March 2023, 13:49:29
ilClan Recognition Guide Volume 31

p.7 HARRIER HEAVY HOVER TANK (RE-LASER)

PROBLEM: The weight of the 265 light engine is listed as 21 tons.

Solution: change to 16 tons
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: GoldBishop on 10 May 2023, 10:15:23
ilClan Recognition Guide Volume 32

Problem: Blood Asp "I" configuration BV accuracy

p.14 lists BV as "2,252"  (entry)
p.48 lists BV as "2,242"  (record sheet)

manual verification concludes that the original entry is the correct value

Solution: on p.48, change BV to "2,252"


Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 21 May 2023, 14:20:46
ilClan Recognition Guide Volume 32

Problem: Viper VP-1 Record Sheet (page 39) lists rules level as Standard but considering the introduction date of the blazers and of the 'Mech, it is incorrect.

Solution: Change tech level to Experimental to reflect the status of the mech as a whole in the Succession Wars era.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: HobbesHurlbut on 05 July 2023, 18:01:33
Recognition Guide, Vol 25, Chameleon
CLN-8V Entry say its Cruising and Maximum Speed are 75kph and 118kph respectively.
The movement is 6/9, not 7/11 for that variant .
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Karasu on 26 December 2023, 04:42:13
Recognition Guide, Vol 33

Page 18, the Harasser (LFE) is described as a 'Missile Platform'.  It has no missiles.  While variants do normally inherit the description of the original, there is a Haraser Laser Platform in the 3039 upgrade Record Sheet

Change the Type to Harasser Laser Platform (LFE)
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Sartris on 30 December 2023, 00:00:36
Vol 33 initial release

pg 23: change Scorpion Tank (MRM) rules level from Advanced to Standard
pg 24: change Scorpion Tank (RAC) rules level from Advanced to Standard
pg 35: change Partisan Heavy Tank (ELRM) role from Sniper to Missile Boat
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jymset on 30 December 2023, 09:54:36
RG2, Sojourner D RS, p. 29, the 2 MPL are meant to be in the LT, not the LA.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Sartris on 04 January 2024, 11:17:17
Rg33 adjust Blood Reaper 3’s BV to 2837
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Baldur Mekorig on 20 January 2024, 11:14:35
I am not 100& sure if it is an error:

RecGuide #33, page 6
"in the Periphery, Rim Motors and manufacturers on Erod’s Escape resolved chronic resource shortages by dipping into ancient stockpiles of primitive rifled weapons."

Rim Motors is in Otisberg, in the Timbuktu Collective. So, either Rim Motors opened a factory in Erod’s Escape (Calderon Protectorade), or the planet mentioned should be "Otisberg", or the company mentioned should be "Protectorate Military Industries".
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Doc Swift on 20 January 2024, 11:23:19
That means that Rim Motors dipped into ancient stockpiles, and manufacturers on Erod's Escape did the same. It's not saying the Rim Motors is on Erod's Escape.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Baldur Mekorig on 20 January 2024, 11:35:42
That means that Rim Motors dipped into ancient stockpiles, and manufacturers on Erod's Escape did the same. It's not saying the Rim Motors is on Erod's Escape.

Sorry, you mean both Rim Motors and PMI (or other manufacturer) are making the Rifle Scorpions? If yes, then i can only blame my still crappy grasp of the English language.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: jasonf on 21 January 2024, 20:13:30
Sorry, you mean both Rim Motors and PMI (or other manufacturer) are making the Rifle Scorpions? If yes, then i can only blame my still crappy grasp of the English language.
I had to take a double take myself (and English is my first language, so don't worry), but yes, that's how I interpreted it: produced by both Rim Motors (Otisberg) and PMI (Erod's Escape).
 
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Tallgiraffe on 14 February 2024, 22:05:56
RG 32

Record Sheet Drillson C pg26/27

Problem Duplicate Sheet in the guide

Solution Remove additional sheet
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: mordel on 06 March 2024, 19:37:44
RG33, GAL-106 Galleon Light Tank, p. 7, the Mass for 56 points of Hardened armor should be 7, not 7.5.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: Empyrus on 07 April 2024, 09:59:35
RG33, Scorpion Light Tank (Ultra) record sheet p. 20.
Error: Machine gun location is marked as TU, but the actual unit entry and art (as this is a WYSIWYG upgrade) indicate it is front-mounted.
Correction: Change the machine gun location to FR on the record sheet.
Title: Re: Recognition Guide: IlClan (all volumes)
Post by: MoneyLovinOgre4Hire on 19 May 2024, 00:47:17
Recognition Guide 30

Page 14: Record sheet for Stormbird BA has AP box checked.  Per page 11 it does not mount an AP weapon and should not have this ability.
Page 15: Record sheet for Stormbird (Jade Falcon) BA has AP box checked.  Per Page 11 it does not mount an AP weapon and should not have this ability.