BattleTech - The Board Game of Armored Combat

BattleTech Miniatures and Terrain => Iron Wind Metals News and Announcements => Fan Financing 2.0 => Topic started by: speck on 27 October 2018, 10:25:23

Title: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: speck on 27 October 2018, 10:25:23
This is the poll to determine the top three BattleMechs / IndustrialMechs that will get threads opened to be financed. You have two votes per user (since only 8 options) and you can change your vote. The poll will be open for 21 days.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Cache on 27 October 2018, 17:57:55
I wasn't able to find a CBT image of the Mining Mech MKII. So nobody else has to dig, here's the WizKids minis of it (standard and mod).
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: speck on 28 October 2018, 21:21:00
I think that is the last MWDA industrial like that, since a few others where done years ago.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Sartris on 28 October 2018, 21:29:28
I’m a fan. That walking dump truck is pretty cool
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hythos on 30 October 2018, 10:27:49
Primitive Emperor
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hythos on 30 October 2018, 10:28:07
Scourge
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hythos on 30 October 2018, 10:28:30
Ursa
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hythos on 30 October 2018, 10:28:48
Raider I
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hythos on 30 October 2018, 10:29:00
Notos
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hythos on 30 October 2018, 10:29:25
Buster
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hythos on 30 October 2018, 10:29:41
Harvester
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hythos on 30 October 2018, 10:30:21
Dig King (MiningMech)
(should be the correct one(?))
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: qc mech3 on 30 October 2018, 10:54:53
Wrong Harvester.  ;)

this is the Harvester Ant that's proposed. (and losing bad for now  :-[)
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Cache on 30 October 2018, 16:29:06
Dig King (MiningMech)
(should be the correct one(?))
The MkII is the dump truck with legs, as in my previous post. Nomination is here. (https://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=62932.msg1446994#msg1446994)
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: koalabirb on 31 October 2018, 01:59:16
Ooooo...come on Ursa, you can do it! I need me a "Rhino" in my life that isn't a clickybase.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Stinger on 31 October 2018, 07:37:36
Dak, do you have a painted buster prototype to show off?
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: mdauben on 31 October 2018, 10:24:53
No!  The Notos has fallen out of the top three!  :'(
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Weirdo on 31 October 2018, 11:15:30
The top three are all Battlemechs. I thought you people were supposed to be interesting!
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Sartris on 31 October 2018, 11:24:16
i'm full-fledged team primitives. after that it was between the quadvee and the mining mech. my arion is lonely so i went with the notos
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: qc mech3 on 31 October 2018, 12:28:12
I must agree with Weirdo, I find it sad to see the workmechs going out.  :'(
I always felt FF should be for things that are less likely to see play like workmechs or XTRO/unique units. Still, if peoples want them, those big mechs should be done.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Azakael on 31 October 2018, 14:49:47
I must agree with Weirdo, I find it sad to see the workmechs going out.  :'(
I always felt FF should be for things that are less likely to see play like workmechs or XTRO/unique units. Still, if peoples want them, those big mechs should be done.

I keep hoping for the workmechs. My Brotherhood of Fianna force needs the Daedalus, Buster, and Harvester Ant.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: klarg1 on 06 November 2018, 13:08:25
The top three are all Battlemechs. I thought you people were supposed to be interesting!

I want a mini of the Emperor's new look very much, so I voted for that.

Then I voted for the poor, unloved, Buster.  :-\
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Maingunnery on 06 November 2018, 13:40:59
I keep hoping for the workmechs. My Brotherhood of Fianna force needs the Daedalus, Buster, and Harvester Ant.
It will likely take some militarized art for them to get some real support.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: klarg1 on 06 November 2018, 14:10:11
It will likely take some militarized art for them to get some real support.

Possibly. The Raider isn't doing all that much better.

I don't think I'm particularly surprised at the relative popularity of battlemechs over their industrial cousins, after all, they are the top-billed stars of the show, but I can understand the disappointment.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Wrangler on 06 November 2018, 15:17:42
If TRO: Irregular tech had come out, it would bolstered the industrial mech crowd.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: The Wayfarer on 06 November 2018, 18:30:35
Unfortunately, with four industrial mechs splitting the vote, we’re working against our own interests.  Between the four we have enough votes to move the Raider into the top three with ease.

Just sayin’.

Mike

Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: truetanker on 07 November 2018, 18:34:42
Since one can't or isn't allowed to vote twice for the same unit...

Industrial love all the way...

TT
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: klarg1 on 07 November 2018, 19:53:16
Since one can't or isn't allowed to vote twice for the same unit...

Industrial love all the way...

