BattleTech - The Board Game of Armored Combat

BattleTech Game Universe => The Inner Sphere => Topic started by: Jaim Magnus on 26 January 2011, 20:04:41

Title: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 26 January 2011, 20:04:41
A new home for the samurai and warriors of the Draconis Combine.  May House Kurita continue to prosper and defeat the yellow bird.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 26 January 2011, 20:12:09
i have to admit, that for a long time i found the combine bland, and only a place where samurai fanboys gather, but i've since come to really like them as a faction, and find a lot of their history really cool, to be fair i do like almost every faction.

also the 7th sword of light rules the day!  [rockon]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 January 2011, 20:36:07
Well... the Combine's Bushido storyline has been hit a few times.  I mean, how long has it been since the Samurai code has paid off for the Combine? Then again, it is an outdated code to begin with.  Still, the Combine will always be close to my heart, if only because it is populated by such die hards.  All I have to do is take a look through Historical: War of 3039 and i'm back in love.

Now, if only the Combine could get the Japanese stereotype of building great cheap machines.

Serve the Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 26 January 2011, 20:40:20
My only problem with the Combine lately has been the prevalence of the Black Dragon.  It turned into the Combine's one trick pony.  I wanna see more of the cultural mixing, how the way of the samurai works when applied to non-Japanese.

Like back in the day when we had Swedenese and Rasalhaguian samurai.  That doesn't come up very often anymore.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 26 January 2011, 20:43:07
My only problem with the Combine lately has been the prevalence of the Black Dragon.  It turned into the Combine's one trick pony.  I wanna see more of the cultural mixing, how the way of the samurai works when applied to non-Japanese.

Like back in the day when we had Swedenese and Rasalhaguian samurai.  That doesn't come up very often anymore.

i agree, we've seen in a lot of the books and on DA pilot cards that the combine is actually as multicultural as the other successor states, whether they acknowledge it or not. i particularly like the picture of stephen dirks, a scottish samurai, what's more badass than that
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 26 January 2011, 21:07:43
Him using his mech to wield a caber as a weapon?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Joshua D on 26 January 2011, 21:07:56
...stephen dirks, a scottish samurai...

hwha?! how have I not seen this yet......
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 January 2011, 21:14:17
(http://i696.photobucket.com/albums/vv326/Freelancer222/FI-L-012.jpg)

Baaaaaaad!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nibs on 26 January 2011, 21:15:28
I think we have a candidate for the next Coordinator...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 26 January 2011, 21:19:18
Indeed.  Those who disagree with him will be tossed like a caber.  And set on fire.

...

Makes seppuku look good.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 26 January 2011, 21:20:43
:O

His battle cry could be 'AAAAAAAAACCCCCCHHHHHHHHHH!!!!'
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: RAE on 26 January 2011, 21:55:58
Does he carry a pair of ceremonial claymores instead of traditional samurai daisho? :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 26 January 2011, 21:57:47
If he doesn't, he should because that would be made of awesome!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 26 January 2011, 22:18:48
that does seem like it would be the right thing to do
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 27 January 2011, 01:14:35
Well, if I didn't know he was from the Combine/Dragon's Fury I would think he's a Cappie.  The green robe and blurry characters on his headband makes me think of some of the old HB:HL illustrations.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Shirotora on 28 January 2011, 02:48:21
Konichiwa, comrades.

5thb SoL is in da hizzouse
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Doug Glendower on 28 January 2011, 04:00:27
I love the Lyran Commonwealth, but I've painted up a full company of 15th Benjamin Regulars led by Sgt. Duane "Kabukiman" Elliason, DCMS.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 01 February 2011, 18:01:29
in the DA there's a combine civil war, unfortunately i don't have the book that outlines the details of this conflict, daughter of the dragon i think, is there anyone out there that can give me a timeline or a crash course in the events that happen during the conflict
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 01 February 2011, 19:14:57
Not so much a full-fledged civil war as a successful coup d'etat with the possibility of a civil war.
Coordinator Vincent Kurita was assassinated thanks to his clinically crazy eldest son.  His younger son Theodore died earlier, trying to breech fortress republic.  The daughter, Emi, is in hiding with the Nova Cats but is presumed dead.
The Coordinator is Yori (Sakamoto) Kurita, granddaughter of Franklin Sakamoto, Teddy K's illegitimate son.  She's (supposedly) a puppet of the New Samarkand Warlord, Matsuhari Toranaga.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 01 February 2011, 20:27:47
thanx man, but i have one more question, in heretic's faith it mentions a bunch of times power jockying between the various warlords that i didn't fully know the context for, do you have anything on that?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 01 February 2011, 20:42:32
The warlords were always jockeying for position.  In the DA it's basically a combination of one-up-man-ship, a weakened coordinator and some misdirection on the part of the coordinator.  The Warlord of New Samarkand had aspirations of becoming Coordinator, but knew a non-Kurita would never be accepted so he 'acquired' a puppet.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 01 February 2011, 22:34:35
perfect, thanks a lot.

if i could trouble you one more time, since you seem to be lord kurita 'round these parts, do you have a list of the warlords in the DA, i only know katana and the guy you mentioned
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 01 February 2011, 22:45:58
Sure!

Doppo Saito - Warlord Pesht
Mitsura Sakamoto - Warlord Benjamin (died)
Mitsuhari Toranaga - Warlord New Samarkand
Katana Tormark - Warlord Dieron
Theodore Kurita II - Warlord Benjamin (replacement, also died)

Oh!  Also....

Ramadeep Bhatia - ISF Director
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 01 February 2011, 22:48:41
ah, i remember bhatia from heretics faith, he's....interesting.


perfect, thanks for all the help man
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 01 February 2011, 22:52:23
No prob.  I is here to serve.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: markhall on 03 February 2011, 04:59:55
(http://i696.photobucket.com/albums/vv326/Freelancer222/FI-L-012.jpg)

Baaaaaaad!
http://beemp3.com/download.php?file=1850304&song=0226+kamikaze+highlander (http://beemp3.com/download.php?file=1850304&song=0226+kamikaze+highlander)
I may have found his Theme song.


Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 25 March 2011, 13:53:13
So, fellow samurai... Kanrei Minamoto: Black Dragon or just the next best thing to one?

Been reading up on the Council of Gems and it seemed most have been named. And there's still one out there that's unaccounted for, could be Jerrar (the new ISF Director) or it could be Minamoto. As apparently the records were purged of a single name.

Also, anyone have any info on the BDS during the 3130s? Some have said that the Black Dragons are back again. And that's just the suck. Same old tired thing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nanaki on 25 March 2011, 14:07:27
Also, anyone have any info on the BDS during the 3130s? Some have said that the Black Dragons are back again. And that's just the suck. Same old tired thing.

Pretty much. The only major difference is that they no longer operate under the 'Black Dragon' name. See the Warlord discussion above for details.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 25 March 2011, 16:47:46
Pretty much. The only major difference is that they no longer operate under the 'Black Dragon' name. See the Warlord discussion above for details.

That was enlightening. Wonderful, another internecine war. I can't believe they killed off Vincent Kurita.

Clinically crazy eldest son? Great, and that guy from the cartoons' grandson is the new Coordinator/puppet.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neufeld on 25 March 2011, 17:18:54
So, fellow samurai... Kanrei Minamoto: Black Dragon or just the next best thing to one?

Been reading up on the Council of Gems and it seemed most have been named. And there's still one out there that's unaccounted for, could be Jerrar (the new ISF Director) or it could be Minamoto. As apparently the records were purged of a single name.

As I saw it, there was two Black Dragon factions during the Jihad: The ones that rebelled and the ones that stayed loyal to the council. Jerrar and Minamoto probably belongs to the second faction. Also, Sapphire can not be Jerrar, since the Sapphire refers to Jerrar in third person in a way that excludes the possibility. Minamoto is probably Sapphire.


Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 25 March 2011, 17:47:57
That was enlightening. Wonderful, another internecine war. I can't believe they killed off Vincent Kurita.

Clinically crazy eldest son? Great, and that guy from the cartoons' grandson is the new Coordinator/puppet.

Granddaughter.  Yori Kurita is a girl.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 25 March 2011, 19:15:32
Hmm, considering how willful Kurita women usually are I think the puppeteers may be underestimating this one.

As I saw it, there was two Black Dragon factions during the Jihad: The ones that rebelled and the ones that stayed loyal to the council. Jerrar and Minamoto probably belongs to the second faction. Also, Sapphire can not be Jerrar, since the Sapphire refers to Jerrar in third person in a way that excludes the possibility. Minamoto is probably Sapphire.

Yeah, seems like. Anyone else bored by this conflict though?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nanaki on 25 March 2011, 19:24:20
Yeah, seems like. Anyone else bored by this conflict though?

Not so much bored, but sick and tierd of it considering we Nova Cats have been continually getting the shaft because of it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 25 March 2011, 19:49:57
I'd have to agree it's time for something new.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 25 March 2011, 23:23:39
Hmm, considering how willful Kurita women usually are I think the puppeteers may be underestimating this one.

Yeah, seems like. Anyone else bored by this conflict though?

Internal division in the Combine is like breathing.  If it isn't ISF and O5P conspring it's the Black Dragons.  The Combine has become the League in that it is largely a second class power and most of it's actual storyline is taking place inside it's borders.  It has gotten a bit old to me, but that's just my opinion.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nanaki on 26 March 2011, 10:18:11
Internal division in the Combine is like breathing.  If it isn't ISF and O5P conspring it's the Black Dragons.  The Combine has become the League in that it is largely a second class power and most of it's actual storyline is taking place inside it's borders.  It has gotten a bit old to me, but that's just my opinion.

Only first-rate powers nowadays are the Capellans, the Republic and the Rasalhague Dominion.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 March 2011, 14:25:32
I dunno, the Feddies haven't really suffered any major setbacks.  They just have a loon for a First Prince
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nanaki on 26 March 2011, 19:34:29
I dunno, the Feddies haven't really suffered any major setbacks.  They just have a loon for a First Prince

Well, to be honest, they have not exactly recieved good luck, either. They have been in a state of slow decay for quite some time, while all three of the top-tier nations have been skyrocketing in overall strength (Well, the Republic's case is because of their possession of a superweapon).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 27 March 2011, 12:48:04
And I don't see it that way.  The Republic is basically surviving in a state of military dictatorship in a pocket of space that can't be invaded.  Most of the territory outside of Prefecture X has been gobbled up either by opportunists like the Senatorial Alliance and Covenant Worlds, or lost to pro-house movements like the Stormhammers and Dragon's Fury which really really hurt the Republic.

Honestly the Lyrans may have been considered a first rate power prior to invading the former League, but they have problems of their own now.  Still wouldn't count them out in the long run, I can't see Alaric being accepted by the Lyran people.  The League is barely reformed and Regulus still poses a big threat, but I don't think anyone is saying the reformed League is in the same category as the Cappies.

The Cappies seem to be the only power that hasn't collapsed in on itself, yet.  The greater and greater alienation of the Canopians may come back to bite them if Canopus formally aligns against Sian with Andurien's help.  That's my pereference as an Andurien sympathhizer, but unlikely.  The Fed Suns really haven't gotten it half as bad as anyone else, but Caleb's insanity is bound to get them into trouble eventually.  I'll be curious to see if he ends up getting the Suns into trouble with the Dragon the Cappies.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nanaki on 27 March 2011, 13:51:05
Quote
that can't be invaded.

That is the key phrase. Name me any other faction with the ability to warp time and space and make themselves impossible to be invaded. Sure, the Republic's fortress is not very big, but honestly, does it have to be? Ask yourself. What would you rather have: Fourty worlds that cannot be invaded by any means, or 400 worlds that can be invaded. I would rather have the fourty, because that would be fourty worlds that are perfectly safe, that I can build a powerful and extensive industry, R&D facilities, and economy within without the enemy being able to breach its defenses. This gives me the necessary power and economy to raid my enemy's facilities and invade their worlds, expanding my powerbase while my enemy can do -nothing- to strike back at me. Infact, if the ending of Surrender your Dreams is followed, this is -exactly- what the Republic does in the future... and it is going to suck when the successor states and clans that possess territory around Terra are going to get attacked and rolled by an enemy they cannot fight back against because the writers saw fit to give the Republic a superweapon that can only be countered by deus ex machina.

This is why the Republic is still a first rate power. Despite all their losses against the Successor States and Clans, those losses are irrellevant because the Republic possesses a superweapon that inevitably reverses the tables.

Quote
The Cappies seem to be the only power that hasn't collapsed in on itself, yet.

Well, The Combine collapsed on itself during the Jihad and the Black Dragons/Warlords has pretty much stopped them from making any progress in recovery. With insult to injury, it looks like the Black Dragons have actually succeeded in a coup de tat, which very likely will mean a civil war as the Warlord of New Samarkand will move to crush his opponents and unify the Combine under his leadership.

The Federated Suns has been pretty stable during and after the Jihad. They have their rogue nobles, but mostly the rogue nobles attack enemy states, not eachother. Their biggest weakness is Caleb,  but while things are almost inevitably bound for the pooper for them because of Caleb, it has not reached that point just yet.

The Lyrans were actually doing really well until their latest leaders made some collossal mistakes that handed their realm to the Wolves and Falcons on a silver platter. They are really in a bad spot, and I think things are so volatile in that region that almost anything could happen.

The Free Worlds League is probably the most intriguing. They are quite officially the Battletech  chew toy, they spent a chunk of their history being irrellevant (3025-3036), another chunk being a Blakist/Comstar catspaw (3036-3069), and the remaining chunk of it dead (3069-3139). So I think their ascendancy is a bit overdue. Despite being attacked by the Wolves and Lyrans the Free Worlds League had managed to stay together, and have been slowly regathering most of the component states back together. Despite their ascendancy, though, they still have a long way to go before they can be considered a first-rate or even second-rate power.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: sandstorm on 28 March 2011, 08:41:01
*quietly observes the discussion while tapping controls on a small noteputer*


Oh, don't mind me... Just a helping hand looking for ways to be of assistance...  8)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Mecha82 on 31 March 2011, 17:49:10
Greetings fellow samurais. I have returned and I'm happy to see that flame of the Dragon is still strong. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 April 2011, 12:52:54
That was enlightening. Wonderful, another internecine war. I can't believe they killed off Vincent Kurita.

Clinically crazy eldest son? Great, and that guy from the cartoons' grandson is the new Coordinator/puppet.

Why am i reading 'crazy eldest son' and thinking 'Jinjiro Kurita'?

Also does anyone know if the Legions of Vega survive into the dark age?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 01 April 2011, 13:07:32
Also does anyone know if the Legions of Vega survive into the dark age?

Yes. At least, there's a 7th LoV.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 April 2011, 13:14:35
Thanks RB.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Mecha82 on 02 April 2011, 13:16:38
I was wondering what were typical enemy mechs that DCMS might had captured during Successor Wars and War of 3039?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 02 April 2011, 13:28:05
Anything common to the AFFS & LCAF should be available in limited numbers.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Mecha82 on 02 April 2011, 13:40:02
Thanks. Thats nice selection from mechs in new boxed as it has so many AFFS mechs in it and alos some LCAF. Its good thing becouse among mechs in that box only 6 are onces that we use regulary.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: shadow_walker on 02 April 2011, 13:40:59
I wonder if the 2nd Legion of Vega survive to the dark age.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 02 April 2011, 21:50:26
Quote
I wonder if the 2nd Legion of Vega survive to the dark age.

They apparently made it through the Jihad.

However, Vega is ceeded to the Republic of the Sphere and then taken by Clan Ghost Bear's Omega Galaxy, so the Legions should probably be renamed.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 03 April 2011, 04:37:44
As roosterboy says on page 3 of the thread, there is a 7th Legion of Vega around in the dark age.

I'm hoping they are back to being the Penal Units they were originally created to be.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 24 April 2011, 02:45:40
I was wondering, in what era(s) do you guys play in with your Kuritans? And why?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 24 April 2011, 19:07:04
I typically play in the 3025-3039 era. I've played in the modern 3050-3067 era in a few campaigns, but I revert to the late Succession Wars era most of the time.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neko_Bijin on 24 April 2011, 19:14:34
My opinion is that House Kurita is most fun to play in 3025 and grows progressively less fun with each iteration of the game.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 25 April 2011, 03:12:16
My opinion is that House Kurita is most fun to play in 3025 and grows progressively less fun with each iteration of the game.

True, hopefully as we get fully into the dark age timeline this well be addressed.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 25 April 2011, 03:14:54
My opinion is that House Kurita is most fun to play in 3025 and grows progressively less fun with each iteration of the game.

I agree with that sentiment both gameplay and rp wise.

The constantly returning Black Dragon routine, the diminishment of traditionalism and the occassional bout of 'kamikaze' are regretful.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Mecha82 on 26 April 2011, 04:25:28
I prefer War of 3039 as I view it as high point of DCMS.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: sandstorm on 26 April 2011, 04:57:27
I have to agree with the end of 3rd SW to just before Clan Invasion being the most 'fun' time to play Kurita, and the closer to Clan invasion things get, the less fun it actually gets.

And past initial invasion and into the FCCW and Jihad, things get downright annoying and dreadful with how dried and dry things get. Dark age had potential for refreshing things up, but then it gets the 'megaloarmyitis' again.

The reason I came to BT and what interests me most is the small units and even lone mechwarriors with the funny stuff, which seems to be on the current official stomp list...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 April 2011, 14:49:04
I actually like playing the clan invasion and the Jihad era just because of the differences in technology between CSJ and the DCMS.  Jihad is fun because there are so many good DC designs at that point, plenty of bad ones too, but good ones i can use.  Plus, by the mid point of the Jihad DC combined arms gets better with the infusion of Hiryos, field gun infantry and .  Good stuff.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Black Mist on 05 May 2011, 10:42:20
Hey!
I am new to the boards,and(as you can see from the icon) the Dragon is one of my factions.One question though,what made each of you like the Combine?(personally it was the cool Japanese cultural aspects......and Grand Dragons I like Grand Dragons!)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 05 May 2011, 13:38:17
Hey!
I am new to the boards,and(as you can see from the icon) the Dragon is one of my factions.One question though,what made each of you like the Combine?(personally it was the cool Japanese cultural aspects......and Grand Dragons I like Grand Dragons!)

The same reason i like the early DC era up until after good ol' Theo.

I like the honor obsession, the values of duty, loyalty and traditionalism. I also like the fact it at times has a highly hypocrite (and hence realistic and human) edge. I'm a historian by education and one of my preferred era's is the Sengoku Jidai... so that explains it in part too.
The autocratic edge is nice, the concept of a 'coordiantor' too.
The DC also has the coolest emblem in my eyes and I like the Sword of Light units.
The DC occassionally also reminds me a little bit of the Scorpion Clan in Legends of the 5 Rings.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Doug Glendower on 05 May 2011, 16:43:48
My opinion is that House Kurita is most fun to play in 3025 and grows progressively less fun with each iteration of the game.
In Dark Age they only have two weapons: MRMs and the AC2. Enjoy. :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 05 May 2011, 17:29:02
In Dark Age they only have two weapons: MRMs and the AC2. Enjoy. :D

And we're probably still doing better than some factions like the Smoke Jaguars...
Then again with that kind of equipment... the poor Dracs will follow the Jags...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Dies Irae on 05 May 2011, 22:33:59
And we're probably still doing better than some factions like the Smoke Jaguars...
Then again with that kind of equipment... the poor Dracs will follow the Jags...

Free Worlds Leaguers scoff at your self-pity.  ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 06 May 2011, 09:53:15
This'd be the mob who rely (or relied) on the Light Gauss, which despite its shortcomings is still better than the A/C-2 or MRM, and which have reformed and are poised on the verge of delivering a beat down on their neighbours, yes?

Meanwhile, the Draconis Combine is riven by civil war, will require Catalyst to rehabilitate all of their Dark Age-era designs, and which is so hopeless they couldn't even re-capture Vega despite sending actual 'Mechs against armed IndustrialMechs.

... yeah.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 15 May 2011, 08:30:54
What is your favourite 'fluffy' but effective composition for the DC in the late Successor States for the DC when they were still gung-ho Samurai for:

- A light lance
- A medium lance (as rare as they were)
- A Heavy Lance
- An assault lance


And are there weight differing mechs (say a light and heavy) that are likely to be combined in one lance?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 30 May 2011, 16:02:26
For a light Fire Lance i'd use the following:-

Whitworth and 3 x Panther's

For the Light Strike/Recon Lance:-

Wolverine, Phoenix Hawk and 2 x Jenner's
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 30 May 2011, 16:29:55
Good to see the Dragon has its own thread.

No one visits the Draconis Combine website anymore.  :(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 31 May 2011, 01:18:08
Good to see the Dragon has its own thread.

No one visits the Draconis Combine website anymore.  :(

We have a website?  :o
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 31 May 2011, 06:35:52
We have a website?  :o

http://battletech.hopto.org/kurita/

Created by Deathshadow IIRC.

I'd love to see it have some life again!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 31 May 2011, 10:35:29
Cool. Regretfully I can't seem to sign up. Wants me to put in a code but no such window has appeared.  :(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: TJHairball on 31 May 2011, 14:01:08
What is your favourite 'fluffy' but effective composition for the DC in the late Successor States for the DC when they were still gung-ho Samurai for:

- A light lance
Panther, Panther, Jenner, Jenner. Make one or both Jenners -Fs and you're good to go.
Quote
- A medium lance (as rare as they were)
Whitworth, PHawk-K, Hunchback, Wolverine-K. One 'mech each at 40,45,50,55, and a mix of capabilities.
Quote
- A Heavy Lance
Dragon, Dragon, Dragon, Dragon. Preferably Grand Dragons at that.
Quote
- An assault lance
Warhammer -K (now that it's retconned to Kuritan), Charger, Battlemaster, Atlas. Unfortunately, the Charger and Atlas are the only assaults that the Combine fields an above-average number of, and assault 'mechs that work well are rare babies in the SW era (hence including a heavy).
Quote
And are there weight differing mechs (say a light and heavy) that are likely to be combined in one lance?
Panthers + Dragons can keep up with each other over mixed terrain (4/6/4 and 5/8/0) and would, by sheer frequency, often be found together.

Actually, probably the most "Draconis Combine" lance you could build would be Dragon + Grand Dragon + Panther + Jenner. The Jenner is a flanking unit in that case.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 31 May 2011, 14:18:14
Cool. Regretfully I can't seem to sign up. Wants me to put in a code but no such window has appeared.  :(

PM Deathshadow.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 June 2011, 16:01:44
is Deathshadow on here?

you should have some replys now Top.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 04 June 2011, 10:23:10
What would be a good selection of mechs to make up a c3 company that averages out at medium weight?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 04 June 2011, 13:43:27
For canon designs:

Blackjack Omni
Firestarter Omni
Kintaro
Avatar
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: sandstorm on 04 June 2011, 14:20:15
Could build it with a Bishamon 4K as lance commanders as well.

Might get a nasty company with pair of Jenner C's for spotting, Bihsamon 4K's for Masters and  possiblut Whitworths or even couple of C3 Archers to fill in some weight to cover the Jenners 'Light' class.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: TJHairball on 04 June 2011, 19:38:17
What would be a good selection of mechs to make up a c3 company that averages out at medium weight?
The Bishamon -4K is probably your best lance leader for a fast light lance. You want to pair it with 'mechs that can take advantage of having a lance that moves 7/11, i.e., Jenner (-C3 is better than -C, it's a lot like the JR7-F), Spider, Venom, Raptor, Owens. This is good if you need strategic mobility or a real recon unit (if you need a real recon unit, include an Owens in there).

The Daimyo can lead a lance of slow lights - Panthers or Wights in particular. 3 Wights plus a Daimyo is a pretty effective light-slugger lance with a uniform 5/8/0 movement bracket. The Daimyo is your "cheap" C3M option - if you don't want to spend a lot in tons or c-bills on C3Ms, put the Daimyo in. It actually wouldn't be ridiculous to use only Daimyos as C3Ms - it's an ERPPC machine, pretty durable for a 40 tonner, and mobile enough not to be easily hunted.

The Komodo is your jumping C3M option. It's 5/8/5 and a little risky (XLFE 45 tonner with close range weapons as a C3M?), but a Komodo lance can scare the crap out of people.

The Scorpion and Dragon are your 6/9/0 C3M options. As such, they make reasonable leaders for actual medium lances. Both are SNPPC+MML machines, which means that they're something of pinch-hit supporters intended to float around medium range. They're really similar to each other.

If you want to "average" at medium weight, you could actually include a heavy-duty 4/6/0 lance using a heavy or assault C3M. The HTM-CM is not a bad pick at 4/6/0 if you can afford the weight.

If you don't want duplicate names and just wanted things to fight with, needing an average weight falling in the 40-55 ton range, I would go with something like, oh:

Skirmish (145 tons)
Bishamon -4K
Jenner -C3
Venom -9KC
Spider -7KC

Middleweight (165 tons)
Daimyo -5K
Wight -1LAW/C3
Phoenix Hawk -7K
Komodo -2C

Assault (280 tons)
Hatamoto-Hi -CM
BattleMaster -K3 (2nd C3M unit; configure as C3 lance master in company battles, configure as a slave in lance battles)
Grasshopper -6K
Blackjack -OD

Average weight is a hair under 50 tons, so the company is on average medium even if only 5/12 'mechs are actually medium.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 05 June 2011, 11:48:02
Question: Are the No-Dachi and Akuma frequently present in the 5th Sword of Light? As I rarely see the Akuma used in such lances. And the No Dachi I only saw a single time used in a Sword of Light lance online.

Any reason for this?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 05 June 2011, 12:27:03
Thanks for the Medium Company (any more suggestions?) also would anyone be able to give me some ideas for Light, Heavy and Assault Companies?

Question: Are the No-Dachi and Akuma frequently present in the 5th Sword of Light? As I rarely see the Akuma used in such lances. And the No Dachi I only saw a single time used in a Sword of Light lance online.

Any reason for this?

Not sure about the Akuma but the No-Dachi is probably avoided as its produced by the Legions of Vega (well it was until Vega was lost to the Combine)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 05 June 2011, 12:35:38
the akuma is fairly new, so that could be the reason, though i'm not 100% sure, also it's a ticking time bomb
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 05 June 2011, 13:23:18
the akuma is fairly new, so that could be the reason, though i'm not 100% sure, also it's a ticking time bomb

It's a ticking timebomb?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kos on 05 June 2011, 14:40:16
Torso bomb, ammo goes Ka-Pow.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 05 June 2011, 14:43:53
LOL!  ;D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 05 June 2011, 15:26:00
Also the factory ends up in Republic space so we probably don't have access to it anymore.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 05 June 2011, 15:28:58
Also the factory ends up in Republic space so we probably don't have access to it anymore.

Well i'm only playing up to roughly the end of the Fedcom Civil War. I'm no fan of the Jihad. Heck not even that big a fan of the FedCom thing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: TJHairball on 05 June 2011, 15:31:45
Thanks for the Medium Company (any more suggestions?) also would anyone be able to give me some ideas for Light, Heavy and Assault Companies?

Not sure about the Akuma but the No-Dachi is probably avoided as its produced by the Legions of Vega (well it was until Vega was lost to the Combine)
The No-Dachi is produced by Independence Weaponry on Quentin. The ROTS does wind up with Quentin, which makes it one of the 'mechs that is probably not being produced post-Jihad; however, I would like to point out these passage in TRO: 3055 Upgrades:

While the Daikyu now serves in most Combine line regiments, newer designs such as the No-Dachi and Ninja-To are beginning to take its place in such prestigious units as the Genyosha and Ryuken.

Luthien Armor Works created the DAI-03 to grab back market share from Cosby BattleMech Research, whose No-Dachi capitalized on a “demon-mask” look and sword (playing to the samurai mindset). Along with Independence Weaponry’s Ninja-To and Shugenja, these designs all threatened to sideline the older Daikyu.

The first was a hand-to-hand struggle, while the second involved combat between Mbeki’s Daikyu and Gipps’ No-Dachi. That fight settled little, but Cosby BattleMech Research picked up on the media attention paid to warriors in such a famed unit fighting duels and is using it to grab market share from Luthien Armor Works’ Daikyu.

The No-Dachi, as of 3067, was biting into the heavy 'mech market share with a vengeance. It shouldn't be avoided any more than other Independence Weaponry DCMS 'mechs. I'd feel comfortable with fielding one in a company if it wasn't too far post-Jihad. Obviously it's not available pre-3062.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 05 June 2011, 15:55:31
I was wondering if 'Historicals - War of 3039' is still a useful sourcebook for a Fifth Sword of Light player?
Does it have a lot of info that is still useful? Or has it become quite outdated?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: sandstorm on 05 June 2011, 16:11:51
Depends on how you describe outdated, really.

Historicals are pretty new series of sourcebooks, so they are not out-dated in same way as some of the oldest FASA sourcebooks.

On the other hand, if you mean in-universe info, then it'd depend on what timeframe you're playing in. For post-Jihad era it'd be pretty outdated, but if you're pre-FedCom Civil War, or even just-edging into Clan Invasion era... Well, it'd be much more relevant.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Darthvegeta800 on 05 June 2011, 16:14:34
I do play Successor Wars up to Fed Com era. But i'm a bit unsure wether to fork over cash for it instead of another miniature. Is there a lot of info specifically for the 5th Sword of Light and 7th Crucis Lancers in there that's more than a little blurb?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 06 June 2011, 15:09:43
Looking at TRO3085's ONN section and XTRO Kurita i'm more confident that the No-Dachi is still in production post jihad.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 10 September 2011, 02:25:36
question for peoples that might know more than me. I am setting up a Sword of Light company, early jihad, and I am wondering the likely-hood of it being a C3 Company. I figure that the Genyosha, Ryuken, Ghost regiments, and Legions of Vega are all moderate to heavy C3 users, but my reading of FM:DC and FM:Updates are inconclusive about the SoL regiments. Do the SoLs use much C3?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 10 September 2011, 09:30:23
The answer is more complicated.  Even within the Sword of Light brigade there are those that ardently rejected any and all reforms to the DCMS, including c3, such as the 2nd Sword of Light.

Ryuken regiments seem like good candidates, given their Dragoon roots.  Sword of Light and Genyosha regiments seem (personal opinion here, not fact) to be more about the individual prowess of their warriors.  After all, the Sword of Light and Genyosha regiments are the hardened elite of the DCMS, as well as the most prestigious assignments.  Typically, if it's a high profile unit they traffic in dumb.  Conversly, the Ryuken, Legions of Vega and a few Ghost Regiments are held in low regard but are the banner carriers of Teddy K's changes, including c3.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: sandstorm on 10 September 2011, 13:13:19
Genyosha is only as old as the Ryukens are. Its only distinction from those is that it was founded by an actual Kurita. But Yorinaga built it as a foil to the Kell Hounds, so they might be more flexible in their thinking than people are necessarily willing to give them credit for.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 11 September 2011, 09:57:26
Well, the Genyosha, looking back on it have all the history to suggest being c3 users.  The 1st Genyosha personally pledged to Teddy, was led by Hohiro and borrows tactics from the Ghost Regiments.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 11 September 2011, 11:32:15
Well going by the equipment used by Sorenson's Sabres in the starterbook the 5th SoL might be flexible enough to use c3.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 11 September 2011, 11:36:11
Well going by the equipment used by Sorenson's Sabres in the starterbook the 5th SoL might be flexible enough to use c3.

i think by that time they're part of the otomo
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 11 September 2011, 21:55:36
Ok round two!

This is what I have right now. This is a Generic (Sword of Light) DCMS company, early to mid Jihad.
Command Lance
Tai-Sho TSH-7S
Mauler MAL-C
Grand Dragon DRG-7K
Black Hawk-KU variant X BHKU-X

Recon Lance
Bishamon BSN-4K
Jenner JR7-C3
Jenner JR7-C2
Spider SDR-7KC

And this is the one I am having problems with. For this project I am trying to use mech minis that I already own (and I am tapped out of unassigned DCMS signature mechs), so what I have right now is:

"Other" Lance
Grand Dragon DRG-9KC
Catapult CPLT-K5
Daikyu DAI-02
Wight WGT-1LAW/SC3

I am pondering turning this into a more traditional fire support lance by replacing the Grand Dragon with a Naginata (that I would have to buy) and changing the Daikyu to the DAI-01 model (swapping the Medium laser for a C3 Slave). Which sounds better, the hodge podge "Almost a Heavy Cav" lance or an actual "Fire Support Lance"? More drastic opinions are welcome, as long as I don't have to buy too many new minis  #P.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 04 August 2012, 11:48:48
I've just been looking at FM3085 again, do you think the way the 1st New Samarkand Regulars are organised could become the norm for District Regular Forces?

If they DCMS split the other District Regulars they would increase the number of worlds that could be garrisoned.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 04 August 2012, 23:15:38
I'm still trying to figure out what exactly its saying the composition is.

I originally though it was composed of combined arms battalions, with a company each of `Mechs, BA and Armor, but now that I've looked over it a few times I'm thinking it its comprised of combined arms companies, each with a lance of `Mechs, BA and Armor.

If its the second...sure, the unit can spread out and cover multiple worlds easily, but I'm not sold on the effectiveness. It might work for a while after the Jihad, when the other factions are just as trashed, but I'm not sure I'd count on it for much as rebuilding goes on.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 05 August 2012, 05:43:51
I took it as 3 combined arms Battalions each with 1 Mech, 1 Armour and 1 Battle Armoured Infantry Companies.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 05 August 2012, 10:28:26
So did I until I got to the line about "...with each company having the same overall composition." I suppose it could mean that each company is 3 lances, but it really seems more like each company has the same component parts, and just whoever is in command switches per company.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: foxbat on 06 August 2012, 02:00:29
I think Maelwys has it right : the FM states that the nS organization is reminiscent of the ceti Hussars or Com Guards, who make use of combined arms at the smallest tactical echelons. So I'll gather individual companies will comprise a mix of mechs, vees and infantry.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 06 August 2012, 13:38:46
So probably good for defensive missions and raids etc.

Or another way of looking at it, perfect for the DA timeline.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 06 August 2012, 17:52:02
So probably good for defensive missions and raids etc.

Or another way of looking at it, perfect for the DA timeline.

Depends on how broken up the unit is. If its a company per planet, then theoretically that's good, and might work against say, the Sub-Factions that MWDA started with, but once the Houses got involved, the smaller size is going to become a liability.

Just after the Jihad it should be fine, able to show the flag and do a little bit of everything, but as rebuilding goes on, its going to be less effective.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 18 August 2012, 05:04:23
Something i thought to ask yesterday but forgot to post.

Given the use of the C3 system in the DCMS should all new designs use it or should it be abandend given the amount of ECM in use on the modern battlefield or should both designs that use and don't use the system continue to be bought by the procurement department in the post jihad era?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 18 August 2012, 05:19:14
The canon trend is that the DCMS is plugging in C3 into everything, hell even DropShips.

ECM is still only 6 hexes, and a C3 spotter is going to be just close enough to get to short range. There is no reason to abandon it because of the prevalence of ECM. However, I feel ECCM should be tournament legal.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 18 August 2012, 05:32:51
Well thats what i thought, but looking back through TRO3085 its close to a 50/50 split and TRO:Prototypes none of the DCMS mechs use it.

This seems to imply that the DCMS is moving away from the system.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 18 August 2012, 08:03:14
Whilst the DCMS has access to what is in theory a great amount of C3-equipped designs, in practice most are "get the original chassis, remove a Medium Laser, and call it a day" models as opposed to designs built from the beginning to take advantage of C3, resulting in them underperforming compared to those of other factions which are purposely designed to make use of C3.

Then there's the problem of C3 being something that flies in the face of the way the Traditionalists (not even Black Dragons, just the old guard) want to approach war. Canon-wise, most regiments prior to Bulldog only had a single C3 Company (or three Lance-level setups) in their ranks.

Compounding that you've got the wide availability of ECM and the crippling cost BV-wise (or under pretty much any other balancing metric) of setting up a worthwhile network based on what it might be capable of under optimal conditions that are never actually seen in play.

Given all that, I'd say that the Bulldog-era ratio is about as good as it's going to get. From 3062 onwards, anything with a C3 device on it is about as likely to be a FedCom machine as a DCMS one any way.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: MadCapellan on 18 August 2012, 08:24:26
Well thats what i thought, but looking back through TRO3085 its close to a 50/50 split and TRO:Prototypes none of the DCMS mechs use it.

Considering their 'Mechs from Prototypes consist of a basic Gauss carrier using an unpopular chassis and an underwater combat specialty unit, I don't really see that as indicative of what the DCMS is using in the 3090s. 

As for 3085, let's take a look -
LCT-5W2 Locust - Everyone is described as fielding it.  It has C³ slave
MON-86 Mongoose - Doesn't have C³
HM-1r Hitman - A variant already exists with C³ slave.  Refit is of existing version that did not have C³ slave.
NX-80C Nyx - New C³ slave variant
SDR-7Kr/8K Spider - A variant already exists with C³ slave (7KC) which is concurrent.
JR7-C4 Jenner - Possesses boosted C³slave!
PNT-13K Panther - A variant already exists with C³ slave.
PXH-7K/8CS Phoenix Hawk - both carry C³ slave
GST-10 Ghost - Import, no C³
SKW-2F Shockwave - Import, no C³
TSN-1Cr Tessen - has C³ slave
GRF-4R Griffin - common refit throughout the Inner Sphere, no C³
SHD-3K Shadow Hawk - has C³ slave
TFT-C3 Thunder Fox - Combine variant has C³ slave.
DRG-5Nr Dragon - C³ slave
DRG-7KC Grand Dragon - possesses boosted C³ slave!
OSR-4K Ostroc - no C³
ARC-9M Archer - produced by multiple nations, no C³
DAI-01r Daikyu - possesses boosted C³ slave!
NDA-2KC No-dachi - possesses C³ slave
MAD-9W2 Marauder - possesses C³ slave
CGR-3Kr Charger - refit of chassis that originally lacked C³ slave.
HTM-28Tr Hatamoto-Chi - possesses C³ slave
VTR-Cr Victor - possesses boosted C³ slave!
BLR-K4 BattleMaster - no C³, but multiple previous versions possess C³ Masters
GUN-2ERDr Gunslinger - C³ master
AKU-2XC Akuma - possesses boosted C³ slave!
CP-11-C3 Cyclops - possesses boosted C³ master!
OR-2I Orochi - no C³
NG-C3Ar Naginata - possesses boosted C³ master!
PKP-1A/1B Peacekeeper - possesses C³ slave

So, as you can see, the vast majority of the 'Mech designs the Combine gained in TRO: 3085 had C³ or boosted C³.  In instances where they did not, it was generally because it was a foreign design a refit of a chassis that previously didn't have C³ to begin with, or a 'Mech that already has serviceable C³ equipped variants.  The only exceptions to those specifications are the Orochi, Mongoose, and the Ostroc.

Considering that a large number of new C³ equipped variants were added to the DCMS by TRO: 3085, and in fact the faction has continued to push development of the technology forward by creating units using boosted C³, I'd have to say that evidenec actually points towards the DCMS continuing to favor the technology.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 19 August 2012, 13:53:56
Thanks for the list MadCap, i didn't realise we had that many boosted C3 systems, what with them being a FedSuns design.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 22 August 2012, 12:34:42
Thanks for the list MadCap, i didn't realise we had that many boosted C3 systems, what with them being a FedSuns design.

Omi was busy copying the drive of Victor's laptop after he would fall asleep.  ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 22 August 2012, 13:13:43
Nice one Top.

Something else i thought of, to give the DCMS more of its own flavour (make it less AFFS), so as an example instead of it being the 1st Genyosha and 2nd Genyosha we would have Genyosha-ichi and Genyosha-ni?

What do the rest of you think? Although as a lot of material has already been published it would have to take place after 3150 ideally with a new Kuritan coordinator on the throne.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: MadCapellan on 22 August 2012, 13:51:46
The Ryuken already does that, does every DCMS unit need to?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 22 August 2012, 14:09:20
I'd like to see it so there's some variety between the differnet great house armies, at the moment, with the exception of the CCAF, they all come across as very similar.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 22 August 2012, 19:13:19
how so? there are no overlapping names at all. and for the less obtuse answer, it's just common military practice as far as my limited military knowledge can make out; there are the occasional regiment like some countries have a 'royal guards' sans numbers and what not but other wise it's kinda just the way it is. cappellan military has a history of integrating mercenary commands into their ranks, as well as allowing some regional commands to be named after their commander and what not. IMO it;s the names of the regiments themselves that define them as being from one nation, not the fact that they use numbering conventions.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 23 August 2012, 00:16:07
Even the Confederation uses the 1st, 2nd, etc on things like the Reserve Cavalry. I don't think it really needs to be translated, it works well enough for its purpose.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: anime ninja on 12 September 2012, 15:52:28
I am new to the boards. 

The Combine was the faction that I played back when I started in the late 80's early 90's (Old age I can't remember when I started but I know it was before I went to Collage).

I have started to get back in to the hobby after being away for years and have things really changed.  I have been trying to catch up on the Jihad story line.

Our group is playing a 3020's campaign but it has mostly stalled.  The players are playing Davion.... :(

I am thinking that I might try a time jump to the War of '39 or the invasion to get some life back in to it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: foxbat on 13 September 2012, 02:27:58
Welcome back to the game!
Our group is playing a 3020's campaign but it has mostly stalled.  The players are playing Davion.... :(

Though there's, IMO, nothing wrong with that, I'll try to lend you a hand from across the border.  ;)

The good news is that you can jump in right into the game from where you left long ago without fear. Battletech has a line of products that spans different eras, and you'll find some recent (not too old at any  rate... ) books to cover the 3020-3039 span pou arez interested in, background-wise.
In fact you have two books that will be of interest to you, pending the publication of the House Kurita Source Book (work is moving forward at speed on this one, as the book developper  just told us), in the Historicals section :

http://bg.battletech.com/?page_id=496 (http://bg.battletech.com/?page_id=496)

- War of 3039 is a blow by blow account of all that took place in this conflict
- Brushwars has a section by Ben Rome about the 3035 Ronin Wars. I'll strongly recommend it, as it is, in my opiniuon, one of the best pieces of BT fiction ever written.

Rules wise, it would be a good idea to get hold of Total Warfare, the revamped version of the rules, in order to get all the improvements to the rules (have no fear, there are no huge modifications) and if you like to design your own units, the Tech Manual. You will also get as a bonus lots of excellent short stories interspersed with the rules, and if you are into miniatures, a very good tutorial on painting them.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 13 September 2012, 02:34:20
3039 is a good conflict. It lets you work in some advanced tech without being overwhelmed by it, and it seems to cover you and your player's favorite factions, the DC and the FS. It even sort of ends in a stalemate so no one goes away too unhappy.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 13 September 2012, 02:47:14
FWIW, I would advise using the Total Warfare weapons and equipment instead of the Prototype gear in Sword and Dragon or H: Wo3039. The Prototype equipment uses rules that are more complicated than the final production stuff, which doesn't really help much.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: anime ninja on 13 September 2012, 17:07:33
I have the old TROs from 2750 to 3058.  As well we are playing with MW2 as the RP part.

I was thinking of doing the jump to 3039 and have the unit as a "test" unit.  They get all of the new and shiny toys but they have to deal with the Combine waiting to get it as well.

The mechs that the group has are:
1 x Archer
2 x Marauder
1 x Griffin
1 x Quickdraw
1 x Stalker

Not all of them are in use, there are 4 players.

I will look at the new rule book.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: felix77-26 on 29 December 2012, 05:05:51
New member here, just wanted to show that the Dragon is still around!

Why the Draconis Combine you ask? Well, I figured the Inner Sphere factions were all dictatorships anyways, so might as well choose the one with the coolest name and logo. The Power of Proper Religion reporting for duty.

To add to the thread and discussion, I have a question. What were the Draconis Combine fleet assets circa 3025? and which book contains information on those ships
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 29 December 2012, 05:25:57
New member here, just wanted to show that the Dragon is still around!
Greetings!

Why the Draconis Combine you ask? Well, I figured the Inner Sphere factions were all dictatorships anyways, so might as well choose the one with the coolest name and logo. The Power of Proper Religion reporting for duty.
At least you have chosen the regiment which survived the Jihad.  O0

To add to the thread and discussion, I have a question. What were the Draconis Combine fleet assets circa 3025? and which book contains information on those ships
If you are asking about capital Warships, then I doubt there were left any. The only preserved one was DCS Togura (in my opinion; and this ship was just orbital museum).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: sandstorm on 29 December 2012, 11:06:03
And as for where to look for 3025 era information on the Dragon? That'd be House Kurita, but that was printed in 1986 and I am not too sure how one can find it anymore.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 29 December 2012, 11:13:51
And as for where to look for 3025 era information on the Dragon? That'd be House Kurita, but that was printed in 1986 and I am not too sure how one can find it anymore.
Well, you mentioned House Kurita Housebook which used to be available for a free download (and perhaps it will be again in the future).

This is what Herb Beas said in the last BattleChat about the upcoming Handbook: House Kurita:
Quote
<Nomer>: And, on the subject of HB how goes HB:K? will we see it by the end of the year?
<Habeas2>: Nomer - Handbook: Kurita is running a bit behind schedule, and may not make it out before year's end, but we keep hoping.
So perhaps in January or February ...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 29 December 2012, 12:13:56
There's a PDF link under Notes here (http://www.sarna.net/wiki/House_Kurita_%28The_Draconis_Combine%29) from Sarna.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 29 December 2012, 13:03:48
So perhaps in January or February ...

Later.

http://benhrome.wordpress.com/handbook-house-kurita/
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 29 December 2012, 13:08:02
Later.
(Expected publication date: mid-2013)
Thanks for answer.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ferrosol on 05 January 2013, 15:57:54
So can you guys recommend me a DCMS regiment.  Some background here, I will be playing in a jihad era campaign and I am looking for a mid range DCMS unit. I.E. not an elite regiment like the Sword of Light or Genyosha but also not a sink hole unit like the Legions of Vega to play as. Preferably they should be one of the regiments that does not defect to the black dragons but I can play a black dragon regiment if need be, (It could be fun from an rp perspective to play a loyal splinter of a traitorous unit). So with that in mind suggest some units for me because my knowledge of the DCMS is sadly lacking.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 05 January 2013, 16:25:44
I believe the 2nd or 4th Arkab Legion is still around, and if you like mobile warfare there are few better.

If you use the Regimental abilities, if your pilots have 3 Gunnery or better they may fire during the movement phase.

No assault class 'mech, though.  :(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 05 January 2013, 16:27:02
So can you guys recommend me a DCMS regiment.  Some background here, I will be playing in a jihad era campaign and I am looking for a mid range DCMS unit. I.E. not an elite regiment like the Sword of Light or Genyosha but also not a sink hole unit like the Legions of Vega to play as. Preferably they should be one of the regiments that does not defect to the black dragons but I can play a black dragon regiment if need be, (It could be fun from an rp perspective to play a loyal splinter of a traitorous unit). So with that in mind suggest some units for me because my knowledge of the DCMS is sadly lacking.

That's pity since the 2nd Sword of Light would be good for this because one half of the regiment joined Black Dragons in December 3067, while the other half remained loyal to the DCMS. In mid-Jihad the surviving Loyalists were re-formed into the 9th Sword of Light. So you could go from the beginning of the Jihad all the way to the victory over the Word of Blake.

Something similar has happened to the 6th Benjamin Regulars.

Chosing regiment which is gonna be nuked from orbit or overrun by a Shadow Division or two promises no big fun.

What enemy would you like to fight? Black Dragons, Clan Diamond Shark, Davions or the Word of Blake?

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ferrosol on 05 January 2013, 16:40:01
That's pity since the 2nd Sword of Light would be good for this because one half of the regiment joined Black Dragons in December 3067, while the other half remained loyal to the DCMS. In mid-Jihad the surviving Loyalists were re-formed into the 9th Sword of Light. So you could go from the beginning of the Jihad all the way to the victory over the Word of Blake.

Something similar has happened to the 6th Benjamin Regulars.

Chosing regiment which is gonna be nuked from orbit or overrun by a Shadow Division or two promises no big fun.

What enemy would you like to fight? Black Dragons, Clan Diamond Shark, Davions or the Word of Blake?

Chances are our game will go non-canon fairly quickly so I would not be surprised to see any of the DC's neighbours on the other side of a battlefield. So it could be anything from the Raven Alliance to the Lyrans. That said from things the GM has let slip that the main opponent will likely be blakists but I should be ready for anything.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 05 January 2013, 17:24:56
Chances are our game will go non-canon fairly quickly so I would not be surprised to see any of the DC's neighbours on the other side of a battlefield. So it could be anything from the Raven Alliance to the Lyrans. That said from things the GM has let slip that the main opponent will likely be blakists but I should be ready for anything.

(http://i.imgur.com/rnHFC.png)

21st Galedon Regulars - "The Dragon's Tail"

They are mobile unit with some OmniMechs, average experience; average weight of their 'Mechs is bordering Medium/Heavy weight classes.

With a bit of luck, you may get some pretty good equipment from RATs.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 05 January 2013, 17:39:58
Do note that while in other militaries an "average weight" in the Medium range is usually indicative of a fair concentration of Medium 'Mechs, whereas the DCMS has historically despised the Medium weight class and an average in that range is more likely to be a reflection of mixed Lights (mostly the Panther) and Heavies (mostly the (Grand) Dragon), though.

Of the units that survive the Jihad, I'd probably recommend the 17th Benjamin Regulars. Veteran, B-rated unit with 30% Clan gear, 55% 3050+ gear, and 45% Omnis is not a bad way to start and they are at full strength before the Jihad. By FR: DC they are down to Regular skill and 30% strength but have full upgrades. They were fairly well-involved throughout the Jihad; there's a Sarna (http://www.sarna.net/wiki/17th_Benjamin_Regulars) page that at a quick glance appeared to be pretty correct.

The Second Deiron Regulars are another good choice; C-grade supply, 50% Clan, 35% 3050+, and 45% omnis, and Elite skill at 85% strength before the Jihad starts. 40% strength, 100% upgrades, and still Elite when the Jihad ends. Sarna link

As a bonus, both units fight in Operation Scour. (http://www.sarna.net/wiki/2nd_Dieron_Regulars[/here[/url)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 05 January 2013, 17:58:12
Of the units that survive the Jihad ...

Well, I was not sure if I should recommend only units that are gonna survive the Jihad, or not. But since the OP said that the campaign will probably deviate from canon soon, I thought that it doesn't matter too much, after all.

Do note that while in other militaries an "average weight" in the Medium range is usually indicative of a fair concentration of Medium 'Mechs, whereas the DCMS has historically despised the Medium weight class and an average in that range is more likely to be a reflection of mixed Lights (mostly the Panther) and Heavies (mostly the (Grand) Dragon), though.

It's true, sure.

But before the Jihad has begun, the DCMS gained access to some pretty good Medium 'Mechs:
WVR-8K/8C Wolverine
LNX-9Q/9C Lynx
GRF-1DS Griffin
BSN-3K/4K Bishamon
BJ2-O Blackjack Omni
FS9-O Firestarter Omni
KIM-2 Komodo
PXH-3K Phoenix Hawk
Just to name a few ...

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 05 January 2013, 20:47:14
I think the "Medium Hate" went away after 3039. The Crab really impressed the DCMS and they even tried a few homebrews and worked on stuff like the Tessen and Grim Reaper. The Kuritan Wolverines are just excellent post 3050. I think the old Jenner/Panther and Dragon mix has fallen by the wayside.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 05 January 2013, 23:38:57
I think the "Medium Hate" went away after 3039.

Nope. FM: DC notes that the Clan Invasion strongly reinforced the dichotomy, and that medium 'Mechs are still not very common in the DCMS on p. 14. The only real change that was made was replacing lighter non-Panther designs with faster heavies like the Grand Dragon.

Quote
The Crab really impressed the DCMS and they even tried a few homebrews and worked on stuff like the Tessen and Grim Reaper.

They were only involved as production partners on the Tessen and Grim Reaper. They are technically available to the Combine (and there are some refits for that purpose), but generally speaking those are ComStar 'Mechs the Combine doesn't use in any real numbers.

Quote
The Kuritan Wolverines are just excellent post 3050.

The WVR-7K is a long-standing favourite of mine, but I'm not big on the -8 or -9 series. I'd have been (and am, custom-wise) quite happy with a -7K that mounted a C3 Slave, at the expense of either the Small Pulse or downgrading the Medium Pulse to a standard Medium. 

Quote
I think the old Jenner/Panther and Dragon mix has fallen by the wayside.

Not according to the fluff. I mean, I'd be reluctant to run a heavily fluff-based DCMS force too since it would mean your most common 'Mechs (in rough order of appearance) would be the PNT-10K, DRG-5K, and HTM-27T even as late as 3067, and when the Combine is fielding entire companies of the first two across multiple regiments going into the Jihad it takes a while to whittle them down. The Jenner was more common in the Combine than anywhere else in the Sphere, but it never came close to having the numbers of the Panther.

I guess that the "good" news is that if you're using the rules from FM: U for force selection in conjunction with Combat Operations a fair propotion of any unit's Clan percentage will be a PNT, DRG, or HTM with one or two random Clan items on it. Like a HTM-27 with a Clan ER PPC and an extra Heat Sink to not help balance the additional burden, or a DRG-5K with a rear-facing Clan ER Medium Laser >.<

That said, if I was expecting to have to fight LAAF or AFFS units (to say nothing of the Blakists) I wouldn't be fielding that many PNT-10Ks, DRG-5Ks, or HTM-27Ts either, but fluff-wise probably the units that would actually look like that are the Ryuken and Genyosha, and even then there would still be some of those three designs present.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 07 January 2013, 10:31:45
Why the Ryuken?  Being bottom of the supply chain?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 07 January 2013, 16:03:14
The worst-supplied Ryuken regiment going into the Jihad is B-rated. When they were re-formed around 3039, it was with A* equipment, suggesting that the bulk of what they started over with had came from the ComStar deal. They were also given a full Battalion of OmniMechs when LAW put them into production, and by '67 the worst-equipped Ryuken regiment is still 33% Omnis and and 20% Clan with 50% 3050+ technology.

That is also an extremely unusual situation for any DCMS unit. By contrast, the average Draconis March Militia regiment is slinging 58% 3050+ tech at a supply grade of D or F, the bulk of which canonically are Project Phoenix/Project Phoenix Upgrade designs, and we're still not talking about AFFS formations that are supplied at the standard rate or better.

The Robinson Rangers, roughly analogous to one of the lesser District of Dieron Regulars in terms of how they are used, have 90-100% upgrades; the Dieron District Regular commands are way behind on upgrade percentages (and individual design quality since they are based mostly around the 3050 PNT, DRG, and HTM even going into the Jihad) at 42% 3050+ and 25% Clan. Frankly, you need to be taking some of the best available design options to make up for the batallion of 3025-era machines you're stuck with if you're expecting to fight even one of the lower-end AFFS units of the time, especially since the AFFS boasts a very high number of Veteran and Elite commands on top of all that.

This still isn't comparing the best-supplied DCMS commands with the best-supplied AFFS commands, where the differences are even more magnified; comparing well-supplied DCMS units to (the lower end of) average-supplied AFFS units is bad enough, and this becomes a problem during campaigns. The bigger issue, to me, is that the campaign is intended to also feature the Lyrans; lopsided as comparing the the AFFS to the DCMS is, they're in for a world of hurt against the DCMS and the AFFS is so much further out in front it boggles the mind.

I'd really have a chat with the GM about unit generation or at least get the group on board with a balanced approach to unit selection. YMMV.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: felix77-26 on 15 January 2013, 16:41:32
Greetings!
At least you have chosen the regiment which survived the Jihad.  O0
If you are asking about capital Warships, then I doubt there were left any. The only preserved one was DCS Togura (in my opinion; and this ship was just orbital museum).
Thanks!

And as for where to look for 3025 era information on the Dragon? That'd be House Kurita, but that was printed in 1986 and I am not too sure how one can find it anymore.
Luck would have it that I found it at a games store for 5 bucks. Dropships and Jumpships too for 3. Now I know why they removed the pictures in the free PDF downloads...

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ferrosol on 16 January 2013, 12:02:25
So can you guys recommend me a DCMS regiment.  Some background here, I will be playing in a jihad era campaign and I am looking for a mid range DCMS unit. I.E. not an elite regiment like the Sword of Light or Genyosha but also not a sink hole unit like the Legions of Vega to play as. Preferably they should be one of the regiments that does not defect to the black dragons but I can play a black dragon regiment if need be, (It could be fun from an rp perspective to play a loyal splinter of a traitorous unit). So with that in mind suggest some units for me because my knowledge of the DCMS is sadly lacking.
Ended up going with the 4th Arkab Legion after a bit of reading, But thanks for the advice and suggestions guys. Now I just need to learn how to play with the dcms's toys. MRMs and C3 on everything here I come.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 February 2013, 03:20:10
Here's to hoping we get to Falcon Punch somebody in the 3150 era.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 05 April 2013, 22:08:30
Here's to hoping we get to Falcon Punch somebody in the 3150 era.

I never thought I'd be so sad after reading about House Kurita Falcon Punching someone.  :'(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: MadCapellan on 05 April 2013, 22:17:43
Hey!  Hey!  There's no crying in the DCMS!  "RARG, ME CONQUER UNIVERSE!" and all that! No sympathy allowed!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Lord Harlock on 05 April 2013, 23:07:48
Hey!  Hey!  There's no crying in the DCMS!  "RARG, ME CONQUER UNIVERSE!" and all that! No sympathy allowed!

Under Dictum Honorium, sympathy will result in TORTURE.

I never thought I'd be so sad after reading about House Kurita Falcon Punching someone.  :'(

Well as I said, ouch. Though I'm going to figure that the kitties and feddies (including me) appreciate the sympathy. Hopefully, this time the Combine doesn't go tear down the Robinson Battle Academy brick by brick. And I guess Mardok was a short term success. Thanks a lot Sandovals.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 06 April 2013, 00:13:33
Yeah, not the targets I'd have preferred.

But man, I'm liking the shape of the Combine politically. Now it's a little more intriguing, though I can't still get over how Theodore Kurita II chose to be part of a jumpship crew to test a jump into Fortress Republic. Maybe not much of a spoiler but still.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 06 April 2013, 06:13:44
After reading the Combine books set in the DA, his choice to be present on the ship makes perfect sense.

And I agree, the Combine looks quite interesting right now.  Nice to see them bouncing back... though I'll miss the Nova Cats.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 06 April 2013, 07:31:18
Ended up going with the 4th Arkab Legion after a bit of reading, But thanks for the advice and suggestions guys. Now I just need to learn how to play with the dcms's toys. MRMs and C3 on everything here I come.

Good man! Well done!  O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 06 April 2013, 15:36:39
I'm rather curious about the Combine's manufacturing capabilities at this point. With the Nova Cats around, there was some sort of collaboration going on between LAW and the Nova Cat's manufacturers. I'm sort of surprised we haven't heard more about this over the years, and it should be interesting to see how it turns out in the end.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 07 April 2013, 01:53:47
I'm rather curious about the Combine's manufacturing capabilities at this point. With the Nova Cats around, there was some sort of collaboration going on between LAW and the Nova Cat's manufacturers. I'm sort of surprised we haven't heard more about this over the years, and it should be interesting to see how it turns out in the end.
One of the rebellion-inducing sore points that the Combine inflicted upon the Cats was dismantling their production sites.  One would presume you'd reassemble them elsewhere under your own control...

Couple that with regaining Marduk, Quentin, and Proserpina and you've potentially got some nice things going on, depending on how they came through the rebuilding of the Jihad and the economic supprssion of military industries of the Pax Republica period.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 07 April 2013, 02:59:48
Huh. I completely missed that they dismantled the Cat's production sites. You got a source on that? That's quite a..wow.

Might be quite interesting to see a Clantech factory running at IS speeds/output.

Of course, that might be what the Republic has as well.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 07 April 2013, 03:11:11
Huh. I completely missed that they dismantled the Cat's production sites. You got a source on that? That's quite a..wow.

Check out the writeup for the 5th Sword of Light.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 07 April 2013, 04:00:40
Ah, that's interesting. I wonder where it wound up. By the 3100's you'd think it'd be pretty advanced. I doubt the Combine just dismantled it and didn't make use of it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 07 April 2013, 04:31:41
Good to see the Combine on the up slope again and hiring the Dragoon's, just shows the class.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: YingJanshi on 07 April 2013, 12:58:40
It's nice to see the Dragon hitting back instead of taking hits. I especially approve of the humbling they've given the Suns. The current leadership leaves me a bit cold though...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 07 April 2013, 13:12:06
Meh. Meet the new leadership, the same as the leadership we've had since the Jihad. Useless Coordinator manipulated by the Gunji-no-Kanrei (whether they actually held that title or not), who is either a Black Dragon or strongly sympathetic to them.

Whilst it's nice to see things working out in our favour for a change, I suspect the Combine's become rather over-extended and will be beaten back somewhat. I think we can expect to see the Bears and Ravens expanding at our expense in the not too distant future.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 07 April 2013, 14:20:44
It COULD happen that Yori proves to be more than Toranaga's puppet.  But it remains to be seen if she WILL. 

It appears that's what we're meant to speculate about in place of whether Yori or Emi will win the throne :}

I quite like the supririse, and rather enjoy the 'Tywin Lannister' flavor of our current leadership.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 08 April 2013, 08:23:13
I admit I didn't bother reading the DA-era novels that dealt with the Combine. Worth reading?

Ruthless and competent? Just what I want in a Kanrei. Really, I'm satisfied with the situation, though curious as to how the Vega Protectorate managed to fend off the DCMS when it seemed it ran roughshod over the AFFS and the kitties quite easily.

Do you think there'll be a "Pan-Asian Alliance" that Max Liao was pushing for more than a century ago? The CapCon and Combine borders are getting real close.

Meh. Meet the new leadership, the same as the leadership we've had since the Jihad. Useless Coordinator manipulated by the Gunji-no-Kanrei (whether they actually held that title or not), who is either a Black Dragon or strongly sympathetic to them.

Whilst it's nice to see things working out in our favour for a change, I suspect the Combine's become rather over-extended and will be beaten back somewhat. I think we can expect to see the Bears and Ravens expanding at our expense in the not too distant future.

Seems like a possibility with the Bears. The Ravens just got 3 worlds without a fight, if they try to grab more they'll piss off the DCMS though.

I could see the Ravens working with Julian for a counter-attack. And I can't let go of the feeling that Yori will use that counter-attack to her advantage and remove the Kanrei.

How are you guys finding the Combine's RATs?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 08 April 2013, 12:20:30
I admit I didn't bother reading the DA-era novels that dealt with the Combine. Worth reading?

I didn't mind them so much, but most (maybe all?) were written by Ilsa Bick, and she seems to be one of those authors where you either like the book or hate it.

Quote
Do you think there'll be a "Pan-Asian Alliance" that Max Liao was pushing for more than a century ago? The CapCon and Combine borders are getting real close.

Might be what gives the FedSuns the breathing room they need, if the DCMS has to deal with the CCAF and the Ravens along with the Feddies.

