Sorry for the late response, but wouldn't Comstar have access to any of the Star League book? And Liberation of Terra 1 and II?
I mean like the Vector, Vali, LB-X Carrier and the Pollux ADA? They did have the Chaparral after all.
There really should be a retcon of Tukayyid scenario book. Keeping the outcome the same, but include BV 2 and allow an extended and corrected master equipment listing. Even if they did it as a PDF file.
List should have Royal, Standard, Clanbuster, Clan Omni / Battlemech and the ability to choose Laser, Machine Gun or Flamer equipped Elementals. Personal pet peeve is we're not even considering the AP port at all! ( We're told that the standard Infantry weapon is the Mauser IIC, but we see on the SOP is an Auto-rifle, SMG or a Shotgun. Clans wouldn't just use these... wasteful as in more ammo to lug around. )
So I say we need an updated version, but that's me.
TT