TT

I think he's suggesting that people could change their votes to support the one Industrial to rule them all.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: truetanker on 07 November 2018, 22:54:07
No, more like " wish I could vote for the same unit, twice ".

TT
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hellraiser on 07 November 2018, 23:31:41
As nice as the new Prim-Emp looks, I still can't make myself vote for something that we already have some type of sculpt for.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Hellraiser on 07 November 2018, 23:38:14
Do we know how many of the list will be made?
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Sartris on 08 November 2018, 00:05:40
This is the poll to determine the top three
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Saint on 08 November 2018, 05:58:45
I changed my vote to the Raider once I saw the Buster fall behind. :'(
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Luciora on 08 November 2018, 10:35:10
Perhaps the suggestion criteria should have been more direct, as in construction mechs only?   Fan funding is a great tool, but if the starting criteria is too open, we will end up with results like this.  On the other hand, we know what will get guaranteed funding.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Weirdo on 08 November 2018, 10:47:56
Nah. People have a right to be boring if they want to.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: RoundTop on 08 November 2018, 11:41:09
Nah. People have a right to be boring if they want to.

Boring is for Mining mechs. These are Construction Mechs.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Weirdo on 08 November 2018, 12:00:29
(http://68.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m650qwKne51r7cs8z.gif)

Okay, well played.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Wrangler on 08 November 2018, 12:00:53
But but its a dump truck with legs...that's unique! MOD version has tons of rockets..
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Maingunnery on 08 November 2018, 12:14:16
MOD version has tons of rockets..
And how does it look like?

Most industrial mechs don't look very good, nor are they very effective.
This doesn't help with find support for them.
Especially if we have to take a gamble for how the weaponized version would look like.

I might have gone for a Daedalus, but how would it look like at the end?
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Wrangler on 08 November 2018, 13:28:58
And how does it look like?

Most industrial mechs don't look very good, nor are they very effective.
This doesn't help with find support for them.
Especially if we have to take a gamble for how the weaponized version would look like.

I might have gone for a Daedalus, but how would it look like at the end?

(https://proxy.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ebayimg.com%2Fimages%2Fi%2F111329109469-0-1%2Fs-l1000.jpg&f=1)
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: klarg1 on 08 November 2018, 15:08:51
And how does it look like?

Most industrial mechs don't look very good, <snip>

This is the big deal breaker for me. I am very unlikely to vote for a dump truck with legs; it just doesn't fit my aesthetic sense, and, at the end of the day, I buy miniatures to paint* much more than I buy them for their game statistics.

I recognize that it's all subjective, so I don't complain when things I wouldn't buy win, but it does control my vote. The buster and raider look like fun to paint to me. The mining 'mech not so much. (There are plenty of combat units I avoid for the same reasons)

I'll grant that the Harvester Ant is unique and interesting, if not exactly beautiful.


* - Well, really I buy miniatures based on aspirations of painting, and plans for hoarding, but the theory is there.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: IAMCLANWOLF on 09 November 2018, 12:28:06
Well, really I buy miniatures based on aspirations of painting, and plans for hoarding, but the theory is there.

Hahaha! So true!

Same-same.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: worktroll on 09 November 2018, 14:26:34
Remember, you can't die with minis unpainted. The more minis you buy, the longer you live!

Plastic modellers talk about their "strategic styrene reserves". I talk about my "magic Davion warehouse" ;)
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Maingunnery on 09 November 2018, 14:31:26
Remember, you can't die with minis unpainted. The more minis you buy, the longer you live!
Is having them only in base coating count?
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Weirdo on 09 November 2018, 15:09:07
If it ain't sealed, it ain't done!

By extension, Pine-Sol is a common ingredient in necromancy. Few live to spread reports that liches actually smell quite nice.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: klarg1 on 11 November 2018, 20:55:52
Plastic modellers talk about their "strategic styrene reserves". I talk about my "magic Davion warehouse" ;)


*ahem*

"Star League Cache"
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: Giovanni Blasini on 11 November 2018, 21:48:13
While I'd live to see the Mining Mech Mk II, I don't think it ever got stats for Battletech, so I went with the Buster and Harvester Ant. I recall both having plenty of variants that could work on the table.

Of course, what I really would want is a Chaffee.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: speck on 26 February 2019, 08:35:24
Due to Scourge not getting funded before release schedule coming out we will fund the Ursa next.
Title: Re: 2018 BattleMech / IndustrialMech Poll
Post by: tristanaqaueusrodentbane on 26 February 2019, 14:45:17
My first choice, the scourge, is already being done by IWM? So fan funding is doing my second choice? Huzzah for House Steiner!