Quote
I could see the Ravens working with Julian for a counter-attack. And I can't let go of the feeling that Yori will use that counter-attack to her advantage and remove the Kanrei.

Yeah, the first major failure and Toranaga's position is quite shaky. Its really hard to turn around and blame the Coordinator for that failure, especially if all the orders have been coming from you. "You lost the FedSuns" is a very very hard charge to get away from.

Quote
How are you guys finding the Combine's RATs?

I think the biggest surprise on them is that the BNZ-X Banzai from XTR Kurita is on the RAT, and in quite a prominent position (a roll of 8 ). I don't know if this is because they made quite a few of them, or if it was simply included to give it a fluffy "Kurita" feel.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 08 April 2013, 20:26:24
Is Kitsune Kurita still alive? I don't recall seeing him mentioned anywhere in ER 3145; wouldn't he be a contender to take over as Coordinator if Yori and Toranaga get murked?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 08 April 2013, 21:13:18
I also doubt that the Dragon would accept a Davion on the throne.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 08 April 2013, 21:43:05
I also doubt that the Dragon would accept a Davion on the throne.

Yes, please don't feed the Black Dragons!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nav_Alpha on 08 April 2013, 21:45:20
Is Kitsune Kurita still alive? I don't recall seeing him mentioned anywhere in ER 3145; wouldn't he be a contender to take over as Coordinator if Yori and Toranaga get murked?

I would imagine he was either killed in one of the various invasions of the Republic or tucked safely behind the wall in Prefecture X
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 08 April 2013, 22:09:34
I think he's stuck in Fortress Republic. We'll see him soon enough.

Anyone think Emi Kurita pulled a "Kathleen Palmer"?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 08 April 2013, 22:33:13
That depends, who's Kathleen Palmer?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 08 April 2013, 22:36:22
She was the mother of Theodore Kurita's bastard son, who substituted another child when the ISF came a-callin' and therefore tricked Subhash Indrahar into thinking that little Franklin was dead and no threat to the legitimate children of Theodore and Tomoe.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 09 April 2013, 02:30:46
Wait..did the ISF kill the substitute kid? Cuz that's a pretty ******-up move on Palmer's part if they did.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Scrollreader on 09 April 2013, 02:33:48
... I like how it's not Indrahar's assassins who are messed up, but the mother saving her son.  It's a lovely little Successor State you guys are running here.   :o
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 09 April 2013, 02:37:53
No, obviously it was a good thing to save her son, it's just that doing it in a way that causes some other random child to get murdered seems a little cold-blooded.

EDIT: Also, obviously it's not cool that the ISF are okay with murdering kids. But what are you gonna do, it's the ISF, that's probably the tip of the atrocity-iceberg (atrociceberg?) for them. DOUBLE-EDIT: And it's not exactly like the other Houses or Clans have any high ground to stand on there. Just ask a member of the Jade Falcon scientist caste. Y'know, if you can find one.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Scrollreader on 09 April 2013, 02:44:27
Eh.  Just amused by the turn of the phrase, is all.  Honestly, I'm a little disappointed in Indrahar.  I don't particularly follow the Combine, but he (was) supposed to be pretty good at his job, I thought?  I'd have figured he would have kept an eye on possible threats like this, before and after sending in the strike teams.  *shrugs*

"Leave no live orphans to seek vengeance, and no live bastards to steal your son's future" is good advice, after all.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 09 April 2013, 02:53:36
Ask yourself this: With the possibility of a illegitimate male child later claiming inheritance right, something that would very likely be back by a malcontent third party, and launching the realm into  a civil war costing millions, if not billions, of lives, is the cost of one infants life not worth eliminating that risk once and for all?

Cynical? yes. Harsh? Definitely. But look at things like the War of Davion Succession as to what can happen if you do not eliminate potential threats early.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Scrollreader on 09 April 2013, 02:57:27
Oh, absolutely.  And I strongly suspect proto-Sucessor Lords (and current ones) who are unable to stomach making such choices, (or letting others make them for them) are doomed, at best, to irrelevance.  Personally, I don't mind (in my fictional settings) proper ruthlessness.  Just kinda surprised someone was picking on Miss Palmer for the whole situation.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 09 April 2013, 03:00:33
Ask yourself this: With the possibility of a illegitimate male child later claiming inheritance right, something that would very likely be back by a malcontent third party, and launching the realm into  a civil war costing millions, if not billions, of lives, is the cost of one infants life not worth eliminating that risk once and for all?

Cynical? yes. Harsh? Definitely. But look at things like the War of Davion Succession as to what can happen if you do not eliminate potential threats early.

And of course no one from that illegitimate line ever ended up Coordinator after being backed by a malcontent third party and then launched the realm into a massive war, so hey, problem solved.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 09 April 2013, 06:18:12
And let's not forget the current ISF director is Ramadeep Bhatia.  He's as ruthless as they come.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 09 April 2013, 06:25:49
She was the mother of Theodore Kurita's bastard son, who substituted another child when the ISF came a-callin' and therefore tricked Subhash Indrahar into thinking that little Franklin was dead and no threat to the legitimate children of Theodore and Tomoe.

Whatever happened to Franklin Sakamoto?  Last I heard he was captured by the Black Dragons, then nothing.  Was he killed in the fighting or executed by the Black Dragons or did he survive the Jihad?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 09 April 2013, 06:34:41
Wait..did the ISF kill the substitute kid? Cuz that's a pretty ******-up move on Palmer's part if they did.

Ninyu Kerai himself did it.

(Teddy the K's best friend, in a sense, offs his son after the announcement that Theodore has a wife and kids. Kathleen Palmer was, of course, an ISF agent sent to befriend Teddy. You can see how Indrahar works there...)

Whatever happened to Franklin Sakamoto?  Last I heard he was captured by the Black Dragons, then nothing.  Was he killed in the fighting or executed by the Black Dragons or did he survive the Jihad?

We're told that the family's fortunes faded after the Jihad, when they're talking about Yori. But beyond that, we know nothing of what Franklin did.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 11 April 2013, 00:21:31
Quote
How are you guys finding the Combine's RATs?

I think the biggest surprise on them is that the BNZ-X Banzai from XTR Kurita is on the RAT, and in quite a prominent position (a roll of 8 ). I don't know if this is because they made quite a few of them, or if it was simply included to give it a fluffy "Kurita" feel.

You know despite reading about their occasional use in the Jihad, I never actually bothered to look up the rules for Booby Traps.. until noticing it in the Banzai.

I giggled. 

I'll echo the sentiment about not being sure what to make of their inclusion in the RAT, but I can certainly envision it becoming notoriously hated by players facing DCMS forces.  It's awful expensive to be a dedicated kamikaze unit, but it doesn't have to be a kamikaze unit despite 'wasting' 9 tons on the bomb.
 The psychology surrounding it makes it a great assault unit, in the traditional sense of the word.  If I want to take that hill, things are gonna go and get OFF the hill if I send the Banzai to secure it..  There's little better choice to compel the other side to abandon a choke point.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GreekFire on 11 April 2013, 01:09:17
I think the Banzai is great for enforcing the Ares Conventions. Who in their right mind would hole up in their cities knowing that these things will be charging down the front gate?

Imagine using the Banzai with the Stackpoling rules. Ell Oh Ell.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 11 April 2013, 11:44:08
I think the biggest surprise on them is that the BNZ-X Banzai from XTR Kurita is on the RAT, and in quite a prominent position (a roll of 8 ). I don't know if this is because they made quite a few of them, or if it was simply included to give it a fluffy "Kurita" feel.


You know despite reading about their occasional use in the Jihad, I never actually bothered to look up the rules for Booby Traps.. until noticing it in the Banzai.

I giggled. 

I'll echo the sentiment about not being sure what to make of their inclusion in the RAT, but I can certainly envision it becoming notoriously hated by players facing DCMS forces.  It's awful expensive to be a dedicated kamikaze unit, but it doesn't have to be a kamikaze unit despite 'wasting' 9 tons on the bomb.
 The psychology surrounding it makes it a great assault unit, in the traditional sense of the word.  If I want to take that hill, things are gonna go and get OFF the hill if I send the Banzai to secure it..  There's little better choice to compel the other side to abandon a choke point.

It's the ultimate spoil-sport, and the fact that it uses Clan weapons means it isn't so disadvantaged by those 9 tons.

Units right next to it are hit with 180 points, those one hex away are hit with 90... Ouch.

I kinda like the psychology behind it all too.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 April 2013, 01:23:14
What are our thoughts about the future of the current invasion?  I'm calling it Operation MARATHON II until we hear otherwise.   It just looks soooooooooo much like the original.. right on the eve of the Kentares Massacre.

Are we due to see some seminal event that wrecks the conquest?  Another front opening up is the obvious threat.  From what we've seen so far, I'm happy to throw my trust in Toranaga's strategic planning deterring Raven perfidy, or at least being ready to respond to it.  The Bears are another story.  Under CGL's writing, they're simply invincible.  The best we can hope for is that the devs decide to write 'against' the Bears by having them too slow to seize the opportunity to conquer the Pesht district.

I don't think we're due another Kentares Massacre.  For one, we just got done with the Jihad.  That's soo last story arc.  Two, neither Toranaga nor Yori are a Jinjiro.  Three, if there's gonna be some game-changing event for the War, I give the devs more credit than to be too lazy to come up with something BESIDES another atrocity that fires the AFFS back up.

I don't think Toranaga would betray Yori, but I could see Yori solidifying her position at his expense.  I don't think it's particularly likely at this point in the war, but who knows.  Perhaps she's silly enough to shoot her own nose off.

Does the map in ER3145 feel like a high water mark? It does to me.. while yes we just saw the Nova Cats go down, I strongly doubt any of the 5 successor states are/were seriously considered for elimination from the story.
 

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 13 April 2013, 02:42:14
The Bears were just as invincible in the FASA days as they were under FanPro and WizKidz. Catalyst has been bound until now by the storyline that was set by the ClickTech plot arc, and so things may change now that they have free rein. Maybe. The Bears of the 3130+ era are still written as being exceptionally powerful and dangerous, and the weight of history is in their favour.

As far as the action against the Suns goes, I'm reminded of the wise words of Aral Vorkosigan: "We're becoming nicely over-extended. Some people think that's the same thing as winning."

We've been down (and getting kicked while we were at it) for so long I can't see the invasion working out any differently to the last time the Combine advanced so far. That may be cynicism or pessimism speaking, but it would be an extreme departure from the norm if the Suns' power is blunted, especially since Julian is basically Hanse 3.0 or Victor 2.0 depending on how you look at it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 13 April 2013, 12:44:31
I'm a little cynical regarding that invasion. I get the feeling the Combine only did so well just so Julian can seem to be such a great leader when he finally fights off the DCMS.

I don't see Toranaga betraying Yori too, it seems like they're setting up Yori to be the next Sanethia or Siriwan. Toranaga may be blamed for the reversals or may actually be killed in battle, both benefiting Yori.

Really interested to see the specs of all the new 'Mechs though.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 15 April 2013, 14:23:44
Does the map in ER3145 feel like a high water mark? It does to me.. while yes we just saw the Nova Cats go down, I strongly doubt any of the 5 successor states are/were seriously considered for elimination from the story.

Same here.  It seems really unlikely that FS is going to stay so firmly knocked down with 2 March capitols in enemy hands.  That is borderline CapCon post 4th SW.

My biggest regret is that we all assume the DCMS is going to get bounced.  There are FS fans screaming they are out of the game after what happened.  I'd really like it if we could enjoy the DCMS's success without knowing a reversal of some sort is coming, while the FS fans could just accept that they are no longer the most powerful great house.  In all, a little bittersweet.

And that's not to say the Suns didn't have it coming.  How many years did they have the largest army, or the most planets, most tech, most sophisticated command structure, blah blah blah blah blah...?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jayof9s on 15 April 2013, 15:20:52
Same here.  It seems really unlikely that FS is going to stay so firmly knocked down with 2 March capitols in enemy hands.  That is borderline CapCon post 4th SW.

My biggest regret is that we all assume the DCMS is going to get bounced.  There are FS fans screaming they are out of the game after what happened.  I'd really like it if we could enjoy the DCMS's success without knowing a reversal of some sort is coming, while the FS fans could just accept that they are no longer the most powerful great house.  In all, a little bittersweet.

And that's not to say the Suns didn't have it coming.  How many years did they have the largest army, or the most planets, most tech, most sophisticated command structure, blah blah blah blah blah...?

I mostly expect the Combine to take major hits from their non-FedSuns neighbors (though the FS may take advantage of it once the fun begins). But the Combine has borders with the Raven Alliance, Ghost Bears and the Republic around them. And when the Fortress comes down, the Confederation and the Combine were the Republic's biggest antagonists and the Era Report brought up several times that the Ghost Bears still consider the Republic their allies. So, even if the Ravens wouldn't start the fight on their own, I could see a major attack by the Republic and the Ghost Bears in the Combine's near future, at which point the Ravens are too opportunistic to just sit it out. And the Suns will at least try to retake their worlds.

Still, the Suns are (likely) so critically low on strength at this point that even with the Combine and Confederation occupied by a very angry Republic, it is hard to say how much progress the Feddies will make in winning back their Marches.

That's also assuming Julian doesn't get captured in Cappie space or some sort of civil war between Regeant and First-Prince to further wreck the nation.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 15 April 2013, 18:57:55
Still, the Suns are (likely) so critically low on strength at this point that even with the Combine and Confederation occupied by a very angry Republic, it is hard to say how much progress the Feddies will make in winning back their Marches.
True, but the idea of a Republic unit attacking a world at the same side the Davions, Kuritans, and Liaos are showing up could be a hilarious fourway...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 15 April 2013, 19:23:30
Some worlds of probable importance near the current lines:

Worlds on the axis of a potential thrust towards New Avalon from Robinson:
Kestrel:  It's 2 jumps from the current border (at occupied Robinson) and is a world of extreme political and military signifigance.  It's also right between New Avalon and Robinson, so if our drive is to continue deeper into the FS Kestrel is a world that is bound to figure prominently as an AFFS strongpoint.  In addition to that, its agricultural riches were heavily exported to the Draconis March, worlds that are probably under DCMS dominion now.   We'd likely want to seize the world just so that we could go on feeding our current conquered populations.
However, my guess is that this is where we'll see Julian make his heroic stand and turn the tide.  Even if he doesn't, its the planet where the ancestral estates of McKinnon's Raiders are located.  How much fun is THAT place going to be to keep under control, if it even falls in the first place.

New Valencia: A bit more out of the way to New Avalon, but still within 2 jumps of Robinson.  And home to rather impressive factories, last known to be producing Avatar and Blackjack Omnis, Victors, Pendragons, and several vehicles.  Even if we don't invade the planet, the AFFS must spread their resources to defend it.

Saunemin: Located between Kestrel and New Valencia, it's mostly unknown in canon but potentially critical as being just within a 2 jump radius of New Avalon.

Worlds of importance on a thrust towards New Avalon from the Palmyra Thumb:
The planets spinward of New Avalon are very thinly described.  There isn't much to speculate about other than by purely their location.  The Palmyra thumb may well be an opportunity to bring attention to this region and start giving planets some fluff as battles rage on or above them.

Tsamma: A world rich in food and water exports.  Possibly the gem of the occupied salient.  Definately going to be a high priority target for AFFS forces to raid or liberate.. defending it will likely sap strength from what could have otherwise gone towards New Avalon or expanding the salient.

Protection & Linneus: Not much is known canonically, but look at the map.  If we lose either system we face having to jump at least once in hostile space to maintain supply into the salient.  A natural place for the AFFS to counterattack, and potentially a natural place for the Dragon to widen the thumb from.

Worlds of note on the Davion side of the current lines:
Dahar IV: It's long been a major AFFS base.  It's probably no coincidence at all that the 3145 lines show this planet holding a bulwark against the invasion.  It's not important enough to go after if New Avalon is a target, but if it's not taken it's a natural strongpoint for the AFFS to reinforce and cause headaches all throughout the occupied Draconis March.

Johnsondale: Every defense industry is critical to the FedRats at this point, and Johnsondale's tank output is going to draw a good defense.  A heavy presence there likewise offers the AFFS a great location to launch raids or a counterattack into the anti-spinward portion of the occupied territory.

Worlds of note in the occupied Draconis March:
The importance of worlds like Robinson and Marduk need no explanation to the casual Kurita fan, but here are some more gems that we took and will likely have to fight to keep:

New Ivaarsen: The loss of this world makes Davion fans squeal almost as much as Robinson itself.  It's a major, wealthy world and has long been the gatekeeper to guarantee against Kuritan successes of the 1st SW from being repeated.  It's also fluffed as being a world noteworthy (even for the Draconis March) as being virulently anti-Combine.  Couple that with it being the homeworld of the AFFS's New Ivaarsen Chausseurs brigade (and therefore home to a plethora of retired AFFS soldiers..) and you've got what I say is the most likely tinderbox of insurrection we have.   I assume the writers will have the AFFS roll us back, and New Ivaarsen is likely to go back to Davion hands once the war is over.

Sakhara V: A deserty world of moderate wealth.  However, it is the homeworld of the renowned Sakhara Mechwarrior Academy.  Considered by many (including myself, and I say this as a Kurita fan..) to produce the FINEST mechwarriors in the Inner Sphere.  There are going to be quite a few mechwarriors out there whos pride is injured at their alma mater being subjected to Draconian occupation.  And most of them are in the AFFS.  This is another world I just don't see the devs allowing to remain in Kuritan hands.  However, if we do end up keeping the planet, it is MOST curious to think about what would become of the Academy.  Assuming they didn't restart the academy elsewhere, the Draconian flavor of training (well, indoctrination) being imposed would likely end the academy's sterling successes.

Tishomingo: Like Dahar IV, long a lynchpin of the defense of the Draconis March.  However now that infrastructure is in our hands and VERY conveniently located.  If the AFFS launches a broad campaign to liberate the occupied territories, this planet should prove to be an early key battleground.

Tancredi IV: Technically not in the same category as it's been in Kuritan hands since before 3130, but I'm including it anyway as it's typically been a Davion planet up till the Dark Age.  It was a major world of the Draconis March and not that dissimilar to Marduk in its production importance.  In fact, when I saw the 3130 map for the first time, I thought of Tancredi IV as 'our compensation' for Marduk falling back into FedRat hands.  Should we suffer a complete collapse of the Palmyra Thumb (or perfidy from the Ravens...) this system would be a gem of a prize to take back.


Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 15 April 2013, 23:01:17
So he phrase "Black Dragon" is thrown around alot with regards to Yori and Toranaga, but is there any proof that Toranaga is part of that organization, or is it just a convenient label for "the other side" that's applied to them?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 15 April 2013, 23:40:14
I dunno, it just struck me as a hilarious idea, and certainly fits his "total war against any of the dragon's enemies, get rid of the late-31st-century-love-in, and turn the Combine back around into the Star League under the Banner of the Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 16 April 2013, 00:01:29
I'm not so sure we need to worry about the Republic bursting out from behind their walls.  Not for another couple books/RL years, at least.

I say this because the devs spoke about how they wanted the ER3145 to be in the midst of things going on, rather than on the eve of something big about to happen.

I can say I appreciate the strategy.  I still remember being pissed at FASA about how they published the 20 year update sourcebook, only to right after render it obsolete with the clan invasion story arc.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 16 April 2013, 03:28:52
So he phrase "Black Dragon" is thrown around alot with regards to Yori and Toranaga, but is there any proof that Toranaga is part of that organization, or is it just a convenient label for "the other side" that's applied to them?

They have a lot in common for their ideology.

If nothing else, the plan to bump off the incumbent Coordinator and replace them with one that was more militaristic and conservative is a pretty strong indicator.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 16 April 2013, 03:43:01
So far what I've seen of Toranaga's ideology is a desire for a strong, militaristic Coordinator. He perceived Vincent as weak, and decided to put a strong Coordinator in his place (or a Coordinator who would be made to appear strong). He seems to have personally disliked Vincent.

On the other hand, we haven't seen any major changes to the DCMS, such as a reverting to older Samurai traditions where personal honor was put ahead of honor of the Dragon. We also haven't seen a change in the tactics used, or in recruitment policies (atleast none that have been mentioned).

Might be interesting to see where FM3145 goes.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Shin Yodama on 16 April 2013, 04:09:30
Ohayo. Only just seen this thread, thought I'd introduce myself and read back through it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 16 April 2013, 06:28:16
On the other hand, we haven't seen any major changes to the DCMS, such as a reverting to older Samurai traditions where personal honor was put ahead of honor of the Dragon. We also haven't seen a change in the tactics used, or in recruitment policies (atleast none that have been mentioned).

Might be interesting to see where FM3145 goes.
Well they did wipe the Cats out. I'm interested in seeing what happens to the Azami. Considering what happened the last time the Black Dragons had any semblance of power, they might be feeling a bit nervous ATM.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 16 April 2013, 08:42:31
So far what I've seen of Toranaga's ideology is a desire for a strong, militaristic Coordinator. He perceived Vincent as weak, and decided to put a strong Coordinator in his place (or a Coordinator who would be made to appear strong). He seems to have personally disliked Vincent.

The irony is that Yuri was inititally not a strong Coordinator, but a puppet.  She may hit her stride, however, now that there isn't any competition for the throne forthcoming.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 16 April 2013, 08:48:55
Yori.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 16 April 2013, 08:58:56
The irony is that Yuri was inititally not a strong Coordinator, but a puppet.  She may hit her stride, however, now that there isn't any competition for the throne forthcoming.

Pretty much. Thus far, the criteria the Black Dragons have presented for what they view as a preferred Coordinator is "one who does what we want them to do."

@ Maelwys: The Dark Age designs we've seen have heavily emphasised the neo-Samurai and single combat ideal. What direction Catalyst will go with that admittedly remains to be seen.

And while the recruitment policies of the DCMS under Theodore was something that left the Black Dragons unimpressed, it was not that high on their list of priorities; I would expect that with the Republic era and military demobilisation of the period that problem mostly sorted itself out, with the Samurai class the extremely dominant majority in the DCMS while the other social orders went back to doing their thing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 16 April 2013, 09:23:32
Indeed.  The DA novels that focus on the Combine lean heavily towards the Ghost regiments having been disbanded and a return to the opinion that yakuza are unworthy of being mechwarriors.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 16 April 2013, 10:49:45
Well they did wipe the Cats out. I'm interested in seeing what happens to the Azami. Considering what happened the last time the Black Dragons had any semblance of power, they might be feeling a bit nervous ATM.

The Nova Cats also raised a rebellion against the sitting Coordinator, starting it off by murdering a regiment of the DCMS. Not just defeating it and taking it prisoner, but executing the regiment.  I'm not too surprised at what the Cats got.

The irony is that Yuri was inititally not a strong Coordinator, but a puppet.  She may hit her stride, however, now that there isn't any competition for the throne forthcoming.

Right, but she appears stronger than Vincent did. Perceptions may not be everything, but they're something.

Pretty much. Thus far, the criteria the Black Dragons have presented for what they view as a preferred Coordinator is "one who does what we want them to do."

True. But Toranaga also seems to be in it for himself/the Combine, rather than some nebulous group of Warriors/Industrial magnates, etc.

Quote
@ Maelwys: The Dark Age designs we've seen have heavily emphasised the neo-Samurai and single combat ideal. What direction Catalyst will go with that admittedly remains to be seen.

That's true, but its also a Wizkids thing that might predate the usurpation of the Throne. Not to mention the whole "Spikes are cool!" crowd. We'll see in the TROs I suppose, and hopefully the FM will answer a question about if those are just special designs, or a trend in their fighting style (after all, they've had the No-Dachi and Banzai before this).

Quote
And while the recruitment policies of the DCMS under Theodore was something that left the Black Dragons unimpressed, it was not that high on their list of priorities; I would expect that with the Republic era and military demobilisation of the period that problem mostly sorted itself out, with the Samurai class the extremely dominant majority in the DCMS while the other social orders went back to doing their thing.

We'll see I suppose.

I just question if everyone that wants power for themselves/a different status quo is necessarily a Black Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 16 April 2013, 10:56:43
Right, but she appears stronger than Vincent did. Perceptions may not be everything, but they're something.

It's strange.  I didn't think Vincent was any weaker than late 3rd Succession War Takashi.  He pretty much went along with the same storyline.  Warlords itching to start fights, getting out of hand, defying his orders and such.  The Coordinator comes off as mostly symbolic in that sense.  The Warlords have the run of things and he just keeps them from tearing the whole Combine apart.  For a culture with so many conformist overtones the power structure is surprisingly fluid.

Quote
I just question if everyone that wants power for themselves/a different status quo is necessarily a Black Dragon.

Really...  The Black Dragons are tiresome enough.  Does the DC ever have a story not involving their own house being out of order?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kyone Akashi on 16 April 2013, 13:53:33
It's strange.  I didn't think Vincent was any weaker than late 3rd Succession War Takashi.  He pretty much went along with the same storyline.  Warlords itching to start fights, getting out of hand, defying his orders and such.  The Coordinator comes off as mostly symbolic in that sense.  The Warlords have the run of things and he just keeps them from tearing the whole Combine apart.
I think Vincent's main problem was how people perveived him. At least according to what he explains to Katana, he seemed pretty adept at playing people and knowing what's going on in the shadows (so much that it even surprised that bastard ISF director) - yet it appears as if unlike Takashi he neglected his public appearance so much that almost no-one actually deemed him capable of ruling the Combine, which finally resulted in a lot of people thinking he should be replaced with someone more skilled.

Let's see how Yori turns out - it will be interesting to see if the puppet continues to play the role the traitors want her to play.
If not .. there's still a certain Tai-shu rotting in the dungeons, who would be happy to get a chance at some bloody samurai-style revenge.  >:D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 16 April 2013, 14:14:13
Exactly. Vincent Kurita came across in the novels as a competent leader. But that's from a 3rd person omniscient view where I can see what he's thinking, doing, etc.

Unfortunately, to many of the Kuritans, he comes across as a Peacock. Its not really fair to him, but there you go.

I was thinking of a future with Yori as Coordinator, and Tormak as the Kanrei. Wouldn't that blow minds.

Also, am I just missing it, but who is the current Keeper?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 16 April 2013, 14:25:38
I think Vincent's main problem was how people perveived him. At least according to what he explains to Katana, he seemed pretty adept at playing people and knowing what's going on in the shadows (so much that it even surprised that bastard ISF director) - yet it appears as if unlike Takashi he neglected his public appearance so much that almost no-one actually deemed him capable of ruling the Combine, which finally resulted in a lot of people thinking he should be replaced with someone more skilled.

Vincent didn't take a stand on much, which is why the whole Sakamoto/Tormark thing happened.  If he had just spoken up and did something...

Which is sort of the Takashi thing.  Yeah, he backed the wrong pony when he chose Samsanov, and he never backed down.  I still wanted him to stand up and yell "I am the Coordinator!  You listen to ME!"

Exactly. Vincent Kurita came across in the novels as a competent leader. But that's from a 3rd person omniscient view where I can see what he's thinking, doing, etc.

Unfortunately, to many of the Kuritans, he comes across as a Peacock. Its not really fair to him, but there you go.

Fair enough.

Quote
I was thinking of a future with Yori as Coordinator, and Tormak as the Kanrei. Wouldn't that blow minds.

Also, am I just missing it, but who is the current Keeper?

They do leave the door open for that.  She could have just been executed, or forced into Seppeku.  DCMS officers have died faster for less.  Tormark is either getting out, being tortured or both.

As for the Keeper, isn't that traditionally a member of the Kurita family?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kyone Akashi on 16 April 2013, 15:03:08
I was thinking of a future with Yori as Coordinator, and Tormak as the Kanrei. Wouldn't that blow minds.
Oh yes, somebody make that happen!
Speaking purely in regards to influence on Combine society and spirit, that might just be the best since the original Theodore's ascension to the Chrysanthemum Throne. In this era, there are few characters who appear as honorable and charismatic as Tormark, and I could see her personality "rubbing off" on Yori.

It's probably wishful thinking, but a nice thought nonetheless.


Vincent didn't take a stand on much, which is why the whole Sakamoto/Tormark thing happened.  If he had just spoken up and did something... Which is sort of the Takashi thing.  Yeah, he backed the wrong pony when he chose Samsanov, and he never backed down.  I still wanted him to stand up and yell "I am the Coordinator!  You listen to ME!"
Hmm, it might just be my perception, but whilst Takashi also pulled a lot of strings in the background, he was still "loud enough", in his own way.

Combine politics seem to work by the Coordinators listening to suggestions from their council, and then choosing the option closest to what they already had in mind, if necessary with careful modifications - this is to shield them from harm, for if something goes wrong, it was the "bad advisor" who gets fingers pointed at them.

The problem with Vincent was that he didn't even seem to do a lot of the choosing. Where Takashi would at least nail Samsanov with an icy stare and say something like "you serve at my pleasure", Vincent addressed Sakamoto by essentially meaning the same thing, but packing it in fluffy words. That's very diplomatic, but just doesn't have the same effect. The Coordinator needs to be able to intimidate wayward Warlords, if need be, and this is a quality that Vincent sadly seemed to lack. He was almost fatherly in his approach, whereas Takashi was known to be ruthless enough for people to fear him. Even just the way his father, the former Coordinator, died caused a lot of people to think twice on whether to mess with him or not.

It's almost ironic. Vincent may have been just as capable in terms of manipulation (even surprising Bhatia at one point), but he hid it so well, played the "go on and underestimate me" card so often that, in the end, this created so much resistance against a supposedly weak ruler that he couldn't contain it anymore.

They do leave the door open for that.  She could have just been executed, or forced into Seppeku.  DCMS officers have died faster for less.  Tormark is either getting out, being tortured or both.
Yeah - it's almost strange that they didn't just dispose of her. Either this is Yori displaying a modicum of influence on what happens around her (and being aware of Tormark's accomplishments for her realm), or it is Katana's rivals being sadistic and drawing out her punishment. Out-of-universe, it just sounds like the classic plot hook for a return of this character. I can just picture her stepping out of that cell, taking the swords offered by some soldier, and drawing up a list of people to kill.

As for the Keeper, isn't that traditionally a member of the Kurita family?
I believe so. And with Emi "out of the way" ...

That said, the Kurita bloodline is fairly large when you consider all the minor roots, and I think the position as Keeper of House Honor does not require as close a heritage as the throne itself. It should not be too difficult to find someone for that job, but I too have yet to see who they actually picked.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 16 April 2013, 15:25:36
Traditionally, the Keeper of House Honor is a Kurita. Even distantly related. They're more than just the head of the O5P, they actually mind the House.

I don't know if the current one is a Kurita or not. I know during the Jihad, the Keeper didn't have a Kurita name, but was killed as a Black Dragon. (Though there's a conspiracy that she was merely framed.)

As for Vincent, I found him to be a subtle, almost Sun-Tzu-esque leader. The problem was that he was a bit complacent. Maybe his position had been denuded over time, maybe he was overcome with a few family issue: it seems that his branch of the family tree developed some disease. I forgot what it's called, so his heirs would all have it too.

Yori as Coordinator and Tomark as Kanrei? Neat. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 16 April 2013, 15:47:26
I was thinking of a future with Yori as Coordinator, and Tormak as the Kanrei. Wouldn't that blow minds.

Yori as Coordinator and Tomark as Kanrei? Neat.

The problem is that Tormark was real traitor, first of the Republic and then of the Draconis Combine. Only traditionally weak and incompetent Coordinator would keep her alive, no to talk about giving her some important post. For what? So she can betray for the third time?
Surely there must be some general or admiral who is both competent and loyal. And if there is no such officer to be found in the DCMS, then it would seem that someone fouled something up.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 16 April 2013, 15:49:19
I don't know if the current one is a Kurita or not. I know during the Jihad, the Keeper didn't have a Kurita name, but was killed as a Black Dragon. (Though there's a conspiracy that she was merely framed.)

You're confusing the Keeper of House Honor and the Abbess of O5P. Two different positions. Tomiro Yomade (or something like that; I can't be bothered to check) was the Abbess while Miyako Kurita was the Keeper.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kyone Akashi on 16 April 2013, 16:08:14
The problem is that Tormark was real traitor, first of the Republic and then of the Draconis Combine. Only traditionally weak and incompetent Coordinator would keep her alive, no to talk about giving her some important post. For what? So she can betray for the third time?
Surely there must be some general or admiral who is both competent and loyal. And if there is no such officer to be found in the DCMS, then it would seem that someone fouled something up.
I would say that there are loads of such people, but politics tend to mess with the selection. With the current setup of Warlords and the current ISF Director, there's just too much backstabbing and ambitious manipulation going on in the higher echelons of Combine leadership. A Coordinator would have to be smart and subtle to find someone from "outside", like Vincent did with Katana. It depends on how much of a puppet Yori really is - but if she doesn't trust her current council, Tormark might ironically be the first choice if she can secure her loyalty, which would not take as much as one might think on the first glance.

After all, it's not that Tormark is disloyal - quite the opposite, she was too loyal.
Her defection from the Republic? Done for the Dragon. Her backing the true heir to the throne? Done for the Dragon. She really is that transparent and single-minded. The latest conflict was pretty much a civil war, and she picked whom she believed was the rightful heir to the throne. Personal power doesn't tempt her; she's got her code and will follow it. And with any rivals to the throne being dead, Yori is the future of the Combine. What other choice would Tormark have than to comply? Tracking down the murderers of Vincent is the only thing she'd demand.

So, there's pretty much two options: Yori is deceived by her council and will continue to be a puppet, which likely means the current Kanrei will keep his job.
Or, Yori does develop a mind of her own and will attempt to break free, at which point anything goes.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 16 April 2013, 17:28:28
You're confusing the Keeper of House Honor and the Abbess of O5P. Two different positions. Tomiro Yomade (or something like that; I can't be bothered to check) was the Abbess while Miyako Kurita was the Keeper.

You're quite right. Looked it up it was Tomade Yamiro
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 16 April 2013, 23:50:38
True. But Toranaga also seems to be in it for himself/the Combine, rather than some nebulous group of Warriors/Industrial magnates, etc.

The Black Dragons always claimed to be in rebellion for the good of the Combine, even (especially) when what they were doing made that a highly questionable claim. Ultimately their motivations come down to the same thing that motivates people of that sort; gaining additional power and prestige. I could understand if the sitting Coordinator was absolutely useless or whatever, but that hasn't been the case for some time- the last it was true was Takashi Kurita after his stroke, and in that case the Black Dragons were solidly on his side, so...

Quote
That's true, but its also a Wizkids thing that might predate the usurpation of the Throne. Not to mention the whole "Spikes are cool!" crowd. We'll see in the TROs I suppose, and hopefully the FM will answer a question about if those are just special designs, or a trend in their fighting style (after all, they've had the No-Dachi and Banzai before this).

It could also be a chicken and egg scenario given how much power the Black Dragons have weilded since the Jihad.

Quote
I just question if everyone that wants power for themselves/a different status quo is necessarily a Black Dragon.

Unfortunately, pretty much everyone in recent history from the Combine who's wanted power for themselves or a different status quo has been a Black Dragon or at least so highly sympathetic to their goals that they may as well be one.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 17 April 2013, 00:19:25
ER3145 mentioned some substantial O5P collusion with the Nova Cats.. prior to their rebellion anyhow.  I wonder how much or how little there is to be read into that.  I can see the Order being tainted by association in the current timeline, much to the ISF's enjoyment.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 17 April 2013, 01:33:41
The problem is that Tormark was real traitor, first of the Republic and then of the Draconis Combine. Only traditionally weak and incompetent Coordinator would keep her alive, no to talk about giving her some important post. For what? So she can betray for the third time?
Surely there must be some general or admiral who is both competent and loyal. And if there is no such officer to be found in the DCMS, then it would seem that someone fouled something up.

Ah, but she's also loyal to the Dragon...she was just loyal to the wrong Dragon. And if Toranaga winds up malfing up big time and is invited to the Garden, then Katana becomes someone who fought against Toranaga. Perhaps in a misguided way, but the perception might be able to be swung.

The Black Dragons always claimed to be in rebellion for the good of the Combine, even (especially) when what they were doing made that a highly questionable claim. Ultimately their motivations come down to the same thing that motivates people of that sort; gaining additional power and prestige. I could understand if the sitting Coordinator was absolutely useless or whatever, but that hasn't been the case for some time- the last it was true was Takashi Kurita after his stroke, and in that case the Black Dragons were solidly on his side, so...

Sure, I just kind of question the term. Its getting to be as nebulous as "Yellow Bird." When Katana (what a really awkward name) and the Nova Cats rose up in Rebellion, did that make them Black Dragons?

ER3145 mentioned some substantial O5P collusion with the Nova Cats.. prior to their rebellion anyhow.  I wonder how much or how little there is to be read into that.  I can see the Order being tainted by association in the current timeline, much to the ISF's enjoyment.

IIRC, the entire Mystic Caste situation was brought about by 05P and Nova Cat collusion.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 17 April 2013, 01:39:12
One problem: Katana hates Yori, and the feeling is mutual. There's no way Katana becomes anything under Yori ever again, even if she is still alive.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 17 April 2013, 01:44:39
Hmm. That might be an issue. I'm rereading the novels to try to recall alot of this stuff, but am only on Sword of Sedition. Daughter of the Dragon is next however.

On the other hand, we've seen stranger pairs. A Kanrei/Warlord that hates you, but is loyal to the Dragon and thus you as long as you don't screw up?

I mean, look at who Takashi had to deal with for years.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 April 2013, 02:06:04
Ah, but she's also loyal to the Dragon...she was just loyal to the wrong Dragon. And if Toranaga winds up malfing up big time and is invited to the Garden, then Katana becomes someone who fought against Toranaga. Perhaps in a misguided way, but the perception might be able to be swung.

And we are back at the square 1. Weak Coordinator.

Because for a strong Coordinator, the Dragon and him are the one. Everyone (Tormark included) serves Coordinator and therefore serves the Dragon as well. If someone raises his or her hand against the Coordinator, then he deserves to die because he raised hand against the Dragon. And Tormark did what ...?

Strong Coodinator doesn't need excuses of some public opinions and perceptions, strong Coordinator does what he sees fit. Every single soldier or citizen exists only to fulfill his will, not other way round.
If Torinaga misses his chance, then the Coordinator should select another loyal officer from the DCMS or DCA.

If I  ;) were the Coordinator, I wouldn't trust Tormark at all. She reasoned her previous treasons for herself that her betrayals were for the good of the Dragon/Combine people, etc. So if someone attacks the DC or hatches some conspiracy against me as the Coordinator, she may turn against me with the same excuse: That her another betrayal is for the good of the Dragon, again ...

On the other hand, we've seen stranger pairs. A Kanrei/Warlord that hates you, but is loyal to the Dragon and thus you as long as you don't screw up?

"I" am the Dragon! (See above). I don't need generals and admirals with conditional loyalty, I need generals with 110% loyalty. As I said above, it's not the task of subordinates to judge the Coordinator's will and then decide if they are in the mood to obey.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 17 April 2013, 02:46:53
On the other hand, we've seen stranger pairs. A Kanrei/Warlord that hates you, but is loyal to the Dragon and thus you as long as you don't screw up?

A Kanrei/Warlord who hates you and rebelled against your rule because she believes you to be an illegitimate Coordinator.

Katana may be loyal to the Dragon, but she doesn't consider Yori to be the Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 17 April 2013, 03:24:57
Sure, I just kind of question the term. Its getting to be as nebulous as "Yellow Bird." When Katana (what a really awkward name) and the Nova Cats rose up in Rebellion, did that make them Black Dragons?


No, but then their goals, methods, and ideologies were markedly different to those of the Black Dragons. Whereas the Black Dragons' power and influence only grew through and after the Jihad, and Toranaga's storyline is what you'd expect from a Black Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 17 April 2013, 09:37:46
Something that was brought up in another thread...

Considering Minoru's involvement in the Mystic Caste's genetic makeup, that might be another reason the DC went all slash and burn and salt the earth on the Nova Cats. Minoru might have given up any claim to the throne, but if someone wanted to find a genetic survivor of the 'true' line...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 17 April 2013, 09:42:01
A Kanrei/Warlord who hates you and rebelled against your rule because she believes you to be an illegitimate Coordinator.

Katana may be loyal to the Dragon, but she doesn't consider Yori to be the Dragon.

I thought all the branches of the Theodore-Hohiro line have been trimmed?

Sure, she's from an illegitimate branch, but are there any other Kuritas out there? Or was Yori just the most convenient tool?

Something that was brought up in another thread...

Considering Minoru's involvement in the Mystic Caste's genetic makeup, that might be another reason the DC went all slash and burn and salt the earth on the Nova Cats. Minoru might have given up any claim to the throne, but if someone wanted to find a genetic survivor of the 'true' line...

Like that Nova Cat that escaped with a few 'warriors? Was he a mystic?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 17 April 2013, 09:50:24
Like that Nova Cat that escaped with a few 'warriors? Was he a mystic?
Kisho Nova Cat? Oh my yes. :D

If the Nova Cat survivors are vindictive enough, and managed to keep Minoru's genetic material around, they could start using him as the genemother for warriors too. Which means they could possibly create a Kurita bloodname. I doubt that'll happen but it'd be amusing to see the DC's reaction to it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kyone Akashi on 17 April 2013, 09:56:18
If I  ;) were the Coordinator, I wouldn't trust Tormark at all. She reasoned her previous treasons for herself that her betrayals were for the good of the Dragon/Combine people, etc. So if someone attacks the DC or hatches some conspiracy against me as the Coordinator, she may turn against me with the same excuse: That her another betrayal is for the good of the Dragon, again ...
"I" am the Dragon! I don't need generals and admirals with conditional loyalty, I need generals with 110% loyalty. As I said above, it's not the task of subordinates to judge the Coordinator's will and then decide if they are in the mood to obey.
To be fair, such an attitude would rule out the majority of known Warlords. Combine politics on this level have always been about X scheming against Y, and a clever Coordinator would play one Tai-shu against another - like Takashi did. Shogunate-style. It appears that loyalty is not the most important trait of a Warlord, although you could say that this also protects the Dragon from succumbing to a weak Coordinator by necessitating the heir to the throne to keep up with his underlings. If you don't manage to keep your house in order (by balancing the rivalries and power games), you're out. Takashi directly said as much, even justified killing his father that way.

Takashi also kept Marcus around even though he knew that guy tried to have him assassinated. Not to mention his opinion of Theodore, of whom he was convinced would kill him on several occasions. I still remember that scene where Theodore, trying to protect his father from the actual assassins, runs into his room with a drawn pistol and Takashi is like "so, it is time!"

Katana may be loyal to the Dragon, but she doesn't consider Yori to be the Dragon.
But then who? The Dragon must live on, and the Combine needs a Coordinator. If Yori is the only obvious heir left, then there is no alternative other than to accept her.

Well, that or seppuku, anyways. :P

One problem: Katana hates Yori, and the feeling is mutual.
Really? Granted, that kinda throws a wedge into that idea. For shame. :(
Unless both realize that Yori has been played by the power behind the Chrysanthemum Throne, that is. Or is there another source for this hatred besides having been on opposing sides during the civil war?

What book deals with their relationship, by the way? I'm still waiting for Dragon Rising to arrive, although I've heard that this one only goes as far as Vincent's death. I just jumped into the Dark Age by reading Daughter of the Dragon, which I probably wouldn't even have picked up if I weren't so committed to learning anything I can about the Combine. Yet the more I read about that era, the more interesting it appears.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 17 April 2013, 10:31:52
I thought all the branches of the Theodore-Hohiro line have been trimmed?

Sure, she's from an illegitimate branch, but are there any other Kuritas out there? Or was Yori just the most convenient tool?

There are always other Kuritas. Yori was just a convenient tool with a blood relation to Theodore.

But then who? The Dragon must live on, and the Combine needs a Coordinator. If Yori is the only obvious heir left, then there is no alternative other than to accept her.

There are always more Kuritas. Cadet lines going back a century or more, for instance.

Quote
Unless both realize that Yori has been played by the power behind the Chrysanthemum Throne, that is. Or is there another source for this hatred besides having been on opposing sides during the civil war?

They disliked each other even before Vincnt's assassination. Afterwards, it grew into hatred.

Quote
What book deals with their relationship, by the way? I'm still waiting for Dragon Rising to arrive, although I've heard that this one only goes as far as Vincent's death.

That's the one.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 17 April 2013, 10:49:31
There are always other Kuritas. Yori was just a convenient tool with a blood relation to Theodore.

True. I guess we could go to Isoroku Kurita's line, he didn't turn out to be so meek after all.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kyone Akashi on 17 April 2013, 11:04:19
There are always more Kuritas. Cadet lines going back a century or more, for instance.
Yes, but those would have an even lesser claim to the throne than Yori. There's no reason to sponsor them over her, unless one would be convinced that Yori is the mastermind behind the assassination.

They disliked each other even before Vincnt's assassination. Afterwards, it grew into hatred. [...] That's the one.
I see... too bad.

Oh well, at least it sounds like I'll have an interesting read. :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Warriors of Blake on 17 April 2013, 11:14:51
How would you recommend the Draconis Combine to a player?

I'm looking for a Great House and realized I'm perhaps not as knowledgeable on the Dragon as I could be.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Atlas3060 on 17 April 2013, 11:22:03
How would you recommend the Draconis Combine to a player?
Low tech Clanners that don't rely on genetics but still really love ceremony.
I play them sometimes because as a Ghost Bear player I love creating opposition forces to go against my main forces.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 17 April 2013, 11:23:23
How would you recommend the Draconis Combine to a player?

I'm looking for a Great House and realized I'm perhaps not as knowledgeable on the Dragon as I could be.

Well, what attracted me to the Combine is summed up by this statement, which worktroll turned into a haiku:

Their contradictions
And their blatant, direct goals.
Also, space ninjas.


Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 17 April 2013, 11:29:08
Yes, but those would have an even lesser claim to the throne than Yori. There's no reason to sponsor them over her, unless one would be convinced that Yori is the mastermind behind the assassination.

So? Katana's objection to Yori isn't about how strong a claim to the throne she has. It's about personal animosity, the belief that she is a puppet for other interests, and that she gained her throne through the assassination of several people whom Katana was quite fond of (whether or not she was personally complicit in those deaths, she was a direct beneficiary).

If the Combine must have a new Coordinator, better they be from a lesser line than be Yori.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 April 2013, 11:32:52
To be fair, such an attitude would rule out the majority of known Warlords. ... It appears that loyalty is not the most important trait of a Warlord, although you could say that this also protects the Dragon from succumbing to a weak Coordinator by necessitating the heir to the throne to keep up with his underlings.
That's one thing I dislike on the Combine - weak Coordinator. Because you can't be sure with the loyalty of your highest generals that should be (together with your family) your most trusted advisors, then you failed as a Coordinator ... plain and simply.

If you don't manage to keep your house in order (by balancing the rivalries and power games), you're out. Takashi directly said as much, even justified killing his father that way.
The best way how to keep your house in order is that you simply make sure that there are no power games in the house, and there is one will which everyone obeys - yours!
You, as the Coordinator, may stimulate such rivalry among generals, but it must be clear to everyone that such rivalry comes from your decision and your will - something similar as rivalry among French Marshalls during Napoleon's rule, or rivalry among Stalin's Marshalls (who will conquer Berlin, for example).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 17 April 2013, 11:34:24
Plus, a few years of isolation/incarceration/torture should also make Katana positively loathe Yori. Still, it'd be neat.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 April 2013, 12:06:25
How would you recommend the Draconis Combine to a player?

I'm looking for a Great House and realized I'm perhaps not as knowledgeable on the Dragon as I could be.

That's an interesting question.   

Technology

Politics

Culture

Enemies
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 17 April 2013, 12:07:46
I just found it odd that ER3145 made sure to tell us twice (I think) that Katana was alive.

Plus, a few years of isolation/incarceration/torture should also make Katana positively loathe Yori. Still, it'd be neat.

Or it will make her positively love her :)

We'll see I guess.

On the plus side, I've just gotten to Daughter of the Dragon in my MWDA novel reread.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 April 2013, 12:18:25
Plus, a few years of isolation/incarceration/torture should also make Katana positively loathe Yori. Still, it'd be neat.
Or it will make her positively love her :)

We'll see I guess.

That's something what a few years of brainwashing could solve.  [drool]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kyone Akashi on 17 April 2013, 13:12:26
So? Katana's objection to Yori isn't about how strong a claim to the throne she has. It's about personal animosity, the belief that she is a puppet for other interests, and that she gained her throne through the assassination of several people whom Katana was quite fond of (whether or not she was personally complicit in those deaths, she was a direct beneficiary).
So nothing. I was not aware of this personal animosity until it was mentioned here. As I said, I did not yet read this novel, and I already pointed out how this would mess with that idea. What little I heard so far simply sounded like Yori being some clueless girl who had no idea about what was going on, and was simply used as an easily influencable tool by the true powers behind the throne.

It was a nice thought for as long as it lasted. :)


The best way how to keep your house in order is that you simply make sure that there are no power games in the house, and there is one will which everyone obeys - yours!
I believe Takashi sort of justified the Warlords' ambitions once by explaining that they must be this way to (a) guarantee that they will use the power granted to them to further the cause of the Combine by using advances and territorial expansion as a game of one-upsmanship about who will receive the Tono's favor, and (b) to make sure that they are able to stand up against one another. You could say it is in part also a pragmatic realization that in such levels of power you will have political rivalries anyways (even with your 110% loyal generals), so you can just as well try to balance them.

Whilst it may on a glance appear this way, the position of Coordinator is not meant to simply mean "absolute ruler" but rather just one part of the larger whole, the symbolic embodiment and personification of the national spirit known as the Dragon. As such, the Coordinator should inspire and guide, but rarely exercise authority, as this would blunt the initiative of his generals. As mentioned before, this also shields the Coordinator from criticism in that the Combine citizen "knows" that the Coordinator cannot be responsible for a bad decision, because then it was made by his council (regardless of how much the Coordinator influenced it behind the scenes). It's an interesting little cultural quirk that protects the sanctity of this post.

In Vincent Kurita's words, the Coordinator is "the null space around which the wheel of the Combine turns".

Up to the 31st century, even the Black Dragon Society was unwilling to go against the Coordinator himself but rather just wished to remove the "bad advisors". This, too, is a reflection of real life Japan, by the way -> http://weaponsandwarfare.com/?p=2848

You, as the Coordinator, may stimulate such rivalry among generals, but it must be clear to everyone that such rivalry comes from your decision and your will - something similar as rivalry among French Marshalls during Napoleon's rule, or rivalry among Stalin's Marshalls (who will conquer Berlin, for example).
I think this is the idea behind it, just that it's even more complicated in the Combine because the Warlords have even more autonomy (controlling not just armies but also production facilities, resources, and having a fortified home base to which they could retreat). Note also that Stalin did kill a number of his generals specifically because he feared they would betray him, so there is that. ;)


How would you recommend the Draconis Combine to a player?

I'm looking for a Great House and realized I'm perhaps not as knowledgeable on the Dragon as I could be.
Space samurai, an elite and highly drilled military that oozes tradition, and giant BattleMechs in front of shoji-walled wooden castles. The cultural clash between high tech and feudal culture could not be more obvious than in the Draconis Combine.

In case you wish for a deeper explanation, I will refer you to something I typed up for the Kurita forums on the MWO website:

If you want the propaganda version, check this link (http://mwomercs.com/forums/topic/99523-why-kurita/page__view__findpost__p__1924554).
If you'd like more objectivity and a recap of characters and diplomatic relations, look at this one (http://mwomercs.com/forums/topic/99523-why-kurita/page__view__findpost__p__1945217).

^_^
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 17 April 2013, 13:26:27
I just found it odd that ER3145 made sure to tell us twice (I think) that Katana was alive.

Well... it didn't, though.

In one place it says she was "sentenced to life imprisonment at the Dragon's mercy" and she "has not been seen since, and we do not know if she still lives." So that's a maybe.

In the other place, the text just references rumors that she is being tortured and is a plaything for the ISF director's "darkest whims". So, rumors only.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 April 2013, 14:40:58
I believe Takashi sort of justified the Warlords' ambitions once by explaining that they must be this way to (a) guarantee that they will use the power granted to them to further the cause of the Combine by using advances and territorial expansion as a game of one-upsmanship about who will receive the Tono's favor, and (b) to make sure that they are able to stand up against one another. You could say it is in part also a pragmatic realization that in such levels of power you will have political rivalries anyways (even with your 110% loyal generals), so you can just as well try to balance them.

Whilst it may on a glance appear this way, the position of Coordinator is not meant to simply mean "absolute ruler" but rather just one part of the larger whole, the symbolic embodiment and personification of the national spirit known as the Dragon. As such, the Coordinator should inspire and guide, but rarely exercise authority, as this would blunt the initiative of his generals. As mentioned before, this also shields the Coordinator from criticism in that the Combine citizen "knows" that the Coordinator cannot be responsible for a bad decision, because then it was made by his council (regardless of how much the Coordinator influenced it behind the scenes). It's an interesting little cultural quirk that protects the sanctity of this post.

In Vincent Kurita's words, the Coordinator is "the null space around which the wheel of the Combine turns".
To say it directly, both aforementioned Coordinators seem to me more like two unsuccessfull men - those who wish to achieve something (absolute power in their case), but they are unable to do so - so they came with excuses, justifications and vindications, pretending they really do not want power.
Otherwise, I know how it worked in real-world Japan.

Note also that Stalin did kill a number of his generals specifically because he feared they would betray him, so there is that. ;)

And that's the reason why from all those dozens of generals and admirals, not a single one rebelled against him. Not a single Military District Chief, no Army commander. And the power they hold wasn't small.(Of course there were losers such as A.A. Vlasov and few others, but they betrayed him in German captivity, when it didn't matter).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neufeld on 17 April 2013, 16:05:28
BTW, what happened to Victor's spawn, Kitsune Kurita?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 17 April 2013, 16:48:24
BTW, what happened to Victor's spawn, Kitsune Kurita?

We're assuming he's in Fortress Republic. Can you imagine if Julian and Yori both die and he lays a claim to both thrones?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 April 2013, 16:53:33
We're assuming he's in Fortress Republic. Can you imagine if Julian and Yori both die and he lays a claim to both thrones?

Nothing happens. Daoshen is on New Avalon and Snow Ravens rule over the former Draconis Combine territory (now Greater Raven Alliance).  ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 17 April 2013, 18:21:43
We're assuming he's in Fortress Republic. Can you imagine if Julian and Yori both die and he lays a claim to both thrones?
His claim gets paid by car-bomb.  Bhatia accepts no BS like that.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 18 April 2013, 08:30:51
Nothing happens. Daoshen is on New Avalon and Snow Ravens rule over the former Draconis Combine territory (now Greater Raven Alliance).  ;)

Well, if Yori dies there's still Toranaga. And another Kurita can be propped up quickly enough. Though the circumstances leading to Yori's death may preclude that.

His claim gets paid by car-bomb.  Bhatia accepts no BS like that.

This Bhatia guy's a more sinister Subhash Indrahar to me. Wanna read more about him.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 18 April 2013, 16:01:27
Well, if Yori dies there's still Toranaga. And another Kurita can be propped up quickly enough. Though the circumstances leading to Yori's death may preclude that.
I get the feeling that Yori's gonna outlive him.  She's striking me as someone who isn't quite the puppet that she seems to be; there's something about her that just says hidden depths to me.  And Toranaga likely knows it, but there weren't too many tigers to grab onto at the time, so he's holding on to the best of the bunch.  I think she'll certainly keep him around until he becomes unpopular, and then move to replace him.  Not with Tormark, but someone.
Quote
This Bhatia guy's a more sinister Subhash Indrahar to me. Wanna read more about him.
Me too.  A good secret police needs a complete patriot jerkhole for a boss.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 18 April 2013, 16:26:43
A good secret police needs a complete patriot jerkhole for a boss.

That man is a disaster in waiting.

Have you actually read his bio?
Disloyal to the Coordinators, thinking that his personal whims are more important than orders issued by the Coordinator. Where have I seen it before? Oh yes, this has been the typical mindset of Black Dragons.

Openly despising his Coordinator. Does anyone really think that high officer or official can do this? In front of his subordinates?
How I see it, it's just another Black Dragon conspiracy or something similar behind the corner.  :(


Of couse I know how unreliable are books written from in-universe view, but even the ... I have bad feeling from this.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: LiaoFan on 18 April 2013, 21:51:44
Serve the Dragon.

Well, okay.

But, only because the roast beef's a bit off.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nav_Alpha on 18 April 2013, 22:40:56
Well, okay.

But, only because the roast beef's a bit off.

Errrgh. Yet another dish that tastes like chicken...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 18 April 2013, 23:32:47
Errrgh. Yet another dish that tastes like chicken...
Hey, just because the Dragon is a lizard-creature...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 19 April 2013, 08:18:09
That man is a disaster in waiting.

Have you actually read his bio?
Disloyal to the Coordinators, thinking that his personal whims are more important than orders issued by the Coordinator. Where have I seen it before? Oh yes, this has been the typical mindset of Black Dragons.

Openly despising his Coordinator. Does anyone really think that high officer or official can do this? In front of his subordinates?
How I see it, it's just another Black Dragon conspiracy or something similar behind the corner.  :(


Of couse I know how unreliable are books written from in-universe view, but even the ... I have bad feeling from this.

I think he knows he's mostly untouchable. First, he's the ISF Director so he knows a lot of secrets. Second, he's a sick, sick malfer. Third, he's smart.

Openly defying the Coordinator without any visible consequences probably undermined Vincent quite a lot. It's a way for Bhatia to maneuver other elements against the Chrysanthemum Throne to get what he wants.

Or so my theory goes. I'll need to strive through the two DA novels and get a clearer picture of him.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 19 April 2013, 15:24:00
I think he knows he's mostly untouchable. First, he's the ISF Director so he knows a lot of secrets. Second, he's a sick, sick malfer. Third, he's smart.
...

It sounds like the description of Lavrentiy Beriya*. Perhaps his life will end the same way since I can see some parallels. If you think about it, it may happen easily - especially in the less-than-stable situation the Draconis Combine is currently in.

* Beriya knew many dark secrets, there is no doubt that Beriya was sick, and he was smart - but not smart enough to hide his chestiness and contempt of all other people.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 19 April 2013, 16:41:00
Here's hoping Bhatia becomes a true Varys....
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 19 April 2013, 16:45:40
Here's hoping Bhatia becomes a true Varys....

I think it's more likely he's a Ramsay Snow.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 23 April 2013, 12:03:51
Just curious if anyone else is feeling less than triumphant over the events of 3145?  I would have thought i'd be elated that we're sticking it to the Fed Pigs, but i'm not.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 23 April 2013, 12:18:51
I'm glad at the Combine's general stability. It seems it's not as crippled as we all feared it'd be post-Jihad.

But it seemed fairly obvious that the only reason the Combine and the Confederation are this successful is so that when Julian Davion finally makes it to New Avalon, he'll kick both evil nations in the teeth so hard they'll just run away.

It seems like we're just being set up to lose it all for some Davion drama.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 23 April 2013, 12:47:41
I'm glad at the Combine's general stability. It seems it's not as crippled as we all feared it'd be post-Jihad.

We are in 3145. The Clan Nova Cat + Katana Tormark Rebellion ended in 3142, mere three years ago. A few posts up the thread I described my feelings on the Secret Service Director. We have Snow Ravens in the Draconis Combine backyard too, waiting for their opportunity and probing defences. That's not what I would describe as "general stability".


But it seemed fairly obvious that the only reason the Combine and the Confederation are this successful is so that when Julian Davion finally makes it to New Avalon, he'll kick both evil nations in the teeth so hard they'll just run away.

It seems like we're just being set up to lose it all for some Davion drama.

I expect no less than one Technical Readout/Davion filled with latest Clan toys, two sourcebooks, three scenario books from Operational Turning Points series and a PC game on top of that, all depicting victorious Davion offensive and I am only half-joking now.  ;)

Is it just me that I feel that I have been cheated a bit, again*. I have expected something interesting on Caleb's death - and not just "... and the Draconis 'Mech just kicked his tank and killed him. Let's move on ..."

* The first time it was the death of The Master. "... and then one nuke fell on him and killed him instantly. Meanwhile, on the other end of the Inner Sphere ..."
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 23 April 2013, 12:58:00
It's impossible to us to say of course, but I think the Davion situation is well in hand.  The AFFS can only do so much.  Even if they sue for peace with the CapCon and throw everything at us, all they can realistically hope for is averting any further loss.  A best case scenario for the AFFS is that they convince the Combine to give back a few key worlds like Robinson and New Ivaarsen for a peace deal.

My real worry is the Ravens.  The Palmyra Thumb leaves the conquest-minded clan with the Outback region of the Draconis March.  If they want anything more than Space Alabama, the DCMS currently has it.  And they were in cahoots afterall with Harrison against the Combine.. it took Caleb to screw that up.  And now Caleb's gone...

As for the Ghost Bears, they're everything we came to loathe the Davions for being.  Obvious protagonists wearing white hats... sickeningly invincible (anyone read Turning Points:Vega and get serious Deja-vu for the Galtor Campaign?) and incapable of doing anything wrong.  The way CGL has guided the universe, our only chance for success is to simply cross our fingers that Bears don't take an interest in conquering us while we're busy conquering Davion.  If anyone is deserving a crotch-kick it's the Ghost Bears, but the writing just isn't on the wall for that yet so we're simply at their mercy for the time being.

As for the avenging Republic bursting forth from behind their Fortress:  I predict that we won't see them again until the 3250 era, when they're ilClan :P
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 24 April 2013, 17:48:07
Just curious if anyone else is feeling less than triumphant over the events of 3145?  I would have thought i'd be elated that we're sticking it to the Fed Pigs, but i'm not.

Like the Magistracy and the CapCon, you're probably waiting for the other shoe to drop. A feeling that there's no way CGL isn't going to let Davion not bounce back against the Kuritans. Or maybe you realize there Ghost Bears, quiet for now, are unlikely to remain quiet forever, and into the DC is as good as a direction as any. Or maybe you're wondering just what's going to happen with the Ravens...

Or maybe you realize there's still the Homeworld Clans out there, and eventually, they might come through Kurita space (one reason I'm surprised Kurita would even think about decreasing their military, for all they knew, at any moment they might face another Clan Invasion).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Atlas3060 on 25 April 2013, 06:43:52
How were the Ghost Bears white hat in 3145?
Heck what they did to the Nova Cats trying to seek asylum sure wasn't white hat acting.
Now they may be the sickeningly invincible boring Clan, they really didn't do much compared to other realms.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 25 April 2013, 07:51:27
Perhaps not "white Hat" as in "good guy" but as in "Can do no wrong" or perhaps just infallible. They project that invincibility, whether real or imagined.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Atlas3060 on 25 April 2013, 13:31:15
I feel that the projected invincibility is really just a frustrated desire by folks to see them get kicked in the teeth for once.
Through the Dark Age you have a lot of things happening to a lot of nations because they took risks.

Dracs have the civil war and the Nova Cat uprising along with their conquest of the Drac March.
Cappies have the retaking of their worlds from the RoTS and the CapMarch.
Davions get swift kicked in the hoozahs by the two nations mentioned earlier
Lyrans try to take a bone away from a hungry dog and get bit hard.
A broken FWL starts to rise again.

