Haha, nah just yanking your chain. BTW, you don't actually ask any clear question in your post. I suppose you're just asking for general reviews?
Hmm, I'm not a Trekkie or BSGer, so I can't comment on most of these.
I liked Stacker Pentecost as the head of a small, dying, (para-)military organisation. He had to juggle recruitment, training, diplomacy, scientific R&D, logistics, the battlefield, and in the end stepping into the cockpit himself when needs must - he is to me THE template for a Battletech commander out of all on this list that I know of.
Ackbar is more the top-down fleet admiral, directing the grand fleet and interacting with squadron/flotilla leaders (Calrissian), yet also showing understanding and compassion for each Rebel lost in the fight. He shows a good combination of command presence, decisiveness and delegation in his brief moments onscreen. I love watching his scenes. It's a pity he doesn't get to shine in the new movies.
Veers is unfortunately the henchman to Vader, the Bad Guy, not much screentime as a result, but his competence is clear - as one has to be, to survive long under Vader's command. Wonderful poise; he is arguably the exemplar of peak Imperial military strength - survives ROTJ as well.
It's easy to dismiss Piett as the butt-monkey, the incompetent henchman to counter Veers' cool effectiveness, but remember he's at least better than Ozzel or Needa*. I guess the Navy just doesn't have m(any) competent commanders. Julian Glover, wish you had done even better serving the Lannister cause.
*who serves mainly to showcase Vader's rad smack talk skillz. Sick burns, homey.