BattleTech - The Board Game of Armored Combat

BattleTech Game Systems => Alpha Strike => Topic started by: Gian on 17 December 2023, 13:19:52

Title: Combat Intuition SPA Clarification
Post by: Gian on 17 December 2023, 13:19:52
Hello guys! Need a clarification on the Special Pilot Ability Combat Intuition. Page 93 of the ASCE Corrected 6th printing edition says:

"If this unit’s side wins Initiative, the unit whose pilot has this SPA can move and resolve all of its attacks during the Movement Phase, applying all damage effects immediately—before any target units can act. This ability can only be used once every 3 turns."

Can you attack first THEN move? Or should the unit move first before attacking?

Clarification please. Thank you.
Title: Re: Combat Intuition SPA Clarification
Post by: Gian on 19 December 2023, 23:53:35
Any answer to this?
Title: Re: Combat Intuition SPA Clarification
Post by: Son of Kerenski on 20 December 2023, 02:05:30
Reading the text logically it says an order of resolution - move first then attack. Thats the way Ive always played it.

But Im not Xotl so my answer isnt the final one.
Title: Re: Combat Intuition SPA Clarification
Post by: MarauderD on 20 December 2023, 11:38:49
Reading the text logically it says an order of resolution - move first then attack. Thats the way Ive always played it.

But Im not Xotl so my answer isnt the final one.

Another way to arrive at the same answer:  if we allowed people to fire and then move (as I read the OP's question) would that provide perhaps too great a benefit?  I can see how people might be able to use CI in those cases to cause the opposing force to lose a unit and then move completely out of the line of fire:  which isn't how the rule has played out in my experience.

Normally when you use CI, you are trying to remove some damaged (or light) units from the board before they get a chance to fire.  In return, your units are left exposed to counter attack.  CI is already a very strong ability in this form.  If you could fire and then move out of the line of fire, this might make it a tad overtuned.  I've used it in my last 3 Alpha Strike matches, and while I'm no authority, I think this interpretation would make it a little OP.