Then you have the Clans:

Wolf's move is rather gutsy and daring, moving into areas near two nations that have fought each other for centuries.
Falcons ran out of pills to calm down their leaders. Other leaders managed to inspect a warship the hard way.
Nova Cats get stomped.
Hells Horsed learn that trying to hold onto a fiery insane Falcon is actually more dangerous than their namesake.

So what do the Bears do? Water the neighbor's lawn so to speak by annexing and protecting some RoTS worlds because "I respect those guys so much".
That was it basically. Oh so thrilling. They don't do anything. That, in how I see some player's frustration, is the key point.

During the Golden Century while other Clans were innovating weapon systems these guys found new rocks in space to mine.
Lyran fortifications move faster than them in terms of speed and progress.

It isn't that they are 'invincible' but rather they hole themselves up so well that if you aren't putting in a concentrated effort to hurt them it won't be worth it.
That's a different notion compared to the other Clans where they take risks and as such suffer the consequences of getting kicked in the teeth sometimes, but they benefit more in terms of technology and story.

They "can do no wrong" because they do nothing at all really.
So there's no real measuring stick, they can do no right either by this logic.
These guys aren't the Clanner equivalent to the FedSuns or anything.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 25 April 2013, 14:37:59
They had the potential for some drama with the Vega situation. But nope. THOSE traitors are allowed to live and look at the result...Nice, friendly reconciliation and they're all buddy buddy again. Kind of boring.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jimdigris on 25 April 2013, 16:24:36
So, when is Wolf's Dragoons contract up, anyway? :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 25 April 2013, 16:48:42
If the Dragon plays it smart, never ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 25 April 2013, 16:51:33
I feel that the projected invincibility is really just a frustrated desire by folks to see them get kicked in the teeth for once.
Through the Dark Age you have a lot of things happening to a lot of nations because they took risks.

This is part of the problem.  We're going to see people get kicked for taking risks... and the GBs never take any.  Yet for all their 'don't bother us, we're doing our own thing' they STILL expand their borders in every story.  So instead of paying the 'price' of fading away to irrelevance for never taking risks, they profit from not taking risks.  While as you say, we expect everyone else to pay some price FOR taking risks.

What started as mild annoyance about the GBs never, ever, EVER coming out on the losing end in any story has become (at least for me) loathing that surpasses even that for Davion.  When was the last time we heard about the GB ever being humbled? Tukayyid?  Not even then, really.  Sure, the Nova Cats scored some pride-wounding Trial of Possession for that shipful of supplies coming in from the homeworlds, which in the end didn't hurt the GB in any meaningful way, and they got the ultimate last laugh at the Cats for their 'success'.  Trash-talking back and forth between factions (when kept good-natured) is one of the most important facets of BattleTech fandom.  And when you can't trash talk the Bears, there's a problem.  "When was the last time we ever lost in anything? Never?  Banter finished.  Everyone who's not a Bear Fan loses."

While Davion got the same 'white hat' treatment from FASA in the SW/4th SW era, at least it ended after that.  While I may 'hate' Davion, I absolutely love the Kurita-Davion rivalry and would never want to see the Suns down for good.  Whereas my feelings about the 'white hat' CGB is that I wish they'd simply cease to exist.  If I had the money to bribe CGL's devs to just arbitrarily write the Bears out of the universe, I would.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 25 April 2013, 17:45:43
So, when is Wolf's Dragoons contract up, anyway? :D

It hasn't been stated, but the first thing that came to mind was that they'd do the whole "work for everyone in the Sphere" again every 5 years.

They can jump to the Lyrans who'll need their help, but they've been working for them for years. So, I think they'll help the FedSuns next and be part of kicking the CapCons around.

Hopefully, there'll be that clause that prevents them from being assigned to fight their most recent employers.

The Dragon and Dragoons can part amicably. I'd love for that to happen, even if it is part of the Suns rising again.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 April 2013, 11:23:10
But who's to say they are doing the same contracting scheme they followed before?  Which, btw, was meant to circulate them throughe very IS military before returning to the Kerensky Cluster.  DC was supposed to be the last before they took the Exodus Road home and then...

But there's no need for them work for everyone after 5 years or whatever.  They contracted multiple regiments to different emplyers prior tothe fall fo Outreach.  And, the current CO has defied Dragoon traditionalists by hiring onto the Dragon.  So there isn't much other than history repeating itself for the sake of repeating it that the Dragoons should have to rotate.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 26 April 2013, 13:04:29
True, though I don't think they were actually planning on returning by the time they signed on the with the Dragon.

They are interested in making a 'comeback' though, and what better way than to work for everyone? They're trying to shed the image of being Lyran lapdogs like the Kell Hounds by going to work for the Dragon. They've earned the reputation as a hardfighting unit again, so why tie yourself down to the Combine?

Work for the Suns. Be instrumental in their reconquista. Or for the Mariks, bury the hatchet there.

It's not best to get tied down to one employer. Though it looks like Tanaga is much smarter than Samsonov.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 April 2013, 13:27:56
True, though I don't think they were actually planning on returning by the time they signed on the with the Dragon.

Yes, they did.  The Draconis Combine was specifically the last house they planned on signing with.  DC completed their clockwise cycle of the Inner Sphere that started with them fighting for the FedSuns.  They stipulated in their contracts they would not fight their previous emplyers, thereby forcing the house lords to send them against every house by the time they had signed with the Combine.  There's a specific conversation in which someone suggests they just go home, as planned during Wolves on The Border.  Jaime Wolf himself says no.

Quote
They are interested in making a 'comeback' though, and what better way than to work for everyone? They're trying to shed the image of being Lyran lapdogs like the Kell Hounds by going to work for the Dragon. They've earned the reputation as a hardfighting unit again, so why tie yourself down to the Combine?

Or work for the guys that are going to attack the house military with the best reputation: the AFFS.  What better way to prove yourself than to be the decisive factor in reclaiming a stalemated territory?

Quote
Work for the Suns. Be instrumental in their reconquista. Or for the Mariks, bury the hatchet there.

What hatchet? 

Quote
It's not best to get tied down to one employer. Though it looks like Tanaga is much smarter than Samsonov.

The one employer thing has worked out well for the Kell Hounds, The MAC and the other commands that went over to the CCAF.  The Dragoons just have a chip on their shoulders ever since they heard about the ELH being company stored.

As for Samsanov... come on.  Totally different characters.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 26 April 2013, 15:33:04
Yes, they did.  The Draconis Combine was specifically the last house they planned on signing with.  DC completed their clockwise cycle of the Inner Sphere that started with them fighting for the FedSuns.  They stipulated in their contracts they would not fight their previous emplyers, thereby forcing the house lords to send them against every house by the time they had signed with the Combine.  There's a specific conversation in which someone suggests they just go home, as planned during Wolves on The Border.  Jaime Wolf himself says no.

Kerlin Ward ordered the Wolf's Dragoons to stop sending updates in 3019 on their last supply run.

They had new orders to prepare the Inner Sphere for a Clan Invasion.

Pure conjecture after that: The best way to finish the new mission is to finish the original one; gain firsthand knowledge of each Successor State's military.

It was never revealed why the Dragoons cut their Lyran contract short to sign on with the Combine (or was it?) in 3023 so I presumed it was them wanting to get the Dragon out of the way as well and start planning.

Quote
Or work for the guys that are going to attack the house military with the best reputation: the AFFS.  What better way to prove yourself than to be the decisive factor in reclaiming a stalemated territory?

They already did that. The Dragoons' and Ryuken's actions were key in reconquering a swath of worlds that had remained independent for decades.

What's a greater challenge? Kicking the beat-up AFFS or helping it fend off the CapCon?

Quote
What hatchet? 

Joshua Wolf. I don't think they've ever really forgiven the Mariks for that. Have the Dragoons ever worked for them since?

Quote
The one employer thing has worked out well for the Kell Hounds, The MAC and the other commands that went over to the CCAF.  The Dragoons just have a chip on their shoulders ever since they heard about the ELH being company stored.

As for Samsanov... come on.  Totally different characters.

The Kell Hounds were founded by a noble with a strong relationship to the ruling family. The Big MAC have been in service since almost forever, but Highlanders abandoned the CapCon to some success though.

I don't think the Dragoons are interested in being a pet merc outfit. That said, I won't mind at all if they stuck around.

Just by the way Toranaga is handling them is already interesting.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 April 2013, 22:19:37
Joshua Wolf. I don't think they've ever really forgiven the Mariks for that. Have the Dragoons ever worked for them since?

Yes, immediately following the end of their contract with the Capellans.  Anton Marik's revolt was not part of their FWL contract.  They were on loan from Max Liao.  The Dragoons signed up with Janos afterward and hit Hesperus II.  The people with the hatchet to bury was Janos Marik, and he got over it.


Anyway, back to the Dragon with one O.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 27 April 2013, 05:48:51
If the Davion's don't find a way of stopping the invasions where do you think the new Confederation - Combine boarder will be?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Scrollreader on 27 April 2013, 08:20:54
If the Davion's don't find a way of stopping the invasions where do you think the new Confederation - Combine boarder will be?

New Samarkand.  With a margin of error to Liao.  Let the atrocities begin!

 (Seriously, though.  I don't think, absent a common enemy (resurgent FedSuns or RotS 2.0) they will make for good neighbors.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nav_Alpha on 28 April 2013, 08:00:45
So... Having just read Redemption Rift, anyone else getting possible Black Dragon vibes...?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 28 April 2013, 08:13:33
So... Having just read Redemption Rift, anyone else getting possible Black Dragon vibes...?

Is that a BattleCorps fiction?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormcrow on 28 April 2013, 08:39:16
Yes, and it was decent start to the story of the new Wolf's Dragoons
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 28 April 2013, 11:23:56
Just downloaded and about to start reading.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 28 April 2013, 22:07:07
So... Having just read Redemption Rift, anyone else getting possible Black Dragon vibes...?

Dammit, can't we be rid of those troublesome bastards?  >:(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Atlas3060 on 29 April 2013, 06:53:18
Dammit, can't we be rid of those troublesome bastards?  >:(
Nope, the Combine can't because that would be progress in the culture.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 29 April 2013, 08:16:28
Is Redemption Rift out in full already? I thought it was going to continue throughout May?

Hmm... may re-subscribe just for that.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Atlas3060 on 29 April 2013, 09:16:42
Part one was recently released.
I liked the Prologue, but sadly was interrupted before I could continue reading.
That's where my lunch hour will go towards today!  :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 29 April 2013, 15:06:24
Its a good read, shame we've not found out which DMM Regiment it is yet though.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nerroth on 30 April 2013, 13:17:42
I saw the recent update from Cassini (http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/cassini/whycassini/cassini20130429.html) about the giant storm on Saturn's north pole, and wondered if any Kurita fans might appreciate this false-colour image (http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/cassini/multimedia/pia14944.html)...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 30 April 2013, 13:23:38
I saw the recent update from Cassini (http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/cassini/whycassini/cassini20130429.html) about the giant storm on Saturn's north pole, and wondered if any Kurita fans might appreciate this false-colour image (http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/cassini/multimedia/pia14944.html)...

Draconis Combine in the mixer, processed into an amorphous mash? Result of another Civil war with Black Dragons?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nerroth on 30 April 2013, 13:47:05
That wasn't quite the comparison I was going for. (Although I suppose many different images could be evoked from the same scene.)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 30 April 2013, 14:29:28
That wasn't quite the comparison I was going for. (Although I suppose many different images could be evoked from the same scene.)

I know, I know. It's the picture of the DCMS flushed down the drain after being overrun in the Davion counter-offensive and Snow Raven and Ghost Bear offensive.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jayof9s on 30 April 2013, 14:31:02
I know, I know. It's the picture of the DCMS flushed down the drain after being overrun in the Davion counter-offensive and Snow Raven and Ghost Bear offensive.

You forgot the resurgent Republic in your list.  :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 30 April 2013, 14:40:45
You forgot the resurgent Republic in your list.  :D

When the Republic gets there, there will be no single DCMS soldier left. Those escapees still alive (by the way, approximately 70% of those survivors are probably Black Dragon Society members and sympathizers) are founding the Draconis-Combine-in-Exile, so the IlClan will have something to worry about ...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jayof9s on 30 April 2013, 20:10:01
When the Republic gets there, there will be no single DCMS soldier left. Those escapees still alive (by the way, approximately 70% of those survivors are probably Black Dragon Society members and sympathizers) are founding the Draconis-Combine-in-Exile, so the IlClan will have something to worry about ...

Fair enough.   O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 04 May 2013, 20:56:22
I didn't notice it until recently but the Orochi is not on the Combine RAT in the ER3145, but it IS on the FedSuns'.  Yet another reason to be happy to get Marduk back :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 05 May 2013, 02:27:31
I never had any luck with the Orochi. I'd either miss, or the few times I hit something, it'd be something with AMS. Not to mention I'm not too sold on only 9 rounds per main gun.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Fat Guy on 05 May 2013, 15:12:41
The Orochi is in desperate need of a C3 slave.

And more ammo.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 05 May 2013, 17:36:34
I look at the Combine in 3145 and wonder if the Black Dragons haven't already won
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 05 May 2013, 19:36:57
The Orochi is in desperate need of a C3 slave.

Its funny. I'll swear up and down that c3 is over BV'd and the proliferation of ECM has killed it.

And then I'll look at the Orochi and say that it's in desperate need of a c3 slave :)

Oh well, next time I use it, maybe I'll just cram a really good pilot into it.

Quote
And more ammo.

Oh yeah. Not really sure where it would come from except for maybe the second ton of SRM4 ammo, but it desperately needs more ammo for the Thunderbolts (a common problem among many of the Thunderbolt `Mechs, IMO).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 06 May 2013, 04:26:20
Since the Combine is likely to share some border with the Capellans and both realms are invading the FedSuns at the same time, do you all think it would be likely that we'll see some sort of (temporary) alliance? Or does the Dragon not associate with inferior cultures?

This could be some sort of touchstone about not only the Gunji-no-Kanrei's mindset (and possible allegations for being in league with the kokuryu-kai) but for how independent the Coordinator really is (if she differs from the Kanrei's opinion on this matter).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 06 May 2013, 10:04:52
Personally I expect the Bears to be unleashed to help save the Davionist bacon.  If that doesn't happen, then the Ravens will cease being content with conquering Space Alabama and turn instead into the New Samarkand District.

It certainly would be refreshing as hell to see a war between Houses play out without clan upstarts stealing any spotlight.  In that case, I'm not so sure Kurita or Liao would end up having borders without the AFFS abandoning the former RotS worlds, leaving them a too-tempting-to-ignore prize for the two invaders to suddenly scramble for.  It certainly could be an awesome move on Julian's part to bleed both his enemies' strengths.

If Davion does not pull back and invite Kurita and Liao to butt heads over the worlds separating them, I think Kurita/Liao conflict would really only likely happen in the unlikely event they both invade the same planet. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 May 2013, 10:22:57
Let them try!  All who challenge the supremacy of the Dragon will be slain!


Nope.  Can't do it.  Can't get excited.  I know we're headed for a fall.  Black Dragons will find a way to mess this up for sure.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 06 May 2013, 10:53:54
I never had any luck with the Orochi. I'd either miss, or the few times I hit something, it'd be something with AMS. Not to mention I'm not too sold on only 9 rounds per main gun.

Thunderbolt-20s are not completely bad weapons, but they have some disadvantages of ammo-fed weapons such as the need of having enough ammunition. Nine shots per weapon is simply not enough. The range could be greater too.

The result is an average 'Mech at best.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 06 May 2013, 10:59:04
The Orochi makes me cry. First, did we really need another O-Bakemono? Second, did it have to suck?

I'm cautiously optimistic that the way we think things will turn out isn't how it'll play out. And I think the Black Dragons have already won.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 May 2013, 11:08:22
The Orochi makes me cry. First, did we really need another O-Bakemono? Second, did it have to suck?

Yes to both.  It is still an assault, and therefor must have glarring design flaws rendering it of questionable value.  If you don't believe me, look at the Peacemaker and new Hatamoto Karu made in the same era.  The only decent DC assault to come out lately was the Bonzai.  And, let's face it, that's only because clantech was involved.  The 3067u Akuma isn't too bad, but it is hardly the equal of the assaults coming out of the LA or FS.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 06 May 2013, 11:21:31
If Davion does not pull back and invite Kurita and Liao to butt heads over the worlds separating them, I think Kurita/Liao conflict would really only likely happen in the unlikely event they both invade the same planet.

Do you think, that if Julian does pull back, a Combine-Confederation war is inevitable?

I don't think so. It may would become more likely, but even Daoshen and Toranaga do realize, they can't really afford another front. And they would gain much more by even just barely tolerating each other and acknowledging to not poach in foreign territory.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 06 May 2013, 11:23:06
Since the Combine is likely to share some border with the Capellans and both realms are invading the FedSuns at the same time, do you all think it would be likely that we'll see some sort of (temporary) alliance? Or does the Dragon not associate with inferior cultures?

Considering that both nations have signed the Kapteyn Accords one century ago ... I think that the Dragon can associate with foreign cultures.

It certainly would be refreshing as hell to see a war between Houses play out without clan upstarts stealing any spotlight.  In that case, I'm not so sure Kurita or Liao would end up having borders without the AFFS abandoning the former RotS worlds, leaving them a too-tempting-to-ignore prize for the two invaders to suddenly scramble for.  It certainly could be an awesome move on Julian's part to bleed both his enemies' strengths.

If Davion does not pull back and invite Kurita and Liao to butt heads over the worlds separating them, I think Kurita/Liao conflict would really only likely happen in the unlikely event they both invade the same planet. 

In that case both states can (at least in theory) divide those planets 50:50. Something similar as when House Marik and House Liao cooperated during Operation Guerrero.
Surely the Draconis High Command knows that there are Snow Ravens probing Draconis-Periphery border. Conflict with the Capellan Confederation is the last thing what the Draconis Combine would need.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 06 May 2013, 11:28:35
Do you think, that if Julian does pull back, a Combine-Confederation war is inevitable?

I don't think so. It may would become more likely, but even Daoshen and Toranaga do realize, they can't really afford another front. And they would gain much more by even just barely tolerating each other and acknowledging to not poach in foreign territory.

Not inevitable, no.  But it's certainly an angle that could be used to explain a Liao/Kurita war.  Opportunistic field commanders eager for glory could easily find themselves dragging their realms into war.  The 1st Dominion War started that exact way.

Assuming the devs do want to allow the FedSuns to rally, something has to happen to facilitate it.  Clan invasion of the Combine is an obvious one, and I share some of Marwynn's cautious hope that the devs won't play that card AGAIN.  Having Liao/Kurita get snarled on each other provides the devs a creative way to give some room for Davion to stage a comeback, as well as giving fans a new rivalry to salivate over.   I'm not predicting it WILL happen, but oh yes it certainly COULD.  I'd definitely prefer it to seeing the clans romp.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 06 May 2013, 11:52:18
Yes to both.  It is still an assault, and therefor must have glarring design flaws rendering it of questionable value.  If you don't believe me, look at the Peacemaker and new Hatamoto Karu made in the same era.  The only decent DC assault to come out lately was the Bonzai.  And, let's face it, that's only because clantech was involved.  The 3067u Akuma isn't too bad, but it is hardly the equal of the assaults coming out of the LA or FS.

It's more than a little sad that the best Assault design we've had recently is built around a 9-ton self-destruct.

The newer Akuma's actually quite a beast though. And the Kaeru... has anyone actually used underwater 'Mechs?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 06 May 2013, 11:55:14
Not inevitable, no.  But it's certainly an angle that could be used to explain a Liao/Kurita war.  Opportunistic field commanders eager for glory could easily find themselves dragging their realms into war.  The 1st Dominion War started that exact way.

Assuming the devs do want to allow the FedSuns to rally, something has to happen to facilitate it.  Clan invasion of the Combine is an obvious one, and I share some of Marwynn's cautious hope that the devs won't play that card AGAIN.  Having Liao/Kurita get snarled on each other provides the devs a creative way to give some room for Davion to stage a comeback, as well as giving fans a new rivalry to salivate over.   I'm not predicting it WILL happen, but oh yes it certainly COULD.  I'd definitely prefer it to seeing the clans romp.

I see your point. Yes, it is a possibility.

However, I think the option that the Combine will keep what it already got or even more (did you realize that the Draconis March nearly ceased to exist?) is still a valid option. There are plenty of examples in BT history, where factions lost territory they had held for centuries. It's a part of the universe's charme.

Why do you all think it is inevitable that the Combine get's punched back? I am optimistic.  }:)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 May 2013, 12:19:01
I see your point. Yes, it is a possibility.

However, I think the option that the Combine will keep what it already got or even more (did you realize that the Draconis March nearly ceased to exist?) is still a valid option. There are plenty of examples in BT history, where factions lost territory they had held for centuries. It's a part of the universe's charme.

Why do you all think it is inevitable that the Combine get's punched back? I am optimistic.  }:)

I would love nothing more than to believe the DCMS and CCAF reduce the FedSuns to a rump state for the next few decades and have it actually happen/  I just don't see it happening.  FS has the largest, oldest and most diehard followings in BT, and reducing them to a post 4th SW Capellan Confederation status would likely lead to a mass exodus of Davion fans.  The Combine meanwhile has had a history of getting torn apart by civil conflicts, massive turnover of regiments, crippling losses and fly by night Warlord loyalty.  It seems really, really odd that all of a sudden things are working properly.  And not just a little bit, either.  Really working.  Beating the FedSuns properly.  Killing off the Nova Cats while fighting the FedSuns working.  Either this is an enormous dose of cosmic karma, or a set up for another glorious Davion cavalry charge.  The situation with Caleb's death and Julian taking over  is just too similar to Ian and Hanse.  The man who would be king, the Prodigal Son is going to turn this situation around, I'm sure of it.

Maybe this is just the result of 2 decades of "Don't get too excited" DC storylines.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 06 May 2013, 12:53:43
It's more than a little sad that the best Assault design we've had recently is built around a 9-ton self-destruct.

The newer Akuma's actually quite a beast though. And the Kaeru... has anyone actually used underwater 'Mechs?

The Tenshi is coming.

The Tenshi is nigh...

 O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 06 May 2013, 13:06:17
The Tenshi is coming.

The Tenshi is nigh...

 O0

On a scale of original Charger to... hmm, the fact that I have to think about a kickass Kuritan Assault on the other end of the Charger...

Looking forward to this and the other unit you tweeted about. In fact, just eager for the TRO itself.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 06 May 2013, 13:09:04
... Either this is an enormous dose of cosmic karma, or a set up for another glorious Davion cavalry charge...

I'll echo that, as this isn't the first time Kurita has had Davion's number prior to some amazing reversal... if you include backhistory that didn't unfold 'live' before the fanbase.

During the War of Davion Succession, Kurita was all over it until SLDF intervened with Operation Smother.
In the 1st Succession War, it took Jinjiro's Joffrey-esque incompetence to undo Operation Marathon.

In the 'living history' era since 3025, we've seen only two kinds of storylines for Kurita military fortunes: Stunning Losses and Narrow Draws.  The few local victories (other than Wolcott) had all been courtesy of the cooperation of the rest of the Inner Sphere. (Luthien, Bulldog, Lyons Thumb)   If this is actually going to be a "Kurita finally wins one!" storyline, we have a lot of track record to overcome before we can believe it :)

The Tenshi is coming.

The Tenshi is nigh...

 O0

I've long assumed there was a conscious design decision made about faction flavor to not allow (m)any good assaults to Kurita.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Fat Guy on 06 May 2013, 13:11:30

Oh yeah. Not really sure where it would come from except for maybe the second ton of SRM4 ammo, but it desperately needs more ammo for the Thunderbolts (a common problem among many of the Thunderbolt `Mechs, IMO).

Replace each streak with 2 medium lasers. You can then have 15 rounds for each T-bolt. Then shave a half ton of armor and upgrade the ER small to a C3 Slave.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 May 2013, 13:46:25
In the 'living history' era since 3025, we've seen only two kinds of storylines for Kurita military fortunes: Stunning Losses and Narrow Draws.  The few local victories (other than Wolcott) had all been courtesy of the cooperation of the rest of the Inner Sphere. (Luthien, Bulldog, Lyons Thumb)   If this is actually going to be a "Kurita finally wins one!" storyline, we have a lot of track record to overcome before we can believe it :)

I still have yet to get my first Davion war lost in living history without some sort of asterix on the end.  Even the latest round of beatings is in no small part thanks to Wolf's Dragoons and the Snow Raven betrayal.



Quote
I've long assumed there was a conscious design decision made about faction flavor to not allow (m)any good assaults to Kurita.

Let's be clear.  The DCMS has some good assaults, like some Charger variants and O-Bakemono.  Some Maulers are passable and the Naginata has the honor of being both a good c3 mech and a good assault even if not connected.  Good stuff.  But, those are the exceptions.  There's plenty of bad Hatamoto-Chi and Atlas out there.  I can forgive the Tai-Sho for being a niche mech.  But the Orochi?  Come on.... can't even get a good substitute for all the Gauss rifles we aren't using?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 06 May 2013, 13:57:36
The Tenshi is coming.

The Tenshi is nigh...

 O0

 [drool]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 06 May 2013, 13:59:14
But the Orochi?  Come on.... can't even get a good substitute for all the Gauss rifles we aren't using?

Load up on CP-11-Bs. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 May 2013, 14:03:36
Or Cerebus or Wolf Traps.  They exist, just not well represented in the DCMS.  I shouldn't complain too much.  If you look at the HPPC as a GR substitute, we have plenty of those.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 06 May 2013, 14:39:45
Or Cerebus or Wolf Traps.  They exist, just not well represented in the DCMS.

One of the many reasons Catalyst doesn't produce any sort of "numbers" for units in factions.  If you don't like the Orochi, don't use it.  Prefer the CP-11-B?  Use as many as you'd like. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 May 2013, 14:44:42
Ah, that old escape clause.  There's a Thunderhawk in every Lyran regiment.  But, in my mind there's 3 Cerebus in every DCMS lance.  Problem solved.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Alexander Knight on 06 May 2013, 14:45:28
In the 'living history' era since 3025, we've seen only two kinds of storylines for Kurita military fortunes: Stunning Losses and Narrow Draws. 

I'm sorry, are you claiming the Kurita-Davion fighting during the Fed-Com civil war was a stunning loss or narrow draw for House Kurita?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 06 May 2013, 15:30:53
Ah, that old escape clause.  There's a Thunderhawk in every Lyran regiment.  But, in my mind there's 3 Cerebus in every DCMS lance.  Problem solved.

If you insist on nothing but assault gauss boats...
Them have fun with it.  You have a problem with playing the units you like?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 06 May 2013, 15:38:37
It's the old RATs thing. Best not to disturb it, we're prickly about that.

I'm sorry, are you claiming the Kurita-Davion fighting during the Fed-Com civil war was a stunning loss or narrow draw for House Kurita?

Hmm, in general though, could you say that the Kuritans won during that whole period? Sure, there was the Lyons' Thumb in the early 3060s. But the Bear-Dragon War was rather brutal for the Combine (and Nova Cats).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 May 2013, 15:45:29
I tend not to look at a single design and think that's the backbone of the entire military unless stated directly, like old Vindicators and Urbanmechs.  My favorite designs are just a minority among designs being fielded.  And when I judge the overall quality of a faction's designs I tend to look at a rough total of all of their designs in any perticular category.  In terms of assaults, I feel DC has a majority of poor designs.  Yes, they have a few good ones and I can ignore the bad ones if I want.  But in making the judgement call I try to go by what is fielded, to the best my brain can hang onto those details.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Alexander Knight on 06 May 2013, 16:36:16
Hmm, in general though, could you say that the Kuritans won during that whole period? Sure, there was the Lyons' Thumb in the early 3060s. But the Bear-Dragon War was rather brutal for the Combine (and Nova Cats).

Compared to the Federated Suns and the Lyran Commonwealth/alliance?  Heck YES they won.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 06 May 2013, 18:33:04
Yeah, Alex is right, the Combine handed the Draconis March a pretty thorough ass-beating after initially being put back on their heels.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 07 May 2013, 00:09:37
I'm sorry, are you claiming the Kurita-Davion fighting during the Fed-Com civil war was a stunning loss or narrow draw for House Kurita?

Obviously, a narrow draw.  In that war, Davion won round one, then Kurita won round two.  There was a net conquest of what, 2 unimportant worlds?  I don't see how that makes it NOT be a 'narrow draw'.  Especially when you consider that the peace happened right when the momentum was in Kurita's favor.

Annexing the Lyons Thumb was certainly a political (if not military) victory.   But as I mentioned, that was made possible by the rest of the non-Lyran IS not caring that the Coordinator was serving his own interest as First Lord.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 07 May 2013, 02:13:09
Considering that both nations have signed the Kapteyn Accords one century ago ... I think that the Dragon can associate with foreign cultures.

Speaking of the Concord of Kapteyn, are those accords still in effect? I mean, even if we never heard anything about them being revoked, they weren't used for many decades then.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 07 May 2013, 05:04:16
The Tenshi is coming.

The Tenshi is nigh...

 O0
Stop teasing the poor players, vile developer!

Speaking of the Concord of Kapteyn, are those accords still in effect? I mean, even if we never heard anything about them being revoked, they weren't used for many decades then.

It is from 100 years ago. That makes it as old as the Kurita-Wolf´s Dragoons feud. And you know what became of that in the current timeline.

I still have yet to get my first Davion war lost in living history without some sort of asterix on the end. 
...

Or my very first on-screen FWL victory. Guerrero had three asterix. (asterixes? asteri? other related as-word?)

But I know what you mean. There remains the feeling that there always was a kind of excuse or justification why the FedRats "lost" a war. If one would be so inclined (and biased as I am I certainly am inclined) one could easily see the implication that "normally" the FedSuns would win any war, because of their sheer awesomeness. Fate (the writers) naturally had to "cheat" for the FedRats not to win a conventional war.

If it weren´t for these meddling kids and all that.

But then this might be a product of our own resentment of the Davions. (Or, in my case their novel characters.)

From a certain perspective it even makes sense. A big part of the FedSuns-Fan-identity seems to revolve around "we are better soldiers than anyone else". If you´d take that from them...well...what´s left?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 07 May 2013, 05:40:29
Compared to the Federated Suns and the Lyran Commonwealth/alliance?  Heck YES they won.

This is only true if you specifically look at the sizes of the militaries before and after the FedCom Civil War. But since the FedCom was not fighting the Draconis Combine, well...

When you examine the Suns/Combine conflict, the Suns very clearly thumped the Combine,  and the only reason the Suns stopped beating the Combine like a drum was because Tancred Sandoval needed to reconsolidate his forces to support Victor. If Victor wasn't making an immediate move on New Avalon, the Draconis March's assaults would have continued to enjoy success, especially given how badly beaten up the DCMS was by the Bears around the same time.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 07 May 2013, 05:47:22
Speaking of the Concord of Kapteyn, are those accords still in effect?

In 3051 Hanse Davion mentioned the Kapteyn Accords in a sense of functional treaty.

Eight years later in 3059 Sunny Liao considered the Treaty of Kapteyn to be still in force. His engagement to Isis Marik was planned to revive the spirit of cooperation based on the Concord of Kapteyn.

In 3067 the Handbook: House Marik mentions the Treaty of Kapteyn as the valid one.

I mean, even if we never heard anything about them being revoked, they weren't used for many decades then.

Of course the Jihad has changed everything and we don't have enough info on post-Jihad international relations.

As far as I know, the last time the Treaty of Kapteyn was invoked was in 3067.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 07 May 2013, 06:44:55
The Tenshi is coming.

The Tenshi is nigh...
Oh goodie. More targets to burn. :D

So, are we getting an Aeka and Ryoko in the process too?
(I'm an anime nerd. I HAD to make the joke)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 07 May 2013, 08:18:13
Compared to the Federated Suns and the Lyran Commonwealth/alliance?  Heck YES they won.

Is that a fair comparison though? I mean, that period is referred to as the FedCom Civil War after all. It only stands to reason that they'd be more badly mauled.

But I recall the Draconis March winning until the Civil War necessitated their forces elsewhere. And that the DCMS was getting whooped by the Ghost Bears (thus explaining our love for them).

The territorial gains are: two border worlds and the Lyons Thumb. All territories that have been taken before and retaken time and again throughout the Succession Wars.

And I hate to bring up FM:U but after that, the DCMS was mauled. The FedSuns... not so much. The Lyrans were smacked around as well.

Your comparison is to two of the main participants in a deadly Civil War versus a third party that got invaded and had rebellious troops prompt another invasion. It's not like the leadership sought out these wars.

But anyway, from my perspective (and I'm guessing a lot of the Combine fans share this as well) we're a backdrop for the 'main' story. We rise only to show how heroic the FedSuns can be.

Which explains our rather short-lived joy at seeing the Combine so successful in 3145.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 07 May 2013, 08:31:10
You know, my gut feeling tells me, it will be different this time.  }:)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 07 May 2013, 09:13:30
Your comparison is to two of the main participants in a deadly Civil War versus a third party that got invaded and had rebellious troops prompt another invasion. It's not like the leadership sought out these wars.

I too was bothered by how cleanly FS got away with a rogue March Lord wagging his own personal war.  I'm glad this theme came back to haunt FS during Operation Sovreign Justice.  Sadly, it was the Cappies that actually killed Sandoval and Hasek.  Oh well, we bumped off Caleb.  Not as showy as Hasek's execution, but 13 regiments and a warship in one engagement isn't bad either.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 07 May 2013, 09:35:55
Not as showy as Hasek's execution, but 13 regiments and a warship in one engagement isn't bad either.

The Dragon has no need for those show trials like the Capellans. If there's an enemy to the Dragon, he or she get's eradicated or the forces trying to do so fail in dishonor.

Public display of death is for honorable samurai and warriors who failed but gained or retained the right for seppuku. Caleb Davion or one of the Sandoval's really did not deserve this kind attention. If you have no other orders, just eliminate them and advance your troops.  8)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 07 May 2013, 09:56:07
And I hate to bring up FM:U but after that, the DCMS was mauled. The FedSuns... not so much. The Lyrans were smacked around as well.

Incorrect.

If you look at the forces at the closest measurable point (FM:DCMS for DCMS and Shattered Sphere for LCAF/AFFC), the AFFS and LAAF both suffered almost twice as many casualties from 3060 to 3067 than the DCMS.

Battlemech Strengths (regiments)
30603067losses
AFFS864343
LCAF773542
DCMS735023

(3060 strengths are assuming all are more or less full strength, since strength %s aren't listed)
(3067 strengths are done by summing all the strength % from FM:U)

With regards,
Øystein
Strategic Assistant
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: MarauderD on 07 May 2013, 10:26:25
In the 'living history' era since 3025, we've seen only two kinds of storylines for Kurita military fortunes: Stunning Losses and Narrow Draws. 

You know, even as a Davion fan I agree here to an extent. Two things stick out for me.

1. Big picture, the Federated Suns border with the DC has slowly but steadily eroded since 3025, which was the high water mark since before the 1st Succession War. In the original House Davion Sourcebook (my first BT product back when I was 12), it says that Hanse Davion made it known that he intends to win back the remaining FedSuns worlds taken by the DC during the 1SW. Later in the sourcebook, this number reads as about 20 systems.

So, even though when you look at DC vs. FS encounters from 3025 to 3145, and you see a series of narrow draws, I still see territory being lost by the FedSuns to Combine forces. Especially when you consider what a schalacking the war of 3039 could have been, but wasn't. (More on this below)

2. Small picture, On that whole border between the FS and the DC, only two worlds have significant strategic importance: Quentin and Marduk. Why, might you ask? Both worlds had fully functional mech production facilities.

Note that Marduk fell during the 4SW. Norse Mechworks was a nearly self reliant mech facility that made Griffins and Wolverines. Captured intact by the DC.

Note that Quentin fell during the War of '39. Independence Weaponry was "the core of the Davion military's heavy 'Mech production." JagerMechs, Marauders, Victors, and Atlases were made here. Without this plant, the heaviest mechs in production in the FS are the JagerMech and Rifleman. Big, Big ouch.

A set of narrow draws that garners you two mech production planets, and costs you very little. Not too shabby IMO.

Lastly, I wonder if people are really considering the FedCom instead of just the Federated Suns. Even as the "white hats" of the universe, the FedSuns has been playing catch up with the Combine ever since the 1SW. I'm pretty sure we're never going to catch them, either. Pretty funny how fans of both factions can feel like they are "losing" to each other in the metagame? I'm sure that this is exactly the feel the developers are shooting for.

Cheers!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 07 May 2013, 11:02:35
The Dragon has no need for those show trials like the Capellans. If there's an enemy to the Dragon, he or she get's eradicated or the forces trying to do so fail in dishonor.

Public display of death is for honorable samurai and warriors who failed but gained or retained the right for seppuku. Caleb Davion or one of the Sandoval's really did not deserve this kind attention. If you have no other orders, just eliminate them and advance your troops.  8)

Remember, though, that orders on Palmyra were to take Caleb alive. So obviously they had something planned for him.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 07 May 2013, 11:04:10
Incorrect.

If you look at the forces at the closest measurable point (FM:DCMS for DCMS and Shattered Sphere for LCAF/AFFC), the AFFS and LAAF both suffered almost twice as many casualties from 3060 to 3067 than the DCMS.

Battlemech Strengths (regiments)
30603067losses
AFFS864343
LCAF773542
DCMS735023

(3060 strengths are assuming all are more or less full strength, since strength %s aren't listed)
(3067 strengths are done by summing all the strength % from FM:U)

With regards,
Øystein
Strategic Assistant

The DCMS suffered half the casualties of the AFFS/LAAF who were both engaged in a war to beat each other silly.

It was not expressed well, my bad. But my point is the Combine still suffered that much from an invasion of a single March and those rampaging bears.

23 regiments lost to a bit of pique from their neighbours, wow I knew there were a lot of 'Mechs lost. I (just personally) consider that a mauling since the Combine didn't really have a stake in the Civil War. But then, there are the Ghost Bears and that was instigated by the Alshain Avengers.

Thanks for the data, Øystein.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 07 May 2013, 11:39:35
Remember, though, that orders on Palmyra were to take Caleb alive. So obviously they had something planned for him.

Yes, I haven't forgot this. And I have to say, that I'm really curious about this order. I guess, that Toranaga wanted the First Prince alive to have some additional bargain chip against Erik Sandoval-Groell or possibly even Julian.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 07 May 2013, 11:47:43
Makes sense. Hold the Prince hostage, with no direct heirs to boot, and you'll either piss off the Suns or make them do as you will.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 07 May 2013, 11:55:55
If Caleb would have been alive and deep down in Luthien's dungeon, Erik may would have stayed Regent. But imagine his troubles: If he looses the war, he's incompetent. If he wins the war, his success may threaten Caleb's life and he'd may be painted as a roughless careerist, trying to supplant Caleb on the throne before Julian could do so. Loose-loose for Erik as current leader of the Suns. (Yes, I know that no one who served as Regent on New Avalon is legally allowed to become First Prince. But he may have tried despite this. Additionally, was he already Regent? Or did he name himself Regent, when Caleb died. He was only Prince's Champion, wasn't he? Oh may, even more trouble for him, if Caleb would have been caught alive!)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 07 May 2013, 11:59:13
I think Erik was named regent after they decided on Julian becoming the next Prince. Might have to re-read that myself later.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 07 May 2013, 12:25:03
If Caleb would have been alive and deep down in Luthien's dungeon, Erik may would have stayed Regent. But imagine his troubles: If he looses the war, he's incompetent. If he wins the war, his success may threaten Caleb's life and he'd may be painted as a roughless careerist, trying to supplant Caleb on the throne before Julian could do so. Loose-loose for Erik as current leader of the Suns.

Actually, there would have been other possibilities open.

In history, there were some moments when the ruling monarch was taken prisoner by the enemy. And although it may seem surprising, his people effectively renounced him and then elected a new ruler (his relative by the way). The Dracs would have possibly executed Caleb as he would have been useless for them.
So if Erik got the right PR, he could have shown himself as The Liberator of the Federated Suns, leader of the national resistance, and not a careerist.

(Yes, I know that no one who served as Regent on New Avalon is legally allowed to become First Prince. But he may have tried despite this. Additionally, was he already Regent? Or did he name himself Regent, when Caleb died. He was only Prince's Champion, wasn't he? Oh may, even more trouble for him, if Caleb would have been caught alive!)

In the moment of the grave crisis, legal niceties are often disregarded. It wouldn'd have been easy for Julian to depose Erik, if the Erik could have present some undisputable war successes. (I mean against Kurita or Liao)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 07 May 2013, 15:19:45
I think Erik was named regent after they decided on Julian becoming the next Prince. Might have to re-read that myself later.

I've reread it. It's a bit tricky: After Caleb's death, Julian is elected First Prince by the Privy Council. And Erik - in his capacity as Prince's Champion - acted as Regent. So, there seems to be some leeway, wether Erik is later subjected to the legal clauses regulating a Regent's ability to succeed the First Prince. Always presuming the Capellans blast Julian out of their sky.


Actually, there would have been other possibilities open.

In history, there were some moments when the ruling monarch was taken prisoner by the enemy. And although it may seem surprising, his people effectively renounced him and then elected a new ruler (his relative by the way). The Dracs would have possibly executed Caleb as he would have been useless for them.
So if Erik got the right PR, he could have shown himself as The Liberator of the Federated Suns, leader of the national resistance, and not a careerist.

That all depends a lot on how Caleb was perceived by his own people. If they saw him as an incapable and volatile ruler, they might not mourn too long for him. But maybe the short time on the Suns throne was enough for him to decently endear the population.

In the moment of the grave crisis, legal niceties are often disregarded. It wouldn'd have been easy for Julian to depose Erik, if the Erik could have present some undisputable war successes. (I mean against Kurita or Liao)

I dunno. Many in the Suns may jerk a lot if this special rule wouldn't be observed.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 07 May 2013, 15:31:04
Isn't it possible Toranaga just wanted him as a prize?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 07 May 2013, 15:38:30
Of course, it is possible.

But it just strikes me, that the cold and calculating Kanrei had more planned for Caleb then just parade him through the streets of Imperial City. But yes, it is possible.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 07 May 2013, 15:49:17
You know, even as a Davion fan I agree here to an extent. Two things stick out for me.

1. Big picture, the Federated Suns border with the DC has slowly but steadily eroded since 3025, which was the high water mark since before the 1st Succession War. In the original House Davion Sourcebook (my first BT product back when I was 12), it says that Hanse Davion made it known that he intends to win back the remaining FedSuns worlds taken by the DC during the 1SW. Later in the sourcebook, this number reads as about 20 systems.

So, even though when you look at DC vs. FS encounters from 3025 to 3145, and you see a series of narrow draws, I still see territory being lost by the FedSuns to Combine forces. Especially when you consider what a schalacking the war of 3039 could have been, but wasn't. (More on this below

The Suns lost a handful of worlds to the Combine in exchange for pinning the DCMS in place due to Takashi's grudge against the Wolf Dragoons while the LCAF took nearly 60 worlds from them and the AFFS smashed the Capellan Confederation. This was all in accordance with Hanse's plan for prosecuting the War.

The Combine's performance in the 4th Succession War was atrocious.

Quote
2. Small picture, On that whole border between the FS and the DC, only two worlds have significant strategic importance: Quentin and Marduk. Why, might you ask? Both worlds had fully functional mech production facilities.

Note that Marduk fell during the 4SW. Norse Mechworks was a nearly self reliant mech facility that made Griffins and Wolverines. Captured intact by the DC.

Note that Quentin fell during the War of '39. Independence Weaponry was "the core of the Davion military's heavy 'Mech production." JagerMechs, Marauders, Victors, and Atlases were made here. Without this plant, the heaviest mechs in production in the FS are the JagerMech and Rifleman. Big, Big ouch.

The Suns was still building the Marauder at Kathil and has the Marauder II plant at New Valencia. Not only that, there's the facilities taken from the Capellans and the influx of heavy and assault 'Mechs from the Lyran half of the realm. This is before taking into account the amount of Heavy and Assault 'Mechs the Suns rushed into production during the Clan War, while also saving the Combine twice from the Clans and headlining the demise of the Smoke Jaguars.

At the end of the 4th Succession War, even with the loss of Marduk, the Suns still had better infrastructure than they did before the war. The Combine's was worse than when it began, and much worse than either of its neighbours.

At the end of the War of 3039, the Combine's infrastructure was still worse than prior to the 4th Succession War, and still much worse than the Suns or Lyrans.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 07 May 2013, 16:13:47
Isn't it possible Toranaga just wanted him as a prize?
Of course, it is possible.

But it just strikes me, that the cold and calculating Kanrei had more planned for Caleb then just parade him through the streets of Imperial City. But yes, it is possible.

Surely such success would have helped him to consolidate his position. General and the Minister of War able to bring defeated ruler and supreme commander of the hated Federated Suns as a prisoner of war wouldn't had to be afraid of dismissal by the Coordinatress.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 00:11:17
@ Re: What would we have done with Caleb had he been taken alive, since the Davions would have just chosen a new First Prince?

Just like in the feudal era, we could have gotten a literal King's Ransom for him.
Unlike the feudal era, the neo-feudal era has high tech stuff.  Like Access Codes to AFFS defense systems.  The ISF could have pried any number of priceless secrets from a House Lord's mind.  Even one like Caleb's.

Alas, it's all conjecture.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Alexander Knight on 08 May 2013, 00:39:52
The Suns lost a handful of worlds to the Combine in exchange for pinning the DCMS in place due to Takashi's grudge against the Wolf Dragoons while the LCAF took nearly 60 worlds from them and the AFFS smashed the Capellan Confederation. This was all in accordance with Hanse's plan for prosecuting the War.

Actually no, the DCMS was not "pinned in place" by the AFFS.  The 8th Sword of Light and three Galedon Regulars regiments were sidelined prior to the war by the Dragoons on Misery.  5th Galedon, 8th Galedon, 12 Galedon, 16th Galedon, 3rd Proserpina were all tasked to attack the Dragoons in the first half of the war.  In addition, they engaged the 10th Deneb.

As you can see, only one non-District regiment was assigned to anti-Dragoons operations.  The majority of DCMS non-District regiments were engaged on the Lyran front.


Quote
At the end of the War of 3039, the Combine's infrastructure was still worse than prior to the 4th Succession War, and still much worse than the Suns or Lyrans.

Arguably false.  The Combine lost a single production facility between 3028 and 3039, that being the one now belonging to the FRR, building the Archer, Phoenix Hawk, and Panther.

In return they captured both Marduk and Quentin.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 08 May 2013, 02:57:34
Quote
Actually no, the DCMS was not "pinned in place" by the AFFS.

Which is not what I said in the quote. During the Warrior trilogy, Hanse specifically notes that he is using the Wolf Dragoons to keep the DCMS forces on his border entirely occupied while routing forces to the Capellan front. He was willing to exchange a desperately small number of worlds on his border for several dozen Capellan worlds and assisting the Lyrans in conquering almost 60.

Quote
The majority of DCMS non-District regiments were engaged on the Lyran front.

With the Ryuken dissolved and the Ghosts yet to form, it's not like the Combine had many non-District forces to assign any way. The units that were dispatched either faced defeat from the LCAF or made what ground Hanse was willing to surrender against the DCMS. They were handily outmaneuvered by the Suns.

Quote
Arguably false.  The Combine lost a single production facility between 3028 and 3039, that being the one now belonging to the FRR, building the Archer, Phoenix Hawk, and Panther.

They actually lost at least three factories mentioned as conquered by the Wolves or Bears later on to the Free Rasalhague Republic.

Quote
In return they captured both Marduk and Quentin.

In return for Marduk, the Suns captured half of the CapCon and allowed the LCAF to have a field day with the DCMS.

In return for Quentin, the Suns had the Combine millimetres from outright destruction and won the War of 3039.

These are trades that favour the Combine?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 08 May 2013, 03:04:34
Just like in the feudal era, we could have gotten a literal King's Ransom for him.
Unlike the feudal era, the neo-feudal era has high tech stuff.  Like Access Codes to AFFS defense systems.  The ISF could have pried any number of priceless secrets from a House Lord's mind.  Even one like Caleb's.

Ah, that is something I haven't thought of before. Our new ISF director got a reputation of being very... effective.  ^-^

But wouldn't the Suns instantly change all the codes and plans as soon as the authorities got wind of Calebs capture? Except we would fake Caleb's death and keep him alive in secret. But I guess the Suns would change codes anyway. Just to play it safe.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 08 May 2013, 03:27:34
It's an open question as to how much Caleb would actually know anyway. People often imagine state rulers have some impressive cache of secrets, but the reality is that various branches of the apparatus they see keep secrets from them intentionally or simply don't know that much any way- Caleb might be able to give an interrogator the details of his planned assault (which had been foiled already) and pass codes for the Prince's palace (of debatable use given that they would be tagged to someone known to not be on planet)... and he was insane.

Capturing the head of MIIO or the like would be a coup for intelligence. First Prince, maybe, maybe not... Caleb Davion probably falls under the latter half of that, though.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 08 May 2013, 05:38:07
Even otherwise mundane facts about the ruling class of a Great House like personal relations, preferences or character are useful bits of information for a competent intelligence service. And the ISF surely is competent.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 08 May 2013, 05:54:57
The ISF's main task, so far as I can tell, has been rooting out and killing anyone loyal to the Combine or Coodinator instead of the Black Dragons ever since Theodore took the throne. They're pretty good at that, but I wouldn't be too sure about much else.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 May 2013, 06:18:48
Even otherwise mundane facts about the ruling class of a Great House like personal relations, preferences or character are useful bits of information for a competent intelligence service. And the ISF surely is competent.

Thinking about last century and half of Draconis Combine's history ... I have some doubts about it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 10:58:31
Ah, that is something I haven't thought of before. Our new ISF director got a reputation of being very... effective.  ^-^

But wouldn't the Suns instantly change all the codes and plans as soon as the authorities got wind of Calebs capture? Except we would fake Caleb's death and keep him alive in secret. But I guess the Suns would change codes anyway. Just to play it safe.

Given the non-instantaneous communications, 'changing codes' ahead of regular schedule is easier said than done.
But codes to various defense systems is only one thing of value someone in the First Prince's position would know.

Where are your secret bases
Where are your supply caches along the front
What are your various covert forces up to right now.. presumably something since you were just about to invade
What are the new weapons development programs
What sneaky secrets have you learned about US that we didn't realize you knew
What body part do you need the least.. I bet I can make you beg me to cut off your pinky...

Knowing that Caleb won't be further undermining the Suns is something of a win for the Davion fans. 

Thinking about last century and half of Draconis Combine's history ... I have some doubts about it.

The ISF isn't uneffective or disloyal... they're pretty consistently effective and loyal.. to the Combine and not necessarily House Kurita.  The ISF's history of undermining or outright removing 'unworthy' Kuritas goes way back.  That is one heck of a fertile field for the Kokoryu-kai to sow.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 May 2013, 12:27:53
The ISF isn't uneffective or disloyal... they're pretty consistently effective and loyal.. to the Combine and not necessarily House Kurita.  The ISF's history of undermining or outright removing 'unworthy' Kuritas goes way back.  That is one heck of a fertile field for the Kokoryu-kai to sow.

So let's just say that the ISF is "competent" to pursue interests of the Black Dragon Society? When four regiments of Alshain Avengers rebelled, shouldn't the ISF provide some warning? When the elite garrison regiment of the capital city attacked the seat of government, where was the ISF? And wasn't the ISF supposed to vet crews of the Draconis Combine Navy and officers of the DCMS? I ask because the work of the ISF was less than perfect ...

Oh, I forgot, the head of the ISF was in the Black Dragon Society.

And the DEST is so loyal that it's probably greater danger for its own Coordinator than for the enemy.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jayof9s on 08 May 2013, 12:37:42
They're competent, not omniscient.

But what it really comes down to - good or bad, at least they aren't SAFE!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 12:38:14
What I was getting at is that while the ISF is especially vulnerable to subversion by the Black Dragons, it doesn't mean they're also ineffective in areas beyond resisting Black Dragon influence.

That the (back)history of the Combine is rife with the assassinations of Coordinators is one of the reasons the Combine has TWO intelligence agencies.  Not to nitpick, but the O5P is actually in charge of vetting military officers.  That the ISF/Black Dragons actually pulled off the Alshain debacle was more of an example of the ISF's prowess.. they managed to sneak their plot past the O5P.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 08 May 2013, 12:44:58
Speaking of the O5P, we haven't heard anything in the current era, have we? Do we at least know, who leads them?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 12:50:15
It seems mighty murky.  The only thing I remember reading about the O5P in ER3145 was how cozy they were with the Nova Cats prior to the falcon punch :}
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 08 May 2013, 13:14:51
They actually lost at least three factories mentioned as conquered by the Wolves or Bears later on to the Free Rasalhague Republic.

I see New Oslo as the only BattleMech producer in FRR in 3040.
New Spittal producing tanks.
Anything else that the Wolves or Bears captured was new to FRR or New Oslo trying to move their production ahead of the Clans?

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 May 2013, 13:26:49
Not to nitpick, but the O5P is actually in charge of vetting military officers.  That the ISF/Black Dragons actually pulled off the Alshain debacle was more of an example of the ISF's prowess.. they managed to sneak their plot past the O5P.

The Field Manual: Draconis Combine says that the ISF has its informants in military schools who search for persons attempting to infiltrate the DCMS.
Candidates approved by the ISF are invited to study on military academies.
It's the ISF who assigns loyalty rating for each regiment.
It's the ISF who watches political views of officers.

For a long time it has been a standard procedure to have the ISF informants in all 'Mech units.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 08 May 2013, 13:37:17
It seems mighty murky.  The only thing I remember reading about the O5P in ER3145 was how cozy they were with the Nova Cats prior to the falcon punch :}

Ouch...

The Field Manual: Draconis Combine says that the ISF has its informants in military schools who search for persons attempting to infiltrate the DCMS.
Candidates approved by the ISF are invited to study on military academies.
It's the ISF who assigns loyalty rating for each regiment.
It's the ISF who watches political views of officers.

For a long time it has been a standard procedure to have the ISF informants in all 'Mech units.

Indeed, you're right. I remember this ISF officer assigned to the 1st Genyosha in the Warrior Trilogy.

Wasn't the O5P some kind of civil counterpart to the ISF?

Guys, we really need this Handbook!  :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Alexander Knight on 08 May 2013, 14:02:35
Which is not what I said in the quote. During the Warrior trilogy, Hanse specifically notes that he is using the Wolf Dragoons to keep the DCMS forces on his border entirely occupied while routing forces to the Capellan front.

That was his plan, yes.  But the Dragoons weren't on Northwind, or Breed, or Klathandu or several other worlds.

Quote
With the Ryuken dissolved and the Ghosts yet to form, it's not like the Combine had many non-District forces to assign any way. The units that were dispatched either faced defeat from the LCAF or made what ground Hanse was willing to surrender against the DCMS. They were handily outmaneuvered by the Suns.

Yes, the Federated Suns handily outmaneuvered forces that DIDN'T EXIST!  You want to know why the LCAF and AFFS were able to pull what they did?  The FWLM sat on its collective posterior during the 4th SW.  Not any brilliant strategy from the AFFS, not any incompetence from the DCMS.

Quote
They actually lost at least three factories mentioned as conquered by the Wolves or Bears later on to the Free Rasalhague Republic.

you are wrong.

Quote
In return for Marduk, the Suns captured half of the CapCon and allowed the LCAF to have a field day with the DCMS.

In return for Quentin, the Suns had the Combine millimetres from outright destruction and won the War of 3039.

These are trades that favour the Combine?

First off, how exactly did the Federated Suns capturing half the CapCon hurt House Kurita?  Did it make the FS stronger?  Yes.  Does that hurt Kurita?  No.  Unless you're claiming that the Capellan Confederation is nothing more than a thinly disguised District of the Combine.

As for 3039...."almost only counts in nukes and hand grenades".  The Federated Suns didn't destroy the Combine, did it?  They pulled back behind the border and abandoned an important factory to the Combine, didn't they?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 08 May 2013, 14:07:43
Ouch...

Indeed, you're right. I remember this ISF officer assigned to the 1st Genyosha in the Warrior Trilogy.

Wasn't the O5P some kind of civil counterpart to the ISF?

Guys, we really need this Handbook!  :D

I, perhaps too simply, view the O5P as the FBI and the ISF as the CIA.

They'll have overlapping areas of responsibilities, but the O5P and ISF are also checks on each other.

For example, in the fluff for the Sabre aerospace fighter, it turns out that the ISF used that to cultivate sources and infiltrate numerous other things throughout the years. But I'd imagine trade of that magnitude (building a Combine fighter in other parts of the Sphere) should've involved the O5P. It may have been the fact that it was military equipment that made the operation an ISF one.

The O5P control the Combine's ivory trade... which seems lucrative. But it also means they're very connected to the rest of the merchants in the Combine and also outside.

I wouldn't mind reading a bit more about them though. Alas, HB:HK...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 May 2013, 14:40:38
Wasn't the O5P some kind of civil counterpart to the ISF?

The ISF is something as the KGB used to be in the old times. The all-encompassing secret police present in all military units as well as in all layers of society. Some of its members are uniformed, some people are "obvious" members and some agents are hidden.
It watches political views, but of course it steals enemy secrets as well. It has DEST as its dedicated special forces, while the KGB had its OSNAZ.

The O5P is different. If I can stay within Soviet borders, the O5P is something as the Department of Administrative Affairs of the Secretariat of the Poliburo of the Central Committee of the CPSU. You know, obscure organisation with unclear competences and so secretive that many common people didn't know it existed. Perhaps we could say that the O5P is such Department combined with the Sicherheitdienst. Naturally, this is only a crude analogy.

The O5P is interested in the political dissent and ideology, but its interest goes deeper and its narrower than in the ISF. The whole point of its existence depends on its independence on the ISF and its ability to provide the Coordinator with unbiased political, ideological and intelligence reports.

Although the O5P is smaller than the huge ISF colossus, it has House Kurita protection and what's important as well - it has independent funding and its own transport assets.

The day when the O5P is subverted by the ISF will be the beginning of grave crisis of the Combine because the Coordinator will know only what the Director of the ISF lets him know. So that's something sane Coordinator can't never allow. Do you know how ended Yezhov when he managed to control both the NKVD and the GRU at one time?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 14:57:59
The Field Manual: Draconis Combine says that the ISF has its informants in military schools who search for persons attempting to infiltrate the DCMS.
Candidates approved by the ISF are invited to study on military academies.
It's the ISF who assigns loyalty rating for each regiment.
It's the ISF who watches political views of officers.

For a long time it has been a standard procedure to have the ISF informants in all 'Mech units.

Right, the ISF has vetting power over who joins the military and naturally spies on it.  But the original House Kurita atlas says how officers must receive their martial arts instruction from the O5P, which in turn gives the order vetting power over whos careers are cut short and whos are allowed to progress.  This is a deliberate check against the ISF being the sole line of defense against treason in the ranks.

Granted, it hasn't been reinforced in real-world decades of new Kurita sourcebooks, but then again not much at all has been published about the Order.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 08 May 2013, 15:08:35
Do you know how ended Yezhov when he managed to control both the NKVD and the GRU at one time?

No, unfortunately not. Please, elaborate. :)

Did I already say, that we really need this Handbook?  :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 May 2013, 15:11:52
Right, the ISF has vetting power over who joins the military and naturally spies on it.  But the original House Kurita atlas says how officers must receive their martial arts instruction from the O5P, which in turn gives the order vetting power over whos careers are cut short and whos are allowed to progress.  This is a deliberate check against the ISF being the sole line of defense against treason in the ranks.

Granted, it hasn't been reinforced in real-world decades of new Kurita sourcebooks, but then again not much at all has been published about the Order.

Perhaps you may re-read the first sentence of the paragraph: "During the time of Siriwan McAllister, ..." The whole paragraph uses the past tense. Siriwan McAllister-Kurita lived in the 26th Century, so let's say the book describes the situation as it was around 2550.

Now we are in the 32nd Century, in 3145.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 15:30:06
Perhaps you may re-read the first sentence of the paragraph: "During the time of Siriwan McAllister, ..." The whole paragraph uses the past tense. Siriwan McAllister-Kurita lived in the 26th Century, so let's say the book describes the situation as it was around 2550.

Neither does it say that situation as described in 2550 ever came to an end.  Semantically, sure they didn't use the words 'Beginning with the time of Siriwan McAllister", but it DOES go on to say what a failure the ISF had in trying to kick the O5P out of the business of training the officer corps.    Whether or not the O5P is still the SOLE provider of martial arts training is arguable, but the argument isn't winnable (barring something coming out in HB:HK addressing this).  So let's just agree to disagree.

Quote
Now we are in the 32nd Century, in 3145.

So what exactly is your point? 

Are you saying that ISF is not more loyal to the Combine than it is to the Coordinator?

Are you saying that the O5P does not spy on the military?

Are you saying that the O5P does not spy on the ISF either?

Are you saying that the ISF is of dubious effectiveness simply because they keep getting infiltrated by the Black Dragons? 

Heck, I'd counter with the possibility that the Black Dragons have WON and those who oppose them are the traitors to the throne/realm now.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 08 May 2013, 15:33:27
By the way, do we have any news on the missing gems of the kokuryu-kai? Long time ago (nearly one year) I opened this thread about it: Black Dragon Society: council of gems (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=21820.0)

For the sake of discussion, I repost my table here. (Please note, that the abbess of O5P was a member of the kokuryu-kai!)

CODE NAME     TRUE IDENTITY                    SOURCE
DiamondQan Hagatomi
Sipher Communications
JS:BD, p. 43
EmeraldTai-sa Li Sak To
CO 2nd Sword of Light
JS:BD, p. 43
Jade[Name missing]
Son of Duke Hassid Ricol (Ruby)
JHS:3072, p. 53
Jasperunknown
possible O5P mole / double agent
JHS:3072, p.53 / JS:BD, p.43
ObsidianErik Nekatagu
Mangon Aeronautical Shipping
JS:BD, p. 43
OnyxTai-sho Paul Omishita
head of DEST
JS:BD, p. 43
OpalHoek Botterfield
CEO Luthien Armor Works
JS:BD, p. 43
PearlRegis Ferward
Minister of Communications
JS:BD, p. 43
RubyDuke Hassid RicolJS:BD, p. 43
Sapphireunknown
Tiger's EyeTomade Yamiro
Abbess of O5P
JS:BD, p. 43
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 08 May 2013, 15:34:40
Heck, I'd counter with the possibility that the Black Dragons have WON and those who oppose them are the traitors to the throne/realm now.

Haven´t they won?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 08 May 2013, 15:44:48
That was his plan, yes.  But the Dragoons weren't on Northwind, or Breed, or Klathandu or several other worlds.

Hanse's plan for Northwind also worked perfectly.

The Combine made extremely limited gains against the Suns, while suffering massive losses to the Lyrans, because Hanse knew Takashi was myopically focused on the Wolf Dragoons and so he was able to reassign units from the Draconis March to the Capellan offensive. In Chess terms, Hanse sacrificed some pawns to put his opponent into check.

