Ok . . . 3 types, corrugated, standing seam, and r-panel; probably best to see what is used in your area and fits in for your neighborhood for value. From what I have heard, the order I gave is their complication on installing.
For Ohio IIRC, your two biggest issues will be hail and snow. I live in tornado Alley and hail is the big one. Each type "shows" hail damage to some degree, see what level you can handle. Replacing damaged portions is all going to depend on how they install.
Another thing, IMO is how many penetrations of your existing roof exists? You will want to know how whoever is putting on the roof intends to handle them.