Quote
Yes, the Federated Suns handily outmaneuvered forces that DIDN'T EXIST!  You want to know why the LCAF and AFFS were able to pull what they did?  The FWLM sat on its collective posterior during the 4th SW.  Not any brilliant strategy from the AFFS, not any incompetence from the DCMS.

You were arguing that the Combine's "independant" commands were all active against the Lyrans instead of the Suns; I pointed out that at the time the Combine had extremely few "independant" units to be assigning any way, and that the overwhelming majority of the DCMS was composed of District Regular forces. As to why the League sat out the Fourth Succession War? As Historical: Brush Wars points out, Hanse was formenting a rebellion over there, and that took all of Janos' energy and ability to deal with.

In sum, the 4th Succession War's plot line was "everything works for the Federated Commonwealth, nothing works for anyone else."

Quote
you are wrong.

The WCSB, Invading Clans, Objective Raids (corroborated by prior and later sources), Masters and Minions and others all indicate otherwise.

Quote
First off, how exactly did the Federated Suns capturing half the CapCon hurt House Kurita?  Did it make the FS stronger?  Yes.  Does that hurt Kurita?  No.  Unless you're claiming that the Capellan Confederation is nothing more than a thinly disguised District of the Combine.

Conversely, how did the loss of Marduk actually harm the Federated Suns? It was producing both the designs offered by Victory/Norse at other facilities it already had prior to the 4th Succession War, or gained enough via the conquest of the Confederation and access to Lyran factories to more than offset the loss of those two lines- and, later, Quentin as well.

As for how it hurt the Combine? Again, Hanse's ploy allowed the Lyrans to ride roughshod over the Combine, taking a number of worlds similar to that which the Capellans lost.

Quote
As for 3039...."almost only counts in nukes and hand grenades".  The Federated Suns didn't destroy the Combine, did it?  They pulled back behind the border and abandoned an important factory to the Combine, didn't they?

The Suns had it in its power to destroy the Combine three times- The War of 3039, Teniente, and Luthien. The Combine exists solely because of the good-will of the Federated Suns; as a Combine fan, that rankles more than a little.

Quote
Haven´t they won?

Looks that way, and since the Black Dragons strenously oppose everything that kept the Combine together through the Clan Invasion and Jihad, well...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 May 2013, 15:45:56
No, unfortunately not. Please, elaborate. :)

Well, he was the head of the NKVD (formerly known as the OGPU, and the KGB after that). His duties were identical to what the ISF does - catching defectors, searching for political dissidents, fighting saboteurs, stealing enemy secrets, sowing disinformations, doing covert operations, purging military units from unloyal soldiers. You know, just common things ...

But in 1938 Yezhov went too far. In his effort to purge disloyal elements from the Red Army and to extend his power base (in secret services) he had executed the chief of the GRU Jan Berzin - the chief of the main directorate of the military intelligence of the General Staff. And then Yezhov made his fatal mistake: He took Berzin's competences and added them to its own he had as the head of the civilian secret police.
At this moment Stalin realized where he made the mistake. Until then both intelligence services - the NKVD and the GRU - had checked each other when it came to power and influence. Both reported to Stalin through independent channels which meant that he always could check reports from one agency against reports from the other service. But with both organisations under one chief, Stalin was in danger of being misinformed about his internal and external enemies by Yezhov.

The solution was a bit unpleasant (for Yezhov). Yezhov was arrested under false pretense and then executed. Some say that he was shot with one bullet from the chekist Nagant, but one source mentions that they buried Yezhov alive.

The state simply needed two independent intelligence services to counterbalance each other.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 08 May 2013, 15:50:29
@Martian:

I see. I didn't know of this before. Thank you very much for this explanation! Seems, we need the O5P more then ever...


@All:

I repeat my question: Do we already know who Sapphire, Jade and Jasper are? Or will we at least get infos on them in one of the announced future products?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 15:55:20
Seems, we need the O5P more then ever...

I always pictured the rival agencies as:

ISF: More loyal to the state than to the Coordinator.

O5P:  More loyal to House Kurita than to the Coordinator.

Not putting the Coordinator in a happy place, but as Martian gave a good example, you need both.  The ancient Kurita tradition of ascending to the throne through assassination has probably been fed by periods of imbalance of power between ISF and O5P.

I repeat my question: Do we already know who Sapphire, Jade and Jasper are? Or will we at least get infos on them in one of the announced future products?

The answer would likely have to come from scratch, as the 3145 era is a big chronological jump from the last known identities.  Though we certainly have at least one likely candidate in Toranaga.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 08 May 2013, 16:00:27
Toranaga? Really? Was he already old enough to be a member of the council of gems?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 16:01:51
Toranaga? Really? Was he already old enough to be a member of the council of gems?

I meant to say that in 3145 we'd probably have an all new council, where we don't know any members yet.  Except possibly Toranaga.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 08 May 2013, 16:02:27
By the way, do we have any news on the missing gems of the kokuryu-kai? Long time ago (nearly one year) I opened this thread about it: Black Dragon Society: council of gems (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php?topic=21820.0)

For the sake of discussion, I repost my table here. (Please note, that the abbess of O5P was a member of the kokuryu-kai!)


There's a theory around here that she was actually loyal to the Kuritas and was merely framed. It spared one of the Council and it removed a supporter in the process.

I don't believe the other identities have been revealed yet.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 08 May 2013, 16:03:23
Though we certainly have at least one likely candidate in Toranaga.

Why? What has Toranaga done to suggest he's anything more than exactly what he appears to be: a very ambitious, very ruthless man. Specifically, what evidence–or even hints–is there for him being a Black Dragon?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 08 May 2013, 16:06:28
Bumping off the legitimate Coordinator so he could install a puppet in their place and run the Combine the way it should be run?

Being extremely cozy with the head of the ISF who looks like your prototypical Black Dragon, the same way the last Black Dragon Gunji-no-Kanrei with an ineffective Coordinator was?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 08 May 2013, 16:08:33
Why? What has Toranaga done to suggest he's anything more than exactly what he appears to be: a very ambitious, very ruthless man. Specifically, what evidence–or even hints–is there for him being a Black Dragon?

+1

I'd rather suspect Ramadeep Bathia. In the novels, there was something I can't recall exactly. Something about a group called "loyal sons of the dragon" or similar. IIRC, this group was somehow in league with the kokuryu-kai decades ago.

Being extremely cozy with the head of the ISF who looks like your prototypical Black Dragon, the same way the last Black Dragon Gunji-no-Kanrei with an ineffective Coordinator was?

Oh, there's one thing I recall lively. Toranaga and Bathia are definitely not members in the same organization, if they're at all members in any organization. They just colaborated to get rid of "that peacock", but were extremly distrustful of each other. IIRC, the bomb which killed Vincent Kurita was planted by Toranaga and was meant to kill Bathia as well. No, they're definitely not Black Dragons. maybe one of them. But not both.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 16:15:58
Why? What has Toranaga done to suggest he's anything more than exactly what he appears to be: a very ambitious, very ruthless man. Specifically, what evidence–or even hints–is there for him being a Black Dragon?

Well, we have 5 Draconis Combine characters in the 3145 era.

One is a dead Nova Cat.
Another is a dead scion of a rival bloodline.

If anyone even IS a Black dragon, 1 in 3 odds isn't that long a stretch.  Even before taking into account he helped engineer the end of Theodore's (First of his Name) line.

And hey, not that even being a Black Dragon is a bad thing. (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,26295.0.html)  Was just saying if we're gonna speculate, he's a likely candidate.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 08 May 2013, 16:17:38
Oh, there's one thing I recall lively. Toranaga and Bathia are definitely not members in the same organization, if they're at all members in any organization. They just colaborated to get rid of "that peacock", but were extremly distrustful of each other. IIRC, the bomb which killed Vincent Kurita was planted by Toranaga and was meant to kill Bathia as well. No, they're definitely not Black Dragons. maybe one of them. But not both.

Minamoto and Jerrar talked a big game about opposing the Black Dragons. What they were actually doing was wiping out the Sons of the Dragon and anyone loyal to the Combine or Coordinator over the Black Dragons and/or their ideologies.

If Bhatia and Toranaga aren't both Black Dragons, they're doing extremely convincing impersonations.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 May 2013, 16:18:07
Neither does it say that situation as described in 2550 ever came to an end.  Semantically, sure they didn't use the words 'Beginning with the time of Siriwan McAllister", but it DOES go on to say what a failure the ISF had in trying to kick the O5P out of the business of training the officer corps.    Whether or not the O5P is still the SOLE provider of martial arts training is arguable, but the argument isn't winnable (barring something coming out in HB:HK addressing this).  So let's just agree to disagree.

Even the book says on the same page that the ISF set up their own dojos training DCMS officers in martial arts. So as I understand it, the O5P monopoly on martial arts training obviously didn't hold for long. My personal estimate is that the O5P's monopoly was lost after Siriwan's death. Because with the monopoly still in place, the ISF martial arts dojos would have been hardly allowed to exist.


So what exactly is your point? 

Are you saying that ISF is not more loyal to the Combine than it is to the Coordinator?

Are you saying that the O5P does not spy on the military?

Are you saying that the O5P does not spy on the ISF either?

Are you saying that the ISF is of dubious effectiveness simply because they keep getting infiltrated by the Black Dragons? 

Heck, I'd counter with the possibility that the Black Dragons have WON and those who oppose them are the traitors to the throne/realm now.

As I said above, my point is that the ISF is either incompetent because it hasn't been able to root out the Black Dragons,
or it was able to root them out, but decided not to do so - in which case the ISF is not loyal to the state and the Coordinator (although it may be loyal to the Black Dragons).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 08 May 2013, 16:20:36
As I said above, my point is that the ISF is either incompetent because it hasn't been able to root out the Black Dragons,
or it was able to root them out, but decided not to do so - in which case the ISF is not loyal to the state and the Coordinator (although it may be loyal to the Black Dragons).

One could always postulate that the coordinator betrayed the dragon and the ISF stayed true.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Alexander Knight on 08 May 2013, 16:27:54
The Combine made extremely limited gains against the Suns, while suffering massive losses to the Lyrans, because Hanse knew Takashi was myopically focused on the Wolf Dragoons and so he was able to reassign units from the Draconis March to the Capellan offensive. In Chess terms, Hanse sacrificed some pawns to put his opponent into check.

Incorrect.  Hanse pulled troops from the Draconis border because he knew the LYRAN ARMY was pouring over the border.  He knew House Kurita could not afford a major invasion because most of their troops were occupied.  Only the Galedon and Pesht Districts were not involved in fighting the LCAF, and Pesht did send some District Regular troops to aid Galedon, which was suffering from a change of command after Takashi ordered Samsonov executed.

Quote
In sum, the 4th Succession War's plot line was "everything works for the Federated Commonwealth, nothing works for anyone else."

And nothing has worked for the Fed-Com since.

Quote
The WCSB, Invading Clans, Objective Raids (corroborated by prior and later sources), Masters and Minions and others all indicate otherwise.

I am slightly incorrect.  Spittal produced the Scorpion and Vedette tanks as well as APCs.  New Oslo built the Archer,Phoenix Hawk, and Panther with a satellite line on Satalice for the Archer.

Marduk netted them the Wolverine and Griffin, while Quentin netted them the Atlas, Victor, Marauder, JagerMech....

Quote
Conversely, how did the loss of Marduk actually harm the Federated Suns?

Irrelevant.  As much as it might shock you, not EVERY gain the Combine makes requires a loss on behalf of the Federated Suns.  Specifically, Marduk's capture increased the Combine's access to the Griffin and Wolverine.  The Federated Suns took Nanking, preserving access.  Thus the Capellan Confederation suffered.

Quote
As for how it hurt the Combine? Again, Hanse's ploy allowed the Lyrans to ride roughshod over the Combine, taking a number of worlds similar to that which the Capellans lost.

Hanse's ploy only "allowed" the Lyrans to go nuts because the FWL sat on its hind end.  You want to complain, complain about Janos Marik deciding your precious treaty was worth bupkiss.

Quote
The Suns had it in its power to destroy the Combine three times- The War of 3039, Teniente, and Luthien. The Combine exists solely because of the good-will of the Federated Suns; as a Combine fan, that rankles more than a little.

And I'm sure the Fedrat fans are all exceedingly happy that their nation helped someone who turned around and shoved the border closer to New Avalon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 08 May 2013, 16:30:57
Bumping off the legitimate Coordinator so he could install a puppet in their place and run the Combine the way it should be run?

One hardly needs to be a Black Dragon for that. So that's not evidence or a hint of anything more than that Toranaga didn't like Vincent and had his own agenda. In fact, his actions since becoming Kanrei would appear to contradict typical BD behavior: rehiring Wolf's Dragoons and giving them a prominent place in his plans; allying or at least working with a neighboring Clan, to the point of just giving them a few worlds; apparently being willing to tolerate the Nova Cats until they went rogue; etc.

You're looking at one action (killing off Vincent and his line) and attributing motives that are not evident in the actual sources because it fits your notions of the kind of person who would do that. While at the same time ignoring a simpler explanation.

Quote
Being extremely cozy with the head of the ISF who looks like your prototypical Black Dragon, the same way the last Black Dragon Gunji-no-Kanrei with an ineffective Coordinator was?

Same question. You can state that Bhatia appears to be a typical BD but what evidence or hints in the actual published sources support your personal belief?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 16:34:11
Even the book says on the same page that the ISF set up their own dojos training DCMS officers in martial arts. So as I understand it, the O5P monopoly on martial arts training obviously didn't hold for long. My personal estimate is that the O5P's monopoly was lost after Siriwan's death. Because with the monopoly still in place, the ISF martial arts dojos would have been hardly allowed to exist.

Right, what I was saying neither of us can prove the other wrong in which is true:
ISF got the O5P to stop training the officer corps, and the Siriwan McAllister era didn't last.
O5P successfully got the ISF to stop training the officer corps after the ISF initially tried to steal that show.

In the 3025 and on era do they both instruct the officer corps in martial arts?  They might, but since that's kind of a big obvious institutional waste in duplication of effort I prefer to believe that they eventually came to a compromise where they acknowledge they can't get rid of each other and allow each other their own bailiwick.  Yes it's an opinion, but seems informed and reasonable enough.  Just as informed and reasonable as the opinion that the ISF and O5P both continue instruct the officer corps as a way to keep tabs and vet careers.

As a peace offering I'll amend my previous statement.

Quote from: Tai Dai Cultist
That the (back)history of the Combine is rife with the assassinations of Coordinators is one of the reasons the Combine has TWO intelligence agencies.  And they both spy on the military.  That the ISF/Black Dragons actually pulled off the Alshain debacle was more of an example of the ISF's prowess.. they managed to sneak their plot past the O5P.




Quote
As I said above, my point is that the ISF is either incompetent because it hasn't been able to root out the Black Dragons,
or it was able to root them out, but decided not to do so - in which case the ISF is not loyal to the state and the Coordinator (although it may be loyal to the Black Dragons).

Loyal to the state is a matter of perspective.  If one believes that the Kuritas have strayed from leading the Combine to its rightful destiny of conquering all of humanity, replacing those Coordinators with a Kurita willing to kick ass and take names IS ultimately serving the Combine, if not those 'meek' Coordinators you replace.

That's what the Black Dragons believe, and with the ISF's track record of being willing to remove unfit Coordinators makes it (as I put it before) a fertile field for the Black Dragons to sow.
One could always postulate that the coordinator betrayed the dragon and the ISF stayed true.

Exactly.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 May 2013, 16:49:04
One could always postulate that the coordinator betrayed the dragon and the ISF stayed true.
Loyal to the state is a matter of perspective.  If one believes that the Kuritas have strayed from leading the Combine to its rightful destiny of conquering all of humanity, replacing those Coordinators with a Kurita willing to kick ass and take names IS ultimately serving the Combine, if not those 'meek' Coordinators you replace.

That's what the Black Dragons believe, and with the ISF's track record of being willing to remove unfit Coordinators makes it (as I put it before) a fertile field for the Black Dragons to sow.


If this is the case, then the Draconis Combine doesn't need the Coordinator at all. The Black Dragon Society in cooperation with the ISF can handle both foreign and internal politics.  ;)

Let's take the rebellion of Alshain Avengers.

If the ISF didn't know that four regiments with numerous important assets such as DropShips, JumpShips and one Warship are are ready to rebel (or already did so), then at least for me it's clear case of incompetence.

And if the ISF knew that and did nothing - well, it means that the ISF surely betrayed the Coordinator.
And did that rebellion help the Combine? Considering that it resulted in the start of war with the Ghost Bear Dominion, which at that time the Combine could hardly afford and only with luck the disaster was averted because the Ghost Bears agreed on honorable combat on Courchevel instead of crushing the Combine - I don't think that it helped the state. Because the state just lost a half dozen regiments and planets for nothing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 08 May 2013, 16:56:46

If this is the case, then the Draconis Combine doesn't need the Coordinator at all. The Black Dragon Society in cooperation with the ISF can handle both foreign and internal politics.  ;)

Let's take the rebellion of Alshain Avengers.

If the ISF didn't know that four regiments with numerous important assets such as DropShips, JumpShips and one Warship are are ready to rebel (or already did so), then at least for me it's clear case of incompetence.

And if the ISF knew that and did nothing - well, it means that the ISF surely betrayed the Coordinator.
And did that rebellion help the Combine? Considering that it resulted in the start of war with the Ghost Bear Dominion, which at that time the Combine could hardly afford and only with luck the disaster was averted because the Ghost Bears agreed on honorable combat on Courchevel instead of crushing the Combine - I don't think that it helped the state. Because the state just lost a half dozen regiments and planets for nothing.

Who and what is the coordinator?

Considering that the combine is a very complex culture, one that escapes western understanding, it should be clear that the whole is worth more than the individual parts.
having that in mind, have the reforms really been worth it, from a neutral view? Couldn´t the "victories" gaines by the reforms have been reached by traditional means, too?

That, for me, is the black dragon/ISF angle.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 May 2013, 17:04:47

If this is the case, then the Draconis Combine doesn't need the Coordinator at all. The Black Dragon Society in cooperation with the ISF can handle both foreign and internal politics.  ;)

Let's take the rebellion of Alshain Avengers.

If the ISF didn't know that four regiments with numerous important assets such as DropShips, JumpShips and one Warship are are ready to rebel (or already did so), then at least for me it's clear case of incompetence.

Probably less so much incompetence in failing to detect it as effectiveness in helping hiding the attack until it was a fait accompli.

Quote
And if the ISF knew that and did nothing - well, it means that the ISF surely betrayed the Coordinator.

Which they've done many times before.  Sure, it's always for the Greater Good, as they themselves define it.  Jinjiro was either put down by the ISF, or they simply allowed it to happen for the good of the realm.  Leonard Kurita also leaps immediately to mind.  ISF probably also had a hand in allowing Hohiro to be assassinated to usher in Takashi's rule, but I don't remember on that case off the top of my head.  Possibly also in allowing the DCMS to assassinate Zabu.

Quote
And did that rebellion help the Combine? Considering that it resulted in the start of war with the Ghost Bear Dominion, which at that time the Combine could hardly afford and only with luck the disaster was averted because the Ghost Bears agreed on honorable combat on Courchevel instead of crushing the Combine - I don't think that it helped the state. Because the state just lost a half dozen regiments and planets for nothing.

Well, the Black Dragons' (and any ISF helpers) goal wasn't to provoke and then LOSE the war, they assumed that they'd win after provoking the war.  In their minds, giving the Ghost Bears what the Smoke Jaguars got would have been good for the Combine.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 08 May 2013, 19:05:48
The ISF is quite competently defending the ISFs´ interests.

Coordinator, House Kurita, the state. All nice things. But surviving the next day and having enough power to survive the next year (and maybe get more power) are more important, aren´t they?

---------------

Black Dragons? I think in the current timeline this topic matters not. Not really. There might be some alliances of convenience within the DC power structure who might call themselves like that, but I do not really think this is still a question of ideology anymore.

It might have mattered during the WoB fun but now it might serve as a front, but little else.

It is simply power politics in the Combine, like it always was. Swimming in a shark tank. Anyone attaining real power in the combine is practically on someone other´s death list. So the players naturally have to stay flexible. Convictions are impratical.

Therefore I think the whole "have the Black Dragons won?" point is a bit moot.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 09 May 2013, 02:03:29
THE BLACK DRAGONS AND ISF PLAN:
Well, the Black Dragons' (and any ISF helpers) goal wasn't to provoke and then LOSE the war, they assumed that they'd win after provoking the war.  In their minds, giving the Ghost Bears what the Smoke Jaguars got would have been good for the Combine.

THE ACTUAL OUTCOME OF THE PLAN:
Following regiments were wiped out:
8th Alshain Avengers
11th Alshain Avengers
14th Alshain Avengers
15th Alshain Avengers
44th Dieron Regulars
17th Galedon Regulars
9th Pesht Regulars
3rd Ghost Regiment
+ numerous Dropships, JumpShips and one Warship -  DCS Dragon's Last Tear
+ many surviving regiments were severely weakened
+ and of course the Draconis Combine lost territory to the Clan Ghost Bear

And those are just units lost directly in the fight against the Clan Ghost Bear.

The Draconis Combine suffered numerous losses against forces of the Draconis March, and keep in mind that the incentive for the FedSuns attack was the fact that the Draconis Combine was engaged in the conflict with the Ghost Bears and seriously weakened. Otherwise, they would have thought twice before attacking the Combine.

So if the ISF have planned to betray its ruler (when the ISF decided not to inform him about the upcoming rebellion which will provoke the war with stronger enemy), but to achieve a decisive victory,
and the result is a serious defeat (both military losses and territory losses), then I'd call it "a serious incompetence" on the side of the ISF (because it's obvious that their plan led to the defeat), combined with disloyalty.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 09 May 2013, 02:04:05
The ISF is quite competently defending the ISFs´ interests.

 :))
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 09 May 2013, 03:38:16
Incorrect.  Hanse pulled troops from the Draconis border because he knew the LYRAN ARMY was pouring over the border.  He knew House Kurita could not afford a major invasion because most of their troops were occupied.  Only the Galedon and Pesht Districts were not involved in fighting the LCAF, and Pesht did send some District Regular troops to aid Galedon, which was suffering from a change of command after Takashi ordered Samsonov executed.

P. 73 of HB: HD summarises what I've said; "... Prince Hanse let loose the Wolf Dragoons along the Draconis March. Having just escaped from the Combine's employ after the disastrous battle of Misery, the Dragoons were itching for revenge, while Coordinator Takashi Kurita bordered on the psychotic in his desire to destroy the Dragoons."

The net result of Hanse's destabilisation of the Free Worlds League, shifting units from the Draconis March the Capellan front, and setting the stage for the Lyran effort?

Draconis Combine +15 systems (Suns), +2 systems (Lyran), -53 systems (lost to Lyrans); total -36 systems. Factory worlds lost: 3 (New Oslo, Satalice, Rasalhague. Factory worlds gained: 1 (Marduk).
Lyran Commonwealth: -2 systems (Combine), +53 systems (Combine); total +51 systems. 3 factory worlds gained (New Oslo, Rasalhague, Satalice).
Federated Suns: -15 systems (Combine), +107 systems (Capellan); total +92. Factory worlds lost: 1 (Marduk). Factory worlds gained: (Nanking, Styk, St. Ives); total +2, with each having at least as many lines as Marduk.

Quote
And nothing has worked for the Fed-Com since.

War of 3039. Clan Invasion. Second Star League era. Suffered probably the least damage during the Jihad (arguably tied with the CapCon), while the Combine suffered the most only because the Free Worlds League ceased to exist. Came through SCOUR in good shape and was doing well at the start of the Dark Age. Julian is Hanse 3.0.

Even the FedCom Civil War hit the Suns less severely than the Lyrans; the AFFS bounced back numerically very well in the three months between the end of it and FM: U, despite having less infrastructure and suffering greater losses than the LAAF, and went on to stack its lowest-priority units with Project Phoenix upgrades, never mind the gear being supplied to higher-priority commands.

Meanwhile, the Combine's current state is the best it's done for centuries, not decades. This is the first occasion on which the Combine has enjoyed any success on screen. And even there it's not because the Combine is displaying particular competance, but because the First Prince is a drooling moron.

As it stands, the plotlines all appear to be leading to "and then First Prince Julian lead a daring raid on Sian before turning the tide against the Draconis Combine, which spectacularly imploded due to infighting between the Coordinator and the Gunji-no-Kanrei while the Snow Ravens and Ghost Bears cut loose," rather than "and then the Draconis Combine consolidated the gains it had made over the last few years and enjoyed its successes."

Quote
Marduk netted them the Wolverine and Griffin, while Quentin netted them the Atlas, Victor, Marauder, JagerMech....

During which time the Combine lost production of the Archer, Panther (manufactured at two of the worlds taken), Phoenix Hawk, and Locust. The Suns, meanwhile, gained lines for the Wolverine, Victor (twice),  and Blackjack along with a massive influx of Lyran manufacturing output.

When you look at what the Combine gained, the Wolverine and Griffin were institutionally despised by the DCMS, while the Victor and JagerMech were rejected out of hand due to their strong Suns ties, winding up exported (sometimes back to the Suns any way). The Atlas (which becomes the horrific AS7-K) and Marauder lines were the only ones the Combine had any interest in or use for.

The stuff the Suns got? Existing favourites all round, plus Lyran gear to fill in any shortcomings they may have had otherwise.

Even looking just at production lines and output, the Combine doesn't break even with its 3028 losses until 3039, and the Suns is still ahead at that point any way.

Not only that, but the Combine also lost major shipyards to the Lyrans. The Suns also managed to capture some shipyards from the Capellans.

Quote
Irrelevant.  As much as it might shock you, not EVERY gain the Combine makes requires a loss on behalf of the Federated Suns.  Specifically, Marduk's capture increased the Combine's access to the Griffin and Wolverine.  The Federated Suns took Nanking, preserving access.  Thus the Capellan Confederation suffered.

You keep claiming that these are gains that somehow obviate other, major, losses the Combine suffered militarily or territorially whilst the Suns expanded. 3039 in particular is a case in point here, with the Suns capturing a lot more than the worlds they finally retained, defeating the Combine defenders and leaving the realm with no hope of reclaiming them only to give up and go home. The Suns could very easily have retained several additional worlds, including recapturing Quentin at will, but chose not to because they knew they had the Combine on its knees and would be able to finish the job later.

That the Suns had some losses against the Combine in the 3020s and 3030s is orthagonal to the point; the Suns enjoyed major success over that period against its bordering states, including having them both on the verge of outright destruction. The gains either neighboring state made since have been reclamation of ground lost in the interim.

Quote
Hanse's ploy only "allowed" the Lyrans to go nuts because the FWL sat on its hind end.  You want to complain, complain about Janos Marik deciding your precious treaty was worth bupkiss.

The FWLM was completely paralysed. It had no ability to respond to any potential weakness on the Lyran border because they could not afford to move troops that were required to quell the rebellions Hanse had started. The Concord of Kapteyn was no good because the Draconis Combine and Capellan Confederation were getting plastered by the FedCom and the League had its work cut out for it just staying together.

Quote
And I'm sure the Fedrat fans are all exceedingly happy that their nation helped someone who turned around and shoved the border closer to New Avalon.

And yet it put the Suns front and centre through the novel story arcs and paints an ongoing picture of the Combine as a nation that exists solely at the sufference of the Federated Suns.

Quote
You're looking at one action (killing off Vincent and his line) and attributing motives that are not evident in the actual sources because it fits your notions of the kind of person who would do that. While at the same time ignoring a simpler explanation.

Unless that was a precursor to making a move on the Coordinator. The Black Dragons spent a few years stacking the Otomo with adherents before making their first attempt on Theodore, and patiently infiltrated the ISF, DCMS regiments, and DCN crews. As already mentioned, the O5P has been more loyal to the Combine and Coordinator than the Black Dragons, and Toranaga didn't waste much time in making sure Vincent's line was extinct and that the O5P had their power diminished either.

As for Bhatia, "Like a spider in his web, he sits on Luthien or New Samarkandand manipulates events to suit his goals of protecting the
Combine, even against its own rulers." (ER 3145, p. 92)... with his service history and personality sounding suspiciously similar to Shakir Jerrar.

Quote
Well, the Black Dragons' (and any ISF helpers) goal wasn't to provoke and then LOSE the war, they assumed that they'd win after provoking the war.  In their minds, giving the Ghost Bears what the Smoke Jaguars got would have been good for the Combine.

Which is basically the problem; the Black Dragons don't consider the whole picture when they act. They wanted to kill Theodore, even though it was his reforms (in conjunction with the Suns deciding to be nice) that allowed the Combine to survive the War of 3039 and Clan Invasion. They wanted to get rid of Hohiro (or have complete control over him, acting through Minamoto) during the Jihad, even though the old style of warfare they wanted to re-establish was no good. They wanted to fight a "worthy opponent" (something Toranaga is noted for) and as a result attacked the Lyrans at Towne and the Ghost Bears to provoke battles they could not win.

Attacking the Bears was particularly idiotic on the face of it; Bulldog and Serpent both enjoyed a 3:1 numerical advantage against an opponent wholly unprepared for a defensive campaign, and without the SLDF there was no way the DCMS could muster the required ~160 Regiments required to have a go at the Ghost Bears.

The Black Dragons are all about cutting their noses off to spite their face.

Quote
The Draconis Combine suffered numerous losses against forces of the Draconis March, and keep in mind that the incentive for the FedSuns attack was the fact that the Draconis Combine was engaged in the conflict with the Ghost Bears and seriously weakened. Otherwise, they would have thought twice before attacking the Combine.

In part. There was also the Blakist false-flag attack that apparently claimed Arthur Steiner-Davion's life, and the discovery of prison camps in the Combine that also has the scent of the Word all over it. Militarily, they were very successful against the Combine, and the result of their attack was entirely dictated by politics rather than battlefield results. The Suns may have wound up sacrificing some worlds, but it did so not because it had to; rather, it did so because the forces needed to hold their new acquisitions was more useful to Tancred and Victor at New Avalon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 09 May 2013, 04:10:05
Unless that was a precursor to making a move on the Coordinator. The Black Dragons spent a few years stacking the Otomo with adherents before making their first attempt on Theodore, and patiently infiltrated the ISF, DCMS regiments, and DCN crews. As already mentioned, the O5P has been more loyal to the Combine and Coordinator than the Black Dragons, and Toranaga didn't waste much time in making sure Vincent's line was extinct and that the O5P had their power diminished either.

In what way did he diminish the power of the O5P? There is no evidence of that in the sources. Even if we assume the Order supported the Nova Cat rebellion (a big, though understandable, assumption) then Toranaga did nothing to them until they backed the wrong horse.

Quote
As for Bhatia, "Like a spider in his web, he sits on Luthien or New Samarkandand manipulates events to suit his goals of protecting the
Combine, even against its own rulers." (ER 3145, p. 92)... with his service history and personality sounding suspiciously similar to Shakir Jerrar.

Bhatia's service history is really nothing like Jerrar's. Nor does his personality bear any resemblance.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 09 May 2013, 04:20:19
Minamoto and Jerrar talked a big game about opposing the Black Dragons. What they were actually doing was wiping out the Sons of the Dragon and anyone loyal to the Combine or Coordinator over the Black Dragons and/or their ideologies.

The Misogi War says otherwise.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 09 May 2013, 04:34:37
Bhatia's service history is really nothing like Jerrar's. Nor does his personality bear any resemblance.

Again, +1.

To me, Bhatia is no Jerrar 2.0. And I have to say, I doubt that either Bhatia or Toranaga are kokuryu-kai. Maybe just a gut feeling, but at least we haven't seen any evidence of it.

The Misogi War says otherwise.

Where can I read more about the Misogi War? I've got all the source books, but I can't recall it right now. Was it in the StarCorps Dossiers and the Field Report?

By the way, please can anyone elaborate on the "Sons of the Dragon"? On whom's side are they now?  :))
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 09 May 2013, 05:12:21
Quote
By the way, please can anyone elaborate on the "Sons of the Dragon"? On whom's side are they now?

They were detailed in the MechWarrior's Guide to Covert Ops. The Sons of the Dragon were Subhash Indrahar's hand-picked elite, also known for being Theodore loyalists, small in number and opposed to the Black Dragons.

Quote
The Misogi War says otherwise.

Which worked so well that both Minamoto and Jerrar were Black Dragons and the organisation as a whole didn't seem to be all that effected by it. PP, the Misogi War is in the Jihad sourcebooks, and had the ISF and O5P trying to counter-infiltrate the Black Dragons. As can be imagined, with two of the three most powerful and important leaders in the Combine being Black Dragons themselves, actual successes were limited.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 09 May 2013, 05:14:37
Which worked so well that both Minamoto and Jerrar were Black Dragons and the organisation as a whole didn't seem to be all that effected by it. PP, the Misogi War is in the Jihad sourcebooks, and had the ISF and O5P trying to counter-infiltrate the Black Dragons. As can be imagined, with two of the three most powerful and important leaders in the Combine being Black Dragons themselves, actual successes were limited.

AFAIK, it was never stated that either Minamoto or Jerrar were Black Dragons.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 09 May 2013, 05:23:09
AFAIK, it was never stated that either Minamoto or Jerrar were Black Dragons.

AFAIK someone from the Republic thinks Minamoto is a member and for Jerrar, well, it´s his wife that has the ties.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 09 May 2013, 06:06:45
AFAIK, it was never stated that either Minamoto or Jerrar were Black Dragons.

Minamoto's write-up in FM: DC states that he is a staunch traditionalist who opposes Theodore's reforms. The JHS series has Hassid Ricol calling him his protege and saying that he is in position to greatly further the goals of the Black Dragons. Jerrar is also a traditionalist, and his efforts in the Misogi War were very succesful in getting rid of Combine loyalists while missing Black Dragons; he also has close ties with Minamoto and, IIRC, is mentioned in Black Dragon dispatches as a member.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 09 May 2013, 07:15:46
Traditionalist =/= Black Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 09 May 2013, 07:37:43
Traditionalist + Eliminating those loyal to the Coordinator and Combine/undoing or otherwise working against Theodore's reforms + Advancing the interests of the Black Dragons + Being said to be a Black Dragon are all pretty strong indicators, however.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 09 May 2013, 07:45:41
Traditionalist + Eliminating those loyal to the Coordinator and Combine/undoing or otherwise working against Theodore's reforms + Advancing the interests of the Black Dragons + Being said to be a Black Dragon are all pretty strong indicators, however.

Indicators that lead to your own personal interpretation of the matter =/= fact.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 09 May 2013, 08:01:09
AS to the O5P in the 3145 era...
Considering their links to Emi Kurita and the Nova Cats, I suspect they got purged big time. I figure we'll find out when the FM shows up.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 09 May 2013, 08:19:51
I did believe Toranaga to be a Black Dragon... until I came to the section about the Wolf's Dragoons. Like all kokuryu-kai I assumed he just mouthed the party line, but if he truly cared about his standing with the Society he'd never hire mercenaries. Not as the Kanrei.

So, no, I don't think Toranaga's a Black Dragon by virtue of how he's handled the Dragoons. Weird, I know.

And Bhatia? He sounds like a loon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 09 May 2013, 08:25:36
Guys, we really need this Handbook!  :D

While there's no new news on that front, this might help (http://benhrome.wordpress.com/2013/05/09/secret-police-and-colored-dragons/).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 09 May 2013, 08:25:57
Traditionalist =/= Black Dragon.

I like that. I miss a stricter Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 09 May 2013, 08:51:07
So, no, I don't think Toranaga's a Black Dragon by virtue of how he's handled the Dragoons. Weird, I know.

Not weird, no. I deem it logical.

And Bhatia? He sounds like a loon.

Oh yes, he does.

While there's no new news on that front, this might help (http://benhrome.wordpress.com/2013/05/09/secret-police-and-colored-dragons/).

Thank you!  O0

I like that. I miss a stricter Dragon.

+1

The good old times do not belong to the kokuryu-kai or those who oppose combined armes approach.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 09 May 2013, 08:56:09
Oooohhhhh... plenty of neat stuff in that preview.

Quote
The current head of the Order and Keeper of the House Honor is Miyako Kurita, daughter of Isoroku Kurita, the Warlord of the Dieron Military District. The Abbess is Tomade Yamiro, who was recently under rigorous investigation by the ISF for possible links to the Black Dragons. Ultimately proven innocent, the Abbess has since cut the Order’s ties with the agency, forming a crack in the already tattered alliance that neither group can afford at this time.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 09 May 2013, 09:02:32
While there's no new news on that front, this might help (http://benhrome.wordpress.com/2013/05/09/secret-police-and-colored-dragons/).

Although some parts of it are from the old House Kurita sourcebook, I like those parts describing 3050s and 3060s.  Thank you.  O0

But when you mention "six" grievances, I can see five points only?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 09 May 2013, 09:07:14
Oooohhhhh... plenty of neat stuff in that preview.

Yeah, this is plain awesome!  O0


@GhostBear

I've got a question about the following:

Quote
Inside the secret police is an even more secret society. Called the “Sons of the Dragon,” the society is a group of agents who are more loyal to the Director of the ISF and the Coordinator.

They are more loyal to the ISF Director and the Coordinator? Does this mean, these are the very elite of the ISF?

Or should it read: Inside the secret police is an even more secret society. Called the “Sons of the Dragon,” the society is a group of agents who are more loyal to the Director of the ISF and than the Coordinator.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 09 May 2013, 09:07:18
Although some parts of it are from the old House Kurita sourcebook, I like those parts describing 3050s and 3060s.  Thank you.  O0

But when you mention "six" grievances, I can see five points only?

....because I forgot to change it back to five after I realized #6 blew a massive plot hole down the road?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 09 May 2013, 09:09:18
I've got a question about the following:

They are more loyal to the ISF Director and the Coordinator? Does this mean, these are the very elite of the ISF?

Or should it read: Inside the secret police is an even more secret society. Called the “Sons of the Dragon,” the society is a group of agents who are more loyal to the Director of the ISF and than the Coordinator.

Nope. Reads as stands. They are the elite of the ISF; their loyalty is first and foremost to the personages of the Director (Ninyu) and the Coordinator (Theodore). Both of whom are also members.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 09 May 2013, 09:10:58
Although some parts of it are from the old House Kurita sourcebook,

Well yeah. I cleaned up a lot of its language and grammar, but the stuff was still relevant. Only confusing/conflicting material was rewritten. (And I took that approach because, at the time, I had a time crunch to deal with.)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 09 May 2013, 09:13:26
Nope. Reads as stands. They are the elite of the ISF; their loyalty is first and foremost to the personages of the Director (Ninyu) and the Coordinator (Theodore). Both of whom are also members.

Very intriguing! Thanks for the answer. :)

By the way, what do we know about the Sons of the Dragon in the Dark Age and now in 3145?

IIRC, Wahab Fusili was a member of them, wasn't he?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 09 May 2013, 09:15:12
....because I forgot to change it back to five after I realized #6 blew a massive plot hole down the road?

 :)

Thanks for explanation.

Well yeah. I cleaned up a lot of its language and grammar, but the stuff was still relevant. Only confusing/conflicting material was rewritten. (And I took that approach because, at the time, I had a time crunch to deal with.)

As I said it's okay. After all, it's no longer available for download and the paper original was published a quarter of century ago.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 09 May 2013, 11:29:58
Oooohhhhh... plenty of neat stuff in that preview.

Re: your bolding of the passage about Abbess Tomade Yamiro, remember that this book is dated 3067 and later events can change/invalidate/explain/expand upon its contents.

By the way, what do we know about the Sons of the Dragon in the Dark Age and now in 3145?

They died off during or shortly after the Jihad but were later resurrected by Bhatia.

Quote
IIRC, Wahab Fusili was a member of them, wasn't he?

He's actually O5P.

Jonathan, aka Kappa aka the Bounty Hunter aka Katana Tormark's psychotic and obsessed older brother, is a former Son.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 09 May 2013, 11:36:54
They died off during or shortly after the Jihad but were later resurrected by Bhatia.

Ah, I wasn't aware of the fact, that he recreated them. Which novel was it? Dragon Rising? And do we know, where the loyalities of the new Sons lie?

He's actually O5P.

Jonathan, aka Kappa aka the Bounty Hunter aka Katana Tormark's psychotic and obsessed older brother, is a former Son.

 :o That fact eluded me as well! Any other chars from the order?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: TS_Hawk on 09 May 2013, 17:44:31
While there's no new news on that front, this might help (http://benhrome.wordpress.com/2013/05/09/secret-police-and-colored-dragons/).

oooohhh shiny and pretty thank you GB for that.  Really can't wait for the book to come out.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 10 May 2013, 08:15:34
Bad news fellas... HBHK has been pushed back to Spring 2014 according to Ben Rome's twitter: twitter.com/bhrome

I'll console myself with TR3145 DC. But still.  :'(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 10 May 2013, 08:18:14
Bad news fellas... HBHK has been pushed back to Spring 2014 according to Ben Rome's twitter: twitter.com/bhrome

I'll console myself with TR3145 DC. But still.  :'(

Thanks for the info.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Pa Weasley on 10 May 2013, 08:36:43
Bad news fellas... HBHK has been pushed back to Spring 2014 according to Ben Rome's twitter: twitter.com/bhrome

I'll console myself with TR3145 DC. But still.  :'(
I just saw that as well. But on the bright side, at least two of the upcoming TRO 3145 units are good enough that Ben's teasing fans with 'em.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 10 May 2013, 09:02:47
Bad news fellas... HBHK has been pushed back to Spring 2014 according to Ben Rome's twitter: twitter.com/bhrome

I'll console myself with TR3145 DC. But still.  :'(

This is sad indeed.

But as I stated in the encouragement thread, I wait as long as it takes for this jewel to be published. It's the way of the cildren of the Dragon to be patient.

Are there any reasons given why it is further delayed?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 10 May 2013, 09:11:28
Are there any reasons given why it is further delayed?

Graphic and layout department busy with work on upcoming volumes of the TRO:3145? Work on materials that will be included in the 3250 Box Set? Getting the FM:3145 out of the door? Black Dragons sabotage? Word of Blake ROM made the manuscript "disappear"?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 10 May 2013, 09:23:28
Personally, I blame the Davions.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 10 May 2013, 09:27:07
Personally, I blame the Davions.

That's the prime suspect. That goes without saying ...           ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 10 May 2013, 09:27:49
[...]
Black Dragons sabotage? Word of Blake ROM made the manuscript "disappear"?

Personally, I blame the Davions.

 ;D

I like that kind of humor.  O0

Though, I suspect the Fidelis.  >:(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 10 May 2013, 09:45:46
Personally, I blame the Davions.

Ohh, House Davion Handbook 3145 Update pushed back HBHK?
*runs for cover*
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 10 May 2013, 11:09:38
Ohh, House Davion Handbook 3145 Update pushed back HBHK?
*runs for cover*

 ;D

 O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: TS_Hawk on 11 May 2013, 23:59:47
that just doesn't seem fair about HBHK :(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 12 May 2013, 09:07:25
that just doesn't seem fair about HBHK :(

I understand your feelings. I dare to say, that Ben may feel the same way about his project being delayed by issues not within his responsibility.

The true Samurai
does not whine and lament
but waits patiently.

 ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kyone Akashi on 13 May 2013, 18:11:10
Bad news fellas... HBHK has been pushed back to Spring 2014 according to Ben Rome's twitter: twitter.com/bhrome
I'll console myself with TR3145 DC. But still.  :'(
mikoshi borne proudly
yellow bird brings news
a sigh .. the parade proceeds
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 14 May 2013, 13:02:37
Yeah, I'm still pretty bummed.

I'd pay for a text only version, to be honest. I don't need the pretties.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: TS_Hawk on 15 May 2013, 01:53:34
Yeah, I'm still pretty bummed.

I'd pay for a text only version, to be honest. I don't need the pretties.

I am with you on that.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 15 May 2013, 10:47:59
I will wait for the full version.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 18 May 2013, 05:49:14
Have you all seen this marvellous cover for the new TRO:3145 Draconis Combine?  O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 18 May 2013, 06:20:23
Have you all seen this marvellous cover for the new TRO:3145 Draconis Combine?  O0

Hai!

I can see the Scimitar MKII in the foreground, with the Saladin behind it. And is it not the Saracen in the background? It seems that the shape of its turret is different from that of the Scimitar, but I am not sure.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 18 May 2013, 07:02:34
Have you all seen this marvellous cover for the new TRO:3145 Draconis Combine?  O0

Immediatelly fell in love with those hover tanks.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 18 May 2013, 07:25:07
For a few moments I hoped that the Draconis Combine might get a hover OmniVehicle - something as the Epona Pursuit Tank, but for the Inner Sphere in general and the DCMS in particular.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 18 May 2013, 07:53:02
Indeed. I'm not-so-secretly hoping that the totem 'Mechs were really OmniMechs. And that most of our combat vees are Omni as well.

Probably not though.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: RedMarauder on 18 May 2013, 08:32:25
i agree, we've seen in a lot of the books and on DA pilot cards that the combine is actually as multicultural as the other successor states, whether they acknowledge it or not. i particularly like the picture of stephen dirks, a scottish samurai, what's more badass than that

A Viking Samurai?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 18 May 2013, 09:27:32
In polite company we refer to those as Rasalhaguians. Or, as the Ghost Bears call them, Stockholmians...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 18 May 2013, 10:53:51
What I really love about that cover art are not only the Mechs and Vees, but the Japanese buildings in the background. I have waiting for something like that very, very long.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 18 May 2013, 13:44:49
It is known, (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,28975.msg681908.html#msg681908) but deserves a link here I believe.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 18 May 2013, 14:24:57
I want this as a wallpaper!  [drool] [drool] [drool]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 18 May 2013, 14:37:33
I want this as a wallpaper!  [drool] [drool] [drool]

It depends how big is your monitor resolution, but if you can try it in the GIMP ...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 18 May 2013, 14:57:51
Won't they do all the TRO 3145 covers as wallpaper?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 18 May 2013, 15:04:04
Won't they do all the TRO 3145 covers as wallpaper?

We don't know. Maybe they will, but who can know when it will happen?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 18 May 2013, 15:31:44
I'm sooo longing for the Marik cover.  [drool]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 18 May 2013, 15:34:23
I'm sooo longing for the Marik cover.  [drool]

The book should be out in August so we should get a sneak peek in July after the FedSuns TRO comes out.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 18 May 2013, 15:37:16
The book should be out in August so we should get a sneak peek in July after the FedSuns TRO comes out.

*drools all over the board*
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 18 May 2013, 15:42:17
I'm sooo longing for the Marik cover.  [drool]

Something as great as the Historical: Brush Wars cover art was ...

*drools all over the board*

Keep calm. They may have to postpone it a month (or two or six). You know, for example the Handbook: House Kurita ....

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 18 May 2013, 15:50:41
Maybe. But so far we haven't heard about any problems with the TRO 3145 series. Plus, they're very high on the priority list.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 21 May 2013, 11:01:46
So which designs are you guys anticipating the most in our 3145 TRO next month?

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 21 May 2013, 11:07:24
Mechs... Shiro.

But i'm really more excited for BA and tanks.  DC combined arms needs more luvin.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 21 May 2013, 11:10:26
So which designs are you guys anticipating the most in our 3145 TRO next month?

Kamakiri.

And the Shi Kamakiri.

 ^-^
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 21 May 2013, 11:29:45
Really hard to say. The Mech Ben mentioned a couple of days ago interests me most: the Tenshi.  }:)

But I agree with False Son about more combined arms. BA is always a highlight for me.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 21 May 2013, 12:09:25
I want to see if the Dragon on the front cover is once again a Dragon and not a Grand Dragon and to see what the trio of hovers look like.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 21 May 2013, 12:28:21
Kamakiri.

And the Shi Kamakiri.

 ^-^

This and the DA totem 'Mechs I need to get a good look at first before really delving into the rest of the book.

And yes, I hope we get updated BA. Wouldn't mind seeing an updated Kanazuchi as well.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 21 May 2013, 12:34:06
So which designs are you guys anticipating the most in our 3145 TRO next month?

Hitotsune Kozo and Shiro.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 21 May 2013, 13:38:08
And yes, I hope we get updated BA. Wouldn't mind seeing an updated Kanazuchi as well.

Updated? No. Replacements? OH YES.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 21 May 2013, 13:42:31
Updated? No. Replacements? OH YES.

Can we haz it yet? NOW I'm excited.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 21 May 2013, 13:47:27
Can we haz it yet? NOW I'm excited.

+1

 [drool] [drool] [drool]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Atlas3060 on 21 May 2013, 14:12:51
Updated? No. Replacements? OH YES.
I'm scared, curious, and excited all in one with this line.
Bravo.  [applause]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 21 May 2013, 14:14:43
Updated? No. Replacements? OH YES.

Now with added remote-accessed seppuku option.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nerroth on 21 May 2013, 14:23:11
I wonder if any DCMS officers use the new "Samurai" 'Mechs to fight giant sword duels...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 21 May 2013, 14:28:30
Maybe duelling with katanas outside the Mechs but probably not with Mechs. Combine warriors are no Clanners. :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Pa Weasley on 21 May 2013, 14:29:57
Nah, swap out the blades for 'Mech scale kendo. It's a sight to behold.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 21 May 2013, 14:41:48
Maybe duelling with katanas outside the Mechs but probably not with Mechs. Combine warriors are no Clanners. :)

Maybe in the Sword of Light or District Regulars, in the Legion of Vega it'd be a stiletto in the back.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 21 May 2013, 14:47:33
Maybe in the Sword of Light or District Regulars, in the Legion of Vega it'd be a stiletto in the back.

The 2nd Dieron Regulars soldiers would have solved it with a hand grenade under the pillow ...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 21 May 2013, 14:47:33
Is the Legion still around in 3145? Not complaining if so. I always liked the DCMS to have some kind of dumping ground.

The 2nd Dieron Regulars soldiers would have solved it with a hand grenade under the pillow ...

 ;D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 21 May 2013, 14:50:34
Is the Legion still around in 3145? Not complaining if so. I always liked the DCMS to have some kind of dumping ground.

 ;D

Yes, Legions are still around.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 21 May 2013, 14:51:49
Sadly so not the Altenmarkt Militia. That would be a REAL black-sheep squadron style RP campaign :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 21 May 2013, 14:54:43
Aren't the Legions slightly less of a dumping ground now?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 21 May 2013, 15:39:50
They were under Theodore but now they are once again the regiments the Warlords send the black sheep of the DCMS to serve, as of 3085 they are back up to 2 regiments the 2nd and 7th.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 21 May 2013, 16:09:52
Hey Ben, can you answer this question at least - will there be enough in the DC TRO to come up with fully stocked combined arms units?  Not just "sure there's tanks and mechs and BA" but are there enough designs in the book that you could put together a battalion with just what's in the book and fill out the usual roles?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 21 May 2013, 20:11:05
Hey Ben, can you answer this question at least - will there be enough in the DC TRO to come up with fully stocked combined arms units?  Not just "sure there's tanks and mechs and BA" but are there enough designs in the book that you could put together a battalion with just what's in the book and fill out the usual roles?

Yes. At least, if it was me building the battalion...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 22 May 2013, 07:06:58
I'm looking forward to seeing the stuff I need to kill, yes.  O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 22 May 2013, 08:10:30
I'm looking forward to seeing the stuff I need to kill, yes.  O0

You and what Clan?  ;) Too soon?

Too soon.

So we're looking at mid-June for this? Another month or so ain't bad.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Pa Weasley on 22 May 2013, 09:16:36
You and what Clan?  ;) Too soon?

Too soon.
Some of us cope by laughing through the pain.

Oh, I'm sure some of the gear will be available as targets during the Nova Cat rebellion.   ;D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 22 May 2013, 09:22:42
I'd imagine there'll be as many Nova Cats units in the TRO as there are Canopian ones in the Capellan TRO.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 22 May 2013, 13:20:25
Wonder if we'd get our own Clan OmniMechs?... As in Combine-designed but Clan tech.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Peacemaker on 22 May 2013, 13:31:58
I'd imagine there'll be as many Nova Cats units in the TRO as there are Canopian ones in the Capellan TRO.

How many Nova Cat units still need a TRO entry? The Cave Lion, Wendigo, Avalanche, Cizin and maybe the Sekhmet Assault Vehicle are all that I can remember.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 22 May 2013, 19:08:23
How many Nova Cat units still need a TRO entry? The Cave Lion, Wendigo, Avalanche, Cizin and maybe the Sekhmet Assault Vehicle are all that I can remember.

Pretty much; it was never clear of the Sekhmet was a Falcon or Cat vee, especially as it had design elements from both. Otherwise, the only one that might warrant an entry is the redesigned Shadow Cat.

Given that the Clan TRO is allready pretty full, I wouldn't be surprised to find them in the Kurita one
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 24 May 2013, 09:54:56
Ben Rome has released a teaser of the Tenshi!

http://benhrome.wordpress.com/2013/05/24/a-dragons-death-angel-with-a-gun/
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Pa Weasley on 24 May 2013, 09:57:02
Here's (http://benhrome.wordpress.com/2013/05/24/a-dragons-death-angel-with-a-gun/) an awesome littl' post by Ben for anyone curious about the Tenshi.

Edit: D'oh! Bested by Marwynn.  O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nerroth on 24 May 2013, 09:59:20
I thought the Galedon Regulars had been re-named to the New Samarkand Regulars by then. Unless some of them had the name switched back in honour of the now-fallen world?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 24 May 2013, 10:01:23
Here's (http://benhrome.wordpress.com/2013/05/24/a-dragons-death-angel-with-a-gun/) an awesome littl' post by Ben for anyone curious about the Tenshi.

Edit: D'oh! Bested by Marwynn.  O0

Woohoo, I Roosterboy'd someone!  O0

Does that sound like an Omni to you guys? (Edit: It *is* an Omni, /facepalm)

I thought the Galedon Regulars had been re-named to the New Samarkand Regulars by then. Unless some of them had the name switched back in honour of the now-fallen world?

New units were called New Samarkand Regulars, but the 16th was an older one, destroyed in the Jihad.

So they could've just rebuilt it using the old name.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 24 May 2013, 10:12:37
Thanks, GhostBear!

Let's hope that the DCMS gets an OmniMech (and its configurations) as good as the Templar.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Peacemaker on 24 May 2013, 10:14:03
Pretty much; it was never clear of the Sekhmet was a Falcon or Cat vee, especially as it had design elements from both. Otherwise, the only one that might warrant an entry is the redesigned Shadow Cat.

Given that the Clan TRO is allready pretty full, I wouldn't be surprised to find them in the Kurita one

I wonder what's going to have happened to all the Nova Cat factories. If they weren't destroyed, maybe the DCMS will start fielding a lot more Clantech.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 24 May 2013, 10:55:21
Thank you, Ben!  O0

What a sexy beast!  {>{>
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 24 May 2013, 10:58:32
I wonder what's going to have happened to all the Nova Cat factories. If they weren't destroyed, maybe the DCMS will start fielding a lot more Clantech.

The DCMS is fielding quite a lot from the ER:3145 RATs at least. Clan-grade Inner Sphere designs? Hmm.

I'd be hammering twitter/battlecorps the day they announce TR45DC's release.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 24 May 2013, 16:46:32
I thought the Galedon Regulars had been re-named to the New Samarkand Regulars by then. Unless some of them had the name switched back in honour of the now-fallen world?

I think the Galedon District Regulars that were extant at the time of the creation of the New Samarkand District were given special permission to continue carrying on the Galedon name.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 24 May 2013, 16:51:42
The Galedon Regulars are still around. It's the Dieron Regulars who were re-named the New Samarkand Regulars.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 24 May 2013, 16:54:11
The Galedon Regulars are still around. It's the Dieron Regulars who were re-named the New Samarkand Regulars.

And presumably, any new/and or former 'Galedon' regiments activated since 3085.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 24 May 2013, 22:38:38
I had a couple of random thoughts while I was just out walking my little Sir-Poops-A lot...

Tenshi's spoiler: I loved seeing the Ghost Bears actually lose a battle.  But what nags at me is the result. 
"and several hundred tons of Clan technology was claimed for the Dragon..."

Wait, what?  They blasted what sounds like two stars of mechs, plus a supporting star of battle armor.  That should be quite a bit more than 'several hundred' tons of tech in salvage alone.

Assuming they didn't get to haul any salvage off the field (since they apparently couldn't bring back 2 of their own downed mechs) there's a potential issue of risk/reward.   They went through the bother and expense of invading Grumium with quite a bit more than 'several hundred' tons of Tenshis.   That's a lot of investment into a venture that rides on the outcome of the Ghost Bears failing to defend the target.  Hardly seems worth it, unless the battle (said to take place in 3103) was more about cutting the teeth on the then-new mech design rather than a dedicated attempt to procure clan-tech hardware.



Additional thought about the state of the 2nd 1st Succession War:
What if the shoe isn't about to drop on Kurita, and the borders are going to stay near where they are now for quite some time.

IF the borders weren't to be rolled back, is it plausible to stand up a new Robinson Military District more or less in place of the former Draconis March?  It'd be the Rasalhague District all over again without having to get rid of the Ghost Bears.  I think a true problem with the idea is making one new Warlord in charge of most of the Davion frontier.  That'd go over poorly with the Benjamin and New Samarkand Warlords if they end up being deprived of opportunity for glory against the Ancient Enemy.

 Purely speculative but I find it interesting to think about.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nerroth on 24 May 2013, 22:58:53
There seems to be something of note for House Kurita on DTRPG and the BattleShop just now...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 24 May 2013, 23:04:26
There seems to be something of note for House Kurita on DTRPG and the BattleShop just now...

Indeedy... reading mine now! :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 25 May 2013, 02:28:38
Just got mine, first thing i noticed from the Kishi write up the 5th Sword of Light has 3 regiments? Back to Brigade strength i guess  :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 25 May 2013, 02:57:26
Best part of the TRO:

The samurai of the Draconis Combine are
famous for their honor. More so than any other
warriors, even the genetically-bred Clansmen,
they hold to the tenets of honorable combat.
Enemies have feared, respected and derided
them across time. They hold themselves to
bushido at all times; every samurai is a man or
woman of honor—but not every soldier of the
Dragon is samurai.
And for those aerospace pilots who are not
samurai, there is Wakizashi’s Koroshiya.


The Koroshiya is All Beast, and whoever wrote that intro for it needs a medal.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 25 May 2013, 03:28:26
What a great book, isn't it?!  {>{>
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 25 May 2013, 04:05:33
I think the DC-TRO paints a very disturbing picture on what the Dragon is capable now:
- Grabbed clan manufactoric plants and have clan-tech units, also have ption for IS-based units to come with clan wepons.
- Seems to be able to produce massive amounts of war material, as shown with the full-scale deployment of the new BAs
- The samurai spirit is back and with the new totem mechs, panther-style tactics and more swords, it´s really enforced

Some strange items I found:
- A burgeoning black market
- A growing emrcenary market with reduced costs for favourite mercs
- The DCMS seems to chose armour and weapons based on their targets now. It gets mentioned a lot that this a vehicles armour is chosen to counter FedSun standard equipment.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 25 May 2013, 05:21:34
I've spotted some new regiment names in the write ups to  :) O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 25 May 2013, 07:03:23
Indeed, after a long time, the Dragon rises his regal head again. Beware those on whom he lays his fiery eyes.  }:)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 25 May 2013, 08:54:48
I only have two questions I have with the new TRO

First: We now have Dieron Regulars, New Samarkand Regulars, and Galedon Regulars. Did some of the NSR become DR or were the DR raised whole cloth as new formations? If so, what happened to the 2nd NSR/2nd DR (Since they are my 2nd unit in my DCMS forces)

Second: When did Procurement becomes all arms dealerly? It seems that some units are still struggling to equip with SOTA and we are selling to mercs at tiered pricing. Sure, I understand somethings below market value to trusted mercs (Gamma Regiment of the goons) for testing but it seems like we are becoming almost Sea Foxy. Are we that hard up for hard currency?

Third: ok, I know I said two questions but can someone get me a towel? This TRO made me HAPPY!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 25 May 2013, 08:57:09
I only have two questions I have with the new TRO

First: We now have Dieron Regulars, New Samarkand Regulars, and Galedon Regulars. Did some of the NSR become DR or were the DR raised whole cloth as new formations? If so, what happened to the 2nd NSR/2nd DR (Since they are my 2nd unit in my DCMS forces)


IIRC, the "new" Derion Regulars are raised from the Dragons Fury and other former Republic-affiliated units. I suspect we'll find out more in FM3145
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Atlas3060 on 25 May 2013, 10:49:09

Good to see a mention of Gannon's Cannons in the Exhumer entry.
The Zou will now be proxied by my Kanazuchis and it seems like a worthy fit.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 25 May 2013, 16:24:16
The new TRO talks about an "unofficial cultural rebirth" taking place in the DC, hence the appearance of the "samurai" `Mechs in the universe.

But...hasn't that been part of the DC for centuries? I've never really seen anything to show that such a culture has ever really disappeared. Did I miss something, or perhaps is this just...a hyper expression of their culture? Not really a revival but a extreme observance of their culture?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 25 May 2013, 16:36:20
The new TRO talks about an "unofficial cultural rebirth" taking place in the DC, hence the appearance of the "samurai" `Mechs in the universe.

But...hasn't that been part of the DC for centuries? I've never really seen anything to show that such a culture has ever really disappeared. Did I miss something, or perhaps is this just...a hyper expression of their culture? Not really a revival but a extreme observance of their culture?

I guess it was meant as an in-universe explanation why suddenly there are so many DC 'Mechs with Japanese aesthetics (which were inherited from the ClickyTech in the real world). So If the Capellan Confederation had its Xin Sheng movement in 3050s and 3060s, the Draconis Combine can have its rebirth in 3130s as well.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 25 May 2013, 17:12:26
I think it tried to establish that post-Jihad there was a bit of a cultural identity crisis.

With Stone-enforced peace for the Sphere, the Combine grew uneasy. I think it fits. Remember, Hohiro was complicit with Victor Steiner-Davion in the whole Republic's "ultimate goal" thing. So the rulership is okay with relaxing the strictures that have kept the Combine a rigid nation. But the populace is dealing with the massive losses of the Jihad, the Black Dragon crises, and see their nation's eroding power and purpose. Which is why Vincent, the Peacock, was seen as a weak ruler.

The rebirth is a denial of these things. A denial of the losses. The setbacks.

It makes sense that there'd be a second wave of japanification, again rooted from the populace, after a period of weak rulership. It happened the first time.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 25 May 2013, 17:55:55
Second: When did Procurement becomes all arms dealerly? It seems that some units are still struggling to equip with SOTA and we are selling to mercs at tiered pricing. Sure, I understand somethings below market value to trusted mercs (Gamma Regiment of the goons) for testing but it seems like we are becoming almost Sea Foxy. Are we that hard up for hard currency?


HBHK explains more of the Procurement Department and its unofficial power. Unfortunately...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 25 May 2013, 18:42:32
HBHK explains more of the Procurement Department and its unofficial power. Unfortunately...

No hope of getting that out earlier than next Spring?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 26 May 2013, 03:16:19
Dumb question, what are the odds of a Shiro showing up amongst the Amphigeans? I've always had the impression that they weren't particularly well regarded but I haven't really read up on the DC in years. Thanks ahead of time.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 26 May 2013, 03:50:09
Dumb question, what are the odds of a Shiro showing up amongst the Amphigeans? I've always had the impression that they weren't particularly well regarded but I haven't really read up on the DC in years. Thanks ahead of time.

Since the Amphigeans were dispatched against the Nova Cats, I'd say they have some quality. So perhaps one of their officers could pilot the Shiro. Or perhaps he could have brought the 'Mech from the service with other, better regarded regiment. So it's not impossible.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 26 May 2013, 12:45:22
Since the Amphigeans were dispatched against the Nova Cats, I'd say they have some quality. So perhaps one of their officers could pilot the Shiro. Or perhaps he could have brought the 'Mech from the service with other, better regarded regiment. So it's not impossible.

Sounds good, thanks martian. I get the idea that the Amphigeans occupy a strange place in the DCMS; better regarded than the Ghosts but nowhere near as well thought of as Ryuken.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 26 May 2013, 12:59:47
Sounds good, thanks martian. I get the idea that the Amphigeans occupy a strange place in the DCMS; better regarded than the Ghosts but nowhere near as well thought of as Ryuken.

I think you got that right. Of course the last detailed mentions about Amphigean LAGs are from 3085, so it's anyone's guess in what shape they are in 3145, six decades later.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neufeld on 26 May 2013, 14:00:11
Speaking about Ryuken, I noticed that there is a brand new Ryuken regiment in the TRO.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 26 May 2013, 14:58:06
Speaking about Ryuken, I noticed that there is a brand new Ryuken regiment in the TRO.

So they have rebuilt those regiments destroyed during the Jihad and added additional one?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 26 May 2013, 15:00:58
I can't recall precisely right now where I read about it, but somewhere is stated, that the DCMS rebuilt many of those regiments lost in the Jihad.

About the Ryoken I only remember about the Ryoken-go, which was rebuilt as well.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 26 May 2013, 15:14:49
2nd Amphigean gets a couple mentions in the new TRO as well.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neufeld on 26 May 2013, 15:55:01
So they have rebuilt those regiments destroyed during the Jihad and added additional one?

Two Ryuken regiments was lost in the Jihad, we already knew that one of the was rebuilt from the Era Report. The other lost regiment is an unknown for now. So, with the new regiment the Ryuken is at least five regiments strong in 3145.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 26 May 2013, 16:02:30
2nd Amphigean gets a couple mentions in the new TRO as well.

Good to see them back, I wonder if the 5th has been reformed as well.

Also I thought the Ghost regiments had been disbanded? I see several of them have resurfaced too.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neufeld on 26 May 2013, 16:19:35
Good to see them back, I wonder if the 5th has been reformed as well.

Also I thought the Ghost regiments had been disbanded? I see several of them have resurfaced too.

Maybe they were just officially 'disbanded' while still existing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Peacemaker on 26 May 2013, 17:30:05
Maybe they returned as part of the post-Blackout military buildup.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 27 May 2013, 00:22:34
Maybe they were just officially 'disbanded' while still existing.

It is mentioned in one of the Ilsa Bick novels that they had been disbanded "decades ago".

With regards,
Øystein
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Nav_Alpha on 27 May 2013, 01:24:21
It is mentioned in one of the Ilsa Bick novels that they had been disbanded "decades ago".

With regards,
Øystein

... and the book in question includes a whole plot arc about a couple of Dragon's Fury agents attempting to prompt some of the Yak clans into pulling their old mothballed weapons out of storage and releasing the warriors they'd secretly been training since the Ghosts were disbanded
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 27 May 2013, 02:51:40
The 7th are back which is all that matters to me.  O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 28 May 2013, 08:03:06
... and the book in question includes a whole plot arc about a couple of Dragon's Fury agents attempting to prompt some of the Yak clans into pulling their old mothballed weapons out of storage and releasing the warriors they'd secretly been training since the Ghosts were disbanded

Actually, it was Warlord Sakamoto.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 28 May 2013, 08:24:53
I'm still holding out hope that the Proserpina Hussars make a comeback. They've been with the Combine when it was still the Alliance of Galedon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 28 May 2013, 11:58:49
With the reconstitution of the Dieron Regulars brigade from scratch, I can hold some hope for the 18th being reconstituted.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 28 May 2013, 12:14:50
I'm still holding out hope that the Proserpina Hussars make a comeback. They've been with the Combine when it was still the Alliance of Galedon.
With the reconstitution of the Dieron Regulars brigade from scratch, I can hold some hope for the 18th being reconstituted.

Yeah, right. But your turn will be after the 46th Dieron Regulars are here, no sooner.   ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 01 June 2013, 16:20:57
Question for the DC lovers out there.

Has there been any new DC "Combat Organizations/Units" formed since the 3020's with the Ryuken & Genyosha ?

(I don't mean things like the new SoL regiment, I mean new "Organizations")

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 June 2013, 16:23:22
New Samarkand Regulars?

Although they did spring from the Dieron Regulars.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 01 June 2013, 16:33:10
New Samarkand Regulars?

Although they did spring from the Dieron Regulars. 

Sorry, I should have mentioned I knew of them & I'm looking for stuff from pre-RotS era.

PS.  IIRC didn't they also exist long ago, having been around back when New Samarkand was the capitol ?

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 01 June 2013, 16:35:24
Question for the DC lovers out there.

Has there been any new DC "Combat Organizations/Units" formed since the 3020's with the Ryuken & Genyosha ?

(I don't mean things like the new SoL regiment, I mean new "Organizations")

Shin Legions (arrived to the Draconis Combine in 3030s)

Ghost Regiments (formed in 3030s)

Izanagi Warriors (created in 3051)

Alshain Avengers (created in 3052 or so)

New Samarkand Regulars (created after 3080 or so)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 01 June 2013, 16:43:24
Hmm, Shin & Alshain are both older in theory.

Hmm, Ghost Regiments, I hadn't thought of that,  that might work for what I'm looking for.

Izangi is IIRC retired troops isnt it ?   (Wait, I think that is Dragon's Claws)
What is the origin of the Izangi's ?

Edit, nvm, I googled it & it is the Dragons' claws renamed.

CO is Shin Yodama,  anyone know what kind of mech he uses ?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 01 June 2013, 16:56:31
Hmm, Shin & Alshain are both older in theory.

Hmm, Ghost Regiments, I hadn't thought of that,  that might work for what I'm looking for.

Hard to help you if we don't know what you are looking for.

Izangi is IIRC retired troops isnt it ?   (Wait, I think that is Dragon's Claws)
What is the origin of the Izangi's ?

Edit, nvm, I googled it & it is the Dragons' claws renamed.
No. Otomo are elite veteran MechWarriors, but it doesn't mean they are retired. They are just hand-picked from the DCMS. They use OmniMechs.

Izanagi Warriors are retired and veterans, skilled both in 'Mech combat and physical combat, and exceptionally loyal to the Coordinator (Takashi at first, and then to Theodore).  They use gold camo with black highlights on their BattleMechs upgraded with the SL technology.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 01 June 2013, 17:13:14
I'm looking for a unit formed since the 4th SW to paint up some minis.

I wasn't thinking of Otomo at all.

Izanagi is the renamed Dragons Claws, formed from retirees all personally loyal to Takashi to protect him from any Coup by Teddy.

I'm thinking the Izanagi is going to be my choice, I'm just not comfortable enough in my painting skills to try some of the Ghost regiments w/ the Yakuza tatoos on those mechs.

Gold w/ Black highlights,  that I can probably handle ;)

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 01 June 2013, 18:15:56
Question for the DC lovers out there.

Has there been any new DC "Combat Organizations/Units" formed since the 3020's with the Ryuken & Genyosha ?

(I don't mean things like the new SoL regiment, I mean new "Organizations")

The Altenmarkt Militia (http://www.sarna.net/wiki/Altenmarkt_Militia) was a new brigade in the 3020s but it didn't have any reason to last the formation of the Free Rasalhague Republic.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 04 June 2013, 03:31:36
Whoever is responsible for the upload of the cover of TRO 3145 DC as a wallpaper:

Thank you very much!!!!  O0 O0 O0

I really appreciate this.  :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: YingJanshi on 04 June 2013, 08:56:51
Whoever is responsible for the upload of the cover of TRO 3145 DC as a wallpaper:

Thank you very much!!!!  O0 O0 O0

I really appreciate this.  :)

Where's that? The only one I see on the site is the Mercs one?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ArcaneRaven on 04 June 2013, 09:01:38
Scroll further down. It's in the TRO section.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 04 June 2013, 09:04:23
Did you guys see all the fancy salvage we got in TRO3145 FS?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 06 June 2013, 13:37:22
I'm still holding out hope that the Proserpina Hussars make a comeback. They've been with the Combine when it was still the Alliance of Galedon.

This but since I saw a mention of the 3rd Pesht Reg, prolly not :-[
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 06 June 2013, 21:31:09
This but since I saw a mention of the 3rd Pesht Reg, prolly not :-[

Yeah, that is sad.

But hey, at least we have the new Davion Black Knights to cheer us up!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 07 June 2013, 02:14:24
Yeah, that is sad.

But hey, at least we have the new Davion Black Knights to cheer us up!

As does the League  :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 07 June 2013, 11:28:49
Along that train of thought.. here's what we are getting out of the Davion TRO:

Sea Fox Amphibious (powered) Armor: Fluff says we're approaching the Sea Foxes to procure these after finding out how fun they were after capturing a few from Davion guerrillas.

Zibler Fast Strike Tank:  Fluff indicates StarCorps was aggressively selling it to everybody in the Inner Sphere prior to Grey Monday.

Vulpes: No production of these for the Dragon, but it's fluffed as being a particularly desirable prize by the DCMS... so they'd go to some lengths to put a shot out one back in service as salvage.

Black Knight: By way of captured RSB; production almost assuredly a large bit behind pre-conquest levels unless all the components and weapons were produced on-world, which appears to be rarer situation in the Dark Age than in the Succession Wars.

Atlas III: Also produced by RSB on Robinson.  Same situation as above.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 07 June 2013, 11:45:34
Zibler and Vulpes...

Aww yeah. Forget the new Scarborough tanks! I want me some Ziblers.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 07 June 2013, 12:41:42
Some worlds of probable importance near the current lines:

Worlds on the axis of a potential thrust towards New Avalon from Robinson:
Kestrel:  It's 2 jumps from the current border (at occupied Robinson) and is a world of extreme political and military signifigance.  It's also right between New Avalon and Robinson, so if our drive is to continue deeper into the FS Kestrel is a world that is bound to figure prominently as an AFFS strongpoint.  In addition to that, its agricultural riches were heavily exported to the Draconis March, worlds that are probably under DCMS dominion now.   We'd likely want to seize the world just so that we could go on feeding our current conquered populations.
However, my guess is that this is where we'll see Julian make his heroic stand and turn the tide.  Even if he doesn't, its the planet where the ancestral estates of McKinnon's Raiders are located.  How much fun is THAT place going to be to keep under control, if it even falls in the first place.

New Valencia: A bit more out of the way to New Avalon, but still within 2 jumps of Robinson.  And home to rather impressive factories, last known to be producing Avatar and Blackjack Omnis, Victors, Pendragons, and several vehicles.  Even if we don't invade the planet, the AFFS must spread their resources to defend it.

Saunemin: Located between Kestrel and New Valencia, it's mostly unknown in canon but potentially critical as being just within a 2 jump radius of New Avalon.

Worlds of importance on a thrust towards New Avalon from the Palmyra Thumb:
The planets spinward of New Avalon are very thinly described.  There isn't much to speculate about other than by purely their location.  The Palmyra thumb may well be an opportunity to bring attention to this region and start giving planets some fluff as battles rage on or above them.

Tsamma: A world rich in food and water exports.  Possibly the gem of the occupied salient.  Definately going to be a high priority target for AFFS forces to raid or liberate.. defending it will likely sap strength from what could have otherwise gone towards New Avalon or expanding the salient.

Protection & Linneus: Not much is known canonically, but look at the map.  If we lose either system we face having to jump at least once in hostile space to maintain supply into the salient.  A natural place for the AFFS to counterattack, and potentially a natural place for the Dragon to widen the thumb from.

Worlds of note on the Davion side of the current lines:
Dahar IV: It's long been a major AFFS base.  It's probably no coincidence at all that the 3145 lines show this planet holding a bulwark against the invasion.  It's not important enough to go after if New Avalon is a target, but if it's not taken it's a natural strongpoint for the AFFS to reinforce and cause headaches all throughout the occupied Draconis March.

Johnsondale: Every defense industry is critical to the FedRats at this point, and Johnsondale's tank output is going to draw a good defense.  A heavy presence there likewise offers the AFFS a great location to launch raids or a counterattack into the anti-spinward portion of the occupied territory.

Worlds of note in the occupied Draconis March:
The importance of worlds like Robinson and Marduk need no explanation to the casual Kurita fan, but here are some more gems that we took and will likely have to fight to keep:

New Ivaarsen: The loss of this world makes Davion fans squeal almost as much as Robinson itself.  It's a major, wealthy world and has long been the gatekeeper to guarantee against Kuritan successes of the 1st SW from being repeated.  It's also fluffed as being a world noteworthy (even for the Draconis March) as being virulently anti-Combine.  Couple that with it being the homeworld of the AFFS's New Ivaarsen Chausseurs brigade (and therefore home to a plethora of retired AFFS soldiers..) and you've got what I say is the most likely tinderbox of insurrection we have.   I assume the writers will have the AFFS roll us back, and New Ivaarsen is likely to go back to Davion hands once the war is over.

Sakhara V: A deserty world of moderate wealth.  However, it is the homeworld of the renowned Sakhara Mechwarrior Academy.  Considered by many (including myself, and I say this as a Kurita fan..) to produce the FINEST mechwarriors in the Inner Sphere.  There are going to be quite a few mechwarriors out there whos pride is injured at their alma mater being subjected to Draconian occupation.  And most of them are in the AFFS.  This is another world I just don't see the devs allowing to remain in Kuritan hands.  However, if we do end up keeping the planet, it is MOST curious to think about what would become of the Academy.  Assuming they didn't restart the academy elsewhere, the Draconian flavor of training (well, indoctrination) being imposed would likely end the academy's sterling successes.

Tishomingo: Like Dahar IV, long a lynchpin of the defense of the Draconis March.  However now that infrastructure is in our hands and VERY conveniently located.  If the AFFS launches a broad campaign to liberate the occupied territories, this planet should prove to be an early key battleground.

Tancredi IV: Technically not in the same category as it's been in Kuritan hands since before 3130, but I'm including it anyway as it's typically been a Davion planet up till the Dark Age.  It was a major world of the Draconis March and not that dissimilar to Marduk in its production importance.  In fact, when I saw the 3130 map for the first time, I thought of Tancredi IV as 'our compensation' for Marduk falling back into FedRat hands.  Should we suffer a complete collapse of the Palmyra Thumb (or perfidy from the Ravens...) this system would be a gem of a prize to take back.

With the relevations in TRO:Kurita and TRO:Davion, here are some additional thoughts:
More worlds on the axis of a potential thrust towards New Avalon from Robinson:
Kirklin: Kallon Weapon Industries produces Paladin artillery tanks here.  With Victoria back under Capellan control, this is the AFFSs last source of the tank.  The factory must be defended, and makes for a tempting raid.  As much as the source of mega artillery CAN be a tempting target, anyway.  Should the lines continue to fall rimwards towards New Avalon, Kirklin has to be a place that will feature a defiant stand by the AFFS.

New Valencia: Add the production of the new version of the Templar to this world's already high importance.

Robinson: I glossed over the word in the initial post, but the TRO:Davion reveals that the new Black Knight and Atlas III are both built there.  Add in the historical mech production and cultural & socio-political importance of the world and it's a fair bet that Robinson's story in the war hasn't seen its final chapter.

More worlds of note on the Davion side of the current lines:
Layover: A Quikscell plant is here that makes Sniper artillery.  Not as big a prize as Johnsondale, but doubtlessly still defended against Kuritan raids.   And makes another logical logistical strongpoint for the AFFS along the border with occupied territory.

Mayetta: It's already a PDZ headquarters, and now equally close to the occupied territories in the Draconis March and the Palmyra thumb.  A logical strategic C2 hub to coordinate AFFS's defense.  And thus also a logical target for Kuritan raids.

More worlds of importance on a thrust towards New Avalon from the Palmyra Thumb:
Augusta: Still a few jumps from the Palmyra Thumb, but should that thrust continue anti-spinward towards New Avalon this world should be one of the must-hold worlds for the AFFS.  I'm not sure if it's one of the 'Golden Five' worlds (or even if all 5 have ever been canonically named) but Corean's major mech plant on-world makes it a crucial world just on that basis. 

Former Republic worlds of importance
Quentin, Al Na'ir, Proserpina: All former Kurita worlds with important military facilities, and should be familiar to any long-time Kurita fans.  Theoretically close enough to Caleb's conquest of former Republic worlds to be hit by spoiling raids, or by the avenging RAF/ilClan boiling out from behind the fortress walls should they ever come down.

Ozawa: Once an important (if fleeting) possession of the Combine, coupled with still having relevant industries, Ozawa could be a wild card of a flash point despite being far from the obvious, 'main thrusts' from Robinson and Palmyra.  If some Warlord doesn't spark a new front to claim it, Julian may launch a Theodore-in-3039-like gambit into the reformed Dieron District from here.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Foxx Ital on 07 June 2013, 12:47:02
*gushs about the Ooze*  The Koroshiya isnt bad, very pretty to look at!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 07 June 2013, 12:58:42
More worlds of importance on a thrust towards New Avalon from the Palmyra Thumb:
Augusta: Still a few jumps from the Palmyra Thumb, but should that thrust continue anti-spinward towards New Avalon this world should be one of the must-hold worlds for the AFFS.  I'm not sure if it's one of the 'Golden Five' worlds (or even if all 5 have ever been canonically named) but Corean's major mech plant on-world makes it a crucial world just on that basis. 

Golden Five:
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 07 June 2013, 13:15:21
*Snip of awesome stuff*

Great job, Tai Dai Cultist! Reading through that is a bit of a shock, the Combine seems to have a lot of new manufacturing capability already and plenty more within reach.

Strike now and over-extend or consolidate and allow the Davions time to muster?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 07 June 2013, 13:20:32
@Tai Dai Cultist

Great job.

@All

Query: Do you think the DCMS is actually planning for taking New Avalon?

I know, it is a question of prestige and if there is anything that can motivate kurita generals it is prestige. But wouldn´t it only be a prime target, if you expect this to be a war that can actually resolve the Davion-Kurita enmity. A total victory, to use a suspect and overused term?

I am speaking of two things.
1.) Attacking New Avalon -will- trigger the Kentares Effect. (pretty self-explanatory, I guess.)

2.) Military theory rightfully places much emphasis on conquering your enemies´capital. You do not even have to break out your Clausewitz to understand that, it is intuitive. Occupy the capital, accept the capitulation, dictate your peace terms. The problem here is I very much doubt the Suns would ever capitulate. And never unconditionally. The DCMS holding a subjugated New Avalon might well find itself in the position of Napoleon in Moscow. You did everything right, you occupy the capital, yet the war just continues. And you know you haven´t got the resources to pacify ALL of the FedSuns. It is too big for that. As long as there are viable AFFS forces, they will just retreat deeper into the Crucis of even Periphery March. The logistics to wage a campaign -there- are a nightmare. An impossibility.

In practical terms I think the "Culmination Point of the Attack" would be way before the DCMS reaches New Avalon. In fact, I think the only possibility to completely overthrow House Davion would be to force the AFFS to a multi-year-long meatgrinder engagement with literally dozens of regiments to swap fresh formations for exhausted ones on New Avalon to ensure that -after that- the FedSuns have nothing left with which continuing resistance has any hope.
(Not leaving any hopes that the tables might turn somewhen in the future is what makes people agree to a shameful peace. Not the almost clerical act of occupying a certain world, even if it is the capital.)


But is completely overthrowing House Davion a realistic war goal? I think not. Strategically speaking I would advocate using the threat to jump to New Avalon as a bargaining chip. Occupy those staging areas coreward of the capital and consolidate. Beat off the first couple of counterattacks and make the Davions grovel on their bellies for a peace treaty.

------------------------------

And all of this doesn´t even factor in the Cappies. They will complicate things for sure, even in the best case scenarios where they will only squabble with the Dracs over the spoils of war. At worst they will make a quick and profitable peace with the Feddies just at that moment when the DCMS is at its most overextended state.
In fact might not the mutual distrust between the Liaos and the Kuritas, the very realistic expectation that the other one just might pull off such a stunt before yourself, actually trigger the "cheap solution" in the first place?

------------------------------

That being said...the Dracs are the Dracs. I wouldn´t like to be the poor guy that has to tell the DCMS generals: "Sorry folks, but the attack on New Avalon was postponed indefinitely. Hey what you´re doing that for? HEY! These Katanas are quite sharp, put it away, you could hurt someo....URGH GRGHL!"  #P
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 07 June 2013, 13:50:51
The current Kanrei is one crafty character.

I think the relationship between the Kanrei and the Coordinator will complicate matters. Yori's now very popular and can begin to flex her authority. If Toranaga sees her as a threat, especially as a threat to his well-being, the Combine may falter as it turns inwards. This may give the AFFS enough breathing room to recover and coordinate.

New Avalon is still a goal. That's where all the planning is done and it has plenty of industries.

I think that the Combine will take it in one surprise attack. Without central leadership the rest of the AFFS is easier to isolate.

The difference between a resurgence of Davion pride and indignation at having New Avalon occupied versus the Kentares Massacre is that Kuritan morale would be at astronomical levels. Can you imagine the sheer banzai-level of madness DCMS soldiers would have after hearing news the DCMS is now occupying the hated Davion's own capital?

Sure, the AFFS would be pissed. So would the average FedSuns citizen. But this time, the Kuritans aren't ashamed of themselves and hopefully aren't massacring civilians either. That was the real reason the Kentares Massacre was such a turning point; it hurt the DCMS's pride.

Now, if they do take that, then the Kanrei would know he'd need a massive occupation army to hold on to it. That makes it perfect as the rest of the AFFS now must choose between striking at New Avalon to retake it or striking elsewhere. That gives the rest of the DCMS time to rest and rotate troops, and begin taking those worlds TDC outlined above.

That's if they're that aggressive. All we know is that the AFFS is on the backfoot, but we don't know their actual numbers. We just know they're fighting on two fronts and haven't collapsed yet. So the situation above is a deadly gamble.

I think there'll be a few more large operations to seize targets too important to pass up, but the border will remain static.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 07 June 2013, 13:57:29
Valid points, but...

...
The difference between a resurgence of Davion pride and indignation at having New Avalon occupied versus the Kentares Massacre is that Kuritan morale would be at astronomical levels. Can you imagine the sheer banzai-level of madness DCMS soldiers would have after hearing news the DCMS is now occupying the hated Davion's own capital?
...
If I were a Kurita fan I would actually -fear- that level of banzai.

But that might just be one of the reasons I staked my claim at the other end of the Inner Sphere, happily petting my Tiger Hill stock and shake my fist towards Oriente in defiance.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 07 June 2013, 14:11:28
@Tai Dai Cultist

Great job.
Thanks :)
I like to obsess over things like that so I have plausible stories to explain the reasons behind even the most ephemeral of btech games.

Quote
@All

Query: Do you think the DCMS is actually planning for taking New Avalon?



I'd say they certainly are hoping to.  Whether our resident Tywin Lannister-nee-Toranaga actually is planning on being that successful, I don't know.  I'd find it rather titillating to think he might be.  The reasons we could fail are legion however, despite any planning.

I don't think the writers are going to have us take New Avalon, but if they did, my thoughts on how that might play out are here (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,29794.0.html).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 07 June 2013, 14:20:12
Valid points, but...
If I were a Kurita fan I would actually -fear- that level of banzai.

But that might just be one of the reasons I staked my claim at the other end of the Inner Sphere, happily petting my Tiger Hill stock and shake my fist towards Oriente in defiance.

It's all a matter of timing. If the Kanrei was coordinating (hah) this, the news of their victory would be a powerful tool. It probably won't demoralize the AFFS, just piss them off.

But the DCMS would get careless. They'll become arrogant, perhaps even negligent and think the war's almost over.

Hopefully, the officers would be able to keep a rein on their troops.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Fatebringer on 07 June 2013, 15:38:01
Looks like we Ravens are poised in the perfect spot to watch the eventual fireworks you cheeky monkeys are preparing for...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 07 June 2013, 16:19:06
Looks like we Ravens are poised in the perfect spot to watch the eventual fireworks you cheeky monkeys are preparing for...

and take advantage of it  ^-^ O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Wellard2006 on 08 June 2013, 09:11:02
Come on..Polish off the Fed Suns and then you can start the real work..Disassembling  the Cappies. Mind you that will never happen as the CC seems destined to beat everyone they fight..even when they lose.

Don't you just hate the CC fanboy tendency in the writing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 08 June 2013, 10:03:39
Come on..Polish off the Fed Suns and then you can start the real work..Disassembling  the Cappies. Mind you that will never happen as the CC seems destined to beat everyone they fight..even when they lose.

Don't you just hate the CC fanboy tendency in the writing.

If there's to be any whining in a Draconis Combine thread, it'll be about FM:Updates good sir!

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Wellard2006 on 08 June 2013, 10:17:42
Wasn't meant as a whine merely a statement of fact as I see it..I for one relish the change in the dynamic, after all when was the last time the DCMS and the CCAF faced off against each other in a proper knock down drag out fight.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: RyuWanderfalke on 08 June 2013, 11:09:31
I agree, as of late the CC seems like it can only be beaten by the even more fiat driven RotS. But meh, whatevs.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 08 June 2013, 14:24:43
I agree, as of late the CC seems like it can only be beaten by the even more fiat driven RotS. But meh, whatevs.

Because the Republic did such a good job of stopping the Capellans after the Blackout?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: RyuWanderfalke on 08 June 2013, 14:57:24
Well, I was more referring to the Republican era, where it was just a 1 on 1 and not a free for all.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 11 June 2013, 12:08:05
Just re-reading the original House Kurita book to reset my head-canon to actual canon. Can't believe I forgot about the Bureau of Bureaucracy!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormcrow on 11 June 2013, 12:21:15
Just re-reading the original House Kurita book to reset my head-canon to actual canon. Can't believe I forgot about the Bureau of Bureaucracy!
Now that is something I would expect to find in the German-based Lyran Commonwealth
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Coldwyn on 11 June 2013, 13:44:41
Now that is something I would expect to find in the German-based Lyran Commonwealth

Huh? How so?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormcrow on 11 June 2013, 14:06:59
The Germans may not have invented bureaucracy, but they seemed to have perfected it (or as close as humanity will ever get to it)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: RyuWanderfalke on 11 June 2013, 14:30:55
The Germans may not have invented bureaucracy, but they seemed to have perfected it (or as close as humanity will ever get to it)

I guess "perfected" was irony? :P
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 11 June 2013, 17:32:48
We deserve a Bureau of Bureaucracy since the Steiners stole the Social General schtick.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 12 June 2013, 14:41:24
Were we ever given names of the various Ministers?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: foxbat on 13 June 2013, 01:25:25

 [copper]
And let's all please get back on topic, ladies and gentlemen.
 [copper]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 13 June 2013, 15:24:47
Just reading Redemption Rift and caught a few "nods":

- Nathan Castle (Nathan Fillion, currently on the Castle TV show)
- Stark and Barton (Iron Man and Hawkeye, piloting a Legionnaire and a Quickdraw respectively)

That's what I've caught so far. There's a reactionary Kuritan element, some white knight Davions, and a lot of 'Mech stomping.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 27 June 2013, 15:26:59
Do we know who replaced Katana Tomark as Warlord Dieron?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 27 June 2013, 15:29:40
That hasn't been revealed yet.  I suspect it will be in FM 3145
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 28 June 2013, 11:22:24
Hope it's in FM:3145.

Have you guys had any chance to play around with the TR3145 DC stuff again?

I've been looking at it and I'm not finding my "groove" with the 'Mechs.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 02 July 2013, 22:43:10
Hope it's in FM:3145.

Have you guys had any chance to play around with the TR3145 DC stuff again?

I've been looking at it and I'm not finding my "groove" with the 'Mechs.

I'm still not getting the hang of making a Shiro make an impact on a game.

I do really like the Hitotsume Kozo, however.  It's not so hard to work the heat scale.  Jumping for the heat and shooting the ground early game is key!  Then the F.I.B. and heat dissipation work well to keep the heat relatively level, enjoying those very punchy TSM hatchet kama strikes.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 03 July 2013, 08:12:43
I'm still not getting the hang of making a Shiro make an impact on a game.

I do really like the Hitotsume Kozo, however.  It's not so hard to work the heat scale.  Jumping for the heat and shooting the ground early game is key!  Then the F.I.B. and heat dissipation work well to keep the heat relatively level, enjoying those very punchy TSM hatchet kama strikes.

Same.

In all honest? I've mentally written off most of the 'Mechs in TR3145 DC. Those, and the Scarborough II-series hover tanks.

The Hito is the one highlight of the bunch, and the Roku with the ER PPC is alright. But the BV on both make it very difficult to use in BV-balanced games. It's 2k for the Hito with a 4/5 pilot.

I dunno, am I the only one having trouble using the others?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 03 July 2013, 08:48:36
Same.

In all honest? I've mentally written off most of the 'Mechs in TR3145 DC. Those, and the Scarborough II-series hover tanks.

The Hito is the one highlight of the bunch, and the Roku with the ER PPC is alright. But the BV on both make it very difficult to use in BV-balanced games. It's 2k for the Hito with a 4/5 pilot.

Hovertanks
- they seemed "acceptable - that is, until Davions got the Zibler OmniHoverTank
Why use Saladin with SnPPC and Streak in the nose, when you can take Zibler C with SnPPC and twin MML-7s in turret?
Ditto for the Saracen.
Scimitar has five small lasers and SRMs - all front mounted. Nice, but Zibler Prime had a quartet of Mediums enhanced with the TC and trio of Streaks - all in the turret.

Cizin is good, as it is ClanTech.

To Sekhmet, I feel nothing - it's just a mobile twin Clan LPLs platform.

Walking eggs are boring, but Wendigo is at least using the ClanTech.

Exhumer is just a remake of the Ninja-To. It's funny that scrapping the MRMs was the first thing they did when they upgraded Ninja-To. And the other variant - three tons of SRM ammo when using 3*SRM-2s Seriously?

Medium Hitotsune costs as much as a low-end Assault 'Mech ...
Dragon II is perhaps an interesting 'Mech, but it's no replacement for classical Dragon/Grand Dragon series.
BV of Shiro is 2.500 and that's quite enough for what you get ...

And the rest ...

I dunno, am I the only one having trouble using the others?

No, you are not the only one.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 03 July 2013, 08:59:00
Oh thank Kerensky.

The DC TRO got saddled with too much of the Dark Age crap. I don't mean Dark Age crap as in everything Dark Age is crap. Just the crap of the Dark Age stuff.

Even in the Redemption Rift story they point out the FedSuns using Avalanches. Then suddenly it's a DCMS design. Even the Wendigo's not good enough compared to the original Black Hawk or Ryoken. And the Exhumer... 3 tons of SRM2s. Seriously...

The Dragon II feels like a Catapult to me. I can make use of it, but man, it feels like a waste. I dunno.

I went from hyped up to mildly hopeful to mostly disinterested after playing with them for weeks. I see no use for the hovers, the Kamakiri is powerful but it can and will go down. The Narukami I can put to some use. But otherwise? I'm bored with the BA designs already and I'll probably not use any of the 'Mechs.

Except the Hatamoto. Maybe. It has a decent payload but it's too slow to deliver most of it.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 03 July 2013, 10:19:57
my one game (*sigh*  :( ) so far had me with a Shiro, Rokurokubi, Hitostume-Kozo, and a Kamakiri, vs a Zibbler?, Centurion-0, Templar, and Atlas III. My hardened armor was not enough to overcome thier assault class armor. My force just did not have enough guns, especially since that damn Kamakiri never hit anything once with the iHeavy Gauss... Don't misunderstand I like that flying iHGR but if it does not hit...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 03 July 2013, 17:45:18
Yeah, we pay a premium for the mobility. I've used both Kamakiris and I prefer the standard variant. I got a headcap with the Shi Kamakiri but I had to fly close and lost it after that turn.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: MadCapellan on 03 July 2013, 19:16:44
my one game (*sigh*  :( ) so far had me with a Shiro, Rokurokubi, Hitostume-Kozo, and a Kamakiri, vs a Zibbler?, Centurion-0, Templar, and Atlas III. My hardened armor was not enough to overcome thier assault class armor. My force just did not have enough guns, especially since that damn Kamakiri never hit anything once with the iHeavy Gauss... Don't misunderstand I like that flying iHGR but if it does not hit...

I don't know if the problem is the designs.  Your force sounds horribly outmatched in terms of tonnage and armor.  Two Assaults, a Medium and a heavy hover vs. a Light, two Heavies and a VTOL sounds like a recipe for failure to me.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 03 July 2013, 20:34:09
I'm guessing it was BV balanced. Still the default method for most games. Also, all the designs are undergunned.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: MadCapellan on 03 July 2013, 20:53:33
I'm guessing it was BV balanced. Still the default method for most games.

That may be so, but I would certainly question such a lopsided match-up were it proposed to me.

Quote
Also, all the designs are undergunned.

Depends on what versions of the Shiro and Rokurokubi were used.  I certainly don't consider the Kamakiri or Hitotsume-Kozo underarmed.  Be that as it may, even if they possessed the average armament for their tonnage, I can't forsee them being able to make up for such a massive difference in equipment weight.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 04 July 2013, 02:13:02
BV balanced, 4 vs 4. My friend told me what his force's BV was so I matched it with mine, using the three new mechs I really wanted to use, with the Kamakiri thrown in. Yeah, the hardened armor was nice, but I could not put out enough damage. I think the Lance needs some non Hardened armor mechs just to have the tonnage for some guns. I used the Rokurokubi with the ERPPC because that is the new panther and I love it, no matter how it performs. The Shiro was the -1V. I am thinking of trying one swapping the LB-X for an ERPPC.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 04 July 2013, 05:22:59
The Dragon II feels like a Catapult to me. I can make use of it, but man, it feels like a waste. I dunno.


You know, when I first saw the Dragon II, I felt that I saw this 'Mech before. Just a experience of déjà vu. I knew that this TRO is new, but at the same moment I knew I met this 'Mech before and that it wasn't so long ago.

And then I got it. ☼  → PKM-2C Patriot.

Dragon II - ER PPC
Patriot - Heavy PPC

Dragon II - Arrow IV and 15 reloads
Patriot - Arrow IV and 20 reloads

Dragon II - Medium X-Pulse laser as back-up
Patriot - TAG and AMS

Dragon II - CASE II in the RT
Patriot - CASE in the RT

Dragon II - 12.5 tons of armor
Patriot - 12 tons of armor

The same 4/6 speed, the same number of double heat sinks 10(20).

The difference in BV is mere 100 points.

The IWM doesn't have to produce the mini of Dragon II. After all, they already manufacture the mini of Patriot. It even looks alike.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 04 July 2013, 06:09:17
Crispy crap on a cracker.

I didn't make the connection. Good one, martian.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 04 July 2013, 07:04:48
You know, when I first saw the Dragon II, I felt that I saw this 'Mech before. Just a experience of déjà vu. I knew that this TRO is new, but at the same moment I knew I met this 'Mech before and that it wasn't so long ago.

And then I got it. ☼  → PKM-2C Patriot.

Dragon II - ER PPC
Patriot - Heavy PPC

Dragon II - Arrow IV and 15 reloads
Patriot - Arrow IV and 20 reloads

Dragon II - Medium X-Pulse laser as back-up
Patriot - TAG and AMS

Dragon II - CASE II in the RT
Patriot - CASE in the RT

Dragon II - 12.5 tons of armor
Patriot - 12 tons of armor

The same 4/6 speed, the same number of double heat sinks 10(20).

The difference in BV is mere 100 points.

The IWM doesn't have to produce the mini of Dragon II. After all, they already manufacture the mini of Patriot. It even looks alike.

catalyst and IWM are two separate companies, I don't think there's a connection at all. I actually think it's been said by people who do stuff for catalyst (whoever that was and how important their words I can't remember) that design and art is not affected by mini production. So I'm not really sure this is a connection at all, except that perhaps the patriot had influence over the design of the dragon II. (and I don't know that it did)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 04 July 2013, 07:12:40
catalyst and IWM are two separate companies, I don't think there's a connection at all. I actually think it's been said by people who do stuff for catalyst (whoever that was and how important their words I can't remember) that design and art is not affected by mini production. So I'm not really sure this is a connection at all, except that perhaps the patriot had influence over the design of the dragon II. (and I don't know that it did)

I am sorry, the sentence about the miniature was just a (bad) joke, when I thought about proxies for unavailable miniatures.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 July 2013, 12:33:41
The more I play with the S-series hovers, the more I like them.

Saladin- this is the one that took me the longest to come around on, as it lacks the power of the AC/20 that defined the lowtech version.  But still, it can do as much as 18 points of damage a turn, so it's not that much lost firepower in exchange for capacity to do at least some damage beyond 9 hexes.. plus it gains crit-seeking capability.. gains a little speed, and most importantly gains a ton of survivability.

Saracen- easiest one to like.  Decent, flexible turreted firepower on a 10/15 chassis.

Scimitar- another that took me a while to appreciate.  Once I realized how pimp it is at making point blank runs on enemy vehicle sides rather than trying to be effective getting that close to mechs' legs, I saw the value.  It TMM and armor is enough to allow it to survive a pass against almost any vehicle, and that many hits from point blank range on side to-hit charts is going to always go well for you.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 09 July 2013, 06:52:47
The more I play with the S-series hovers, the more I like them.

I have them in 'my' merc regiment. In addition to be good machines, they have replacement part compatability, easing logistics for them.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 09 July 2013, 09:01:06
They're not terrible, but they're not especially good. Someone is still going to have to explain to me why the Scimitar has one ERSL and 4 standard SLs. And why it's a good idea to put short-ranged weapons on the front of a high-speed hovercraft instead of on the turret.

There's 2 tons on the turret, which can accommodate 5 tons. 5 small lasers are 2.5 tons.

They had to adhere to the Wizkids stats perhaps, but I don't have to like it or pretend it was a good design decision. Just because it can actually kill something sometimes isn't good enough.

What's the point of having 10/15 movement if I have to be both right next to something and/or pointed directly at it?

I'm glad you guys are putting them to good use.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 09 July 2013, 15:53:04
They're not terrible, but they're not especially good. Someone is still going to have to explain to me why the Scimitar has one ERSL and 4 standard SLs. And why it's a good idea to put short-ranged weapons on the front of a high-speed hovercraft instead of on the turret.

There's 2 tons on the turret, which can accommodate 5 tons. 5 small lasers are 2.5 tons.

They had to adhere to the Wizkids stats perhaps, but I don't have to like it or pretend it was a good design decision. Just because it can actually kill something sometimes isn't good enough.

What's the point of having 10/15 movement if I have to be both right next to something and/or pointed directly at it?

I'm glad you guys are putting them to good use.

While going with 5 ER smalls would be better since that'd be a nice perfect 10 heat, I chalk the 4/1 configuration up to a meta decision to design in some sub-optimal features.  Or, indeed it could be a clicky-tech stat they wanted to stick to.  Maybe ER small lasers are in short supply in the Combine and the tank can be produced faster/in greater numbers with the standard smalls.  Whatever the reason, since it also uses Machine Guns, ER smalls would be an extravagance that is almost a waste since it wants to get to point blank range anyway.

As for the turret, I'd rather put the SRM4 with the 360 fire arc, than the short range needlers.  I think that's reason enough to relegate the small guns to the Front Arc.  I see putting the point blank crit seekers in the front rather than the turret to be a good idea actually, as it forces me to take any lucky hits on the front to-hit chart, rather than giving me the opportunity to fall to the temptation to expose my own side to the victim as I make my pass.

They're not the end-all be-alls, and sure they might fall short of a Zibler in some comparisons.  But, they're A) cheaper and B) domestically produced.  Those are some hard-to-scoff advantages.   And, as the Zibler fluff indicates, it's not like it's an either or.. a DCMS hover force can very plausibly include Ziblers AND S-series tanks!

EDIT:  As a series they're not that great at anti-mech roles, but they're excellent tank hunters.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 09 July 2013, 19:12:01
If the Draconis Combine has a shortage of ER Small Lasers I'll eat hardened armour.  ;)

It would be nice to have the choice between maintaining high-speed and exposing myself to potential side hits or pointing my tank straight a something (more or less). It is limiting for a high speed tank, unnecessarily so.

The Scimitar is outdone by the Saracen in my eyes. The crit-seeking is a very niche thing, but the MML/7 an substitute for that in a pinch. You're risking most of it in one shot of course, but that's still 7 potential SRMs. Coupled with the two ER Medium Lasers, and you're hitting at short range when the SLs are still at long.

Damage-wise, the Saracen actually beats it out too. Yeah, you're rolling a lot more to-hits which will lead to more crits for sure. But that's such a niche thing and it requires the flimsy hovercraft to be near point-blank.

Does the Combine not make any Magshots? They weigh the same as a machine gun or small laser but have thrice the range. Each one's like an SRM1.

I know, I sound real petty niggling over the design. I'm not saying they can't be used, or even operate effectively, it's just that it's just so unnecessary. Contrived. I don't get why the DCMS is supposedly happy about these hovercraft. The Saracen's the only somewhat decent one out of the blend.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 09 July 2013, 20:05:34
If the Draconis Combine has a shortage of ER Small Lasers I'll eat hardened armour.  ;)

It would be nice to have the choice between maintaining high-speed and exposing myself to potential side hits or pointing my tank straight a something (more or less). It is limiting for a high speed tank, unnecessarily so.

I don't follow the logic.  When would you be able to get into point blank range side-to-side but not nose-to-side?  Why would you want to?

Quote
The Scimitar is outdone by the Saracen in my eyes. The crit-seeking is a very niche thing, but the MML/7 an substitute for that in a pinch. You're risking most of it in one shot of course, but that's still 7 potential SRMs. Coupled with the two ER Medium Lasers, and you're hitting at short range when the SLs are still at long.

Damage-wise, the Saracen actually beats it out too. Yeah, you're rolling a lot more to-hits which will lead to more crits for sure. But that's such a niche thing and it requires the flimsy hovercraft to be near point-blank.

I agree that a hover force should include more Saracens than Scimitars.  But that's because Saracens are all purpose while Scims are niche vehicle hunters.  If I've got enemy hovers harassing me, the Scimitar is a go-to unit for knocking the speed off that thing or immobilizing it outright.

Quote
Does the Combine not make any Magshots? They weigh the same as a machine gun or small laser but have thrice the range. Each one's like an SRM1.

I know, I sound real petty niggling over the design. I'm not saying they can't be used, or even operate effectively, it's just that it's just so unnecessary. Contrived. I don't get why the DCMS is supposedly happy about these hovercraft. The Saracen's the only somewhat decent one out of the blend.

There's something appropriately Soviet Kuritan about using cheap components in brutal tactics.

As for being happy with them.. I had to play with them to be convinced as I thought they looked pretty sad on paper.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 09 July 2013, 20:24:14
Maybe I'm spoiled by turrets on high-speed tanks, but I've gotten into the habit of pointing them away from their target. Or at least the direction I want to go the next turn. Typically, if they want to shoot the hovercraft, then I feel like I'm not doing a good job of supporting it with something scarier.

If these BV-cheap tanks are high priority targets, then something's off, in my mind.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 10 July 2013, 01:05:59
I don't follow the logic.  When would you be able to get into point blank range side-to-side but not nose-to-side?  Why would you want to?

How I understand it, assuming the same distance from the enemy you must cross, if the Scimitar has all those Small lasers in the nose, sometimes it will need additional MPs for the change of facing, just to align the nose with lasers against the enemy.

At least in my experiences I had this problem sometimes.

And do not forget that you know that you must get away with the Scimitar after the attack, so at the same moment you need its nose pointing away from the enemy.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 July 2013, 01:32:34
I can see what you're saying, but I'm not buying what you're selling.

Way I like to use the Scimitar is slashing 'kamikaze' runs at the sides of either an extra big-bootie'd tank or some fast harasser/ECM carrier.

In the case of the former, the 10/15 speed is such that which way I'm pointing is moot.. assuming I wasn't immobilized on the attack run next turn I've got such speed it doesn't matter that I'm pointing right at him.

It's much the same in the case of the latter.  After a good raking on the side chart, that enemy hover won't be going nearly as fast as my Scim, if it's even able to move at all.  Any of my units can dispatch the little nuisance from there.

Edit:  You know, for all the talk about how the Saracen is better in general terms than the Scimitar.. you know what's perfect for killing a Saracen?  A Scimitar :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 10 July 2013, 01:50:40
I can see what you're saying, but I'm not buying what you're selling.

Way I like to use the Scimitar is slashing 'kamikaze' runs at the sides of either an extra big-bootie'd tank or some fast harasser/ECM carrier.

In the case of the former, the 10/15 speed is such that which way I'm pointing is moot.. assuming I wasn't immobilized on the attack run next turn I've got such speed it doesn't matter that I'm pointing right at him.

It's much the same in the case of the latter.  After a good raking on the side chart, that enemy hover won't be going nearly as fast as my Scim, if it's even able to move at all.  Any of my units can dispatch the little nuisance from there.

This is the problem. Why do you assume that the enemy has no additional units and that he allows you to undertake those slashing attacks without punishment? If he manages to position one of his units at the sides or behind your Scimitar, then Scimitar's Small lasers are useless.

You know, House Davion has the Fireball moving 11/17 (and one version with MASC 11/17(22). And do not forget 12/18 Locusts. Or very fast Dart with three lasers.

As occasional FWL player I am glad for the Zibler Prime.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 10 July 2013, 07:23:14
The additional units will punish any Scimitar that's dedicated to taking out a priority target...but those same additional units will also punish a turreted tank trying to do the same thing. It wont make a huge difference in the hover's tactics unless you're just going after targets of convenience.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 10 July 2013, 07:55:34
It kinda does matter, since I'm forced to spend MP bringing my really short-ranged weapons to bear instead of using it for maneuvering.

10/15 is not that fast. The Davions' new light 'Mechs both match and can even exceed that. Other hovercraft can be just as swift.

I can see what you're saying, but I'm not buying what you're selling.

Way I like to use the Scimitar is slashing 'kamikaze' runs at the sides of either an extra big-bootie'd tank or some fast harasser/ECM carrier.

In the case of the former, the 10/15 speed is such that which way I'm pointing is moot.. assuming I wasn't immobilized on the attack run next turn I've got such speed it doesn't matter that I'm pointing right at him.

It's much the same in the case of the latter.  After a good raking on the side chart, that enemy hover won't be going nearly as fast as my Scim, if it's even able to move at all.  Any of my units can dispatch the little nuisance from there.

Edit:  You know, for all the talk about how the Saracen is better in general terms than the Scimitar.. you know what's perfect for killing a Saracen?  A Scimitar :)

The hell it is. That is, I respectfully disagree.  O0

A Scimitar's going to be screwed every single time it loses initiative because it won't be able to direct the bulk of its so-called critseeking fire at the target.

The Saracen can stay at any range it wants. It can open up the distance on the turns it loses init, and close to medium if it needs to.

Any machine can be good enough if you just kamikaze it. I'm guilty of that. Even so, it costs the design absolutely nothing to swap to ER SLs or to move the SLs into the turret. If the turret gets locked, odds are the damn thing is about to die anyway.

I guess it's a matter of playstyles and gaming experiences.

EDIT:

I have taken these out. All of them, even the Shelly. I got kills with them, but at the cost of the tanks themselves.

So I'm not arguing from purely a theoretical perspective.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 July 2013, 09:32:08
I guess it's a matter of playstyles and gaming experiences.

I think so.  Yes, a Scim is certainly vulnerable to enemy hover-hunters.  But if I lose my Scim critting the heck out of a Behemoth, I'd consider that a trade in my favor.  I think the play experience is coloring our perspectives on the nose-only attack run thing.  I haven't found it to be much of a consideration.  If I can get to range 1, I can get there facing whichever way I want virtually all the time since I have to be pointing nose-at-it anyway to approach.  And even if the conditions were just right to go side-to-side but 1 MP short of turning the nose in, then that's not the turn for the attack run.  It's a conditional attack anyway.. it comes in like a remora rather than a shark.  It relies on the victim (and if applicable, its nearby comrades) having to choose between shooting at the little ninja or at my mechs ideally in another firing arc.  The time isn't right for an attack run every turn.


If my Scim and YOUR unit with a mirror role both stay out of the fight because we both wait for the other to commit and become open for a strike.. then that's ALSO a win.  My Scim probably had the lower BV value.   And that's also why I don't think you ever need more than 1 or 2 Scims.. they spend most of the game lurking on the flanks of my force waiting to pounce rather than barraging with support fire like a Saracen or even a Saladin.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 10 July 2013, 09:58:58
I understand the criticism.  The original Saladins at least had the 3/6/9 range of the AC20 to play with some arcs and range.  Front mounted SLs require you to drive right up to the enemy, which is far less forgiving.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 July 2013, 10:33:07
I understand the criticism.  The original Saladins at least had the 3/6/9 range of the AC20 to play with some arcs and range.  Front mounted SLs require you to drive right up to the enemy, which is far less forgiving.

Well the Saladin MkII drops the AC/20 for a Snub-PPC and Streak SRM4.  Nearly the same (slight downgrade) in overall firepower, but gaining flexibility and range.  Since the Scimitar gets crits so much easier, despite having to get to point blank range, I didn't think the Saladin had much to do until I realized it's the one that does anti-mech work.  I miss the AC20, but it can circle of death the target at 9 hexes and bleed it out, especially if it's already got bigger fish to worry about.

The Scimitar is the one that changed so much in firepower its entire role changed.   It went from turreted AC/5 & Twin SRM2s to a completely different loadout.. going from general fire support to dedicated hamstring-seeker.

EDIT:  It does have a variant that is very similar in armament and spirit to the original Scimitar.. the variant has turreted LPCC & SRM4.  It trades out the ECM for a Boosted C3 slave.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 10 July 2013, 10:55:48
Yes, but the role the original Saladin occupied is now held by the SM1 Tank Destroyer.

As for the scimitar... there was the original AC5 model and the later RAC2 model.  Neither really made an impression on me.  Not the same way the TAG version had.  I'm not overly thrilled by the Scimitar II, but for different reasons.  I'd rather have the old TAG version.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 July 2013, 11:03:50
Yes, but the role the original Saladin occupied is now held by the SM1 Tank Destroyer.

As for the scimitar... there was the original AC5 model and the later RAC2 model.  Neither really made an impression on me.  Not the same way the TAG version had.  I'm not overly thrilled by the Scimitar II, but for different reasons.  I'd rather have the old TAG version.

I find myself wishing the X-Pulse Pegasus from prototypes came with TAG.  Still between that and the MkIIs and the SM1 series, the DCMS has some very nice hover options.  It's tempting to try to make an all-hovers force work.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 10 July 2013, 11:21:06
The SM1 is, essentially, the Saladin II. The SM1A does a great job of critseeking as well with an LBX-20.

Phallic jokes aside, the Tank Destroyer is great. BV-wise, it's expensive. You can get two or three hovercraft for one of them.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 16 July 2013, 12:06:58
I happened to notice a Combine world lost during the Succession Wars on a Star League era map.

Dunklewälderdunklerflüssenschattenwelt

Epic name is epic.  We sooo need to recolonize that place just to put the name back on the map.

(although, on second thought, it'd be inside the Raven Alliance now.  better to leave it dead than let a Clan hold something so awesome.)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 16 July 2013, 12:18:20
Epic name has wrong grammar.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 17 July 2013, 13:04:13
I think it also got canonically renamed to Bob.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 17 July 2013, 13:12:06
Wait.  Who died and made you...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 17 July 2013, 16:26:03
I think it also got canonically renamed to Bob.

Regrettably, people spell it backwards all the time.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 17 July 2013, 17:24:26
Ahh, Planet boB. No place quite like it.

In other, more Dragon-relevant, musings... Which District Regularss do you guys like? I mean, we always hear about the Genyosha, the Ghosts, the Ryuken, etc. But it's the Regulars that make up the DCMS.

Share which regiment, why, and what era if applicable.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 17 July 2013, 20:55:31
Ahh, Planet boB. No place quite like it.

In other, more Dragon-relevant, musings... Which District Regularss do you guys like? I mean, we always hear about the Genyosha, the Ghosts, the Ryuken, etc. But it's the Regulars that make up the DCMS.

Share which regiment, why, and what era if applicable.

I have a special affinity for the 18th Dieron, one that goes back to the heady days of 1987 when all was right with BattleTech.

I picked them as a sentimental favorite largely because of how they were depicted in the original House Kurita sourcebook.  One, they're a Heavy regiment.  Two, they're elite.  Three, their nickname was "Pride of Dieron", named after the capital of the most awesome District.  Four, they had a cool specialty.  Urban Combat!  Not only is that interesting, as the Succession Wars' informal code of Chivalry was revealed, specializing in 'naughty combat' seemed even MORE awesome.  Five, and possibly most important, they were 'mere' District Regulars and so I had 'my own' regiment to brag about and could distinguish myself from other Kurita fanboys.   "You keep the Sword of Light or the Proserpina Hussars.  I'll take the 18th Dieron Regulars any day of the week!"*

*note- there were no Genyosha or Ryuken to have fans yet at that time

So, as the plot changed gears from a status quo presentation to ongoing story, I got to see my chosen favorite partake in the events of the Inner Sphere.  The 18th's kicking of ass and taking of names (defeated an entire RCT, PLUS an additional merc regiment, all tasked specificially with destroying the 18th) was one of the all-too-few bright spots for the Combine in the 4th Succession War.

I got treated to the 18th repeating the performance in the next story jump through the War of 3039.  Again, another RCT augmented by another merc mech regiment were not up to the task and were sent packing in defeat.

With two dominating victories in two wars, I was treated to a third story in the Clan Invasion.  They fought the Cats hard enough to require the full weight of Beta Galaxy to force a final last stand, which sadly their orders mandated rather than bleeding the Cats prior to retreat.  Which you know they oh so could have done so thoroughly.

I had long considered them a martyr of the Clan era, but with the Dark Age's reconstitution of the brigade of Dieron District Regulars, I'm hopeful that the colors of the 18th will be among those restored.  May the Pride of Dieron strike fear into the Dragon's enemies again!

The grognard nature of the 5th Galedon is also beginning to appeal to me in the Dark Age era, but they're Johnny Come Lately's after the 18th Dieron :)
I also need to shout out to the long-lost 5th Rasalhague.  Not only did they have the magic number, they had the best ever nickname/specialty. "The Crushers of Insurrections" specialized in crowd control.  Was there ever a better use for a mech regiment than that?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 18 July 2013, 03:52:53
Which District Regularss do you guys like? I mean, we always hear about the Genyosha, the Ghosts, the Ryuken, etc. But it's the Regulars that make up the DCMS.

Share which regiment, why, and what era if applicable.

46th Dieron Regulars

- the Clan Invasion era.
- and although they are non-canon, they figured in four canon publications, two of those products have been CGL-branded   ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 18 July 2013, 04:14:28
For me it was the 15th Benjamin Regulars 'Tribute to the Unproductive'
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Heregar on 18 July 2013, 08:17:23
Ahh, Planet boB. No place quite like it.

In other, more Dragon-relevant, musings... Which District Regularss do you guys like? I mean, we always hear about the Genyosha, the Ghosts, the Ryuken, etc. But it's the Regulars that make up the DCMS.

Share which regiment, why, and what era if applicable.
I really like all the Dieron Regulars, I am really quite found of the 3rd. Yet my favorite Regulars has to be the 3rd Benjamin and the 8th along with the 17th Galedon Regulars. I was never found of elite units and these units have great SW history and action, plus in the "future" clan invasion the 3rd on asgard is very satisfying.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 20 July 2013, 04:48:38
I was a fan of both the 3rd Benjamin Regulars and the 22nd Dieron Regulars ever since I first got FM: DC (one of the first two FMs I ever got), due to their write-ups in the FM. I especially liked their armored forces (Rook's Armored Wall with the 3rd and the Devil Dogs with the 22nd), mostly due to the fact that they were elite armored units in a military that alternately ignored and despised them.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Heregar on 20 July 2013, 12:44:29
I forgot to mention that I would love the Rasalhague Regulars and the old Alshain Regulars but info is scattered and there is a lack of it. Talking about info when is our long over due house book going to be released?

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 20 July 2013, 12:48:35
I forgot to mention that I would love the Rasalhague Regulars and the old Alshain Regulars but info is scattered and there is a lack of it. Talking about info when is our long over due house book going to be released?

Handbook: House Kurita will be published in 2014 (perhaps).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Heregar on 20 July 2013, 12:56:17
2012 then 2013 now 2014.... well I shall be patient. I do pray that is in the same time frame as the others with NO advancements into the newer eras.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 20 July 2013, 13:06:22
Handbook: House Kurita will be published in 2014 (perhaps).

It was actually published in the thirteenth month of 2012, in a very limited release.  Supplies were damaged due to the lousy Smarch weather.  I attempted to get one, but I was hit by a flying yak.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 20 July 2013, 13:07:15
2012 then 2013 now 2014.... well I shall be patient. I do pray that is in the same time frame as the others with NO advancements into the newer eras.

Yes, it will be set in 3067 or so.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 20 July 2013, 13:12:00
Yes, it will be set in 3067 or so.

Actually I believe it may be published in 3067.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 21 July 2013, 21:38:13
I was always a free floater as they weren't as hide bound as the SoL or the Galdeon boys. My second love was the 2nd Dieron though. My friends were Steiner and Davions so it was fun to beat the Wall of Steel with light mechs. I did prefer the Dieron over the other district forces though. Galdeon was to hide bound, Benjamin the forgotten middle child, Pesht Regulars were pirate hunters and they wasn't any good pirates in the Rift, the the Rasalhague boys--I couldn't decide if they were good or red headed step children. It was fun to fight Steiner with heavies but the Dieron Regulars were the best. I'd say better than the SoL. They had local pride and you could fluff some as Hegemony leftovers.

I have a unit of the starter mechs painted forest camo with red right arms that I call Ichi Company (The Red Arms), 2nd Battalion, 2nd Dieron Regulars. I use them as an opfor for my kids forces. They too like the heavies and assaults and its fun to win with Spiders, Jenners and Panthers. I need to do a 3050/3067 and Jihad version. I just hope the 2nd didn't get wiped out in the DA when they became the 2nd New Samarkand Regulars, since some of those don't exist anymore.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Daishi411 on 21 July 2013, 22:13:04
There are a good few that i like but the first one that comes to mind in the 3rd Benjamin. They surprised everyone on asgard and embarased the jags with old equipment to the point that they didn't even want to continue pursuit. And also as Kojak said their armour is the coolest part of the unit, and are seriously badass!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Heregar on 22 July 2013, 07:23:32
There are a good few that i like but the first one that comes to mind in the 3rd Benjamin. They surprised everyone on asgard and embarased the jags with old equipment to the point that they didn't even want to continue pursuit. And also as Kojak said their armour is the coolest part of the unit, and are seriously badass!
Agreed! They fought like true warriors  >:D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 12 August 2013, 17:47:21
Dragon's loots from the Clan TRO 3145:

Constable Pacification Suit- Anti-insurgent battle armor imported from the Dominion for use by the ISF & Civilian Guidance Corps
Skadi Swift Attack VTOL - Lyrans exported it to entire Inner Sphere during the decades they held Pandora
Skanda Light Tank - Ditto as above
Gravedigger - Exported heavily by the Dominion.  Combine wasn't mentioned specifically as a noteworthy importer, but its battle history includes a story of one being claimed by the Combine.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 28 August 2013, 13:46:04
I was a fan of both the 3rd Benjamin Regulars and the 22nd Dieron Regulars
22nd Dieron is a cute bunch, and knows how to use its assets.  I imagine they're heavily specced in close-range work.
46th Dieron Regulars - and although they are non-canon, they figured in three canon publications, two of those products have been CGL-branded   ;)
Okay, I'm curious.  Do tell?

And I want to chime in with the 7th Pesht, for being slacker jello salad out in the middle of nowhere.  The fact that they send all their good troops off to real regiments makes me think of a force stacked with kids and old folks that just shuffles giant mechs around on parade, more like a demonstration unit than anything else.  Everything painted up all spiffy and creative, more like a 'Mech show than a 'Mech regiment.

I would have loved to see the 22nd Benjamin go on further, but they apparently get wiped out in their first showing on Marduk.  A unit that takes all the old secondline gear once the star league upgrades come out, and has factory access and orders to "make effective units" would have been fascinating.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 28 August 2013, 14:40:29
Which District Regularss do you guys like? I mean, we always hear about the Genyosha, the Ghosts, the Ryuken, etc. But it's the Regulars that make up the DCMS.

Share which regiment, why, and what era if applicable.
46th Dieron Regulars
- the Clan Invasion era.
- and although they are non-canon, they figured in three canon publications, two of those products have been CGL-branded   ;)
Okay, I'm curious.  Do tell?

Well, there is not much to tell.

Of all District Regulars, I have always like the Dieron Regulars. When I read the FedCom Civil War sourcebook, those 46th Dieron Regulars were mentioned on half a dozen places - beginning with their formation, continuing with their victory over the 1st Robinson Rangers, etc.
My impression about them was very good. They were pretty solid unit, mostly veterans, but neither a cannon fodder as some other Combine units, nor a super-elite unit such as the Genyosha.

My feeling was similar as when I read about the forming and training of 109. Infantry Division of the Imperial Japanese Army (on Iwo Jima). You know the moment, when even the most traditionalist generals come to the conclusion that fanaticism to the exclusion of everything else might not be the best solution, and instead of ordering their men to commit Banzai charges (real world) or one-on-one duels (BattleTech universe), they order them to "think out and use some working tactics".
----------------------------------------------------------------
I was eager to learn more about this interesting unit - and I found a short mention in the new Technical Readout: 3058 Upgrade. (the Pilum Heavy Tank entry)
----------------------------------------------------------------
The Field Manual: Draconis Combine had nothing, but it was understandable, as this document was from 3058 and the 46th Dieron Regulars were formed two or three years later.
I hoped that I may find something in the Field Manual: Updates (in-universe date 3067), and in a certain sense, I really found something.

The 46th Dieron Regulars were not listed among active units, but there wasn't a single word about their destruction. As if this fully fleshed-out regiment never existed.
And yet, they were mentioned in the 1st Ghost Regiment entry, when they helepd to reclaim Proserpina for the Draconis Combine.
----------------------------------------------------------------
But they were mentioned again, in a quite recent BattleCorps story "Epaulet Matte".

I thought that they might be "missing-in-action" and hiding somewhere, just as the 5th FedCom RCT disappeared and was hiding in the Periphery for years, to save the day during the Jihad.
----------------------------------------------------------------
But when nothing happened, I asked a question here and got the answer: Sorry, the 46th are not canon.

So, they are my personal unit.  ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 28 August 2013, 15:46:55
Nice explanation Martian, the unit that got me hooked on the FWL are similar appearing in 1 FASA era product but nothing else.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 28 August 2013, 15:52:06
Sigh, now I'm gonna have to find another one that isn't canon like that!  Great idea.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 28 August 2013, 20:53:57
Hey there. Long time listener, first time caller here on The Dragon's Lair Coast to Coast! ...Actually, I'm a first time listener too.

The last time I followed the Combine in any detail, it was 3055-ish; they were shown as a very stern, authoritarian society that was nonetheless effective at protecting their people from numerous threats and were busy getting victor steiner-davion addicted to anime (or whatever it is they did to make him start acting like an otaku), hampered by some internal troubles and problems with their military industry being unable to make things like Double Heatsinks or CASE. They were basically "Previously Evil, but reforming into Effective Neutral with some harshness still present" back then.

In very quick summary, what are they like in 3145? What is their society basically like, what are the faction's goals and who are their enemies? Any neat 'Mechs they have acquired recently? How do they feel about mercenaries now?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 28 August 2013, 21:23:07
Hey there. Long time listener, first time caller here on The Dragon's Lair Coast to Coast! ...Actually, I'm a first time listener too.

The last time I followed the Combine in any detail, it was 3055-ish; they were shown as a very stern, authoritarian society that was nonetheless effective at protecting their people from numerous threats and were busy getting victor steiner-davion addicted to anime (or whatever it is they did to make him start acting like an otaku), hampered by some internal troubles and problems with their military industry being unable to make things like Double Heatsinks or CASE. They were basically "Previously Evil, but reforming into Effective Neutral with some harshness still present" back then.

In very quick summary, what are they like in 3145? What is their society basically like, what are the faction's goals and who are their enemies? Any neat 'Mechs they have acquired recently? How do they feel about mercenaries now?

They've put their black hats back on.  It's back to 3025, in a sense.  It is once again the Combine's destiny to rule all of mankind.  Whether they accomplish it or not is another story.. but militarily they're doing rather well in 3145.  So well that Kurita fans are more anxious than elated it seems.. as the other shoe must be about to drop..
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 28 August 2013, 22:02:28
Oh boy. So if I'm understanding that right, they're back to "talk about honor honor honor all the time while simultaneously having a very vague definition of what honor actually is" and "kill everyone else" behavior right out of the worst stereotypes from the 1980s? That's kind of how they were back in 3025 and this bothered me a lot.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 28 August 2013, 22:48:27
I am not sure about that portrayal. But we do have a lot of cool hardened armor mechs! The 35t Rokurokubi is my favorite! 7/10 with and ERPPC and sword, and more (effective) armor than most medium mechs, it is everything a modern Panther pilot needs. While many of Theodore's reforms seem to have been officially abandoned. I believe the modern DCMS fights more like the Ryuken of old. combined fire (C3), artillery, and combined arms are okay, but use the occasional duels to keep up personal honor.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 29 August 2013, 02:08:01
The Rokurokubi was one of the major things that made me stop by to want to learn more about the current Combine. It looks neat and effective.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 29 August 2013, 04:17:00
It makes you wonder if the Combine would be interested in still honoring the Kapyten accords and letting us import a few companies.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 29 August 2013, 05:14:47
It makes you wonder if the Combine would be interested in still honoring the Kapyten accords and letting us import a few companies.

You know, I thought about it - and I think it may be quite possible. Think about it: The Draconis Combine had one big problem between 2780 and 3050 and again between 3085 and 3140 - the Lyran Commonwealth. Of course, there have been the Clans, FedSuns, etc., but the Combine generals could never not ignore the Lyrans on the border. 

Why did the Coordinator sign the Treaty of Kapteyn? Because it meant that acquiring one Draconis ally on the other side of the Lyran Commonwealth would relieve the pressure/threat of the LCAF against the Draconis Combine. And, when you think about it, the situation has been the same in the Dark Age. The Draconis Combine still borders with the Lyran Commonwealth, and the Free Worlds League (or some states such as the MSC, Oriente and Tamarind) may still act as the counterbalance of sorts against the Lyrans.

Even from the geopolitical view the Draconis Combine should try to keep the Lyrans in the FWL in check. And, since the Lyrans sell BattleMechs to the Regulans, again it would make sense for the Combine to sell Draconis 'Mechs to those FWL provinces that are hostile towards the Lyrans and the Regulans. And as I mentioned above, I have two provinces in mind:
a) the MSC - it is the primary target of the Lyran aggression (together with the Tamarind), so it's in the best interest of the Draconis government to support it. Because as long as the LCAF is busy there, it doesn't have enough forces to harass the Combine.
b) the Oriente Protectorate - we know that there has been some ties between the DC and the Oriente. I remember that the Orienet has manufactured the PXH-7K Phoenix Hawk. The Phoenix Hawk L and SD1-O Sunder seem to suggest continuing cooperation too.

To summarize it, I would say that it may possible to see some more common non-premiere Draconis 'Mechs in the MSC or Oriente service. No Shiro, but something as the Thunder Fox, Grasshopper, Komodo, Cerberus - this kind of stuff.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 29 August 2013, 15:08:06
We know the cooperation between the realms continued long after the 4th Succession War.  The AWS-10KM for example is a cooperative effort featuring then cutting edge tech.  The PXH-7K was also built with export to the DCMS in mind, but it fell through, to the League's crazy benefit.  And, let's not forget that Imperator exports standard, LBX and Ultra ACs, as well as Gauss Rifle to the Dragon for all those Wolf Traps, Maulers and Atlases.

It's a strange relationship, the League and the Combine, but it has worked out nicely. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 29 August 2013, 15:10:35
I consider it mostly a pen pal relationship. With the occasional bank transfer.

Which suits both sides best, I guess. I like the Dracs at the other end of the Inner Sphere.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 29 August 2013, 21:09:06
I'd be all for the FWL and Combine expanding their tech/'Mech sharing. Both are fun to play as-is, but if they were to share certain machines from recent books with one another that would make them even more interesting.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Dies Irae on 29 August 2013, 21:30:38
I consider it mostly a pen pal relationship. With the occasional bank transfer.

Which suits both sides best, I guess. I like the Dracs at the other end of the Inner Sphere.

"We like you. We'll oppress you last."
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 29 August 2013, 23:49:48
In very quick summary, what are they like in 3145? What is their society basically like, what are the faction's goals and who are their enemies? Any neat 'Mechs they have acquired recently? How do they feel about mercenaries now?
Definitively fascist with a focus on the military.  Note that that's the classical definition of fascism, rather than the perjorative; a unified monoculture (with a slim few exceptions that are more or less on their own at this point) with a very strong ideology of conquest and a re-formed Star League with a dragon for a banner.  Still based very heavily on Edo-period Japan as far as society, with obvious exceptions allowing for more modern technology.  Samurai ethos, honor above a lot, and an acceptance of Theodore's reforms to reflect the honor of the Dragon prime above all.

They're still superior jerks, and are finally getting around to proving the Sandovals half-right, and get lots of really spiffy toys in 3145 - especially the Davion toys, like the Atlas III and Black Knight.  As far as the doomsayers go, personally I'm not waiting for the other shoe to drop and "oh no we are fiatted into nothing again." I'm looking forward to a rampaging Draconis Combine - and I imagine it'll last for a while, before it's the Kuritans' turn in the meat grinder once more.  And I can accept that, because hey - empires rise and fall, everyone has success and everyone has defeats. 

The fun part is surviving the defeats and coming back more awesome than ever, rather than turning into Peacetech.  I'm frankly glad the Sandovals were nuts; Omi and Victor becoming a serious thing would have been disastrous for the game.  And now that Yori's the Coordinator I can't wait to see what she'll do.

Also, Tenshi omnimechs.  Because hell yeah.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 30 August 2013, 01:47:55
Interesting. So basically "glory to the Dragon!", but not plainly cruel to their citizenry... just very rigid? Would something like comparing them to 1940s militaristic Japan, with some aspects of modern Japan's general society, be about right?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 30 August 2013, 04:09:23
"We like you. We'll oppress you last."

Here is a leaflet with useful information about how to abuse and eradicate a pet clan.


Interesting. So basically "glory to the Dragon!", but not plainly cruel to their citizenry... just very rigid? Would something like comparing them to 1940s militaristic Japan, with some aspects of modern Japan's general society, be about right?

Not sure if this is an apt comparison. I think it a fallacy to imagine a historic society (or an amalgation of different ones) and just transplanting it into the 32st century. To begin with the whole Edo-Japan style as a guideline wasn´t present from the beginnings of the Combine. It was introduced later and (maybe like the Marian Hegemony) based mostly on misconceptions and reinterpretations that come along with any pop-culture. In other words the first things that come to mind when you think about specific historic timelines were not neccessarily the dominating factors for those actually living in those times. I am not trying to pretend I am an expert on japanese history here, but the simple fact that it was a conciously adopted theme for a modern society that had little direct connection to its model practically guarantees misinterpretations by the combine citizenry and leadership.

In total I would paint the Draconis Combine as a military dictatorship that personifies the state (the "Dragon") as a quasi-transcendent entity and derives its ideology starting from that point.

I could start with comparisons to Hobbes´ Leviathan, but I think this would go too far and invites half-baked political philosophical controversies (because he too was subject to "pop-culture-isations") that are surely out of bounds of a forum post and therefore misleading, at best.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 30 August 2013, 07:40:54
That's cool. So, to backtrack a bit... mercenaries in the Combine in 3145? Does this even happen? I know traditionally they have worked with very few, sometimes no, merc units. How about now?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 30 August 2013, 07:46:57
That's cool. So, to backtrack a bit... mercenaries in the Combine in 3145? Does this even happen? I know traditionally they have worked with very few, sometimes no, merc units. How about now?

Wolf's Dragoons.  That's the major one.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 30 August 2013, 08:28:41
Yeah, mercenaries were also working for the Combine prior to the Jihad.  After Teddy took over the attitudes normalized again.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 30 August 2013, 08:59:12
Right now, i think the Wolf's Dragoons are half the reason for the successes of the DCMS against the Sandovals.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 30 August 2013, 09:55:49
Right now, i think the Wolf's Dragoons are half the reason for the successes of the DCMS against the Sandovals.

Maybe not so much as half. But certainly without the Dragoons the circumstances for the fall of Robinson wouldn't have occurred. 

The Dragoons were the tipping point that ended the stalemate for control of the Draconis Reach in the Combine's favor.  Then it took the perfect storm of the Dragoons & Ryuken holding the Reach against the Sandovals while simultaneously Caleb Davion denies any extra support to retaking the territory.    Once the Draconis March forces were exhausted, the DCMS was finally done being preoccupied with retaking the Dieron District and putting down the Tormark/Nova Cat rebellion.  DCMS, fresh off several successful campaigns versus the exhausted AFFS that is licking its wounds.  Small wonder the Draconis March is largely Kurita territory now. 

The Dragoons didn't make it all happen, but it wouldn't have happened without them.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 30 August 2013, 10:04:36
Interesting. So basically "glory to the Dragon!", but not plainly cruel to their citizenry... just very rigid? Would something like comparing them to 1940s militaristic Japan, with some aspects of modern Japan's general society, be about right?
There are similarities to Imperial Japan, in the pro-military "all glory to the samurai" mindset.  But it's also a thousand years divorced from that time period, so just like the romanticised vew we have of the medieval era and the Knights In Armor and whatnot, there's going to be a similarly inaccurate view of the Edo period for the Kuritans.

Now, pointedly, we don't yet have the Handbook out, so this is all secondhand from the Field Manuals and novels.  But I'd say culturally there's a lot of appreciation and emulation of the old era, with allowances made for things like modern technologies - there'd probably be a lot of jidaigeki films (including Seven Samurai for obvious reasons) but there'd be a ton of remakes and whatnot with battlemechs.  Take a lot of the conceptual ideology and apply it to modern settings - and make sure EVERYONE stays in line.  That's what the ISF is for...

PS: And having flipped through the Regulars again, 10th Pesht is where it's at for me.  And they're still around in the post-Jihad era, so here's hoping they survive 3145!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 30 August 2013, 14:33:14
I for one am sad that our "western" border is now all Ghost Bears all the time. I'll miss the Lyrans. Port Moseby is ours though!

I for one am liking the new DCMS. Its how I always envisioned it. I understand the cult of the Mechwarrior/Samurai but one cannot forget the other arms as well. The modern (3145) DCMS gets this. I also like our new use of mercs. I hope more come along.

I am excited for FM3145 to see two things:

1. If the 2nd Dieron are back, if they're still the 2nd New Samarkand Regulars or if they were one of the NSR units that were purged around 3110.
2. If the Proserpina Hussar brigade has been reconsituted or if my 3rd Hussars are still the 3rd Pesht Regulars.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 31 August 2013, 02:03:42
Thanks for the info! If it's okay, I have a few more curiosities?

Are there any interesting line-service (e.g. non-Elite) units, or underdogs? For an example of the latter, back in 3050 it was noted that the 5th Sword of Light was forced to rebuild from less-than-noble family lines, technicians from a variety of backgrounds, and accept far more female pilots than the society of the time would normally think proper. I thought that was neat; a relatively 'ragtag' group rising up to the challenge of living up to elite/famous regiment standards, and doing so while simultaneously rejecting and embracing said cultural norms.

Any sort of interesting regiments like that in 3145?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 31 August 2013, 13:25:15
Any sort of interesting regiments like that in 3145?
Right now we only have data on four regiments.  Ryuken-go's big thing is leading the assault into the AFFS alongside Wolf's Dragoons; they were about the only unit that went bro-fist with the Dragoons when they were hired and welcomed their former originators, later bagging Duke Sandoval on Robinson.  The 5th SoL kicked Bear butt for a while in the Second Dom-Com war, then turned out the lights on the Nova Cats, so they're probably rolling in Clan tech; it might be why they were instrumental in beating the pants off the FedSuns later at Palmyra.  7th New Sam Regulars is a new unit, formed after a big putsch against Black Dragons (again) after the aforementioned 2nd Dominion-Combine war; they mostly did pirate duty until the new invasion of the Fedsuns and are currently in R&R at Kesai IV.  And the 1st Genyosha went gonzo during the Republic invasion, then were pretty much instrumental in ending the Nova Cat rebellion and conquered Irece and putting it to an end.  No real other info about the 7th NSR unfortunately, a little bit more than a quick battle history is what I'm hoping for in FM:3145.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 31 August 2013, 14:33:36
I'm actually kind of hoping the Legions of Vega have been retired/succeeded.

The Combine has used the idea of penal regiments many, many times prior Takashi's iteration of the old idea.  I'd like to see something 'new' take their place, especially since Vega hasn't been a Combine planet now in the lifetimes of most people by 3145.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 31 August 2013, 15:10:31
Pretty sure one of the Legions of Vega appears in a dark age novel.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 31 August 2013, 15:51:16
Vega hasn't been a Combine planet now in the lifetimes of most people by 3145.
They did make a few attempts at it, but the Seventh Legion is directly referenced in the text of ER3145.

Now, there IS a 1st Vega Relgulars unit but they're definitely not Kuritan...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 31 August 2013, 16:13:58
Well, that's a pretty good summary. Thank you!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Peacemaker on 31 August 2013, 23:52:58
I'm actually kind of hoping the Legions of Vega have been retired/succeeded.

The Combine has used the idea of penal regiments many, many times prior Takashi's iteration of the old idea.  I'd like to see something 'new' take their place, especially since Vega hasn't been a Combine planet now in the lifetimes of most people by 3145.

All the WizKids veteran Kurita 'mechs had the Legion of Vega rat emblem. And since the Legion of Vega isn't very closely associated with the world Vega, their continued existence doesn't bother me too much.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 September 2013, 00:40:01
Take-aways from cursory speed-reading of FM3145:

Hate and fear anything equipped with a re-engineered laser

We've got 39 'Mech regiments.  More than Davion in the post-Palymra era, but (a lot) less than Liao.

The ****** Rokurokubi 4T model replaced the 4K model on the RAT. (for those who place value on RATs..)

Next to no information given about the state of the DCA, but that was probably to be expected.

No reborn 18th Dieron Regulars in the reconstituted brigade.

My god the losses on Palmyra gotta sting the AFFS.  We knew it'd be bad.. but finding out exactly HOW bad is kind of... wow.

Confirmation that battlemech output on Robinson is supplying the DCMS.  All it takes is guns to the heads of family members, and factory workers keep on working!


We STILL don't know what planet Sun Tzu School of Combat is located on.


Weren't there supposed to be maps?  I didn't see any maps..

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 10 September 2013, 00:57:04
The Dragon appears to be hiring mercs to raid the FedSuns. while the Ronin are working for the AFFS. So much fun to be had!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 10 September 2013, 01:59:24
The ****** Rokurokubi 4T model replaced the 4K model on the RAT. (for those who place value on RATs..)
The -4K is just a variant, the -4T is the standard.  I expect that'll be the case; it's not like it's a difficult swap.

How much of the RATs are 3145 tech versus post and pre-jihad machines?

And well lastly...re: the size of the DCMS, not counting the mercs or Arkabs there were 36 regiments in various states of disrepair in the post-Jihad Field Report.  That's not a terribly big increase overall.  How many new units are there that weren't in the FR, and do they get anything more than a name and a planet?  I like regimental fluff.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 10 September 2013, 02:26:39
Weren't there supposed to be maps?  I didn't see any maps..

GAAAH!!!  RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 10 September 2013, 08:40:11
And well lastly...re: the size of the DCMS, not counting the mercs or Arkabs there were 36 regiments in various states of disrepair in the post-Jihad Field Report.  That's not a terribly big increase overall.  How many new units are there that weren't in the FR, and do they get anything more than a name and a planet?  I like regimental fluff.

We know from the Shillelagh entry that new units were being formed in secret.  We also know from Daughter of the Dragon that the Ghost Regiments may have disbanded, but retained their equipment and some level of training.  The DCMS might be far larger in reality than the analysts in the RAF thought.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 September 2013, 11:25:57
We know from the Shillelagh entry that new units were being formed in secret.  We also know from Daughter of the Dragon that the Ghost Regiments may have disbanded, but retained their equipment and some level of training.  The DCMS might be far larger in reality than the analysts in the RAF thought.

The Ghost Brigade is back, having been reactivated and surprising the AFFS by existing much like they did back in 3039.    We're seeing two entire brigades (Ghost, Dieron Regulars) added since 3130 and those are included in the FM3145 totals.  The DCMS is far smaller than I thought it'd be given the successes that were revealed in ER3145.

It doesn't appear to be a case of 'it's just the mech force that's tiny', either.  They did go into how the DCMS went the 'wrong way' during the Pax Republica about devaluing conventional forces and overvaluing mechwarriors.  Only in the past few years (well after 3130) has acceptance of combined arms begun creeping back into the DCMS.

Some other things of note now that the maps are added and making troop deployments easier to see:

We've got the Goons deployed on two un-conquered planets near the Palmyra thumb, alongside AFFS forces.  We're watching the thumb either expand or stall with those planets (presumably) being actively fought over.

OMG Toranaga is trusting the Snow Ravens.  We've got almost nothing on that border...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 10 September 2013, 14:17:27
I lose myself in Rome 2 for a day and this creeps out on me?

Sayonara fellas!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 September 2013, 14:59:45
Some more updates to important worlds on the Draconis-Federation front (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,397.msg699719.html#msg699719)

The only planets between Robinson and New Avalon with an AFFS mech garrison are Dewitt and Markesan.  I totally would not have called that.  I don't know if leaving planets like Kestrel and New Valencia w/o a mech garrison is a deliberate choice or simply forced upon the AFFS by a lack of units to go around.

The AFFS is instead making its stand in the pocket between the Combine as a whole and the Palmyra Thumb.  Dahar IV is indeed a major base, but there are many more in that region as well.  I had a feeling Mayetta would be the crux of a strongpoint, but didn't figure it'd be that STRONG a strongpoint.

I found the DCMS's heavy presence anti-spinward of Robinson to be surprising.. far more weight there than coverage against spoiling raids would require.  There are some AFFS heavyweights on their side of the border.  Either they're all stuck in a quagmire cancelling each other out, or there's about to be a new front centered on Kentares.



Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kamose on 10 September 2013, 15:31:17
Take-aways from cursory speed-reading of FM3145:

Hate and fear anything equipped with a re-engineered laser

We've got 39 'Mech regiments.  More than Davion in the post-Palymra era, but (a lot) less than Liao.

Glad to see that, with all the fighting the Combine is doing lately, the count sounds reasonably accurate.  Unlike Liao.
Kamose
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 10 September 2013, 20:13:24
Glad to see that, with all the fighting the Combine is doing lately, the count sounds reasonably accurate.  Unlike Liao.
Kamose
The cappies have been quietly ignoring every treaty they signed to reduce forces, it's hardly inaccurate or surprising.  There were 42 regiments in 3067, and considering how generally "quiet" the whole Inner Sphere was for 50-odd years after the Jihad, I'm more surprised everyone ELSE didn't bulk up like that.  But it all depends on how much you go along with Stone's reforms.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 10 September 2013, 20:21:08
The cappies have been quietly ignoring every treaty they signed to reduce forces, it's hardly inaccurate or surprising.  There were 42 regiments in 3067, and considering how generally "quiet" the whole Inner Sphere was for 50-odd years after the Jihad, I'm more surprised everyone ELSE didn't bulk up like that.  But it all depends on how much you go along with Stone's reforms.

Given how much opportunity everyone had to rebuild, I can only conclude TPTB simply prefer a paradigm of 30-40 regiments per faction rather than numbers twice that size under FASA's reign.  Stone's Kool-Aid is just the handwavium to get us to where their vision for the game is.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 10 September 2013, 21:04:39
Reading the current DCMS roster makes me shiver. A good chunk are written up as pretty stone killers. Capable, competent even, and deadly. There are still dregs, but this DCMS seems like it can actually hold the chunk of FedSuns space the Dragon has grabbed so far.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Stormfury on 10 September 2013, 23:57:32
Being a Combine fan has taught me to wait for the other shoe to drop.

I'm expecting a combination of the Ghost Bears and Snow Ravens cutting loose while Toranaga and Yori face off to give Julian a chance to go on a rampage.

But only time will tell.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 11 September 2013, 00:02:30
The only upside to a betrayal by the Ravens is that it'll hardly do any damage to the DCMS.

There's virtually no troops on their border to be ambushed O.o
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 11 September 2013, 02:48:04
Given how much opportunity everyone had to rebuild, I can only conclude TPTB simply prefer a paradigm of 30-40 regiments per faction rather than numbers twice that size under FASA's reign.  Stone's Kool-Aid is just the handwavium to get us to where their vision for the game is.

Incorrect. The DCMS has lost probably 10-15 regiments worth of troops in attrition during it's wars since 3134, which would have put them at 50+ regiments if not for the fighting.
But rebuilding is not done overnight. You need to retool factories to start new BattleMech production, you need to train new MechWarriors.

The DCMS has rebuilt from the treaty-size of around 30 regiments with around 2-2.5 regiments a year on average. The same is really true for all the Houses. That rebuild speed is about the same the DCMS rebuilt with after the Clan invasion (3052-3057).
Capellans just started a year or two earlier (they were the first House to go on the offensive) and had slightly more hidden resources (whereas most houses had probably 2-3 regiments of unused Mechs as strategic reserves in violation of the treaty, the Capellans had maybe 5-6), and has been saved the attrition the DCMS has gotten simply due to the fact that the Capellan border was stripped of many AFFS units for Palmyra, and units been shifted to the Combine front.

With regards,
Øystein

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 11 September 2013, 07:26:07
Being a Combine fan has taught me to wait for the other shoe to drop.

I'm expecting a combination of the Ghost Bears and Snow Ravens cutting loose while Toranaga and Yori face off to give Julian a chance to go on a rampage.

But only time will tell.

It's taught me the same thing, but yes we'll see in time.

I like how... present Yori Kurita is as the Coordinator. She's not closeted away but is actively tied to many regiments, and even makes her pleasure (and I suppose the opposite too) known.

Good for her.

It was rather glaring that the Sun Tzu School of Combat didn't have a planet to call its own. For the most part, I'm really impressed with the DCMS and liking the Benjamin Regulars even more than usual.

I'd love to see more of the Kuritan aerospace, like any new PWS and such. Oh, and go Crater Cobras! Still going strong in the Combine after all these years.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: MarauderD on 11 September 2013, 10:12:44
Just curious: which units produced on Robinson are you gents interested in incorporating into your forces?

Are their any you think would be too "FedRat" to use?

Personally, I think you'd be crazy not to use as many Black Knight's as possible. But FedSun and Kuritan mech usage isn't always parallel.

Thoughts?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 11 September 2013, 10:23:07
The Black Knight and Atlas III are very worthy designs. I prefer them both to some of the Kuritan 'Mechs in our TRO.

Hell, I'll take a few Vulpes too if I could.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 11 September 2013, 10:37:45
An Atlas III would be nice to tank it's way down a city street, or a Black Knight for some much needed long range support.  The mechs in TRO3145 DC are very close assault or short-medium range oriented.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 11 September 2013, 14:25:39
There's a pile of Black Knight variants that are all delectable, including that electronics boat.  And the Clan ride.  So yeah, Kurobushis for everyone. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kamose on 11 September 2013, 14:45:37
The cappies have been quietly ignoring every treaty they signed to reduce forces, it's hardly inaccurate or surprising.  There were 42 regiments in 3067, and considering how generally "quiet" the whole Inner Sphere was for 50-odd years after the Jihad, I'm more surprised everyone ELSE didn't bulk up like that.  But it all depends on how much you go along with Stone's reforms.
I will respectfully disagree with you.  I could buy it if they had not been doing so much fighting, but double invasions and this is what they have left?  Just doesn't ring true.  Of course, this is all fictional, so it doesn't matter much anyway.  BTW, I love your avatar.
Regards,
Kamose
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 11 September 2013, 15:52:22
The cappies have been quietly ignoring every treaty they signed to reduce forces, it's hardly inaccurate or surprising.  There were 42 regiments in 3067, and considering how generally "quiet" the whole Inner Sphere was for 50-odd years after the Jihad, I'm more surprised everyone ELSE didn't bulk up like that.  But it all depends on how much you go along with Stone's reforms.

The Capellans was down to 16 regiments worth of strength in 3085. By 3130 they were operationally at the treaty strength, with some reserves (as I mentioned, maybe 3-4 regiments more than the other Houses). But they started their war early, and their buildup went ahead almost as soon as the HPGs went down, and they understood it was not just temporary and their assault on the Republic of the Sphere began. Thus they got 6 to 12 months head start on the DCMS, and more on the AFFS (Harrison started rearming, but not at the same pace, as he wanted to honor his alliances to the Republic).

The CCAF also did not have to fight a civil war, or a protracted war against the Federated Suns, they struck a weak Republic, and a stripped Federated Suns border. As such their combat losses have been much lower than the DCMS, they have also funneled their replacement mechs into new units, while the DCMS are reinforcing their battalion sized units into full regiments.

With regards,
Øystein
Strategic Assistant
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GespenstM on 11 September 2013, 18:58:23
Edit: Disregard, found what I was looking for.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 12 September 2013, 13:10:00
Just finished the DCMS part of FM3145 and three things popped up in my head. Maybe I overlooked something, so correct me if it looks like I did.

1. The FedSuns are Russia. The DCMS might win itself to death during all the costly clashes near the former borders while the vastness of the Suns gobbles up the depleted units assigned to the thrusts.
Even if the Palmyra Salient would be pushed directly to New Avalon, ignoring guarding its flanks completely, there would still be at least 15 planets to conquer before even reaching the Davion capital.
From my point of view House Kurita should really consider absorbing more territory on a broad front, let´s say to fill the void between Robinson and the Salient and call it a day. The way I know the glory hounds in the DCMS they will not, though. Their pride will, as always, be their undoing.

2. The RotS border and the whole Dieron area is painfully undermanned. Even if Stone completely ignores the Dragon the Bears, the Suns and even the Cappies pose a threat

3. The First Amphigean Assault Group twiddles their collective thumbs on New Samarkand. Folly, I say. They might not have the prestige of other premier units they always were a command that got results. Not throwing them directly into the fighting is a waste of their talents. If one really fears a massive Raven backstab, then keep those units near their border that have ample experience in keeping them on their toes with raids, the New Samarkand Regulars. Especially the swapping out the 2nd sounds like a good idea, before they batter themselves to a pulp.


So after what I read I am joining the "waiting for the other shoe to drop" crowd.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 12 September 2013, 13:58:15
The story could go a number of ways.  Even if the Dragon is pushed back to their pre war border i'd still be happy knowing that a march capitol fell.  It seems unlikely to me that the Dragon will take the majority of the Draconis March.  The "Remember Kentares!" storyline bit isn't about to be tossed out.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 September 2013, 22:27:13
Now that we've had some time to digest FM3145, anyone feeling better or worse about Kurita's fortunes given the revelations therein?

The general feel of the AFFS seems stronger than in ER3145, but then again we seem surprisingly well off as well.  (other than having had to strip the Raven border)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 13 September 2013, 22:30:45
I'm not liking the trend back towards 'Mech-centricity with the DCMS. Just when conventional assets would help with so much the DCMS re-emphasizes 'Mechs. They should be prioritized, of course, but it seems like a potential reason why things will turn sour.

I'm cautiously optimistic that the FedSuns won't hand the Combine their heads. Can't say the same for the two Clans...

I really, really wanted the Proserpina Hussars to be reactivated.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 September 2013, 23:11:47
I am pleasantly surprised that we apparently caused some damage to the Ghost Bears in the 2nd Dominion War.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 14 September 2013, 00:11:44
I am pleasantly surprised that we apparently caused some damage to the Ghost Bears in the 2nd Dominion War.
Ya know, sometimes there can be problems when your two favorite factions share a border....  #P
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 14 September 2013, 17:16:19
I'm not quite sure if its just that I was reading the FedSuns section, but that part of the book gave me the impression that many of the DC's victories where Pyrrhic or "we won, but we took alot of damage." I can't help but wonder if Palyrma is the exception rather than the rule.

Its probably too early, but it might be interesting to see whose forces are actually coming off better in the conflict.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Foxx Ital on 14 September 2013, 18:24:44
Ya know, sometimes there can be problems when your two favorite factions share a border....  #P

 I'll second that  #P With the cats gone now, can't we all just get along?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 16 September 2013, 09:01:55
I'm not quite sure if its just that I was reading the FedSuns section, but that part of the book gave me the impression that many of the DC's victories where Pyrrhic or "we won, but we took alot of damage." I can't help but wonder if Palyrma is the exception rather than the rule.

Its probably too early, but it might be interesting to see whose forces are actually coming off better in the conflict.

Hard to tell.  The rosters put the strengths of the DCMS very high, higher than those of Clan Wolf or the CCAF.  If they suffered huge casualties they must have shuffled wrecked units together and/or replenished their strength.  Still, 39 apx regiments, and many with veteran or higher rating, after having fought the AFFS and slain the Nova Cats.... fairly impressive.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 October 2013, 00:02:57
*looks through 3145 New Tech New Upgrades*

*squeals happily*
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 13 October 2013, 00:15:52
Yes, the new Panther, Grand Dragon and Maelstrom are all quite nice. And the Raiden II is downright delightful.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 October 2013, 00:20:57
Yes, the new Panther, Grand Dragon and Maelstrom are all quite nice. And the Raiden II is downright delightful.

The Raiden II is so good it's a wonder it's not the DCMS standard instead of the Kishi.

And finally... An Achilles upgrade.  With NC3!

I'm not sure I'm sold on Kurita's 'faction feel' doubling down on C3 and going for so many boosted refits.. but when you pay for the weight by moving to clan-spec weaponry, what's not to like?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 13 October 2013, 00:46:52
Did you notice that our only new Boosted C3M carrier was a Strider? With two of them?

I'm not a fan of the ABA-equipped stuff either. Am I missing something with that armour?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 October 2013, 00:53:06
Did you notice that our only new Boosted C3M carrier was a Strider? With two of them?

I'm not a fan of the ABA-equipped stuff either. Am I missing something with that armour?

It doesn't have them in my copy?  In fact I don't see any new BC3M carriers at all.  Never mind, there it is.  And, yeah.  Wow.
Still, when you're using random forces and turn up some BC3 slave units, even if you don't end up with a BC3M it's still not too shabby because of the extra goodness they pack in to compensate.  I think the Longbow is an exception, but generally the BC3 slave units in this book have Clan-tech to make up for the 'wasted' 2 tons.

But I agree with you on the ABA armor.  I can't see it being preferable to Ballistic-Reinforced in any reasonable situation.

EDIT: There was MC's post earlier (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,397.msg495701/topicseen.html#msg495701) where there's also a couple more variants already out there with BC3Ms, one of them being a Naginata.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 13 October 2013, 00:56:37
It doesn't have them in my copy?  In fact I don't see any new BC3M carriers at all.

But I agree with you on the ABA armor.  I can't see it being preferable to Ballistic-Reinforced in any reasonable situation.

Page 109, the Strider SR1-OM... two BC3Ms. That's it.

Too bad it's not a straight swap to get Ballistic instead of ABA: need room for 4 more slots.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 October 2013, 11:26:34
Page 109, the Strider SR1-OM... two BC3Ms. That's it.

Too bad it's not a straight swap to get Ballistic instead of ABA: need room for 4 more slots.

Having slept on it.. the weaponless Strider actually has grown on me some.  Sure, you're essentially 'giving up' a mech by including it, but no one says it has to put itself in any sort of danger.  It can just lurk in the sandbaggiest corners of the playing area and hide as best it can because ECM won't break the strung-out network.  And when using BV as your force balancer, you won't find a more cost effective company-level network master.

And let's face it.  What loadout makes a Strider any good as a combatant anyway?  :)  Letting it contribute by hiding out of LOS the whole game is a stroke of genius.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 13 October 2013, 13:15:50
It's a nice gimmick, sure. I'd have preferred a Sunder that carried one of the BC3Ms though. Or perhaps an Avatar.

I suppose the Black Hawk-KU stuff makes up for it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 13 October 2013, 21:09:34
Well...you could always come up with an OmniMech variant that has one single BC3M...that IS what they're for after all.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 13 October 2013, 22:14:19
Same old argument. Of course I could've done that, I make enough customs. It still doesn't explain why some of these things are so facepalm inducing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 14 October 2013, 07:24:59
I can't help but think that the new Panther is some sort of tongue in cheek comment about all the problems the old Panther "Upgrades" had with single heat sinks, since its now using Clantech Double Heat sinks.

A nice little touch, and it needs them due to critical slot issues.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 16 October 2013, 23:30:13
Well, I tried to find out (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,33166.0.html) what's the current fluff with the 6-regiment strong Sword of Light Brigade.  Apparently the answer is a non-answer, so what's the fan opinion?

Who's the Steel Dragon? 4th, 2nd, or none of the above?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 17 October 2013, 01:40:33
Steel's probably the second again, for continuity's sake.  Past that, no idea.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 17 October 2013, 10:57:42
I'd say 2nd with the 4th being a floater regiment.

There used to be 12 SoL regiments so I think the link to the five pillars was a recent addition (post 2nd War) after those other regiments were stuck due to unit destruction/absorption. Maybe there are twelve virtues that we aren't aware of that Ben is going to spring on us in 3014 when the DC Handbook is released. Yes, I meant 3014. Then each regiment gets be be a virtue. Duty, Honor, Honesty, etc.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 17 October 2013, 12:59:03
I'd say 2nd with the 4th being a floater regiment.

There used to be 12 SoL regiments so I think the link to the five pillars was a recent addition (post 2nd War) after those other regiments were stuck due to unit destruction/absorption. Maybe there are twelve virtues that we aren't aware of that Ben is going to spring on us in 3014 when the DC Handbook is released. Yes, I meant 3014. Then each regiment gets be be a virtue. Duty, Honor, Honesty, etc.

The reformat into 5 elite Sword of Light regiments based on the Five Pillars happened towards the end of the Star League, as per FM:DC.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 17 October 2013, 13:15:26
The SOL brigade being larger than 5 regiments is a bigger deal than 'Cool, there's 6 regiments now!'.  The link to the 5 pillars has gone for so long that it's pretty much integral to the identity of the brigade.

So if it does still maintain that identity, one regiment is left out.  Probably the 4th, but I do like the idea of the 4th remaining the 'new' Pillar of Steel and the reconstituted 2nd being the bearer of a new 6th title in the brigade, "The Coordinator's Own".

If the 2nd gets the Pillar of Steel title back, what title (if any) do you think the 4th should have?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 17 October 2013, 16:15:05
I think, IC, that the brigade was larger than 12 for longer. The SoL regiments were one of Shiro's first. OOC, they've been the 5 for far longer.

I would like it to be Duty or Honor. Those two concepts are as old as Urizen's reforms. Then we could get a 3rd SoL as the other.

"Coordinator's Own" is more to Otomo or Ignazi to me.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 17 October 2013, 16:33:02
Duty and Honor are good ideas too.   

But I wouldn't consider the bodyguard regiments as 'X's Own'.. that more means "THIS REGIMENT IS MY BEATSTICK".  The Otomo and Izanagi Warriors only do beatstick work when the Coordinator puts himself in harm's way.

Another possibility, harkening back to the flaming sword of the Myoo insignia, is going the opposite direction of Honor and Duty.  The Sword of Light is literally named after the weapon of Erinyes-like beings dragging the unrepentant to their fates.  I could really dig something based on the three cardinal sins of Bushido, like "Purgers of Fear","... Regret", and ".. Desire".

Then again, maybe I put too much of L5R's take on Bushido into my Kurita Bushido :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 November 2013, 15:40:36
I'm enjoying a theme I found in the DC 3145 TRO: the depicted variant is underwhelming.  The other variant(s) is awesome.  That's true of the Rokurokubi, Shiro, Cizin and Narukami.  Sweetness.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Pa Weasley on 07 November 2013, 07:04:14
Really, you included the Cizin in that list? I figured a quintet of Clan ER mediums tied to a targeting computer on a fast, well-armored hover would at least rate "nothing to sneeze at".  ???
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 07 November 2013, 09:26:04
It's ok, but with the BV of a decent Warhammer and all the vulnerabilities that come with being a hovercraft, yes, I prefer the Support variant.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Peacemaker on 08 November 2013, 15:26:42
The SOL brigade being larger than 5 regiments is a bigger deal than 'Cool, there's 6 regiments now!'.  The link to the 5 pillars has gone for so long that it's pretty much integral to the identity of the brigade.

So if it does still maintain that identity, one regiment is left out.  Probably the 4th, but I do like the idea of the 4th remaining the 'new' Pillar of Steel and the reconstituted 2nd being the bearer of a new 6th title in the brigade, "The Coordinator's Own".

If the 2nd gets the Pillar of Steel title back, what title (if any) do you think the 4th should have?

I think there might be a clue in the old Amaterasu dossier that came with the first MechWarrior: Dark Age starter box. I remember there being something about there being a rivalry between the Amaterasu and a Sword of Light Regiment associated with the Japanese god Susanoo. Sadly, I can't find those dossiers anywhere online, so the trail might be cold.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 08 November 2013, 18:41:23
I think there might be a clue in the old Amaterasu dossier that came with the first MechWarrior: Dark Age starter box. I remember there being something about there being a rivalry between the Amaterasu and a Sword of Light Regiment associated with the Japanese god Susanoo. Sadly, I can't find those dossiers anywhere online, so the trail might be cold.

Not exactly. The dossier mentions that the goddess Amaterasu traditionally had a rivalry with Susa-No-Wo and that there is a DCMS unit dedicated to that particular god. It goes on to suggest that if the Amaterasu are really into their namesake, they might someday clash with the unnamed DCMS unit. It's mentioned as a future possibility, not a fact.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Peacemaker on 08 November 2013, 22:25:19
Not exactly. The dossier mentions that the goddess Amaterasu traditionally had a rivalry with Susa-No-Wo and that there is a DCMS unit dedicated to that particular god. It goes on to suggest that if the Amaterasu are really into their namesake, they might someday clash with the unnamed DCMS unit. It's mentioned as a future possibility, not a fact.

Oh well. I think I must have confused the deities the Sword of Light Regiments got their name from with Susa-No-Wo and mistakenly extrapolated from there. So much for going from memory.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 01 December 2013, 03:31:32
I think I remember seeing somewhere that the Dieron Regulars of 3145 are an entirely new formation that didn't inherit the battle honors of the defunct regiments they share names with.  But I can't find the reference, and now I'm not sure I'm not misremembering some out-of-context beemer-poster's comment in some thread.

Am I taking crazy pills or does anyone remember this?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 01 December 2013, 10:04:14
It's in either Era Report 3145 or field Report 3145. But you are correct, the Dieron Regulars was reformed when the Combine took the district from the Republic of the Sphere. The surviving old regiments are still named New Samarkand Regulars and has settled into that identify after 60 years.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 02 December 2013, 15:54:54
It's in either Era Report 3145 or field Report 3145. But you are correct, the Dieron Regulars was reformed when the Combine took the district from the Republic of the Sphere. The surviving old regiments are still named New Samarkand Regulars and has settled into that identify after 60 years.
That's what I thought I remembered.

What conventions are used to differentiate between Dieron regiments of the 1st and 2nd Legions?  For example, the 2nd Dieron Regulars and the 2nd Dieron Regulars, which as we know are completely seperate regiments :D 

Maybe in a metaview, knowledge of when the scenario or context of the historical reference takes place is enough.  For a scenario set in 3145, it's obvious it'd be the 'new' 2nd, since the original is now the 2nd New Samarkand.  And since the two regiments are never coterminous, that might be enough in-universe as well?

But, for clarity's sake, would it be better to identify which 'incarnation' of the Legion of which they are a member?  Perhaps something like 2nd of the 1st Dieron Regulars ..for historical references to the 2nd Dieron Regulars that would eventually become the 2nd New Samarkand Regulars.. and 2nd of the 2nd Dieron Regulars for the 2nd Dieron of the 3145 era?  (perhaps abbreviated in script as 2/1 or 2/2 Dieron Regulars)

I'd ask these questions in the 'ask the devs' forum, but I feel I already know the answer is "we don't know/haven't thought about that" so here it is, asked in this thread where people who'd care enough to speculate and/or offer better alternatives would see it :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 02 December 2013, 17:14:39
You're making a problem where there is none. Neither of the units exists concurrently. There is only one 2nd Dieron in existance at one time. The move from 2nd Dieron to 2nd New Samarkand happened at the will of the Coordinator and overnight, any objectors got their heads on spikes as a warning. The rest very quickly thought of themselves as New Samarkand Regulars.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 02 December 2013, 17:31:37
Seems fair, 'my life for the dragon' and all that.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 02 December 2013, 18:32:22
You're making a problem where there is none.

It's not MUCH of a problem, granted.  I don't imagine anyone other than Kurita obsessivists to even care.  But, I can't see how having identically named but separate regiments is "never going to be a problem".  Especially if the 3145 era at some point becomes 'historical' rather than 'current' and the distinction between the regiments being 'then' and 'now' both become 'then'.

Additionally, every tradition & honor (as in award) associated with the Dieron Legion has transferred to the New Samarkand Legion.  When talking about the District Forces as an entire Legion rather than individual regiments, we have the same phenomenon.  The Dieron District Forces (of pre-Jihad) are a completely separate institution from the Dieron District Forces (of 3145).  What is the best way in writing to distinguish between them when you are explicitly discussing only one and not the other?  Considering one the "first" and one the "second" makes perfect sense to me.


Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Peacemaker on 02 December 2013, 22:36:23
But, I can't see how having identically named but separate regiments is "never going to be a problem".  Especially if the 3145 era at some point becomes 'historical' rather than 'current' and the distinction between the regiments being 'then' and 'now' both become 'then'.

But they're not identically named. One is called the "2nd New Samarkand Regulars" and the other is called the "2nd Dieron Regulars".
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 03 December 2013, 02:41:37
But they're not identically named. One is called the "2nd New Samarkand Regulars" and the other is called the "2nd Dieron Regulars".

Actually.  They are.
Consider these two sentences talking about completely different units in different periods of time:
He fought for the 2nd Dieron Regulars.
He fought for the 2nd Dieron Regulars.

If you can point out which is a reference to the 2nd Dieron Regiment of the 3145 era, and which is talking about the regiment known as 2nd New Samarkand in 3145, then I'm wrong.
Since both sentences can plausibly be said by (or written in-universe by) someone in the 3145 era, I'm rather convinced I *do* have a point.

It's not like I ignored that there hasn't been 2 regiments active at the same time with the same name:
...

Maybe in a metaview, knowledge of when the scenario or context of the historical reference takes place is enough.  For a scenario set in 3145, it's obvious it'd be the 'new' 2nd, since the original is now the 2nd New Samarkand.  And since the two regiments are never coterminous, that might be enough in-universe as well?

...

I'm not trying to provoke an argument, I just get prickly when what I'm saying is so dramatically mischaracterized.
Honestly, I value the discussion.  Peacemaker, if your opinion is that the context of the reference will provide the audience (out of universe AND in universe) with the cues necessary to determine which regiment is being mentioned, then I respect that.

Me, I largely agree.  Only in the out-of-universe perspective.  A gamer with sufficient knowledge of all things Kurita will be able to infer which regiment when numbers are replicated simply by figuring out the year of the reference.  A gamer who isn't so literate in all things Kurita on the other hand is unlikely to care about the distinction so it doesn't matter which regiment is which.

In-universe however, not so much.  Especially in the bureaucracy of personnel records.  It simply won't do for battle records, decorations, retirement pay, and a host of other factors to have any question whatsoever about which regiment a MechWarrior was assigned to.  And then there's the issue of the New Samarkand Legion inheriting all of Dieron's traditions.  The new Dieron Legion wouldn't want to just copy them; those are New Samarkand traditions now.  They must make an identity for themselves to set themselves apart from the Dieron Legion of the past.  Not just for administrative clarity, but for esprit de corps as well.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 03 December 2013, 15:02:44
Consider these two sentences talking about completely different units in different periods of time:
He fought for the 2nd Dieron Regulars.
He fought for the 2nd Dieron Regulars.

If you can point out which is a reference to the 2nd Dieron Regiment of the 3145 era, and which is talking about the regiment known as 2nd New Samarkand in 3145, then I'm wrong.
Since both sentences can plausibly be said by (or written in-universe by) someone in the 3145 era, I'm rather convinced I *do* have a point.
You mention it's two different points in time, but then you only look at it in the 3145 era - in which case any mention of "2nd Dieron Regulars" would refer to the unit in 3145 known as the 2nd Dieron Regulars.  Not the 2nd New Samarkand Regulars, or else the sentence would have said "2nd New Samarkand Regulars."  And if you're arguing as to which timeframe you're in, I daresay that such things are quite well established elsewhere in fluff.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 03 December 2013, 15:16:28
You mention it's two different points in time, but then you only look at it in the 3145 era - in which case any mention of "2nd Dieron Regulars" would refer to the unit in 3145 known as the 2nd Dieron Regulars.  Not the 2nd New Samarkand Regulars, or else the sentence would have said "2nd New Samarkand Regulars."  And if you're arguing as to which timeframe you're in, I daresay that such things are quite well established elsewhere in fluff.

Not at all.  For the sentence referring to the 2nd New Samarkand Regulars, the speaker could be referring to a MechWarrior who served prior to the change.  So, at that time, it WAS the 2nd Dieron, even though 'now' it's the 2nd New Samarkand.

When it comes to administrative records, consider examples like: the Xth Dieron performed a raid on planet Y where the personnel were exposed to (insert medical hazard here).  MechWarrior Snuffy was a Chu-i in the Xth Dieron prior to his discharge. Unless the year is also explicitly mentioned right there, the reader has no way of knowing which incarnation of the Dieron District Forces is being discussed.  Maybe that's the answer, is the year must always be included to give the clue as to which is which?  Still, if you get something impossible like "18th Dieron in 3145", is that a mistake or a typo for "18th Dieron in 3045"?  Too much ambiguity, especially when (in-universe) records are involved.
Honestly I think it's easier for the 2nd incarnation to simply stress they are the 2nd incarnation, aka Xth/2 Regiment.  It could easily be one of the new traditions that the Legion might make up for itself to distinguish itself.

Anyway, this is my last comment on this thought.  If I'm the only one who sees an issue that needs an in-universe explanation, so be it.  I can do that for my Head-Canon w/o needing to try to convince anyone else.
My last comment, that is, so long as no one else tries to argue that in a historical context, the 2nd Dieron Regulars is not the exact same name as the 2nd Dieron Regulars.  Honestly I don't get why people don't get it.  If you can cut and paste the name, it's frikkin the exact same name.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: FedSunsBorn on 03 December 2013, 23:02:58
Just bought FR 2765 DCMS and haven't looked at things in complete detail just yet but I do love the 2 warships and the writeup about the Rasalhague Regulars so far.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 07 December 2013, 03:51:45
The Rasalhague Regulars sort of confuses me when I sit down and think about it.

The Regulars are the 2nd largest brigade, if I remember right.

Why?

Okay sure. You're policing the area as well as defending it, so you probably want more troops there. But why not more Dieron Regulars or something? Are you really recruiting that many more people from the Rasalhague District compared to other districts (I'll have to check the size of the districts again tomorrow)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 07 December 2013, 03:59:13
Reading the new Field Report mostly made me realize how fiercely I miss the Proserpina Hussars in the post-Jihad eras.  :'(
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 07 December 2013, 04:27:50
Okay sure. You're policing the area as well as defending it, so you probably want more troops there. But why not more Dieron Regulars or something? Are you really recruiting that many more people from the Rasalhague District compared to other districts (I'll have to check the size of the districts again tomorrow)

Because there isn't a Dieron Military District in 2765, and Dieron has not been a full Combine world for about 400 years?

Also, the Galedon Regulars has the most units by far. 10 more than the Rassies. Both districts are charged with guarding the long hostile borders, and as such are the most numerous with native troops.

With regards,
Øystein
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 07 December 2013, 04:42:55
The Rasalhague Regulars sort of confuses me when I sit down and think about it.

The Regulars are the 2nd largest brigade, if I remember right.

Why?

Okay sure. You're policing the area as well as defending it, so you probably want more troops there. But why not more Dieron Regulars or something? Are you really recruiting that many more people from the Rasalhague District compared to other districts (I'll have to check the size of the districts again tomorrow)

Back in the day, the Steiner border was split between 2 districts while the Davion border had 3 districts.
Plus, the Steiner border would be the one that constantly fell back to Kurita advances thru the Succession Wars.
A bunch of good Mech factories were in the Rasalhague District, to boot.

A large Rasalhague Legion makes sense to me :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 07 December 2013, 04:53:03
Because there isn't a Dieron Military District in 2765, and Dieron has not been a full Combine world for about 400 years?

Sure, but there are still Dieron Regulars out there, even if they are Dieron in name only. Still seems better to create something other than another Rasalhague unit.

Quote
Also, the Galedon Regulars has the most units by far. 10 more than the Rassies. Both districts are charged with guarding the long hostile borders, and as such are the most numerous with native troops.

With regards,
Øystein

I'm pretty sure I said second biggest! :)

Back in the day, the Steiner border was split between 2 districts while the Davion border had 3 districts.
Plus, the Steiner border would be the one that constantly fell back to Kurita advances thru the Succession Wars.
A bunch of good Mech factories were in the Rasalhague District, to boot.

A large Rasalhague Legion makes sense to me :)

I admit that units in the Rasalhague District are good. I'm just not sure Rasalhague units in the district are good. If Dieron units can serve in the same district as Benjamin units, then sure "Dieron in name only" units can serve in the Rasalhague district.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 07 December 2013, 05:57:01
I was pleasantly surprised to find the Arkab Legions fielded 5 brigades in 2765.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 07 December 2013, 14:50:42
I was impressed with the number of infantry and armor units assigned to most of the `Mech regiments in order to make them Brigades. Kurita may not like their conventional forces, but atleast they're willing to assign them to most units.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 07 December 2013, 14:54:51
I was impressed with the number of infantry and armor units assigned to most of the `Mech regiments in order to make them Brigades. Kurita may not like their conventional forces, but atleast they're willing to assign them to most units.

And yet the Davion's still rattle on about their being the home of combined arms.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 07 December 2013, 16:50:38
Well, in Davion's defense, they treat their combined arms as combined arms, whee the Star League and Succession War era Kuritans treated their conventional units more as second class warriors and (most) didn't work well or take full advantage of what the conventional units could offer.

Of course, combined arms has existed since the BattleMech showed up, but the RCT might still be the most effective at combining all of its parts and training together (atleast for a while)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tomoe on 08 December 2013, 18:00:13
Youkoso irasshai mashita.

I am the Kuritan Ambassador to the MRBC and I appreciate this spirited conversation about our great house.

See you on the field of battle.

(Note: derived from the game system found at http://battletech-mercenaries.com)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 08 December 2013, 22:25:09
So what're your thoughts on the Kuritans having the Dragoons working for them again in 3145?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 08 December 2013, 23:48:55
Personally I find it somewhat amusing, but its a good thing since it moves the Dragoons further into the realm of being mercs rather than being a faction in and of themselves.

I sort of hope we begin to see more of the house-bound mercs acting like mercs rather than House troops.

Its also good to see the Combine not foolishly wasting talent opportunities.

It also helps to put some of the "The Kanrei is a Black Dragon!" complaints, since hiring the Dragoons is something I can't see the old Black Dragons acquiescing to. (That, or the Black Dragons have evolved to the point where they're intelligent about things, rather than simply a return to what they consider traditional, even if it means failing).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 09 December 2013, 09:11:23
Well, the Dragoons tried playing at a nation state before and it didn't work out entirely as planned...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: IronLichRich on 09 December 2013, 11:20:32
Relatively new to the 3145 stuff and I was wondering if anyone had tips on using the Tenshi in its prime configuration. Love the look, but it seems to underperform for me next to other mechs in it's weight class.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 09 December 2013, 12:55:52
Everyone's new to the 3145 stuff :)

The Prime doesn't look too bad off. You've got a Light engine with only the Gauss Rifle as something that can explode. You've got max armor, a supercharger to push you slightly faster, and a crit packed CT with a compact Gyro.  Damage output is...okay. Its going to depend on what you're used to fighting with. 40 points of damage isn't too bad, especially since its at range with a 15 point hit, and then a bunch of small 5 point hits to exploit the damage. You even have a targeting computer so you can fight at range and hit, and enough GR ammo that you can use it pretty freely.

Seems your best bet is to use the supercharger to stay at range, wearing down your opponent.

I think it compares favorably to what its going to see on the battlefield. The Templar II Prime is 10 tons lighter, but has about the same damage potential. The Atlas III is going to want to close, but you've got it beat at range with damage (though the variant with the HAG30+Streak LRM20 is going to make you miserable).

If you're facing Clantech...then yeah. 40 damage is going to seem anemic. The Tomahawk II Prime configuration is going to leave you in the dirt. Double HAG30's with triple ERLLs to back them up. Sure, it can't handle the heat of all its weapons (like the Tenshi can...so never stop firing those weapons), but it can handle enough to double your damage at longer ranges than you can.

So against IS opponents, it seems to be about evenly matched. Your best bet is to stay at range and just keep pouring in shots, using the Supercharger when needed to keep you out of range. Against Clan opponents, you face pretty much the same problem as anyone else, unfortunately.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 09 December 2013, 13:08:44
One problem with the Tenshi Prime is that its BV is not exactly low.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 09 December 2013, 14:13:53
Ouch, yeah, I didn't even notice that.

On the other hand, it puts it inbetween the Templar II and the Atlas III, and well below the Tomahawk II, which is about what I'd expect.

I wouldn't mind seeing what could be done with it in a pure Clantech role, rather than the sort of interesting hybrid that is the R variant. I find it sort of amusing that the R's 5 Clan ERMLs alone almost match the Prime's damage output.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 09 December 2013, 14:26:37
I don't give the Prime a fair shake.  When I read variants my eyes go to the A and the R.  Both scream "pay attention to me!" while running up the middle and distracting.  The Prime and B require more subtlety than I am looking for in a DC assault.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 09 December 2013, 15:37:26
So what's everyone's opinions on the new Hatamotos (Suna and Godai)?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 09 December 2013, 15:58:47
I'm trying to wrap my mind around the information about Dieron in the FM2765.

Was that book the first instance of Kurita considering Dieron a 'rightfully' Draconis world prior to its conquest in the Succession Wars?  Well, EVERY world was 'rightfully Kurita' in a it's our destiny to rule all of mankind kind of way.   But the Dieron District existing during the Star League?  What insanity is this?   It seems to fly in the face of 30 years of canon, but then again maybe I just am stuck in the 80s canon.

Star League, pg 172, Dieron atlas entry:
".. Legend has it that Minoru Kurita chose Dieron to be a provincial capital just so he could boast of having one of the crowning glories of the Star League so prominent a part of his own realm. ..."

So what's everyone's opinions on the new Hatamotos (Suna and Godai)?

I've been on a kick of learning Alpha Strike lately.  Hatamoto-Godai actually looks pretty good in AS as a command platform, in my opinion.  MHQ11 and RCN?  Yes, please.  That it's capable of running a company-scale boosted network is a bonus.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 09 December 2013, 16:25:55
So what's everyone's opinions on the new Hatamotos (Suna and Godai)?
►Suna
 - no, thanks. Slow 'Mech with a shortranged weaponry is not a good idea.

►Godai
- no, thanks.

1) The Davions have Atlas with the Angel ECM suite, the new Black Knight with the Angel ECM suite, Centurion Omni with the Angel ECM suite, Hollander III with the Angel ECM suite and possibly Warlord with the Angel ECM suite.
2) Although both Hatamotos are protected with the BR Armor, it seems to me that the Davions invested into advanced energy weapons (they manufacture some Clan-grade energy weapons too). The BR Armor provides no advantage against those weapons.

The Republic has some Angel ECM equipped 'Mechs too.

The Clans field the Cauldron-Born and Loki Mk.II with the Angel ECM, plus some vehicles with the Clan Angel ECM .

The Kite is fielded by almost everyone, be it the IS or the Clans, as is the Malice.

So building Boosted C3 networks is not especially good idea.

So No, thanks! to the Suna, and the Godai only if there is nothing better to take. PLus, I don't like those XL Gyros.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 09 December 2013, 16:58:09
I'm trying to wrap my mind around the information about Dieron in the FM2765.

Was that book the first instance of Kurita considering Dieron a 'rightfully' Draconis world prior to its conquest in the Succession Wars?  Well, EVERY world was 'rightfully Kurita' in a it's our destiny to rule all of mankind kind of way.   But the Dieron District existing during the Star League?  What insanity is this?   It seems to fly in the face of 30 years of canon, but then again maybe I just am stuck in the 80s canon.

Star League, pg 172, Dieron atlas entry:
".. Legend has it that Minoru Kurita chose Dieron to be a provincial capital just so he could boast of having one of the crowning glories of the Star League so prominent a part of his own realm. ..."

My guess is there's some fluff somewhere that has the Dieron Regulars being around before the fall of the Star League, so they're trying to come up with a good reason, but that's just personal theory (I actually thought Dieron was one of the jointly administered worlds, but that seems to be incorrect, based on a quick look through the original SLSB).

As for the Hatamotos, those were about my opinion as well, though I lean towards wanting to like the Suna, though the movement curve makes me wince (amusingly, it has a greater damage potential than the Tenshi being discussed earlier).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Lazarus Jaguar on 17 December 2013, 15:41:52
Quick question:  When the COmbine annihilated Clan Nova Cat, were the factories on Irece kept intact?  Or are they shut down (razed out of spite, damaged in fighting, or whatnot)?  Just wondering how likely it is we'll see clan designs like the Clan medium battlearmor or Nobori-Nin showing up as regular parts of the DCMS.

Just can't seem to find the answer myself in all the stuff we've gotten so far.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 17 December 2013, 16:01:43
Quick question:  When the COmbine annihilated Clan Nova Cat, were the factories on Irece kept intact?  Or are they shut down (razed out of spite, damaged in fighting, or whatnot)?  Just wondering how likely it is we'll see clan designs like the Clan medium battlearmor or Nobori-Nin showing up as regular parts of the DCMS.

Just can't seem to find the answer myself in all the stuff we've gotten so far.

Some were retained/moved, some were doubtlessly destroyed in the rebellion, and some were sold to the Sea Foxes.  Exactly which was which we'll likely never know.  There's a ton of Clan stuff in the DCMS RATs in FM3145, but telling which is domestically produced and which is salvage and which is Sea Fox imports is unknowable.

Given the trajectory we're seeing in the 3145 stuff, mechs that are clan-spec from head to toe are becoming common, not just in the DCMS.  Whether they develop their own new 'Clan' mechs in the future or retain the capability to produce some Nova Cat gems is deliberately unanswered at this point.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 December 2013, 16:02:55
Quick question:  When the COmbine annihilated Clan Nova Cat, were the factories on Irece kept intact?  Or are they shut down (razed out of spite, damaged in fighting, or whatnot)?  Just wondering how likely it is we'll see clan designs like the Clan medium battlearmor or Nobori-Nin showing up as regular parts of the DCMS.

Just can't seem to find the answer myself in all the stuff we've gotten so far.

Irece was one of two places where the Nova Cats made their last stand, so you can expect some serious damage there, per the ER:3145.

However, the battle was quite short, so it's hard to tell. For example the Cizin plant on Irece has survived relatively intact and was dismantled and transported to Luthien.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 27 December 2013, 12:15:57
CSO has a posting for the 7th New Samarkand Regulars (http://www.camospecs.com/Unit.asp?ID=1121) and I think they look great. I need to get my Rokurokubis and my Shiro together and painted now.

I always appreciate simple paint schemes; if I can actually paint it I'll play it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 27 December 2013, 16:22:50
Quick question:  When the COmbine annihilated Clan Nova Cat, were the factories on Irece kept intact?  Or are they shut down (razed out of spite, damaged in fighting, or whatnot)?  Just wondering how likely it is we'll see clan designs like the Clan medium battlearmor or Nobori-Nin showing up as regular parts of the DCMS.

Just can't seem to find the answer myself in all the stuff we've gotten so far.

After the Nova Cats took a pounding in the Second Dominion War, Coordinator Hohiro Kurita ordered the DCMS to supervise the "dismantling of the remaining Nova Cat industry and the relocation of many Nova Cat civilians to “cultural preservation districts.”" (ER3145, p47)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 09 February 2014, 06:30:59
Is there anything describing the actual formation of the Second Genyosha?  They just sort of showed up sometime between 3028 and 3039, and there's plenty of information about their post-Clan-Invasion rebuilding but nothing saying how they were first created.  Was a battalion or some other chunk of the 1st Genyosha spun off as cadre to form the new regiment around, or were they headhunted from other elite forces and formed fresh?  And WHEN were they created?

If it's not actually specified anywhere I'll go ask the writers, but I'm assuming I'm missing something first.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 09 February 2014, 22:57:43
Is there anything describing the actual formation of the Second Genyosha?  They just sort of showed up sometime between 3028 and 3039, and there's plenty of information about their post-Clan-Invasion rebuilding but nothing saying how they were first created.  Was a battalion or some other chunk of the 1st Genyosha spun off as cadre to form the new regiment around, or were they headhunted from other elite forces and formed fresh?  And WHEN were they created?

If it's not actually specified anywhere I'll go ask the writers, but I'm assuming I'm missing something first.

All I know is the 2nd Genyosha seem to magically appear out of thin air when the Ronin War breaks out, along with the 1st, after Yorinaga's original regiment was disbanded in disgrace after Nusakan.  Whatever origin story there is about a 2nd regiment is likely a footnote in the story of why are there any Genyosha regiments at all.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 10 February 2014, 11:54:02
I don't know why, but there's something in the back of my mind saying that the creation of the 2nd was rumored to be because they wanted to keep the Genyosha equal to the Kell Hounds.

Of course, I don't know when the Kell Hound's Second regiment was created compared to when the 2nd Genyosha first showed up, so I don't know if that works out or not.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 10 February 2014, 18:20:14
Very little is known about this period that also saw the reconstitution of the Ryuken at Theodore's command.  As far as Takashi (and the DCMS High Command) was concerned both units were failed experimental units as they failed in their duty to destroy their mercenary opposition.

However, I would imagine, that while plans to increase the size of the Genyosha were made prior to Theodore's secret agreement with ComStar, it wasn't until they started receiving the shipments of SL 'Mechs that the 2nd Genyosha started coming together.

I don't know why, but there's something in the back of my mind saying that the creation of the 2nd was rumored to be because they wanted to keep the Genyosha equal to the Kell Hounds.

Popular supposition but unsupported by canon, the Ryuken, in the other hand...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 February 2014, 11:32:55
I don't know when it happened, but I noticed the MUL entries for the units from 3145 DC TRO have artwork now.

Hooray for Kurita art!

EDIT:  Oh yeah, and the MUL can be searched by AS keywords now.  No longer such a hassle to find units with boosted C3 masters!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 14 February 2014, 16:36:31
So I'm looking to put together a light battalion, modern era, 6/9 being a minimum speed.  I'll take any kinds of suggestions you guys want for mechs; preferably I'd like to know about what designs you like, what work, and what are paper tigers that die horribly as soon as someone with an AC/5 looks at them funny.  I know there's a few Dragons in this range, and a decent supply of mediums and lights...but I want to avoid the more generic and stick with the iconic Kuritan machines.

I ran across a thing on tantojutsu, the fighting art of the knife, and it's all about speed and getting into position with the blade before the larger, heavier sword can come into play.  A bare hand is used to help defend, primarily blocking at the attacking hand while the knife blade makes its move in the other.  There's some youtube videos that highlight the concept, specifically the Ogawa Ryu style of tantojutsu, but it occurred to me.  The parallel concept works for light 'Mech units, the whole idea of moving rapidly and getting inside your enemy's action-segment of the OODA loop as well as rapid movement on the field to gain a firing position before your enemy can react and bring firepower to bear.

So what 'Mechs would you prefer for a 'tanto' style of fighting - able to take on heavy and even assault units by means of rapid advance and firepower?  Obviously things like the Venoms, the Phoenix Hawk-L (namely the SNPPC+cap variant), or the Exhumers work, but I'd like to get folks' thoughts on this.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 14 February 2014, 16:49:19
So I'm looking to put together a light battalion, modern era, 6/9 being a minimum speed.  I'll take any kinds of suggestions you guys want for mechs; preferably I'd like to know about what designs you like, what work, and what are paper tigers that die horribly as soon as someone with an AC/5 looks at them funny.  I know there's a few Dragons in this range, and a decent supply of mediums and lights...but I want to avoid the more generic and stick with the iconic Kuritan machines.

I ran across a thing on tantojutsu, the fighting art of the knife, and it's all about speed and getting into position with the blade before the larger, heavier sword can come into play.  A bare hand is used to help defend, primarily blocking at the attacking hand while the knife blade makes its move in the other.  There's some youtube videos that highlight the concept, specifically the Ogawa Ryu style of tantojutsu, but it occurred to me.  The parallel concept works for light 'Mech units, the whole idea of moving rapidly and getting inside your enemy's action-segment of the OODA loop as well as rapid movement on the field to gain a firing position before your enemy can react and bring firepower to bear.

So what 'Mechs would you prefer for a 'tanto' style of fighting - able to take on heavy and even assault units by means of rapid advance and firepower?  Obviously things like the Venoms, the Phoenix Hawk-L (namely the SNPPC+cap variant), or the Exhumers work, but I'd like to get folks' thoughts on this.

An all-fast force the size of a battalion is probably going to be best done as a mixed force, particularly in the 3145/modern era.
DCMS has no shortage of great hovers for sheer speed on flanking units and VTOLS like Yashas and Kamakiris can add some good striking power.  Battle Armor might even fit into the concept, being mechanized via Hiryo's and/or fast omnis.  Maybe even include a few ASFs for air-to-ground artillery strikes that can be spotted by any TAG units you have.

As for mechs, Grand Dragons are a no brainer for consideration.  Both 35 and 45 ton P-Hawk chassis would be good, I'd say.  The criterion for minimum speed 6 makes it tricky for good candidates from there, but I'd suggest the Rokurokubi class. 

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 14 February 2014, 17:23:28
Generic/Dark Age/IS
CVR-A1 Cadaver
GBT-1G/L Gambit
HVC-P6 Havoc

DC specific
Hitman
JR7-C2/C3 Jenner
MON-76/86 Mongoose - let them work as a pair - one has BAP, the other has Guardian ECM suite)
OTT-7K Ostscout (a bit useless without artillery 'Mechs)
Owens OmniMech (check those Dragon Roars variants, in 3145 they are no longer "exotic")
Phoenix Hawk L (both models)
Raptor OmniMech (underestimated, but very good and versatile)
RK-4X Rokurokubi (crap, but it has Clan ER PPC)
SDR-7KC Spider (cheap and mobile Light PPC)
SDR-8K Spider (Snub-nose PPC with Capacitor)
SDR-10K Spider (Large RE Laser)
SDR-9KC Venom (pulse lasers+protection+DHS)
BSN-5KC Bishamon (fast, durable and stable SnPPC)
EXR-2X Exhumer (Ninja-To of the Medium Class)
Firestarter Omni
Hitotsume Kozo (Hardened Heavy PPC)
CMA-2K Chimera (jumping Sword + TSM - but is that still Chimera?)
PXH-7K Phoenix Hawk (very good 'Mech, useful for the new FWLM and the DCMS)
Strider (it's OmniMech, after all; try configuration with twin MMLs or with Clan Streak LRMs)
Tessen
WFT-2 Tora for killing PBIs and logistic personnel in enemy's backfield - it's a dirty job, but somebody has to do it)
WFT-2B Tora (Gauss Rifle for long range, twin Medium X-Pulse laser as backup; probably variant with thickest armor of all series production Toras)

Battalion CO's ride:
LNC25-01 Lancelot
Ninja-To (3 models, I would prefer NJT-3)

Special 'Mech for the most brutal member of this battalion who gets out of the brig only when the battalion goes on mission - TDR-60-RLA Thunderbolt
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 14 February 2014, 17:30:32
The Mk 2 Scaracen/Scimitar/Saladin family give you a lot of options; they're all 10/15 with decent weapons loads which make them good flanker/harassers/etc. Likewise is the readily available Cizin. At 10/15 with 4 cERMLs and a targeting computer, it's pretty beastly, and you can always load infernos for laughs.

The Rokurokubi 4T and 4X are fair to good peril 'Mechs that have their moments. The former's hardened armour makes it surprisingly durable (until you meet the RELs) and the latter with an 8/12+Supercharger and a cERPPC is basically a non-jumping Pack Hunter with a pig-tickler for a bonus. The ballistic-reinforced armour is just gravy.

If you wanted to be a little more esoteric, you could justify a leftover Wendigo or two in your forces. 6/9 with jump jets on some models, and relfective armour means that pulse lasers will be a lot less of a hassle.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 14 February 2014, 18:37:40
The points about the Cizins and Arkab hovers isn't lost.  Perhaps two 'Mech companies, then, and a hover company.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 14 February 2014, 21:32:04
Also worth checking into:

Nyx NX-80/NX-100: An excellent scout and skirmisher. Fast enough to offset its lack of jump jets, for the most part.

Morrigan: A fairly savage skirmisher in every variant, although I wouldn't recommend the 3. All four other variants are great, though.

Ocelot: Like a Wolfhound with a chip on its shoulder. All four are pretty solid but the 3 is probably my favorite.

Talon TLN-6W: A heavy PPC at high speed, with twin standard mediums to backstop the minimums. Can't go wrong here.

Cicada CDA-3F/3G: Old classics, I always like these in my light/medium harasser forces.

Griffin IIC 4/6: I haven't used either but they look nasty on paper, and according to the MUL the DCMS has 'em, so...

Hermes II HER-5Sr: A Marik import that'll slap fools around with the HPPC and smoke infantry with the flamer, plus it brings some ECM on the field.

Stormcrow: I don't think I need to sell you on the Stormcrow. And it's on the DC MUL list.

Wraith TR1/2: Again, I really don't need to sell you on the Wraith, I'm guessing.

Hellhound 2: It was common with the Nova Cats and shows up on the DC's MUL. Looks great on paper but I haven't used it myself.

Mad Cat Mk III: This seems like it would make an excellent ride for a lance commander. Alternately, a whole lance of these as fire support would be pretty brutal.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 14 February 2014, 21:40:51
So many good ideas.  This is a problem I (personally) have with the Dark Ages; there's so much choice I can't keep stuff organized in my head like I could in the old days, even into 3050 or so.  I'm not complaining about the game, only my own brains, and to help fix that I have you guys.  So many good rides...now if only I could get my hands on the Ferro-Lamellor prototype of the MCIII...and so many other good things.  Time to stalk the MUL!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 14 February 2014, 22:47:15
I will always profess my love for the Rokurokubi -4K. This mech is the new Panther. It still has an ERPPC, and heavy armor (thanks to Hardened armor it can take more damage than many medium mechs), but now it is much faster (7/10 vs 4/6/4). Pair these with Jenners and drive your enemies mad with fast, unkillable little support mechs. ...and last, just for fun, hack them apart with your sword.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 15 February 2014, 00:40:28
I will always profess my love for the Rokurokubi -4K. This mech is the new Panther.
Suddenly this 'Mech has passed from 'okay not bad' to 'AH HAH' in my head. I do love me some Punts, and the longneck (which is even funnier as it's so damn stumpy) is a perfect followon.

The Mad Cat III is going to have to show up just because yes.  And all the other ideas...yeah, I'm all over this.  Thank you guys, I love you so.  I'll have a unit put together at some point soon enough; maybe I'll even splurge on minis for them - haha yeah right, I couldn't paint a mini if I dunked it in the jar.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 15 February 2014, 01:28:30
Happy to help. It's a very cool concept for a unit. Please do post the completed roster up when it's finished, I'm curious to see how it turns out.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 17 February 2014, 17:41:38
Happy to help. It's a very cool concept for a unit. Please do post the completed roster up when it's finished, I'm curious to see how it turns out.
http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,37412.msg865699.html (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,37412.msg865699.html)
Gentlemen, behold, etc etc.  It works I guess.  Trying to keep it going with as much DC-specific stuff as I could, guess it works.  Kamakiris and mixed hovers makes me giggle in bad, bad ways.  The 'Mech design turned out well enough, snubbies and LPLs everywhere with a dose of HPPCs and ERs for fun.  Yay concepts.

Anyway, that out of the system, who thinks Katana Tormark is still around, and if her name is cool enough in an 80s way that she isn't going to die anytime soon?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 17 February 2014, 20:23:49
I think with most stories, since they've mentioned her twice now without specifically saying that she's dead (Just imprisoned, IIRC) I'd say she's going to be around and important.

With the storyline focused mainly on sourcebooks, that's a little less likely. Easier to forget about her/write her off.

I wouldn't be surprised to see her as a possible disliked ally of convenience of Yori's at some point.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 17 February 2014, 20:38:57
Well, she is a good commander, and DID get Dieron.  Maybe a royal pardon or something, and she comes back partially cyborg'ed from her torture.  That would be...god could you GET any more 80s than that?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 17 February 2014, 21:07:18
Tormark got Dieron because the Republic put up pretty much no fight for it. Things might have gone differently had they decided they needed to hang onto it. Not saying the Combine wouldn't have prevailed in the end, but the fight would have been much nastier and costly. I'm not sure the ease with which Tormark got Dieron is really a point in her favor.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 17 February 2014, 22:44:52
Eh, fair enough.  We just need more cool names like that.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 18 February 2014, 10:23:12
Tormark got Dieron because the Republic put up pretty much no fight for it.

Mostly in the form of a guilt trip.

Her being imprisoned does leave some storytelling possibilities open.  I wonder if/when Katana gets out she'll be as lovestruck with the Combine as she was before.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 18 February 2014, 10:29:37
Mostly in the form of a guilt trip.

Her being imprisoned does leave some storytelling possibilities open.  I wonder if/when Katana gets out she'll be as lovestruck with the Combine as she was before.

I'm figuring that in the event there is a Yori/Toranaga power struggle, I give a 1 in 3 chance one of them busts Katana out to use against the other. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 18 February 2014, 11:12:28
I'm figuring that in the event there is a Yori/Toranaga power struggle, I give a 1 in 3 chance one of them busts Katana out to use against the other. 
Reading through her entry on Sarna, I'm curious how that might play out.  She seems to be more skilled in underhanded deals and information/bribery/other means than direct battle, though Tormark did end up doing very well in her battle drills and other such things.  I dunno, maybe she Littlefingered her way to the top, rather than was any sort of Mighty Warrioress.  That would explain why she's given such a suspicious notdeath and implications of being a tortured prisoner.  Who wouldn't want to know all her secrets at that point?

I find it interesting, though, that Vincent appointed her to the post.  I find it much more interesting that she sent a note to a Nova Cat and got a galaxy at her back in return.  It certainly shows why she'd have backed Emi Kurita, since she's the only direct relation.  A little too much loyalty at the wrong time, but...

12 MAR 3143 Katana Tormark imprisoned on Luthien, ultimately to rot and be forgotten until the day the Dragon decides to execute her.

Mr. Chekhov, your firearm is ready.  (Then again I believe in red herrings and such, and disagree with the second half of his concept)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 18 February 2014, 11:23:48
Reading through her entry on Sarna, I'm curious how that might play out.  She seems to be more skilled in underhanded deals and information/bribery/other means than direct battle, though Tormark did end up doing very well in her battle drills and other such things.  I dunno, maybe she Littlefingered her way to the top, rather than was any sort of Mighty Warrioress.  That would explain why she's given such a suspicious notdeath and implications of being a tortured prisoner.  Who wouldn't want to know all her secrets at that point?

I find it interesting, though, that Vincent appointed her to the post.  I find it much more interesting that she sent a note to a Nova Cat and got a galaxy at her back in return.  It certainly shows why she'd have backed Emi Kurita, since she's the only direct relation.  A little too much loyalty at the wrong time, but...

12 MAR 3143 Katana Tormark imprisoned on Luthien, ultimately to rot and be forgotten until the day the Dragon decides to execute her.

Mr. Chekhov, your firearm is ready.  (Then again I believe in red herrings and such, and disagree with the second half of his concept)

I think the more likely 2 in 3 odds is that TPTB just removed Katana summarily from the storyline as a small part of the bigger picture of cleaning house from moving he focus of the BTU from Pirate Bands back to the states and Houses of the Inner Sphere.

That being said, if they do 'resurrect' Katana's role in the story, here are some ideas how within the context of Yori vs Toranaga power struggles:

Toranaga lets her out:  He arranges for her to be sprung from jail and re-arms her via intermediaries while keeping his hands clean.  Points to any and all successes Katana has in embarrassing the Combine by existing, and blames it all on Yori.  Once Yori is replaced with a more compliant cadet branch scion (no point in subduing her once she breaks free the first time) he plans to crush Katana's pitiful band again at his leisure.

Toranaga lets her out, mk II: He springs Katana out to use her AS a new puppet in place of Yori after she slips his control.   I suppose he'd have to play her up as a misguided but true patriot while he martyrs Emi Kurita.  (easy enough to do at this point, now that she's long dead).  Rather than putting Katana on the throne, he'd be using Katana as a lightning rod while he Oliver Cromwels HIMSELF on the throne.

Yori lets her out: If/when Yori gets to where Toranaga is an enemy, she needs allies.  I'm sure the ISF and/or the O5P can ensure/compel compliance on behelf of a 'rehabilitated' Katana while she's named the new Kanrei and tasked with putting down Toranaga.. and I can even see Katana being mostly willing to go along due to his prominent role in engineering her downfall in the first place.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 18 February 2014, 12:34:58
You forgot the option where the director of the ISF releases her.  She is (or at least was), after all, in their custody.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 18 February 2014, 12:45:13
You forgot the option where the director of the ISF releases her.  She is (or at least was), after all, in their custody.

Wasn't so much as 'forgot' as wasn't attempting to list all conceivable scenarios.  True, the security apparatus might release her for its own ends rather than being directed to by Yori or Toranaga.

There's not yet any foreshadowing that the ISF might open a new front on the domestic intrigue of the Combine, but within the fluff we've yet seen the ISF might take it upon itself to play kingmaker and pick a side between Yori and Toranaga.  Could be particularly interesting if they choose to act before those two come to a decision to act against the other...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 18 February 2014, 13:02:06
I think the more likely 2 in 3 odds is that TPTB just removed Katana summarily from the storyline as a small part of the bigger picture of cleaning house from moving he focus of the BTU from Pirate Bands back to the states and Houses of the Inner Sphere.
Sad but true, but such is the wheel of time.
Toranaga lets her out, mk II: He springs Katana out to use her AS a new puppet in place of Yori after she slips his control.   I suppose he'd have to play her up as a misguided but true patriot while he martyrs Emi Kurita.  (easy enough to do at this point, now that she's long dead).  Rather than putting Katana on the throne, he'd be using Katana as a lightning rod while he Oliver Cromwels HIMSELF on the throne.
Considering that's damn near what the Kanrei's namesake did in Shogun, I'm backing this one with a donut.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 18 February 2014, 17:50:47
Wasn't so much as 'forgot' as wasn't attempting to list all conceivable scenarios.  True, the security apparatus might release her for its own ends rather than being directed to by Yori or Toranaga.

There's not yet any foreshadowing that the ISF might open a new front on the domestic intrigue of the Combine, but within the fluff we've yet seen the ISF might take it upon itself to play kingmaker and pick a side between Yori and Toranaga.  Could be particularly interesting if they choose to act before those two come to a decision to act against the other...

Historically the ISF have repeatedly been involved in the replacement of a Coordinator they deemed unworthy and the ISF did play a key role in replacing Vincent Kurita's line with Yori Kurita (whether by actively participating in the elimination of the line or ignoring the plots to eliminate the line is not quite clear).  It should be interesting to see what happens if the ISF decides that Yori and Toranaga's (or maybe simply Toranaga's-they might want to remove his influence on the Coordinator and replace it with their own) existence is detrimental to the future of the Draconis Combine.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 18 February 2014, 18:54:33
Historically the ISF have repeatedly been involved in the replacement of a Coordinator they deemed unworthy...

Indeedy so.

Ever since the touchy-feely era of Teddy K's reign, the Combine has been notably deficient in its traditional changing of power via political assassinations.

Kinda nice to get back to the fundamentals in 3145, isn't it? :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 18 February 2014, 20:13:50
Kinda nice to get back to the fundamentals in 3145, isn't it? :)
Amen.  Hardass types who like their samurai ways, I can go for that.

Clearly the Combine needs more duelist mech designs...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 18 February 2014, 22:54:05
Eh, I'd rather not see a return to that. I can understand it in a limited amount (maybe a few designs), but the idea of a duelist on the battlefield hasn't worked since the Clan invasion (and arguably since the end of the 3rd Succession War)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 19 February 2014, 00:14:33
Granted; I should say less 'duelists' and more a case of 'pulling away from teddy's reforms' - not going outright Clan gonzo, but giving more of a nod to the samurai ideal.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 19 February 2014, 02:49:46
Eh. Teddy K's military reforms allowed the Combine to survive. Stepping away from them is a pretty bad idea. Especially with the emphasis on combined arms that we see more and more of.

This was one of the major problems with the Black Dragon Society in the 3050's and 60's. You could almost agree with them returning to a more "traditional" society. But their attempts to undermine the military reforms of Teddy K and return to the "traditional" DCMS would've destroyed the DC.

Sure, it might be one thing to emphasize a traditional "Samurai" outlook for MechWarriors, and maybe even set up some dueling rules/dojos for them and their `Mechs, but that warrior needs to realize that when it comes to actual combat, he'd better be fighting as a team with the rest of the DCMS.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kitsune413 on 24 February 2014, 17:16:49
Operation Bluepeter? Really?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Auren on 25 February 2014, 01:25:48
Eh. Teddy K's military reforms allowed the Combine to survive. Stepping away from them is a pretty bad idea. Especially with the emphasis on combined arms that we see more and more of.

This was one of the major problems with the Black Dragon Society in the 3050's and 60's. You could almost agree with them returning to a more "traditional" society. But their attempts to undermine the military reforms of Teddy K and return to the "traditional" DCMS would've destroyed the DC.

Sure, it might be one thing to emphasize a traditional "Samurai" outlook for MechWarriors, and maybe even set up some dueling rules/dojos for them and their `Mechs, but that warrior needs to realize that when it comes to actual combat, he'd better be fighting as a team with the rest of the DCMS.

All I remember about them is reading their plotline and thinking 'Oh my god you guys are barking idiots.'
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 25 February 2014, 03:35:09
All I remember about them is reading their plotline and thinking 'Oh my god you guys are barking idiots.'
Arf arf arf!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 25 February 2014, 09:32:13
Granted; I should say less 'duelists' and more a case of 'pulling away from teddy's reforms' - not going outright Clan gonzo, but giving more of a nod to the samurai ideal.

The prevailance of the mechwarrior over other forms of combat.  Notice how the DCA quickly lost favor after the Jihad and aerospace hasn't rebounded since?

And those samurai are always disrespectin' the ashigaru.  Farmers and fishers with spears, sure.  But a tank's autocannon means business.  Better recognize, samurai.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 25 February 2014, 10:24:32
The prevailance of the mechwarrior over other forms of combat.  Notice how the DCA quickly lost favor after the Jihad and aerospace hasn't rebounded

Not true check the Wars of the Republic Era. ASF  doubled from 3081 to 3099. Mostly due to the Ravens but still
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 25 February 2014, 11:00:16
Objectives: DCMS notes the critical shortage of ASF pilots not being addressed.  This is a similar situation to 3145 where ASF losses aren't be replaced at the rate they should.  I'm just saying, there is some kind of attitude within the Dragon's conservative elements that don't put as much emphasis training ASF pilots.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 25 February 2014, 11:08:52
...Or they are following the IJN's model in WWII of training the aerospace pilots TOO much. Only accepting the very best candidates and giving them lengthy training cycles could mean that too few pilots are graduating to refill the losses. Sure those pilots in the air are amazing, but they just cannot turn them out fast enough.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 25 February 2014, 11:13:54
It's possible.  That was the mentality for the DCMS academies.  But, they somewhat relaxed that standard to reinforce losses by 3145.

Good catch on the Wars of the Republic numbers.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 26 February 2014, 13:28:50
I've seen Bear and Cat fans talking about the 2nd Dominion War in Historical: Wars of the Republic.  Haven't seen any Kuritan perspective posts.. so here's mine.

The Good:  We knew Ursa Major and most of the DCA's warship fleet died in the war.  I'm glad the Admiralty smashed the Ursa Major in a straight up-fight rather than the ISF destroying it via covert action or some such.  Pretty pleasantly surprised to see that the DCA's battle plan pretty nearly worked perfectly; the warships we lost in that naval battle were nearly not lost.

The Bad: I was unsurprised but still disappointed to see that what kept the Bears from winning the war was the indig Rasalhagian discontent rather than the Pillar of Steel.  I was hoping to finally see the Bears finally lose a conflict militarily, and we'll have to go on waiting for that day to come.  Likewise, I was hoping to see more carnage inflicted upon the Bears' touman and industry than we did.

The Ugly: I'm kind of torn about the torture porn depicting the Nova Cats.  Rather than a grudging toleration for their inclusion into my beloved Kurita faction, I actually have some empathy for them.  Not a good time to be empathic for the Cats.  Not at all.  For those that haven't read it yet, it does indeed make the 3145 books merciful in comparison.
The Black Dragon treatment is kind of puzzling.  They go from omnipotence to oblivion without much of an explanation.  The book, to me, seems to be deliberately setting up a kind of Kurita-specific WoB-parallel "do they still exist in or don't they?" scenario for 3145.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 February 2014, 13:43:28
The Good:  We knew Ursa Major and most of the DCA's warship fleet died in the war.  I'm glad the Admiralty smashed the Ursa Major in a straight up-fight rather than the ISF destroying it via covert action or some such.  Pretty pleasantly surprised to see that the DCA's battle plan pretty nearly worked perfectly; the warships we lost in that naval battle were nearly not lost.

Yeah, the DCA has become a proper blackwater navy.  Fighting the Snow Ravens will do that.

Quote
The Bad: I was unsurprised but still disappointed to see that what kept the Bears from winning the war was the indig Rasalhagian discontent rather than the Pillar of Steel.  I was hoping to finally see the Bears finally lose a conflict militarily, and we'll have to go on waiting for that day to come.  Likewise, I was hoping to see more carnage inflicted upon the Bears' touman and industry than we did.

I think you hit the nail on the head.  It's the Bears, and therefor a military loss is simply not in the cards.  But, it is interesting to see the Rasalhagians actually speaking up for Kuritan interests.  How things have changed...

And yet, not.  As long as Black Dragons are anywhere close to the DCMS it will suffer at the hands of the Ghost Bear Touman.  The Courcheval Trials should have put an end to their silly philosophy.  le sigh.

Quote
The Ugly: I'm kind of torn about the torture porn depicting the Nova Cats.  Rather than a grudging toleration for their inclusion into my beloved Kurita faction, I actually have some empathy for them.  Not a good time to be empathic for the Cats.  Not at all.  For those that haven't read it yet, it does indeed make the 3145 books merciful in comparison.

Without dragging in RL events, I can't say i'm overly surprised by the turn of events.  The use of the term Ganjin under the Ajax Drummond write up says it all.  The Cats aren't Draconis and that's the end of the discussion.  Yeah, they sort of brought it on themselves (not really, i mean who really deserves genocide?) by screwing with the Bears.  But, as someone else said, it highlights the importance of the Spirit Cat movement as being vital to the survival of the clan.

Quote
The Black Dragon treatment is kind of puzzling.  They go from omnipotence to oblivion without much of an explanation.  The book, to me, seems to be deliberately setting up a kind of Kurita-specific WoB-parallel "do they still exist in or don't they?" scenario for 3145.

I gather that Minamoto was the main figurehead allowing the Black Dragons to exert so much control.  With his demise everyone went into hiding.  I took this mostly to mean the ISF finally got sick of the BD meddling and went for an unmasking.  Minamoto's seppuku saved him from being outed and all of his people revealed.  And yeah, the Black Dragon mentality still very much exists.  Toranaga's goals are so parallel it's spooky.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 26 February 2014, 15:47:44
I'm still not convinced Toranaga's a closet Black Dragon.

And ugh, those WarShips! Very painful to read this section.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 February 2014, 15:56:29
I'm not sure he is a Black Dragon, either.  But some of his ideas seem influenced by Black Dragon thought, like the supremacy of the samurai class, mechwarriors and a general disdain for combined arms and eta.  His attack against the Nova Cats is also mentioned before he has Chomie, Vincent or Emi (supposedly) killed, which indicates he had plans to put the boot to them prior to Khan Nostra offered refuge to Emi.  That could be a cooincidence, sprung from a general dislike of the Nova Cats, or it could be a continuation of Black Dragon policy of Nova Cat extermination.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 26 February 2014, 16:06:24
Its a shame about the mobile factories. I had hoped they would get away with the sacrifice of the Amber Lotus.


This may sound somewhat cruel...but how cool is it that the mainline DC comes across as the sane one in the fight? No state sponsored genocide programs, no mass executions of prisoners as far as I can tell. Compared to the Ghost Bears, the DC comes off as the voice of Reason.

Okay, the reactionary Black Dragons don't, as we see with mass graves at the end, but that isn't official DC policy.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 26 February 2014, 16:44:03
I think you miss the chance to be the good guy when you fail to purge the Black Dragons after the Jihad.  Minamoto or not, they tried to take over the Combine by force and used nuclear weapons on Luthien.  It is the Dragon's fault they were all hunted down like the dogs they are.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 26 February 2014, 17:18:59
That doesn't make them the bad guy though, or really take away from seemingly being the good guy in the conflict with the Ghost Bears.

Failing to destroy the Black Dragons just makes them flawed, not skewed on a moral scale.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: E. Icaza on 26 February 2014, 18:38:18
Being less bad than everyone else does not make you the good guy.   ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 26 February 2014, 18:40:38
It's not like the Combine didn't try; it's just that a movement like this is going to be hard to ever get rid of.  I find a poetic sort of circularity, actually.  The Black Dragon society, an underground terrorist movement, started the 2nd DomCom war - and an underground terrorist movement from Rasalhague ended it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Auren on 27 February 2014, 13:54:55
This may sound somewhat cruel...but how cool is it that the mainline DC comes across as the sane one in the fight? No state sponsored genocide programs, no mass executions of prisoners as far as I can tell. Compared to the Ghost Bears, the DC comes off as the voice of Reason.

What? Reasonable commands in my DCMS? More likely then you think! :o

Failing to destroy the Black Dragons just makes them flawed, not skewed on a moral scale.
Yeah, having the Draconis Combine having their crap together is... a rare thing.  ;D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 27 February 2014, 14:12:52
What? Reasonable commands in my DCMS? More likely then you think! :o

Speaking of reasonable commands, was anyone else surprised that enough members of the Genyosha were Black Dragon to go raiding into the Republic to try to trigger a war? Sure, they're Samurai, but the Genyosha are hardly what one would consider "traditional."
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 27 February 2014, 16:13:34
Speaking of reasonable commands, was anyone else surprised that enough members of the Genyosha were Black Dragon to go raiding into the Republic to try to trigger a war? Sure, they're Samurai, but the Genyosha are hardly what one would consider "traditional."

I did think that was odd unless they were duped by that other unit.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 27 February 2014, 16:16:33
I'm not sure he is a Black Dragon, either.  But some of his ideas seem influenced by Black Dragon thought, like the supremacy of the samurai class, mechwarriors and a general disdain for combined arms and eta.  His attack against the Nova Cats is also mentioned before he has Chomie, Vincent or Emi (supposedly) killed, which indicates he had plans to put the boot to them prior to Khan Nostra offered refuge to Emi.  That could be a cooincidence, sprung from a general dislike of the Nova Cats, or it could be a continuation of Black Dragon policy of Nova Cat extermination.

I don't know. The ISF Director thought he was one and after the Director/Coordinator morning meeting (7 hours long) ole Mini was invited onward. I'm thinking there was enough evidence to convince Hohirto that his best buddy was a Black Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: roosterboy on 27 February 2014, 16:23:53
I don't know. The ISF Director thought he was one and after the Director/Coordinator morning meeting (7 hours long) ole Mini was invited onward. I'm thinking there was enough evidence to convince Hohirto that his best buddy was a Black Dragon.

False Son is talking about Toranaga, Kanrei in 3145, not Minamoto, Kanrei in the late 3000s.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kitsune413 on 28 February 2014, 10:14:36
False Son is talking about Toranaga, Kanrei in 3145, not Minamoto, Kanrei in the late 3000s.

It doesn't talk much about who Toranaga's co-conspirators are. But the dude certainly has a huge dark secret trait.

I haven't really dug into the Draconis Combine Books for the Dark Ages.

Any hints RB?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 28 February 2014, 10:29:05
It doesn't talk much about who Toranaga's co-conspirators are. But the dude certainly has a huge dark secret trait.

His list of pawns is long.  Not sure about co conspirators.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 28 February 2014, 17:45:24
I assume his Toranaga's dark secret is that he killed of the majority of the Kurita line that was ruling the DC at the time and put Yori on the throne.

He doesn't really come across as a Black Dragon however. He seems to want a strong DC and not necessarily a return to the "Traditional" that will kill the DC.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: wolfgar on 02 March 2014, 22:42:20
Ok I have a stupid question.  What would be a normal medium ASF for a combine pilot in the late 3050's?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Alexander Knight on 02 March 2014, 22:52:25
Ok I have a stupid question.  What would be a normal medium ASF for a combine pilot in the late 3050's?

Shilone
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 03 March 2014, 18:47:09
Ok I have a stupid question.  What would be a normal medium ASF for a combine pilot in the late 3050's?
Shilone

That's the correct answer pretty much irrespective of a specific timeframe.  It's so important it was one of the first things to ever get double heat sinks.  And it seems a priority to keep the spaceframe updated as tech continues to advance.  The SL-18 is about as all-round good as an ASF gets without a XL engine.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 04 March 2014, 12:11:19
I assume his Toranaga's dark secret is that he killed of the majority of the Kurita line that was ruling the DC at the time and put Yori on the throne.

He doesn't really come across as a Black Dragon however. He seems to want a strong DC and not necessarily a return to the "Traditional" that will kill the DC.

Where does conservative end and Black Dragon begin?  We know Toranaga abuses the Ghost regiments, isn't replacing aerospace or conventional forces as quickly as he should, put an illegitimate puppet on the throne and killed off the Nova Cats.  Every one of those sounds like Black Dragon material to me.  Other than getting rid of C3 and battle armor it sounds like a page out of the Black Dragon handbook.

And there were some references to the gemwork in the Kuritan Dragon tapestry in the Combine novels.  I'm not sure if that is an indirect reference to how Black Dragons went by gemstone names, and that one of them is now literally in the throne room.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 04 March 2014, 13:09:22
That's the correct answer pretty much irrespective of a specific timeframe.  It's so important it was one of the first things to ever get double heat sinks.

And that's all they did to a design that didn't actually need DHS to stay cool unless someone was throwing Infernos around.  This may be one of the least inspired upgrades the Combine has ever issued for field service.  It's definitely among the most pointless.  Then they turned around and did it again with the Slayer.

Considering the number of DCMS 'Mechs that seriously needed DHS in the 3050s, this is even sadder.

And it seems a priority to keep the spaceframe updated as tech continues to advance.

Personally, I think if that was a priority, they would have actually done the job correctly on the SL-17R or issued a refit to meaningfully improve on the SL-17 sometime in the intervening 26 years before the SL-18 entered service.

The SL-18 is about as all-round good as an ASF gets without a XL engine.

[legal]  It has an XL engine.  It says that right in the TRO entry.  The 7 tons difference between the launcher and ammo tonnages (15 tons on the SL-17/17R, 22 tons on the SL-18) was paid for with an XL engine and the change over to ferro-aluminum.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 04 March 2014, 15:02:15
And that's all they did to a design that didn't actually need DHS to stay cool unless someone was throwing Infernos around.  This may be one of the least inspired upgrades the Combine has ever issued for field service.  It's definitely among the most pointless.  Then they turned around and did it again with the Slayer.

Well, as much as I like the Slayer, it's a relic of an entirely different game.  Back when you had to actually pay for your thrust, both in terms of heat and fuel, it was designed to not only blaze its weapons every turn but maneuver while doing it, all without overheating.  Now that you pay nothing to maneuver, it's criminally oversinked and overfuelled.  It should have gotten a redesign when the rules changed, but que sera.  It could well be that the Shilone is a wacky case of OOC inertia represented IC, since iirc the Aerotech rules changed about that time DHS Shilones showed up.

Quote
It has an XL engine.  It says that right in the TRO entry.  The 7 tons difference between the launcher and ammo tonnages (15 tons on the SL-17/17R, 22 tons on the SL-18) was paid for with an XL engine and the change over to ferro-aluminum.

So it does.  Goes to show how enthusiastic I am about XL ASFs.  All the advantages for none of the drawbacks!  How exciting to keep atop of how the new stuff makes the old stuff obsolete.  I guess it certainly does make the SL-18 less special now ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 06 March 2014, 10:14:40
Where does conservative end and Black Dragon begin?  We know Toranaga abuses the Ghost regiments, isn't replacing aerospace or conventional forces as quickly as he should, put an illegitimate puppet on the throne and killed off the Nova Cats.  Every one of those sounds like Black Dragon material to me.  Other than getting rid of C3 and battle armor it sounds like a page out of the Black Dragon handbook.

I agree. Its tough to call the line between a Black Dragon and a simple conservative. (if there even is one). But he's not as bad as the Black Dragons. After all, he's employing mercs, something which would probably be anathema to the Black Dragon society, especially the Dragoons. He's competent, which seems to be a departure from the Black Dragons as well, whose meddling usually causes the DC to get into fights it can't afford (See First Combine/Bears War, Second Combine/Bears War, Invasion of Towne, etc).

Yes, `Mechs are getting put back into the forefront of DC society, but that isn't too surprising. And FM3145 states that its a lack of trained pilots that's holding the DC back, not necessarily because they're dragging on replacing the forces.

Quote
And there were some references to the gemwork in the Kuritan Dragon tapestry in the Combine novels.  I'm not sure if that is an indirect reference to how Black Dragons went by gemstone names, and that one of them is now literally in the throne room.

The only thing I remember like that was a mural with each planet being represented by gemstones, with the "missing" planets in black, IIRC.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 06 March 2014, 10:28:13
I agree. Its tough to call the line between a Black Dragon and a simple conservative. (if there even is one). But he's not as bad as the Black Dragons. After all, he's employing mercs, something which would probably be anathema to the Black Dragon society, especially the Dragoons. He's competent, which seems to be a departure from the Black Dragons as well, whose meddling usually causes the DC to get into fights it can't afford (See First Combine/Bears War, Second Combine/Bears War, Invasion of Towne, etc).

His policies are not as riddled with obvious flaws as Black Dragons of the past.  Hadn't thought of the Dragoons angle.

Quote
Yes, `Mechs are getting put back into the forefront of DC society, but that isn't too surprising. And FM3145 states that its a lack of trained pilots that's holding the DC back, not necessarily because they're dragging on replacing the forces.

The mechwarriors academies loosened their graduation standards to fill the needs of DCMS mech replacements.  The same policy could have happened with the DCA, but didn't.  It seems odd to mass mobilize the way the DCMS did without doing it across the board, especially when the DCA helped pull off the Palmyra massacre.  I'm led to believe it isn't an accident.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 March 2014, 02:54:57
Wat!?!

Did y'all see this erratum? (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,33732.msg849525.html)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 08 March 2014, 04:49:01
Wat!?!

Did y'all see this erratum? (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,33732.msg849525.html)
Frankly that's how I thought it worked the whole time.  It makes sense; think of it as ECM-vulnerable C3 and ECM-invulnerable C3.  If your Master's vulnerable, and caught in an ECM field, then the invulnerable slave doesn't have anything to talk to.

In other words, boost every Master you have and never bother with the unboosted ones, but Slaves can be either or - they're a lot less critical.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 08 March 2014, 11:36:59
I thought of the rise of BC3 components was weakening C3, since they were ruled for a while as being incompatible.

Now that they ARE compatible, BC3 units from 3145 are looking much more attractive.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 08 March 2014, 23:28:21
So, this is going to be a step into the wayback machine, but for the longest time, FM: Draconis Combine was more or less the only one of the old set of Field Manuals that I didn't own.  Well, finally broke down and got it from eBay.

And holy crap.  These are some of the most interesting and entertaining units I've seen!  I'm sad I didn't get this Field Manual earlier!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: FedSunsBorn on 09 March 2014, 00:14:18
I lost my original copy years ago and only recently got a new one back and I'm not regretting it one bit. Now I have all 5 field manuals...it only took a decade or so...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 09 March 2014, 15:39:51
So given the question and answer here :- http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,37867.0.html

What designs do you expect LAW to have resurrected.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 09 March 2014, 15:50:17
So given the question and answer here :- http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,37867.0.html

What designs do you expect LAW to have resurrected.

If I'm not mistaken, a lot of the LAW designs are being produced at other facilities as well (whether it's satellite LAW offices such as the ones on New Samarkand and Nykvarn, or other companies entirely, such as Victory Industries and possibly Independence Weaponry assuming they successfully moved/created a factory on New Samarkand while the DC doesn't own Quentin, which it does again).  So ideally, they'd go for some of the designs that aren't being produced elsewhere.

2/3s of the original IS Omnis, I'm looking at you.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 09 March 2014, 15:55:50
So given the question and answer here :- http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,37867.0.html

What designs do you expect LAW to have resurrected.

Well, I'd like to see more Daimyos.  I've always had a soft spot for those little guys.  Seems like a pretty appropriate candidate for the "such as Komodos" language.  Since it's all intentionally left to the GM's playground, I suppose virtually anything could be fit in.  I'd consider any of the classes formerly produced on Luthien as being perfectly plausible. (especially Chargers.. I'm pessimistically convinced we'll never away from those being the DCMS standard assault class)  A 'new' line of some old DCMS favorite like Wolverines or Panthers could fit within the bounds of reasonable doubt as well, perhaps.  I agree with jklantern that classes that are already being produced elsewhere in the Combine are probably lower priority than something else widely used but no longer produced.

The fanboi in me would also love to see the 1st generation IS omnis getting new production lines on Luthien, too.



Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 09 March 2014, 15:59:09
Well, I'd like to see more Daimyos.  I've always had a soft spot for those little guys.  Seems like a pretty appropriate candidate for the "such as Komodos" language.  Since it's all intentionally left to the GM's playground, I suppose virtually anything could be fit in.  I'd consider any of the classes formerly produced on Luthien as being perfectly plausible. (especially Chargers.. I'm pessimistically convinced we'll never away from those being the DCMS standard assault class)  A 'new' line of some old DCMS favorite like Wolverines or Panthers could fit within the bounds of reasonable doubt as well, perhaps. 

The fanboi in me would also love to see the 1st generation IS omnis getting new production lines on Luthien, too.

Hey, what's wrong with the Charger?  Bigger lasers are for people who don't know how to fight.   O0

(Actually, looking through FM: DC, I got a laugh out of the F Rated Assault Table.  If you're sane, you REALLY don't want to be in an F Rated Assault unit in the DC at that time!)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 10 March 2014, 02:36:16
DCMS Chargers are fine machines.  They don't ONLY produce the 1A1 you know.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 10 March 2014, 02:55:57
DCMS Chargers are fine machines.  They don't ONLY produce the 1A1 you know.

CGR-KMZ - relatively usable variant, although not especialy great

CGR-3Kr - nasty brawler
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 10 March 2014, 03:00:24
Hey, even the 1A9 and 3K are good machines for their eras.  And could darn well be a lot worse.  No argument on those two, though.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 11 March 2014, 13:44:38
These are some of the most interesting and entertaining units I've seen!  I'm sad I didn't get this Field Manual earlier!

I got kind of soured on the FM:DCMS.

The writers seemed to have some serious faults in doing their Kurita homework, and in my view they apparently issued unintentional retcons out of their laziness.  Most egregiously in the entire organization of the Pillar of Steel: the relationships between the Ministry of War, the DCMS, and the DCA.  Whereas that can theoretically be chalked up as a 'clarification' rather than error, the completely new Amphigean Brigade lore can be nothing but ignorance of its pre-existing lore.

Obviously, I prefer the pre-existing lore and unit insignia (sourced from the Galtor campaign) to the FM:DCMS lore and robo-shark insignia. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: foxbat on 11 March 2014, 15:05:04


Obviously, I prefer the pre-existing lore and unit insignia (sourced from the Galtor campaign) to the FM:DCMS lore and robo-shark insignia.

The robot-shark insignia dates back to the FM:DC actually (p95) so it's nothing new as far as I can tell.  :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 11 March 2014, 15:49:42
The robot-shark insignia dates back to the FM:DC actually (p95) so it's nothing new as far as I can tell.  :)

My point is the Roboshark insignia and lore as being descendants of Chain gangs are 'newfangled' as of FM:DC.  Prior to that, they were established as having a bugle insignia (http://www.fightingpirannhagraphics.com/decals/KuritaAmphigeanLAGold.htm) and the lore of being the armed force of a Combine agricultural corporation.  (One of Amphigean's big money makers was renting out their regiments to debt collectors) Being 'domestic' Combine troops they were not considered truly 'mercenary', but still operated on behalf of the DCMS on a for-profit basis.

Since none of this was mentioned in FM:DC, I can only presume the writers wrongly assumed the Amphigean brigade had no previous fluff (since they didn't get their original lore in the House Kurita book) and ignorantly made up 'new' lore.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 11 March 2014, 20:28:00
My point is the Roboshark insignia and lore as being descendants of Chain gangs are 'newfangled' as of FM:DC.  Prior to that, they were established as having a bugle insignia (http://www.fightingpirannhagraphics.com/decals/KuritaAmphigeanLAGold.htm) and the lore of being the armed force of a Combine agricultural corporation.  (One of Amphigean's big money makers was renting out their regiments to debt collectors) Being 'domestic' Combine troops they were not considered truly 'mercenary', but still operated on behalf of the DCMS on a for-profit basis.

Since none of this was mentioned in FM:DC, I can only presume the writers wrongly assumed the Amphigean brigade had no previous fluff (since they didn't get their original lore in the House Kurita book) and ignorantly made up 'new' lore.

I like the agricultural legbreaker fluff better as well for the ALG.  But units like the 11th Legion of Vega, the 5th Ghost, the Nightstalkers, the Ryuken-San, the characterization of basically the entire Benjamin Regulars, I thoroughly enjoyed.  They had some of the most personality of any units in Battletech.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 13 March 2014, 05:12:54
No write up for the units history but they have used the original bugle symbol.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neufeld on 13 March 2014, 07:31:18
Some say that they were originally troops of an agricultural company, others say that they was originally a chain gang, ... All we know is they're called the Amphigean Light Assault Group.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 13 March 2014, 07:48:41
Does anyone know if they revisit the original lore for the Amphigeans in the modern .pdf?

It has the bugle logo, but there's no mention of any lore prior to Galtor.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 13 March 2014, 08:39:36
It has the bugle logo, but there's no mention of any lore prior to Galtor.

I find it a shame they didn't re-confirm the Galtor lore version of the Amphigean units.  But I'll take a non-confirmation of the Chain-gang lore as a win, as well.  Incidents like this is surely why TPTB try so hard with fact checking new publications.

(I wish they'd just quit refusing to budge on simply retconning away lore that blatantly contradicts pre-existing lore, like the chain-gang origin story or Kaznejov being spelled Kaznejoy)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 15 March 2014, 06:17:42
While this discussion is interesting, I need to point out that FM:DC does not state that the Amphigean Light Assault Groups were formed from chain gangs nor does it completely exclude the lore as portrayed in the original Galtor scenario book.  FM:DC (p94): "While organizing the Chain Gang Missions....Jinjiro recognized that the Draconis Combine could use a few standing regiments of shock troops trained to soften up an enemy's tough spot.  Thus, he proposed the creation of the Amphigean Light Assault Groups."  No direct connection, besides acting as inspiration for their formation, between the chain gangs and the Amphigean Light Assault Groups is given.

As far as their insignia is concerned, it wouldn't be the first time that a regiment changed its insignia.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 15 March 2014, 10:28:50
Was there anything that described the composition of a chain gang?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 15 March 2014, 10:40:32
Was there anything that described the composition of a chain gang?

House Kurita Housebook (FASA 1620), p. 62. It used to be available for free download.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 20 March 2014, 14:34:55
Since doing regimental nicknames doesn't seem to be in vogue for TPTB anymore, I didn't bother asking for them in the ask the writers/dev forum.  What do we fans think the undefined nicknames for regiments of 3145 should be?  Who knows, we might give each other some winners for our own head-canons.

Benjamin District Regulars:
2nd Regiment: Defenders of the Combine
6th Regiment: Lord Kurita's Hopes
17th Regiment: The Power of Proper Religion
43rd Regiment:
44th Regiment:
45th Regiment:

Dieron District Regulars:
1st Regiment:
2nd Regiment:
3rd Regiment:
4th Regiment:

Galedon District Regulars:
5th Regiment: Pride of Galedon
16th Regiment: The Keepers of Treasures
19th Regiment: The Protectors of Karma

New Samarkand District Regulars:
1st Regiment:
2nd Regiment: Pride of Weisau?
7th Regiment:
12th Regiment:
20th Regiment:
22nd Regiment:
45th Regiment:

Pesht District Regulars:
3rd Regiment: possibly assumed The Gray Panthers, possibly retained Warriors of the Night, possibly something entirely new.
6th Regiment: The New Hopes -probably ripe for something new in 3145.. their 3025 era name is backhanded compliment towards their semi-reservist nature that rarely saw combat and doesn't account for the modern action on the Clan borders
7th Regiment: The Future Guards -probably ripe for something new in 3145.. their 3025 era name is backhanded compliment towards their semi-reservist nature that rarely saw combat and doesn't account for the modern action on the Clan borders
10th Regiment: The Red Dawn
17th Regiment:
19th Regiment:
20th Regiment:
21st Regiment:

Sword of Light Legion:
1st SoL: The Ivory Dragon
2nd SoL: The Coordinator's Own?
4th SoL: The Steel Dragon?
5th SoL: The Gold Dragon
7th SoL: The Teak Dragon
8th SoL: The Jade Dragon

Genyosha Legion:
1st Regiment: The Legacy of Yoranaga
2nd Regiment: Lord Yori's Vanguard ?

Otomo Legion:
1st Otomo: The Dragon's Warders

Izanagi Legion:
1st Izanagi Warriors: The Dragon's Claws

Sun Zhang Legion:
5th Cadre: Perseverance
13th Cadre: Tenacity
16th Cadre: Diligence
17th Cadre:
18th Cadre:
19th Cadre:

Ryuken Legion:
Ryuken-ni: Dutiful Sons
Ryuken-san: Strength of the Dragon
Ryuken-go: The Steel Edge
Ryuken-roku: Flawless Victory
Ryuken-nana:
Ryuken-hachi:

Legions of Vega:
2nd Regiment: The Pillagers
7th Regiment:
8th Regiment:

Ghost Regiments:
1st Ghost: The Many-Colored Winds of Fate
5th Ghost: The Mirrored Edge of Dedication
7th Ghost: Cleansed by Dragon's Dark Passing
11th Ghost: Bringers of Light and Life

Amphigean Legion
1st LAG: Satterthwaite's Regiment, may have become Legacy of Blood
2nd LAG: Gramenov's Regiment, Stonethrower's Regiment in 3145?

Arkab Legions:
1st Regiment:
2nd Regiment: Defenders of the Faithful
4th Regiment: Allah's Blessings
6th Regiment: Desert Nomads

An Ting Legions:
2nd Regiment: The Light of Enlightenment
3rd Regiment:


Red=name that goes back at least as far as 3025
Purple=name that goes back at least as far as 3059
Green=Possible new name as of the Dark Age
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 20 March 2014, 16:46:28
When were the 3rd Proserpina Hussars ever the Grey Panthers? THey were always Warriors of the Night.

The 2nd New Samarkand Regulars was the 2nd DR. Before the name change they were The Pride of Shionoha. as the 2nd NSR they are Pride left Weisau. Maybe the new 2nd DR should rename themselves  the Pride of Shionaha.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 20 March 2014, 16:57:22
When were the 3rd Proserpina Hussars ever the Grey Panthers? THey were always Warriors of the Night.

Never, but the 3rd Pesht Regulars of the 3025 era were called the Gray Panthers.  When the 3rd Proserpina became the new 3rd Pesht, did the Ministry of War retire the colors of the 3rd Prosperpina or the colors of the (orginal) 3rd Pesht?  Or, maybe, both, and starting anew akin the New Samarkand Regiment situation.  Speaking of...

Quote
The 2nd New Samarkand Regulars was the 2nd DR. Before the name change they were The Pride of Shionoha. as the 2nd NSR they are Pride left Weisau. Maybe the new 2nd DR should rename themselves  the Pride of Shionaha.

There was a whole to do about the ex-Dieron regiments being reborn as new entities.. the 2nd Dieron did not retain its battle honors or traditions once it became the 2nd New Samarkand.  Although, if there's a source that says they've since become the Pride of Weisau, that'd be cool to know.

I'm dubious about the new 2nd Dieron assuming that old nickname.  Not only is the 7th Vega currently showing the flag for Kurita on that world, it's probably too tentatively-held to have an entire regiment bearing its name yet.  Way too much loss of face should Shionoha fall to the Dominion or a resurgent Republic.  And besides, it defeats the purpose of insisting the 2nd Dieron Regulars of 3145 is a completely different regiment than the pre-Jihad 2nd Dieron.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neufeld on 20 March 2014, 17:25:00
Since doing regimental nicknames doesn't seem to be in vogue for TPTB anymore, I didn't bother asking for them in the ask the

You realize that nearly all of the CC and FWL units got nicknames in 3145? So, to me it looks more like it depended on the author, rather than being some kind of general policy.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 21 March 2014, 11:42:32
Never, but the 3rd Pesht Regulars of the 3025 era were called the Gray Panthers.  When the 3rd Proserpina became the new 3rd Pesht, did the Ministry of War retire the colors of the 3rd Prosperpina or the colors of the (orginal) 3rd Pesht?  Or, maybe, both, and starting anew akin the New Samarkand Regiment situation.  Speaking of...

There was a whole to do about the ex-Dieron regiments being reborn as new entities.. the 2nd Dieron did not retain its battle honors or traditions once it became the 2nd New Samarkand.  Although, if there's a source that says they've since become the Pride of Weisau, that'd be cool to know.

I'm dubious about the new 2nd Dieron assuming that old nickname.  Not only is the 7th Vega currently showing the flag for Kurita on that world, it's probably too tentatively-held to have an entire regiment bearing its name yet.  Way too much loss of face should Shionoha fall to the Dominion or a resurgent Republic.  And besides, it defeats the purpose of insisting the 2nd Dieron Regulars of 3145 is a completely different regiment than the pre-Jihad 2nd Dieron.

The 3rd still sees itself as the Proserpina Hussar. There was some grumbling when Proserpina came back to the Dragon that the Hussar brigade wasn't reconstituted. They also have a majority of the University of Proserpina taking place in an Overlord (weird but hey). I'd say they have kept the Warriors of the Night rather than the Grey Panthers from a P. Regulars unit that was wiped out by the Clans.

My source for the 2nd is Sarna so I'm taking it with several grains of rice. However it does follow my train of thought. They keep the "Pride" from their Dieron days but add the new name from their battles with the Ravens in the post-Jihad era.

The new Dieron Regulars confuse me. I for one would try to connect to the past and would take the Pride of  Shionoha to establish a link to the past and to one of the best of the DCMS units. Hell the 7th Vega don't belong to Vega either. Just because they are not posted there doesn't change a link. Shionahans might want to re-establish their links to a Regulars unit. Another option would be the Golden Scorpions as a link to the old 2nd DR.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 21 March 2014, 12:11:11
The 3rd still sees itself as the Proserpina Hussar. There was some grumbling when Proserpina came back to the Dragon that the Hussar brigade wasn't reconstituted. They also have a majority of the University of Proserpina taking place in an Overlord (weird but hey). I'd say they have kept the Warriors of the Night rather than the Grey Panthers from a P. Regulars unit that was wiped out by the Clans.

I'm torn on it.  I can see what you're saying, but then again their situation as being 'demoted' from a free-floating regiment to the Pesht District Regulars wasn't up to them.  Being forced to assume the identity of the original 3rd Pesht could serve the Ministry of War to further remind the ex 3rd Proserpina of its 'new place'.

On the other hand, maybe they'd want them to keep their 3rd Proserpina traditions, since they were supposed to be an example to the rest of the Pesht Legion.

So maybe neither option; maybe a new nickname entirely for the new situation of the ex Hussars 'overwriting' the tradition of the 3rd Pesht Regulars.

Quote
The new Dieron Regulars confuse me. I for one would try to connect to the past and would take the Pride of  Shionoha to establish a link to the past and to one of the best of the DCMS units. Hell the 7th Vega don't belong to Vega either. Just because they are not posted there doesn't change a link. Shionahans might want to re-establish their links to a Regulars unit. Another option would be the Golden Scorpions as a link to the old 2nd DR.

I think they confuse the writers, too.  Whether regimental traditions are retired, struck from the rolls, or recreated anew seem to be distinctions they simply don't comprehend. (or, to be charitable, simply don't want to think about)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 21 March 2014, 17:00:35
Were there regimental names for any units in FR2765? If so would they re-use them?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 27 March 2014, 10:59:47
Can someone explain to be the Pillars of ___ philosophy behind Swords of Light Formation. For example, if gold is government and jade is economy then ... what is ivory?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 27 March 2014, 11:27:17
Can someone explain to be the Pillars of ___ philosophy behind Swords of Light Formation. For example, if gold is government and jade is economy then ... what is ivory?
The Five Pillars:
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 27 March 2014, 11:55:39
Does that mean there are only five SoL regiments in active duty at any given time?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 27 March 2014, 12:08:04
Does that mean there are only five SoL regiments in active duty at any given time?
Negative. At this moment there are six SoL regiments active.

Historically, there were twelve different SoL regiments, so perhaps the number of active SoL regiments was even higher.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 27 March 2014, 12:17:22
But only five have "pillar status"?

Sarna cites FM:DC (which I do not yet own so cannot check) saying:
Quote
Numbering twelve regiments until 2740 when the number of regiments in the Sword of Light was reduced to five, with each regiment representing one of the five Pillars of Combine society, to compensate for the smaller brigade the regiments themselves reorganised to consist of four battalions instead of three.
So, I guess, what do you mean by "at this moment"? What is the sixth SoL regiment?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 27 March 2014, 12:30:18
But only five have "pillar status"?

Sarna cites FM:DC (which I do not yet own so cannot check) saying:So, I guess, what do you mean by "at this moment"? What is the sixth SoL regiment?

The Field Manual: Draconis Combine describes the situation as it was in 3058. But that's history.
Now we are in 3145.

We don't know names of the 4th SoL and the 2nd SoL. And to be honest, even those four remaining regiments (traditionally named after the Pillars) could have been renamed.
So the best thing we can do is to wait for future canon materials. Or you can ask in the "Ask The Writers (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/board,41.0.html)" section, if you wish.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 27 March 2014, 12:46:01
We don't know names of the 4th SoL and the 2nd
Surely the Second is the Steel Dragon, right?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 27 March 2014, 12:56:10
Surely the Second is the Steel Dragon, right?
We don't know. The regiment disgraced itself pretty deeply ...
You can speculate, but I think that it may be wiser to wait for what canon materials will say.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 27 March 2014, 13:04:38
Well, we'll see if we get any bites but the line is in the water:

http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,38309.msg886106.html#new

I don't plan on doing a Dark Ages SoL force any time soon so no need for me to speculate one way or the other. I was more just wondering about these pillars, what they're all about, why the SoL regiments are associated with them, that sort of thing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 27 March 2014, 13:17:06
See if you can find the old House source book Kurita. It used to be a free .pdf on the main site. It breaks down the pillars very well.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 27 March 2014, 13:18:16
I don't plan on doing a Dark Ages SoL force any time soon so no need for me to speculate one way or the other. I was more just wondering about these pillars, what they're all about, why the SoL regiments are associated with them, that sort of thing.
1) These Five Pillars are the basis around the Draconis Combine exists. Each Pillar symbolizes one necessary aspect of the Draconis Combine culture.
2) If the Five Pillars are crucial for the survival of the DC, then it's more than fitting to name the five most elite regiments of the DCMS after tese Pillars.
3) For spiritual significance, check the House Kurita housebook (FASA 1620), p.70
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 27 March 2014, 13:25:20
The eponymous "sword of light" that the brigade is named after are the flaming swords of the Myoo, which are angelic beings that drag the unrepentant, undeserving souls to enlightenment.  Kind of like Buddhist Furies.

I think that's actually quite a badass background ideal for the Swords of Light:  "We'll make you accept Kurita domination and you have no say in the matter!"
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 27 March 2014, 13:30:18
The eponymous "sword of light" that the brigade is named after are the flaming swords of the Myoo, which are angelic beings that drag the unrepentant, undeserving souls to enlightenment.  Kind of like Buddhist Furies.

I think that's actually quite a badass background ideal for the Swords of Light:  "We'll make you accept Kurita domination and you have no say in the matter!"

Actually, it's along the same line as the Pollux Proclamation. The only fitting response is nuke or two.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 28 March 2014, 14:15:12
Well I managed to procure a copy of FM:DC. When five of the SoL regiments had been raised, Takiro Kurita had them desiganted per pillar. It doesn't clarify why the pillar regiments are not simply the First through Fifth.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 28 March 2014, 14:36:52
Well I managed to procure a copy of FM:DC. When five of the SoL regiments had been raised, Takiro Kurita had them desiganted per pillar. It doesn't clarify why the pillar regiments are not simply the First through Fifth.

Military reorganizations often make no sense.

By the way, congratulations. The FM:DC is one of my favourite field manuals.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 28 March 2014, 14:54:28
Yeah, it's a nice book in a seemingly good series.

As for the question or re-organization, FM:DC appears to indicate that the pillar-named regiments were the only ones that had been raised so far at that point (i.e, in the course of the original formation). So maybe the pillar-designated regiments were originally the first through the fifth but that changed over time.

Also - according to Sarna, Field Report: DCMS indicates the Ninth was designated Steel Dragon as of the late 3070s. I don't have the source (not a fan of PDFs) but this appears to be a result of the remaining Second SoL loyalists being reorganized into a new Ninth SoL, which was then given away to the Republic of the Sphere in 3082.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Alexander Knight on 28 March 2014, 16:21:39
According to FR 2765: DCMS, the Sword of Light numbered a dozen 'Mech and conventional regiments until a reorganization in the 2740s that turned them into the "Soul of the DCMS" with one regiment per Pillar.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 28 March 2014, 16:29:58
Yeah, it's a nice book in a seemingly good series.

As for the question or re-organization, FM:DC appears to indicate that the pillar-named regiments were the only ones that had been raised so far at that point (i.e, in the course of the original formation). So maybe the pillar-designated regiments were originally the first through the fifth but that changed over time.
2765 shows that there were indeed a lot more - those five were just the ones that survived.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 28 March 2014, 16:57:06
Sure, what I meant was Tariko Kurita conferred the pillar designations at the point when five regiments had been raised for the SoL legion (legion might not be the technically correct term but it is used in FM:DC). Presumably, the regiments were raised in numerical order ... although, yes I know that is a BIG assumption. Maybe they were raised in chronological order as First, Second, Fifth, Seventh, Eighth. FM:DC does not clarify.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Øystein on 29 March 2014, 05:04:42
2765 shows that there were indeed a lot more - those five were just the ones that survived.

No, they were the five who were chosen to become the "new" Sword of Light brigade. The others were transferred to other brigades. This is a classic 'FASA Two-step' to consolidate the old House Book info that there were Sword of Light units before 2740s, and the FM:DC which seemed to indicate the Sword of Light brigade was formed towards the end of the Star League.

Cheers
Øystein
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 29 March 2014, 09:09:16
The new 2nd should take the name of the 2nd during the Reunification War: Bloody Snakes
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 31 March 2014, 08:15:50
The new 2nd should take the name of the 2nd during the Reunification War: Bloody Snakes

Not dignified enough.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 31 March 2014, 09:24:10
I also cannot see the Samurai of the DCMS referring to themselves as "snakes"
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 31 March 2014, 10:27:49
Who called them "Bloody Snakes" to begin with? Fedsuns generals, sounds like.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 31 March 2014, 10:41:12
Who called them "Bloody Snakes" to begin with? Fedsuns generals, sounds like.

Victor Steiner-Davion claims that somebody called them with such nickname.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 31 March 2014, 10:47:21
This makes me think of how the Dragoons and 2nd Sword of Light fought the Snake Stompers.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Manchu on 31 March 2014, 11:05:53
Right and you see how well that worked out.  :P

"Snake" is a pretty clear pejorative for the DCMS.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 31 March 2014, 13:51:32
Who called them "Bloody Snakes" to begin with? Fedsuns generals, sounds like.

It was Rim World partisans who called them that for their occupation efforts on Timbuktu. The 2nd ran with according to the book.

Page 36 of Reunification War
"Unofficially nicknamed the “Blood Snakes” (their official nickname was the Steel Dragon)for their bloody actions against the Second Amaris Dragoons on Timbuktu, the Second Sword
was roundly despised by the RWA and the SLDF alike."
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 05 April 2014, 14:26:50
But it seems to me that the quoted sentence doesn't say who was the author of that nickname.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 05 April 2014, 19:49:41
So, seeing as I'm an official convert to the cause of the Dragon, anyone care to sell me on a District?  I'm leaning towards Benjamin at the moment, due to them being aware of their middle-of-the-road status and general sneakiness, but I definitely could be convinced otherwise!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 06 April 2014, 00:11:09
It depends on the era. In 3145 I can hardly sell you on the Rasalhague or Alshain Military Districts. Even the Dieron Military District has been reclaimed recently.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 06 April 2014, 09:06:35
It depends on the era. In 3145 I can hardly sell you on the Rasalhague or Alshain Military Districts. Even the Dieron Military District has been reclaimed recently.

Hah, too true.  For now, let's just say generally what is your favorite District, and we can worry about era specifics later.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 06 April 2014, 09:14:58
Hah, too true.  For now, let's just say generally what is your favorite District, and we can worry about era specifics later.

You can check this thread:
questionnaire for the Draconis Combine fandom (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,21790.0.html)

The fifth question asks everybody to name their favorite Military District.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 06 April 2014, 10:19:08
You can check this thread:
questionnaire for the Draconis Combine fandom (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,21790.0.html)

The fifth question asks everybody to name their favorite Military District.

I'd forgotten about that, I voted Benjamin.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 06 April 2014, 11:44:08
Huh.  For some reason I was expecting more people to say Galedon/New Samarkand.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 06 April 2014, 23:53:12
How about the Draconis District.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 07 April 2014, 00:02:07
How about the Draconis District.
Draconis District?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Foxx Ital on 07 April 2014, 00:23:08
I'm a big rasalhague district fan myself
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 07 April 2014, 19:08:38
I'm a big rasalhague district fan myself

I find Rasalhague in general to be entertaining.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 07 April 2014, 20:32:09
Draconis District?
The former Draconis March.  I was kidding.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 07 April 2014, 20:44:06
The former Draconis March.  I was kidding.

Now that I've begun re-collecting minis, I'm painting (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,36116.msg839424.html#msg839424) them in Robinson Military District livery :)

But fandom/AU/joke districts aside, the Combine is unique in the Inner Sphere in its degree of trying to achieve uniformity... so there isn't really much difference between the districts (despite MW3/ATOW's attempts to force it for chargen).  Specific world of origin means more than district, really. 

But if I had to pick a district, it's the long lost Rasalhague Military District because however much I love the eternal Kurita-Davion rivalry, I found the Steiner-Kurita frontier a much more interesting place.  The more successful the Combine was against the Lyrans, it would get paradoxically worse for them both on the frontier and in-garrison behind the lines. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 08 April 2014, 08:24:44
Draconis District?

Robinson District has a little more brag about it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 08 April 2014, 09:11:56
Robinson District has a little more brag about it.
I like that one better.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 08 April 2014, 10:14:40
The former Draconis March.  I was kidding.
Oh, yes!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 08 April 2014, 12:13:56
Robinson District has a little more brag about it.

Yeah Robinson District, soon to be followed by the New Avalon District?  ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Molossian Dog IIC on 08 April 2014, 18:50:00
Why would you give a swath of barren, lifeless planets a name?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 08 April 2014, 18:56:09
To rub it in the faces of those that once treasured those barren, lifeless worlds.

Duh.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 08 April 2014, 19:27:14
Agreed on the feeling of uniformity in the Draconis districts; to me the only one that ever stood out (Rasalhauge aside) was Derion, and that was largely based on Derion itself and its ties to the Hegemony and Star Leauge.

One of the reasons why I tend to find Benjamin the most interesting is how much it's changed over the course of BT history. So much of it was Historically Lyran (Hello Buckminster prefecture), plus the back and forth shifting of the Davion border, plus the Republic, plus Derion District existing (or not) at any given time, plus...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 25 April 2014, 17:15:22
Oddly timed question:

Despite them having a noted preference for them (to the point of having relatively recent variants of them), I can find no info on the DC producing Warhammers.  Likewise, I can find no info on them producing the bug Mechs (aside from the Stinger LAM back when Lexatech of Irece wasn't a smoking hole in the ground).  Do they just purchase these from the FWL, or am I missing something?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 25 April 2014, 17:19:04
Oddly timed question:

Despite them having a noted preference for them (to the point of having relatively recent variants of them), I can find no info on the DC producing Warhammers.  Likewise, I can find no info on them producing the bug Mechs (aside from the Stinger LAM back when Lexatech of Irece wasn't a smoking hole in the ground).  Do they just purchase these from the FWL, or am I missing something?

I think they were all just inheritances and salvage.  The Unseen were, once upon a time, all so common that you didn't have to produce warhammers to have warhammers; you just salvaged enemy warhammers to keep your own supplied with parts.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 25 April 2014, 17:21:55
I'm not 100% certain, but I'm fairly sure that the DCMS just imports old beater WHM-7Ms from the Free Worlds League and refits them into WHM-7Ks and WHM-8Ks.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 25 April 2014, 17:24:37
I think they were all just inheritances and salvage.  The Unseen were, once upon a time, all so common that you didn't have to produce warhammers to have warhammers; you just salvaged enemy warhammers to keep your own supplied with parts.

Gotcha.  I remember in some of the novels it felt like every other mech was a Warhammer, Marauder or Archer, regardless of faction (because, let's face it, despite their ubiquity, the bug Mechs just don't make for flashy major character rides).

Still, something about House Kurita not making Warhammers makes me feel slightly unclean.  Ah well, no biggie, that's what the Hatamoto series is for, I suppose.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 25 April 2014, 18:06:40
Gotcha.  I remember in some of the novels it felt like every other mech was a Warhammer, Marauder or Archer, regardless of faction (because, let's face it, despite their ubiquity, the bug Mechs just don't make for flashy major character rides).

Still, something about House Kurita not making Warhammers makes me feel slightly unclean.  Ah well, no biggie, that's what the Hatamoto series is for, I suppose.

One can fairly enough assume they had factories(s) producing warhammers (via license or knock-off clone 'copies' that for game purposes are identical).. but those factories (like so many others) were destroyed early on in the Succession Wars.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: (SMD)MadCow on 25 April 2014, 21:30:12
One can fairly enough assume they had factories(s) producing warhammers (via license or knock-off clone 'copies' that for game purposes are identical).. but those factories (like so many others) were destroyed early on in the Succession Wars.

Also, only Primary production facilities are listed, there could very well be secondary facilities that make 1 mech every 3 years or something.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 26 April 2014, 01:05:28
Oddly timed question:

Despite them having a noted preference for them (to the point of having relatively recent variants of them), I can find no info on the DC producing Warhammers
Still, something about House Kurita not making Warhammers makes me feel slightly unclean. 

They produced them in the past.

Of course, it may be possible that the factory was destroyed during the Succession Wars. (as Tai Dai Cultist suggests)
Or perhaps the production line was offline temporarily and therefore not listed in the 3039 "Primary factories" overview.

Likewise, I can find no info on them producing the bug Mechs (aside from the Stinger LAM back when Lexatech of Irece wasn't a smoking hole in the ground).  Do they just purchase these from the FWL, or am I missing something?

TRO:3039 says that the Wasp is produced "by at least nine factories"  (but lists only three). And  "every major government in the Inner Sphere and Periphery manufactures the Wasp."
Ditto for the Locust and Stinger.

So I guess that the Draconis Combine produced its own WSP-1K Wasp and probably even those two Bug 'Mechs too.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 26 April 2014, 08:11:28
Also, only Primary production facilities are listed, there could very well be secondary facilities that make 1 mech every 3 years or something.

"Welcome to Miyamoto Steve's Battlemech Plant, home of the Warhammer.  Can I take your order?"

EDIT:  I'd love it if the "Y" key on my computer worked consistently.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Fat Guy on 26 April 2014, 12:53:26
Still, something about House Kurita not making Warhammers makes me feel slightly unclean.  Ah well, no biggie, that's what the Hatamoto series is for, I suppose.

No, that's what they have Catapults for. With the exception of the K5, all the other Kurita catapults are Warhammers in all but name. Please see the K2, the K2K, the K3 and the K4.

As for the bugs, Lexatech started building the Wasp 3K on Hun Ho in 3111.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 26 April 2014, 13:39:30
Picking through some stuff, I find no production. Closest the Dracs can get is the highly undefended Crofton, which wouldn't be too far out of the way from the Palmyra thumb but is kind of in the other direction.  I'd say the Catapult derivatives are their WHMs, outside of the special -6K variant.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 26 April 2014, 16:49:17
According to FR2765 Amalgamated Sword and Steel were building the Warhammer for the DCMS along with the Wolverine.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 26 April 2014, 18:28:01
Any Assault 'mechs in production in 2765?  Is there anything other than Chargers?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 26 April 2014, 19:50:03
The BattleCorps article on the WHM-8K said that it was a refit, but also indicated that where said refit was taking place is unknown. Given that the DCMS has seemed to have an ample suppy of Whammers across the history of BT fiction, I can only assume that they're a mixture of old stock and imports from StarCorps.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 26 April 2014, 21:43:37
It specifically says a field refit for the WHM-8K.  Which has an endo steel chassis, which you aren't going to install in the field.  So I think the WHM-8D as the only WHM with endo steel at the time is the likely base (made in FWL space).  Though I suppose it's also possible the article is in error (in universe author assumed it was field because he didn't know of a Kuritan Warhammer factory).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 26 April 2014, 22:03:16
Any Assault 'mechs in production in 2765?  Is there anything other than Chargers?
The Zeus came out in 2407...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 26 April 2014, 23:55:49
The Zeus came out in 2407...

I think he meant produced in the Combine.

Also, didn't they adjust that date in TRO 3039 to something that made more sense?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 27 April 2014, 01:48:52
Overview: Warhammer

1) We know that that the Draconis Combine used to produce the Warhammer (Field Report: 2765).
2) We know that that the Draconis Combine used to produce the WHM-6Rk Warhammer (Era Report: 2750).
3) We know that the Kuritan Succession Wars WHM-6K variant wasn't a field refit, but factory production run (Technical Readout: 3025).
4) It's interesting that WHM-7K is the first Warhammer with Endo-Steel chassis (if we disregard forgotten Star League Royal WHM-7A Warhammer). Not even other 3050 Warhammers such as WHM-7M or WHM-7S used ES.
So it's either a very consuming refit that includes replacing the entire chassis,
or that Kuritan factory retooled its production line to use ES. It may be possible, as the House Kurita used ES on the earlier Hatamoto-Chi.
5) That BattleCorps article and TRO:3085 both say that WHM-8K is refit of old WHM-6K. (BattleCorps article specifically says that it's a field refit). We have seen something similar with the WVR-8K Wolverine.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 27 April 2014, 14:04:10
Based on the timeframes then I'd imagine their production facility may have been in the Smoke Jaguars zone.  That would explain the production up to a certain point, the loss of the factory, and the production of some endo-steel skeletons that went into machines that were later upgraded.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 27 April 2014, 14:36:21
Based on the timeframes then I'd imagine their production facility may have been in the Smoke Jaguars zone.  That would explain the production up to a certain point, the loss of the factory, and the production of some endo-steel skeletons that went into machines that were later upgraded.

Razzinfrazzin Jaguars always wrecking up the place, razzinfrazzin...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 27 April 2014, 15:41:33
IIRC, there's a large BattleMech refit center on New Samarkand. Perhaps they're built there.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 27 April 2014, 15:55:04
Could be.  And Moonsword informs me that the -7K didn't come out until 3054 anyway, after the Jag expansion stopped, so my speculation is kaput.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 28 April 2014, 07:57:46
I must admit that I like WHM-7K Warhammer. It's a pretty good design and I would use it anytime, in the Dark Age even.

Perhaps the only thing that this 'Mech lacks is C.A.S.E., but that one explosive critical is in well-padded side torso, so it's tolerable.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Fat Guy on 28 April 2014, 12:29:47
I'm curious why they chose to give it TAG instead of a C3 slave.   ???
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 28 April 2014, 12:58:31
I'm curious why they chose to give it TAG instead of a C3 slave.   ???

Perhaps its designers were unsure if C3 networks are the right choice and perhaps they noticed that some Clan OmniMechs (a dozen or so, although the number used by the Jaguar and Nova Cats was smaller) are equipped with ECM suites that can jam C3 links.

Anyway, one of the first TAG-equipped IS 'Mechs was Kuritan OTT-7K Ostscout from TRO:3050. So the DCMS knew about advantages of Arrow IV artillery.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 28 April 2014, 13:00:51
Or Copperheads.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 28 April 2014, 13:15:40
Or Copperheads.

Actually, Copperheads have been reintroduced by the Capellans (who lacked sufficient number of CPLT-C3 Catapult), not by the Dracs.

It seems to me that the Dracs had more trust in standard Arrow IV missiles, as they deployed their first dedicated Arrow IV 'Mech a few years later - OBK-M10 O-Bakemono.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 28 April 2014, 13:33:48
I'm curious why they chose to give it TAG instead of a C3 slave.   ???

At the time (3054), nothing carried c3 systems as a standard production model?  The DCMS wasn't sold on c3 yet to order production runs of them.  They were still all field refits of the 'mech after assigned to a c3 network?
Perhaps there's a WHM-C around somewhere to swap out that TAG for c3..
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 28 April 2014, 13:50:01
At the time (3054), nothing carried c3 systems as a standard production model?  The DCMS wasn't sold on c3 yet to order production runs of them.  They were still all field refits of the 'mech after assigned to a c3 network?

RTX1-OD Raptor wasn't a field refit and it had C3 two years earlier (3052). But I am happier with WHM-7K "as is" than with C3.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: nckestrel on 28 April 2014, 16:34:10
RTX1-OD Raptor wasn't a field refit and it had C3 two years earlier (3052).

When my point is that c3 only appeared where it could be fitted in the field, an omni configuration change is even easier than a field refit.   
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 28 April 2014, 17:31:06
Actually, Copperheads have been reintroduced by the Capellans (who lacked sufficient number of CPLT-C3 Catapult), not by the Dracs.

3 years earlier.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 01 May 2014, 10:57:43
May the eternal Kurita-Davion rivalry (http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/84427609391/battletech-alpha-strike-companion-cover-final) last BattleTech's entire run :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: (SMD)MadCow on 01 May 2014, 11:12:07
May the eternal Kurita-Davion rivalry (http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/84427609391/battletech-alpha-strike-companion-cover-final) last BattleTech's entire run :)

I cant quite tell what that red mech in the right side background is. With that huge head antenna, I want to say Black Knight.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 01 May 2014, 11:19:08
I cant quite tell what that red mech in the right side background is. With that huge head antenna, I want to say Black Knight.

Basic shape seems to suggest Whitworth.  Maybe that vertical is something behind the mech rather than its own giant antenna.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 01 May 2014, 11:21:48
We'll probably know more when they forward the larger resolution version of the art over to the web team for the Downloads page.  (At least I hope they do, it looks gorgeous.)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 01 May 2014, 22:16:04
I cant quite tell what that red mech in the right side background is. With that huge head antenna, I want to say Black Knight.

Looks like it has fists.  So maybe a Black Knight?  And I might see the right arm PPC hanging off there.  It might also be smoke or possibly a cow.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 04 May 2014, 07:20:15
A Quickdraw taking on a Victor, now that's a pretty sight indeed! Pretty cool over.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 04 May 2014, 12:52:50
Honestly, I am not sure if that the 'Mech in the background is the Black Knight. Its arm-mounted PPC should be mounted higher on the upper arm. And it seems to me that its head has got a small "ear" on the right side.

I would say that's the Panther and that supposed "antenna" is actually a tree trunk or some pole behind it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 04 May 2014, 14:01:23
A Quickdraw taking on a Victor, now that's a pretty sight indeed! Pretty cool over.

I'm personally terrified of that Quickdraw.  Obviously, the pilot is insane and therefore the most dangerous thing on the battlefield.  Honor to the Dragon!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: (SMD)MadCow on 04 May 2014, 14:03:09
Honestly, I am not sure if that the 'Mech in the background is the Black Knight. Its arm-mounted PPC should be mounted higher on the upper arm. And it seems to me that its head has got a small "ear" on the right side.

I would say that's the Panther and that supposed "antenna" is actually a tree trunk or some pole behind it.

Theres already a Panther jumping in the fore ground, the torso stucture is different on the one in the back ground - its not a Panther.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 04 May 2014, 14:14:26
If you wish.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 04 May 2014, 14:26:08
We'll compromise by all agreeing to be very wrong.  It's clearly a Catapult.   >:D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 04 May 2014, 14:45:24
We'll compromise by all agreeing to be very wrong.  It's clearly a Catapult.   >:D

More like Jenner ...

I have noticed that the Panther depicted in TRO:3039 has exactly such long whip antenna.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 09 May 2014, 10:42:20
I think it's a long shot but maybe a Mongoose?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 13 May 2014, 22:31:50
So of all the units that the glorious Dragon decided that it needed, I have to wonder, why did it feel the need to appropriate the Quickdraw?  Couldn't we have let the FWL keep that one?

I say this as an avowed fan of the Charger.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: (SMD)MadCow on 13 May 2014, 23:33:12
So of all the units that the glorious Dragon decided that it needed, I have to wonder, why did it feel the need to appropriate the Quickdraw?  Couldn't we have let the FWL keep that one?

I say this as an avowed fan of the Charger.

It partners well with a Dragon?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 13 May 2014, 23:41:09
So of all the units that the glorious Dragon decided that it needed, I have to wonder, why did it feel the need to appropriate the Quickdraw?  Couldn't we have let the FWL keep that one?

I say this as an avowed fan of the Charger.

The first note saying that the Quickdraw is manufactured in the Draconis Combine was in the original House Kurita housebook.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 14 May 2014, 07:08:20
The first note saying that the Quickdraw is manufactured in the Draconis Combine was in the original House Kurita housebook.

Really?  Been years since I've read it.

It partners well with a Dragon?

I suppose.  I don't know why I've never liked the Quickdraw, as there are many other admittedly suboptimal mechs that I love, but I just never liked the thing.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 14 May 2014, 13:45:37
QKDs have been Kuritan as long as there've been QKDs.  They do match well with the Dragon, providing jump mobility at the same fast-cav ground speed, and the LRM10 commonality means ammo is easy to come by.  I'd personally like to see an updated one, LPPCs over LRMs, and give it a sword and call it the Iaido.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: (SMD)MadCow on 14 May 2014, 13:56:13
QKDs have been Kuritan as long as there've been QKDs.  They do match well with the Dragon, providing jump mobility at the same fast-cav ground speed, and the LRM10 commonality means ammo is easy to come by.  I'd personally like to see an updated one, LPPCs over LRMs, and give it a sword and call it the Iaido.

Give it a Banjo instead and call it "El Ka-bong".
I swear, I cant read Quickdraw without hearing Quick-straw in my head.  :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 14 May 2014, 17:57:49
Give it a Banjo instead and call it "El Ka-bong".
I swear, I cant read Quickdraw without hearing Quick-straw in my head.  :D
Hell no, those things are dangerous, didn't you see that episode of Harvey Birdman?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 14 May 2014, 18:14:58
Give it a Banjo instead and call it "El Ka-bong".
I swear, I cant read Quickdraw without hearing Quick-straw in my head.  :D

Okay, I now have a reason to like the Quickdraw.   ;D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 15 May 2014, 09:08:38
Try the QKD-9M; it's a Quickdraw that actually manages not to suck.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 15 May 2014, 09:29:42
It's a good 'Mech. But its designation seems to suggest that it's from the Free Worlds League (perhaps Savannah or Shiro III) than from the Draconis Combine.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 15 May 2014, 11:39:01
Try the QKD-9M; it's a Quickdraw that actually manages not to suck.

That was the general idea when I designed it, yes.  I was also trying hard to make it still be a Quickdraw.

It's a good 'Mech. But its designation seems to suggest that it's from the Free Worlds League (perhaps Savannah or Shiro III) than from the Draconis Combine.

It's definitely an FWL 'Mech.  The extra ammo bin and TAG are nods to the FWL's habit of using special munitions, especially semi-guided LRMs.  Since availability hasn't been released yet, that's all I can tell you.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 16 May 2014, 19:40:13
I didn't think the Combine was producing the Quickdraw at any of the non-Luthien LAW sites (or elsewhere), but I could be very much mistaken.  But that would definitely hinder being able to get a new variant out.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 16 May 2014, 20:58:28
Good point, that...though by 3150 I imagine they've got other mechs they'd rather be making anyway.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 17 May 2014, 00:36:25
Good point, that...though by 3150 I imagine they've got other mechs they'd rather be making anyway.

Like more Chargers!

...I'm going to go in the corner and think about what I've done.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 27 May 2014, 17:22:53
Lance completion time!

Okay I have two lances that need finishing and I am taking suggestions. Both are 3145 Lances and these are getting painted, so they need to have Minis.

Lance 1: Sword of Light - Shiro, Rokurokubi, Rokurokubi, _________

Lance 2: Ryuken Roku - Shiro, Mad Dog IV,___________, _____________

So any good suggestions to fill in the blanks? Aside from the mechs listed above I am unsure about the new tech, and even the Mad Dog IV is kinda foggy.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: glitterboy2098 on 27 May 2014, 18:54:43
I think it's a long shot but maybe a Mongoose?
i think it is.. it has the right torso and the backwards canted legs.. the aerial might be part of a surviving lostech active probe?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 27 May 2014, 22:12:45
Lance completion time!

Okay I have two lances that need finishing and I am taking suggestions. Both are 3145 Lances and these are getting painted, so they need to have Minis.

Lance 1: Sword of Light - Shiro, Rokurokubi, Rokurokubi, _________

Lance 2: Ryuken Roku - Shiro, Mad Dog IV,___________, _____________

So any good suggestions to fill in the blanks? Aside from the mechs listed above I am unsure about the new tech, and even the Mad Dog IV is kinda foggy.

I would say Hitotsume Kozo for Lance 1 (mini is coming soon). And Dragon II and Koshi for Lance 2, both also coming soon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 28 May 2014, 08:13:35
I'd say Kozos for them both.  It's a great all-rounder and it definitely keeps up with the others, and the ERPPC version is just hell on wheels.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 30 May 2014, 14:48:08
Lance completion time!

Lance 1: Sword of Light - Shiro, Rokurokubi, Rokurokubi, _________

Lance completion time!
Lance 2: Ryuken Roku - Shiro, Mad Dog IV,___________, _____________
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 30 May 2014, 15:03:22
Thanks guys

For lance 1 I like the suggestion for the Hitostume Kozo.

For lance 2 I like the idea of the Dragon II, I'll just use the 5/8 version. But now I need a TAGer for the lance. Any good TAG mechs that don't waste tonnage on C3? (if only one mech has C3, its a waste)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 30 May 2014, 15:13:42
For lance 2 I like the idea of the Dragon II, I'll just use the 5/8 version. But now I need a TAGer for the lance. Any good TAG mechs that don't waste tonnage on C3? (if only one mech has C3, its a waste)

HM-1r Hitman
LCT-5W2 Locust
OTT-7K Ostscout - pure TAG platform, but very BV inexpensive
- all three 'Mechs have minis

GBT-1L Gambit
NSR-K3 Night Stalker
- both without minis
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 30 May 2014, 18:47:11
Thanks guys

For lance 1 I like the suggestion for the Hitostume Kozo.

For lance 2 I like the idea of the Dragon II, I'll just use the 5/8 version. But now I need a TAGer for the lance. Any good TAG mechs that don't waste tonnage on C3? (if only one mech has C3, its a waste)

The Koshi mentioned above has a light TAG. Otherwise I'd go with the above recommendations.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 30 May 2014, 23:44:25
KIM-2/2A Komodo has mini too, but's not especially great TAGger.

And one Dark Age BattleMech with miniature: FS9-M3 Firestarter.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 14 June 2014, 21:06:23
I think I mentioned it in another thread; the majority of my minis seem to have disappeared recently. Rather than mourn their loss I've decided to use the opportunity to go on a mini buying spree. I'd like to put together a company of 'Mechs to represent the 1st Amphigean Light Assault Group in 3145. So, what would work for an A rated DCMS unit with a focus on lighter faster units? Let's keep it to units that have minis or will have minis sometime soon.

Thanks as always.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 15 June 2014, 03:47:17
I think I mentioned it in another thread; the majority of my minis seem to have disappeared recently.

I know that the ISF used to be full of the Black Dragons, but what about the Order of Five Pillars?

I'd like to put together a company of 'Mechs to represent the 1st Amphigean Light Assault Group in 3145. So, what would work for an A rated DCMS unit with a focus on lighter faster units? Let's keep it to units that have minis or will have minis sometime soon.

Just a few 'Mechs that catched my eye:

Hitman
JR7-C2/C3 Jenner
MON-76/86 Mongoose - let them work as a pair - one has BAP, the other has Guardian ECM suite)
OTT-7K Ostscout (a bit useless without artillery 'Mechs)
Owens OmniMech (check those Dragon Roars variants, in 3145 they are no longer "exotic")
Phoenix Hawk L (both models; no mini, but you could use mini for the Reseen PXH and you will be okay)
Raptor OmniMech (underestimated, but very good and versatile)
RK-4X Rokurokubi (crap, but one model has Clan ER PPC)
SDR-7KC Spider (cheap and mobile Light PPC)
SDR-8K Spider (Snub-nose PPC with Capacitor)
SDR-10K Spider (Large RE Laser)
SDR-9KC Venom (pulse lasers+protection+DHS)
BSN-5KC Bishamon (fast, durable and stable SnPPC)
Wight
Daimyo
Komodo
Firestarter Omni
GST-10/11 Ghost (ECM cover)
LNX-9C Lynx
Hitotsume Kozo (Hardened Heavy PPC)
CMA-2K Chimera (jumping Sword + TSM - but is that still Chimera?)
PXH-7K Phoenix Hawk (very good 'Mech, useful for the new FWLM and the DCMS)
Strider (it's OmniMech, after all; try configuration with twin MMLs or with Clan Streak LRMs)
Tessen
WFT-2 Wolf Trap for killing PBIs and logistic personnel in enemy's backfield - it's a dirty job, but somebody has to do it)
WFT-2B Wolf Trap(Gauss Rifle for long range, twin Medium X-Pulse laser as backup; probably variant with thickest armor of all series production Toras)
Koshi (BattleMech)
WVR-8C/8K Wolverine
FS9-M2/3/4 Firestarter

Battalion CO's ride:
LNC25-01 Lancelot
Ninja-To (3 models, I would prefer NJT-3)

Special 'Mech for the most brutal member of this battalion who gets out of the brig only when the battalion goes on mission - TDR-60-RLA Thunderbolt

Clan 'Mechs offered on general market:
Black Hawk (BattleMech)
Griffin IIC 3
Shadow Hawk IIC 3,4,5,8
Mad Cat III

 Those 'Mechs should have miniatures (it's possible that the IWM has some of them in their archive, but the RPE offers them; it depends where you usually shop)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 15 June 2014, 04:43:43
I'd also throw in the Morrigan (Nova Cat built and/or salvage) and the PNT-13K Panther (because IJJ hell)

Also, the best thing about the 2K Chimera is that it is no longer a Chimera
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 15 June 2014, 04:52:25
Morrigan 5 (that model without Heavy Laser) is good.

I don't like the PNT-13K. Ten shots and you can go home.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Deadborder on 15 June 2014, 05:13:55
Another one for the list would be the Wraith; the DCMS are a user of the design, and it's definitely on the "Fast" side
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 15 June 2014, 05:56:06
Another one for the list would be the Wraith; the DCMS are a user of the design, and it's definitely on the "Fast" side

Additional 'Mech with a mini could be the Valiant.

SHD-3K Shadow Hawk.

The Tarantula, Shockwave (mini in October), Cicada or HER-4K Hermes (30 tons) - but we should keep the Draconis flavor.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 15 June 2014, 13:53:41
Thanks for all the suggestions everyone!  O0

Kind of an odd question; in TRO:3145 DC in the deployment section of the Cizin there's a reference to Clan Nova Cat fielding two Shadow Cat II 'Mechs. What are the odds that that this unit has proliferated to the Draconis Combine? I assume CNC received them from the Sea Foxes but I wonder if just one would be out of place in the Amphigean LAG.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 15 June 2014, 14:32:25
Thanks for all the suggestions everyone!  O0

Kind of an odd question; in TRO:3145 DC in the deployment section of the Cizin there's a reference to Clan Nova Cat fielding two Shadow Cat II 'Mechs. What are the odds that that this unit has proliferated to the Draconis Combine? I assume CNC received them from the Sea Foxes but I wonder if just one would be out of place in the Amphigean LAG.

Personally I wouldn't expect especially big proliferation in the DCMS, but if it's just one 'Mech ...

Some Dark Age materials show them in mercenary service, in Republic service and in the Nova Cats service.
Perhaps the Combine has confiscated it from some mercenaries. Or it was found in some Republic world reincorporated into the Combine. Or it's just a salvage.

If you like this 'Mech, go for it. Its mini is available.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 16 June 2014, 00:13:05
Okay another one; it's 3145 and I need to move some jump capable BA. Hiryo or Cardinal?

Edit: Almost forgot; thanks so much Martian, that's pretty much how I feel but it's really great to hear it from someone else.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 16 June 2014, 01:34:18
Okay another one; it's 3145 and I need to move some jump capable BA. Hiryo or Cardinal?

1) Speed and BV are identical, so that's okay.

2) Cargo space favors the Cardinal, but only slightly, and since you will probably transport two teams of BA, it's no big difference.

3) In-universe, the Hiryo is significantly cheaper, homegrown, more durable and probably easier to maintain, while the Cardinal is more expensive, less protected and imported.

4) The Hiryo has Snubnose PPC, but I would be cautious to use it in direct combat. The Hiryo is still quite fragile for a direct short-range combat and I wouldn't want my BA to stay stranded somewhere without transport.
The Cardinal has armament (LBX Autocannon and LRMs), so it can engage enemy from the long range.

4) Plus, the Cardinal's advantage is that as helicopter it's easier to use - for me, at least. So personally, I would go with the Cardinal.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 16 June 2014, 09:33:37
Sadly, Cardinal.  It allows you to drop BA into woods.  Hard to beat that.

On the other hand, after deploying the BA, i'd rather have the sNPPC Hiryo.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 24 September 2014, 11:14:48
We have art!

http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/98313576101/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-some-art

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 24 September 2014, 11:25:16
Very nice art!

I hope the book will have some info on the Concord of Kapteyn in 3050s and 3060s.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 24 September 2014, 11:53:53
We have art!

http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/98313576101/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-some-art

Very nice, what's the class of the jumpship on the middle right?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: foxbat on 24 September 2014, 12:04:28
Awesome! I think this is the best illustration of Azami warriors I have ever seen. They're distinctly arabic, and yet have a touch of the ninja, as all good Kuritan should.
Kudos too for the coupled JS/DS. THis helps figure how things work a lot.  O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 24 September 2014, 13:16:26
Very nice, what's the class of the jumpship on the middle right?

Dunno ... Yamato? Or Kirishima? Or maybe a new unit created just for this book.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Fat Guy on 24 September 2014, 15:02:19
Olympus class space station?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 24 September 2014, 15:38:37
Hadn't thought of that, yeah, could be.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 30 September 2014, 12:02:50
And even more art! http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/98814392146/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-some-more-art

Looks like Akumas being built.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 30 September 2014, 12:12:49
And even more art! http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/98814392146/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-some-more-art

Looks like Akumas being built.

You are too slow:  Re: More crack please (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,36701.msg968607.html#msg968607)   ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: O5P_Ghost on 30 September 2014, 12:13:54
SQUEE!!!!!!

I love the charging infantry with swords. Also that rifle of the security guard at the Akuma plant is nice, like a P90 on roids
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 30 September 2014, 12:28:52
And even more art! http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/98814392146/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-some-more-art

Looks like Akumas being built.

Now that is nice.  [drool]
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 12 October 2014, 06:27:22
Question for you all/Opinions sought, I have to design a Company to take on a Ghost Bear Star, the Company must use 3025 tech to represent the original Clan invasion, his Star will weigh at most 50% of my Company.

I was thinking of something along the lines of this:-

Command Lance - 4 x Dragon-1N
Fire Lance - Catapult-K2/Whitworth-1/2 x Panther-9R
Strike Lance - Wolverine-6K/Phoenix Hawk-1K/2 x Jenner-7D

So is the above good enough to give a decent account of itself? And if not what would you change?

Game is 6 weeks away so plenty of time for fine tuning.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 12 October 2014, 07:16:48
Question for you all/Opinions sought, I have to design a Company to take on a Ghost Bear Star, the Company must use 3025 tech to represent the original Clan invasion, his Star will weigh at most 50% of my Company.

I was thinking of something along the lines of this:-

Command Lance - 4 x Dragon-1N
Fire Lance - Catapult-K2/Whitworth-1/2 x Panther-9R
Strike Lance - Wolverine-6K/Phoenix Hawk-1K/2 x Jenner-7D

So is the above good enough to give a decent account of itself? And if not what would you change?

Game is 6 weeks away so plenty of time for fine tuning.

But there have been examples upgraded BattleMechs designed after 3025, but before 3050. Anyway, here is my take:

9th Alshain Regulars
Pursuit Lance

Command Lance

Flanker Lance
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 16 October 2014, 14:35:12
Handbook: House Kurita…some more art… (http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/100176620756/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-some-more-art)

What a nice pair of Von Rohrs BattleMechs. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: foxbat on 17 October 2014, 00:45:37
Handbook: House Kurita…some more art… (http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/100176620756/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-some-more-art)

What a nice pair of Von Rohrs BattleMechs.

Thanks. This is defnitely some most inspiring art, makes me even more impatient to get that book!  O0
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Yorishiro on 17 October 2014, 00:52:13
I figured this would be the only acceptable place to make my first post.

I'm pretty excited for the new HB. I am curious though - how much history will the new book cover?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 October 2014, 01:03:51
I figured this would be the only acceptable place to make my first post.
Greetings!

I'm pretty excited for the new HB. I am curious though - how much history will the new book cover?
1) It serves as the partial replacement for the old Draconis Combine Housebook from 1987.
2) On top of that, it updates the information on the status of the House Kurita in newer eras. I think that the in-universe date will be 3067 or 3068.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 17 October 2014, 02:15:26
The Handbook series predates the Jihad, so the Kurita one will as well, so the In-date publication will be late 3067 (the other ones range from September to November, though I didn't see a specific month for the CapCon one after a quick check).

The book should cover all of the history of the DC, and even some time before that, most likely with the protostates that were conquered. The Davion one starts around 2100 and goes to 3067, so we can expect a similar range for the Kurita one.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 20 October 2014, 06:58:55
Question for you all/Opinions sought, I have to design a Company to take on a Ghost Bear Star, the Company must use 3025 tech to represent the original Clan invasion, his Star will weigh at most 50% of my Company.

I was thinking of something along the lines of this:-

Command Lance - 4 x Dragon-1N
Fire Lance - Catapult-K2/Whitworth-1/2 x Panther-9R
Strike Lance - Wolverine-6K/Phoenix Hawk-1K/2 x Jenner-7D

So is the above good enough to give a decent account of itself? And if not what would you change?

Game is 6 weeks away so plenty of time for fine tuning.

That roster could easily be an Arkab company.

Use the 2nd or 4th Arkab Legion; their pilots with gunnery skills of 3 or less can fire (and resolve damage) during the movement phase. Clan weapons can't hurt you if they've been shot off. ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 20 October 2014, 15:02:11
That roster could easily be an Arkab company.

Use the 2nd or 4th Arkab Legion; their pilots with gunnery skills of 3 or less can fire (and resolve damage) during the movement phase. Clan weapons can't hurt you if they've been shot off. ;)

Cheers for the advice Top, not sure if the Arkab are for me though, i've developed a soft spot for the LAG.

Any thoughts about the heaviest lance? Not sure if 4 Dragon's is the way to go.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 04 November 2014, 15:35:03
Dev Blog 1 for Handbook House Kurita: http://bg.battletech.com/news/battleblog/handbook-house-kurita-developers-blog-1/

Honestly, it's the Pillar of Jade I look forward to reading about the most. Sure, Steel's all shiny and killy, but Jade is the more undefined part of Combine society.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 04 November 2014, 15:57:31
Yep.  I hope there is an explaination as to why a society devoted so strongly to conquest hasn't won against the criminal incompetance of the Lyrans and the rain puddle economy of the FedSuns.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 04 November 2014, 16:18:39
Yep.  I hope there is an explaination as to why a society devoted so strongly to conquest hasn't won against the criminal incompetance of the Lyrans and the rain puddle economy of the FedSuns.

Easy. Fiat.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Savage Coyote on 04 November 2014, 16:43:48
Yep.  I hope there is an explaination as to why a society devoted so strongly to conquest hasn't won against the criminal incompetance of the Lyrans and the rain puddle economy of the FedSuns.

Being devoted to conquest and being able to conquest are two different things  :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 04 November 2014, 16:50:46
Yep.  I hope there is an explaination as to why a society devoted so strongly to conquest hasn't won against the criminal incompetance of the Lyrans and the rain puddle economy of the FedSuns.

My guess is they're so strongly devoted to conquest it undermines investment into their economy, meaning it's not really significantly better than the Suns' is.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 04 November 2014, 19:17:54
Easy. Fiat.

Wow.  Not who I expected to be the first one to sling that out.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Alexander Knight on 04 November 2014, 19:24:46
Eh, pretty much the only answer that'd be accepted....
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 04 November 2014, 19:30:59
Being devoted to conquest and being able to conquest are two different things  :D

Well, we've read that the Dracs have supposedly high percentages of their population under arms, a proven training regime, the political will to fight, industrial output enough to pollute entire planets and a population willing to endure frugality.  The Draconis Combine in light of those factors resembles a winner, at least by Spartan standards. I know they have counterbalancing problems, but a little more explaining might be nice.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: foxbat on 05 November 2014, 03:09:03
Strategical conditions. Essentially, both the FS and the LC are less threatened by the CC and the FWL than the DC is by the both of them.

Add to that that the LC economy is huge and efficiant, and that the FS are the masters at combined arms warfare. And that the DC leadership is traditionnally rife with infighting. This should even the odds somewhat out, shouldn't it?  ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 05 November 2014, 09:06:55
Quote
This should even the odds somewhat out, shouldn't it?  ;)

No.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Knightmare on 05 November 2014, 09:55:57
Easy. Fiat.

Bam! Lawyered.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Savage Coyote on 05 November 2014, 14:43:52
No.

Uh... seems like good ones to me?

Or maybe the DCMS bushido dueling tradition ham-strings their performance in the field (see Wolves on the Border or Heir to the Dragon) where even the "inept" Lyran Commonwealth can keep them at bay?  IIRC War of 3039 and Blood of Kerensky Trilogy have the Davion/FedComs anticipating the DCMS traditions and using them against them, at least until then.  Hanse was pretty frank with Teddy in the trilogy that they had counted on those traditions in 3039 but since Teddy had "secretly" changed things they were caught off guard.

Of course there could be a whole other discussion about the LC and whether they are truly that inept or if it's more of a stereotype perpetuated through the fiction.  They are still there through the time period, enough to indicate someone is doing something well enough to keep the Dragon at bay...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 05 November 2014, 15:49:10
Still not satisfied.  A society as obsessed with war as the DC has to produce results of face the consequences.  At what point does the citizenry finally tire of sacrificing everything for the sake of wars they can't win?  The ground level population of the Dragon is committed, while the top has dubious motives.  Now, maybe this is me and my post French Revolution mindset, but heads roll when that kind of situation persists.

Some of it is the hyperbole of the past, as well.  When we read that the average DC citizen is thrilled to get a piece of fruit with his morning rice as a sign of modern prosperity I begin to regard the whole situation as silly.  At least the Lyrans enjoy a high standard of living while failing miserably.  They may sink disfunctional amounts of money into the LCAF, but that doesn't resign them to a life of hulled rice and high infant mortality rates.  I'm really hoping the culture and economics sections will help to dispell this living, breathing meatgrinder culture that has been elluded to in the past.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Savage Coyote on 05 November 2014, 16:06:59
I'd speculate the average DC citizen doesn't know much about the area out side of their continent or maybe planet.  With a heavily controlled media, they won't be finding out about defeats suffered at the hands of the Lyrans or FedSuns.  You could lose a whole front and the interior citizens might not find out about until export products dry up and then it would only be speculation.

And in the olden-FASA days, with feudal systems in place, the peasants opinion doesn't count for much and if they only know about the glorious victories, they'll keep sending their sons and daughters to the front to fight.

AND, at the end of the day, it is FASA.  FASA-nomics can also work for parts of the story that don't really seem to make sense and have nothing to do with an economy.  For the sake of the story and all that.  Of course, I've never thought of the DC society as a war-hungry populace, but I got into the game late and saw the Combine as a feudal Japan type of thing, where your samurai go and fight for their shogun's and ultimately emperors while the peasants toil in the fields trying not to get in the samurai's way.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 05 November 2014, 17:14:47
Now, maybe this is me and my post French Revolution mindset, but heads roll when that kind of situation persists.
Compare the DC with its most direct parallel, the pre-1945 Japanese Empire.  And well, there wasn't much of a revolution after they lost that war despite being a culture built around military ability.  The French Revolution came about from a number of factors, many of which simply don't exist in the Combine...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Bosefius on 05 November 2014, 17:20:18
No one has crossed any lines yet however that line into Rule #4 territory is approaching rapidly. Let's go ahead and stop this conversation here.

Thank you
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 05 November 2014, 22:26:45
Pre reading ideas? I still have the old FMDC but the binding is failing. The old house book is still up somewhere.

There are some Jihad stuff that I didn't retain in my head which will probably be worth rereading too. Any ideas which books?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 05 November 2014, 22:48:18
You are going to need to be a little more specific as to what you are looking for.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 05 November 2014, 23:13:53
I gotta say, I LOVE Field Manual:  House Kurita from the FASA days.  It was the last one I picked up (I only got it off eBay THIS YEAR, compared to, like, 2007 at the latest for the others), but there are SO many interesting units in House Kurita.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 06 November 2014, 00:25:45
I gotta say, I LOVE Field Manual:  House Kurita from the FASA days.  It was the last one I picked up (I only got it off eBay THIS YEAR, compared to, like, 2007 at the latest for the others), but there arewere SO many interesting units in House Kurita.

Corrected.   ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 06 November 2014, 08:26:14
Corrected.   ;)

The funny thing is, I was debating writing the post that way...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 15 November 2014, 16:17:41
Handbook: House Kurita…some art… (http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/102706167591/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-some-art)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 16 November 2014, 00:33:41
"And that's when Joey learned that the Daboku was the only 'Mech that ejected like that."
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 16 November 2014, 15:41:20
"And that's when Joey learned that the Daboku was the only 'Mech that ejected like that."

Man, if I wasn't busy procrastinating on homework, I'd totally rewrite Warren Zevon's "Hit Somebody" to fit this picture...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 10 December 2014, 13:22:14
Handbook House Kurita Developer's Blog 3: http://bg.battletech.com/news/battleblog/handbook-house-kurita-developers-blog-3/

These previews hurt me. I need this in my hands.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Peacemaker on 10 December 2014, 19:03:14
That's great writing. Rome knows how to turn a phrase. Seeing things from the lower-caste perspective is a fascinating way to reexamine the setting. I actually felt bad for the Nova Cats reading that. Their civilians got a raw deal.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 10 December 2014, 19:17:04
I'm beginning to think that the smart Nova Cats jumped ship to join the Republic after the Jihad. Did many go with the Spirit Cats?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Istal_Devalis on 11 December 2014, 07:57:12
As far as we know, no one from the Nova Cat's proper is with the Spirit Cats. They're all from the Republic Nova Cats. (And how many of those jumped ship is a bit of an open question, I'd think. No firm numbers were given)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: HuronWarrior on 11 December 2014, 12:22:00
Handbook House Kurita Developer's Blog 3: http://bg.battletech.com/news/battleblog/handbook-house-kurita-developers-blog-3/

These previews hurt me. I need this in my hands.
I'm excited for it, I've been dying to learn more about the Combine.

How would you Dragons sell your faction to a new player?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 11 December 2014, 14:04:45
I'm excited for it, I've been dying to learn more about the Combine.

How would you Dragons sell your faction to a new player?

I actually did just that the other day; I convinced a new player to take all of my ALAG minis and start playing DC. To be honest he was pretty well sold with "space samurai" but I explained that the DCMS has some really great cavalry units and while they are often criticized for having little in the middle (medium 'Mechs) they have some really good stuff in the other weight classes. I also showed off the new 3145 stuff like the Shiro, Rokurokubi and Hitosume Kozo with their samurai styling and thick armor.

As far as fluff I told him that the best part about being Kuritan is never having to say you're sorry;  you get to be the proud and stoic bushi and fight for the glory of the Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 11 December 2014, 16:22:14
The DC has a surprising range of medium 'Mechs.  Don't read too much into the stereotype that they don't use them much, especially from the 3050s on.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 11 December 2014, 17:41:24
To be precise, the DCMS does't like medium mechs, but like any Great House, they will use whatever they have. When compared to the normal speeds of lights and firepower/armor of heavies, Mediums fall in the middle (duh) which the DCMS is not a fan of. But they will use any mech they have. Because a mech is a mech....
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 11 December 2014, 18:43:41
The DC has a surprising range of medium 'Mechs.  Don't read too much into the stereotype that they don't use them much, especially from the 3050s on.

You're right but the stereotype seems to persist. The two 'Mech lances I gave him had I believe two mediums between them so I may very well be guilty of perpetuating it. When he said he liked the cavalry concept I immediately thought Kurita.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 22 December 2014, 14:10:31
BattleTech: Handbook House Kurita (Prefinal Cover) (http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/105880504051/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-prefinal-cover)

So perhaps in a few weeks ...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 22 December 2014, 15:44:05
Hope so, it would make a great late birthday present to myself.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 23 December 2014, 07:50:08
BattleTech: Handbook House Kurita (Prefinal Cover) (http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/105880504051/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-prefinal-cover)

So perhaps in a few weeks ...

Nope.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 23 December 2014, 08:35:31
Nope.
Nice Christmas 2015 gift, then? All right.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Marwynn on 24 April 2015, 08:54:04
It's out! http://catalystgamelabs.tumblr.com/post/117194278061/battletech-handbook-house-kurita-is-available

Just finished downloading it. If I don't surface within a few hours send some coffee.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 24 April 2015, 09:32:27
I'm really curious as to how everyone receives it; I've been waiting 4 years for reactions to what's in the book....
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 24 April 2015, 11:20:22
Depends.  Do you want both barrels on here, or over headset?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 24 April 2015, 11:55:02
Depends.  Do you want both barrels on here, or over headset?

Oh, lay it all out for everyone to pile in on. I don't know when we'll be on the One together blowing up Fallen.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 24 April 2015, 11:57:35
I haven't actually downloaded it.  In the meantime i'll simply say you suck to cover my bases until then.  I'm sure it is a good read.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 24 April 2015, 12:19:12
I'm really curious as to how everyone receives it; I've been waiting 4 years for reactions to what's in the book....
Petrhaps the next week. There are more pressing things to do this weekend:    ;)
(https://static.mwomercs.com/img/news/media/4677e6749684d7a2b2f982a423cc16e2.jpg)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 24 April 2015, 14:59:12
I haven't actually downloaded it.  In the meantime i'll simply say you suck to cover my bases until then.  I'm sure it is a good read.

I can't speak for anyone else but I enjoyed it quite a bit.  It really helped me get a better grasp on the Combine's sometimes unique point of view.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 24 April 2015, 16:49:09
Still perusing the new book; I like what I see thus far.

On a different topic; what is a PNT-10LAG Panther (http://masterunitlist.info/Unit/Details/5865/panther-pnt-10lag)?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 24 April 2015, 17:40:38
There's a note on there that says what it is - a faster Panther for the Amphigean Light Assault Group.  There are no official stats or we'd have listed a record sheet on the unit.  My off-the-cuff guess would start with the old PTR-8Z's basic specs on a PTR-10K's frame, only with DHS and maybe throw a little hot rod red in there.

EDIT: I could've sworn the PNT-8Z was 5/8/5 but apparently not.  Anyway, that's generally what I had in mind.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 24 April 2015, 18:16:54
There's a note on there that says what it is - a faster Panther for the Amphigean Light Assault Group.  There are no official stats or we'd have listed a record sheet on the unit.  My off-the-cuff guess would start with the old PTR-8Z's basic specs on a PTR-10K's frame, only with DHS and maybe throw a little hot rod red in there.

EDIT: I could've sworn the PNT-8Z was 5/8/5 but apparently not.  Anyway, that's generally what I had in mind.

That sounds good to me. I've often wished for a faster Panther.

Of course now we have the (dirty Panther killing) Wight
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 25 April 2015, 03:27:00
Still perusing the new book; I like what I see thus far.

On a different topic; what is a PNT-10LAG Panther (http://masterunitlist.info/Unit/Details/5865/panther-pnt-10lag)?

I'm hoping we find out at some point, got a soft spot for the LAG.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 25 April 2015, 04:37:33
I'm hoping we find out at some point, got a soft spot for the LAG.

Same here. Kurita was the first faction I followed and the ALAG was my favorite command.

I'm still trying to figure out the ALAG in 3145; they aren't hardcore samurai so I doubt the totem units fit. In some cases they're A rated so I'd think they'd have high-end equipment. However, they're also "expendable shock troops" so I don't know how crazy their equipment could be.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 25 April 2015, 05:38:38
The book seems to be taking a more "Pro-Combine" tone than some of the other Handbooks, though, IIRC, the House Liao Handbook seemed to be the same way compared to some of the earlier Handbooks. Its sort of hard to tell how much. Its also been a while since I read the original Housebooks, so its hard to make any comparison to find any differences.

Part of the problem with the non-Neutral tone, its sort of hard to figure out if its factual, or lots of face saving is going on (its surprising how many Coordinators end rather abruptly with little in the way of details).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 25 April 2015, 07:03:57
They're shock and fast attack units.  I think that'd bring in a lot of Rokurokubis (hopefully mainly the ER PPC variant) and Hitosumes (especially in the First; the Second's aerial assault specialty works better with jump jets) but without much in the way of Dragon IIs, which are too slow to fit their tactics and are outside the unit's usual weight profile.  The emphasis on jump-capable BA is interesting given the Dragon's range of newer suits and might lead to an unusually heavy concentration of the old Raiden suits.  Either one might be willing to make exceptions for the Kishi and the First could find themselves holding the bag with Onis, which have a good ground speed but don't jump.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Foxx Ital on 25 April 2015, 18:06:09
Were i a coordinator, i would avoid the Following, Horses,Shovels,Stairs. All while wearing a neck brace.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 25 April 2015, 19:45:20
Were i a coordinator, i would avoid the Following, Horses,Shovels,Stairs. All while wearing a neck brace.

Add to that list hilltops where you make an easy sniper target, as well.  Saves everyone a lot of trouble.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Cyc on 25 April 2015, 21:56:30
The book seems to be taking a more "Pro-Combine" tone than some of the other Handbooks, though, IIRC, the House Liao Handbook seemed to be the same way compared to some of the earlier Handbooks. Its sort of hard to tell how much. Its also been a while since I read the original Housebooks, so its hard to make any comparison to find any differences.

Part of the problem with the non-Neutral tone, its sort of hard to figure out if its factual, or lots of face saving is going on (its surprising how many Coordinators end rather abruptly with little in the way of details).

That reflects both the Combine and Confederation's tighter control of message/history books. I'm more amazed that we got confirmation of the conspiracy theory suggestion for who Snow Fire was working for from Handbook: House Marik.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 25 April 2015, 23:03:51
I'm more amazed that we got confirmation of the conspiracy theory suggestion for who Snow Fire was working for from Handbook: House Marik.

Or was that propaganda/misinformation from the ISF or Black Dragons?   ^-^
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Foxx Ital on 26 April 2015, 18:36:50
I'm gonna just start calling the DCMS the praetorian guard
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 26 April 2015, 19:54:19
I'm gonna just start calling the DCMS the praetorian guard

God Dammit, I already needed to buy this book.  Now we're throwing "I, Claudius" references in?*  Y'know what, Ben Rome?  Take my Bank Account.  Just take it.

*Yes, I know it's a GENERAL historical thing, and not solely from "I, Claudius," but I've got to have my John Hurt and Derek Jacobi.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Foxx Ital on 26 April 2015, 20:12:20
The red in the combine logo comes from the spilled blood of its coordinators, So let the poison that lurks in the mud, hatch out!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 28 April 2015, 00:18:38
There's some odd little bits in it, related to the tone that I mentioned before. Some tongue in cheek comments on the courts and their objectivity, IIRC. Something I'd sort of expect from a neutral observer rather than the Pro-Combine tone the rest of it takes. Nothing really big, just sort of weird at times.

And I'm sort of confused on uniforms. It states that Senior Officers wear black versions of the standard uniform for their branch (so a senior officer in infantry goes ahead and wears a black infantry uniform), but then it goes on describing a Senior officer uniform that's completely different from anything anyone wears (high collared tunic and pants). Later on, you get told about a dress uniform that all members of the DCMS wear.

So its a little confusing. Unless I'm missing something.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 28 April 2015, 20:12:48
OK if I'm going to do up a Hitosume Kozo and a Rokurokubi in ALAG colors I think I want to ditch the nobori. Should I just fill in the hole or are the ALAG crazy enough to sport bosozoku style "pipes" off of their samurai 'Mechs?

Yes, I'm considering bosozoku space samurai...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Neko_Bijin on 29 April 2015, 22:43:59
There's some odd little bits in it, related to the tone that I mentioned before. Some tongue in cheek comments on the courts and their objectivity, IIRC. Something I'd sort of expect from a neutral observer rather than the Pro-Combine tone the rest of it takes. Nothing really big, just sort of weird at times.

And I'm sort of confused on uniforms. It states that Senior Officers wear black versions of the standard uniform for their branch (so a senior officer in infantry goes ahead and wears a black infantry uniform), but then it goes on describing a Senior officer uniform that's completely different from anything anyone wears (high collared tunic and pants). Later on, you get told about a dress uniform that all members of the DCMS wear.

So its a little confusing. Unless I'm missing something.
Some of the text is taken verbatim from the original HKSB, which is putatively a ComStar document.  Its portrayal of the Combine is also a bit campier than the modern conception.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Cyc on 30 April 2015, 00:42:12
Some of the text is taken verbatim from the original HKSB, which is putatively a ComStar document.  Its portrayal of the Combine is also a bit campier than the modern conception.

*shuffles uneasily* It might just be me, and the fact I've been re-reading the original House Kurita book heavily this year (why Sarna got a proper Taragi entry), but does Handbook: House Kurita seem to have a higher volume of verbatim text compared to the other Handbooks?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 30 April 2015, 01:39:03
I was sort of curious about that myself. I know the uniform issue I had earlier was the same in both books, so no help there, but I don't know the Kurita housebook well enough to compare the two.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ANS Kamas P81 on 30 April 2015, 08:14:49
OK if I'm going to do up a Hitosume Kozo and a Rokurokubi in ALAG colors I think I want to ditch the nobori. Should I just fill in the hole or are the ALAG crazy enough to sport bosozoku style "pipes" off of their samurai 'Mechs?

Yes, I'm considering bosozoku space samurai...
You just gave me the perfect inspiration for a Ghost company. :D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 30 April 2015, 09:07:55
You just gave me the perfect inspiration for a Ghost company. :D

Of course it fits the Ghosts perfectly!  O0

Wish I'd thought of that,  good call.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 30 April 2015, 09:28:10
*shuffles uneasily* It might just be me, and the fact I've been re-reading the original House Kurita book heavily this year (why Sarna got a proper Taragi entry), but does Handbook: House Kurita seem to have a higher volume of verbatim text compared to the other Handbooks?

Not really verbatim, but definitely used as a heavy draw. There were portions I reviewed in the old book that I knew would be just fine to port over, so rather than come up with a new way to reinvent the wheel, I just cleaned up a lot of the older text, including word choice, phrasing, and punctuation. As well as aligning it to our internal style guide.

So it sounds identical mainly because several portions are very closely aligned.

Also note that there were sectional chunks that I felt were interesting in their own right, but didn't fit the narrative I was constructing, so they found their way into a sidebar rather than the main text.

From a narrative standpoint, I felt that while ComStar 'sorta' got it right in their original document, the Kuritan historians would rely on the outsider's viewpoint except where it was needed to explain or solidify the Dragon's own stance on events. Blend that with the Kuritan penchant for 'reading between the lines'.....

Hope that explains things.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 04 May 2015, 19:28:11
Hello, 

I'm wondering if anyone can tell me how the DCMS deploys BA?

Amounts attached to BM Regiments?
Amounts attached to Infantry Regiments?
Deployed Independently?

Also, if there is any Unit specific deployments will also be great.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 05 May 2015, 00:47:19
I'm not sure its ever been detailed beyond what we had in the original Field Manual Draconis Combine, which was basically "Attached in platoon size to conventional infantry regiments."

The passage in that book suggests breaking them away from Conventional Infantry and attaching them directly to the Battlemech forces, but that's just a possible thought in the future, that I don't think is mentioned again.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 13 May 2015, 22:46:13
Alright, sons and daughters of the Dragon, I need some advice. I recently painted a lance for the 6th Ryuken, circa 3145. I Just grabbed some mechs that I liked for the DCMS: Shiro, Hitostume-Kozo, Mad Dog MK.IV, and Dragon II. After painting that lance I realized, "this is a command Lance" The Shiro and the Dragon II are command and support mechs while the Mad Dog MK.IV and Hitostume-Kozo are general combatants/body guards. So I have a conundrum, what should the rest of the company be? I want a 3145 feel, and I will need some TAG to put that Dragon II to work. Any suggestions for the other 2 lances?

P.S. I love Rokurokubi's (-4K model) so any suggestions with one or two of those lovely little mechs will look better.  ;D
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 14 May 2015, 11:13:17
Alright, sons and daughters of the Dragon, I need some advice. I recently painted a lance for the 6th Ryuken, circa 3145. I Just grabbed some mechs that I liked for the DCMS: Shiro, Hitostume-Kozo, Mad Dog MK.IV, and Dragon II. After painting that lance I realized, "this is a command Lance" The Shiro and the Dragon II are command and support mechs while the Mad Dog MK.IV and Hitostume-Kozo are general combatants/body guards. So I have a conundrum, what should the rest of the company be? I want a 3145 feel, and I will need some TAG to put that Dragon II to work. Any suggestions for the other 2 lances?

P.S. I love Rokurokubi's (-4K model) so any suggestions with one or two of those lovely little mechs will look better.  ;D

Command Lance

Battle Lance

Scout Lance
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 22 May 2015, 23:08:42
Ordered the minis I'll be using for my 3145 Amphigeans today. I went with a fair amount of Nova Cat stuff like Morrigans and Ocelots and such. I just wanted to thank everyone for their help in deciding on what to get.

Is safe to say the 1st ALAG is probably A rated from Nova Cat salvage and not because they're being sent top of the line equipment?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Phalanx on 25 May 2015, 20:43:53
Let's talk about 2303. We get the following phrase concerning the Alliance of Galedon invasion of Sverdlovsk:

Quote
The first full-scale interstellar military operation ever run in the inner sphere had begun.


So even if we ignore the territorial grabs of the Tikonov Union BEFORE the Outer Reaches Rebellion, the former colonies efforts to annex each other (which could have been accomplished through espionage/bribery/trade/alliance), and focus ONLY on those events which are explicitly stated as military campaigns:

The Republic of Marik's Expansion Campaign which began in 2245? A Concert Tour.

Marik Commonwealth's 2265 intervention on New Olympica(which was stopped by the Regulans)? Alonzo Marik was stopping there for lunch.

The Stewart War? An FWL Picnic.


The only argument I can see in favor of the text is the idea that Shiro Kurita's campaign was the first which did not focus on one world at a time. If the idea is that he is the first to think in terms of interstellar "fronts" rather than single-world flash points, then I am inclined to agree. 




Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GhostBear on 26 May 2015, 09:44:33

If the idea is that he is the first to think in terms of interstellar "fronts" rather than single-world flash points, then I am inclined to agree.

That's exactly how Shiro saw it. He was a 'visionary' in the sense that 'all the worlds I see belong to me' and set out to do just that. He had the bigger picture in mind, a grand Draconian vision.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 26 May 2015, 15:47:46
I'm really curious as to how everyone receives it; I've been waiting 4 years for reactions to what's in the book....

I've been waiting longer than that to have the book.  And I'll be honest, I truly came to believe you (plural) would never actually publish it.

So I'd like to applaud you (singular) for sticking to it through to the end.  I for one am as surprised as I am appreciative.

I haven't digested it yet, but at least with regards to my forum name I couldn't help but notice Scientologists appear to have replaced Dead Heads in Combine space.  With tongue planted firmly in cheek, I wonder if the ISF did ever locate Terrapin Station.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 03 June 2015, 14:08:27
Surprised no one is commenting on Ben's twitter teaser posts for TRO3150 it's full of little nuggets like this:-

Tai-i Nejem’s company of the Second Arkab Legion defended a Dominion raid by the Second Drakøn Cluster in 3146.


And this:-

Sao-wei Nilyavich worked beside DCMS counterparts during part of the recent Capellan-Combine joint invasion of Republic space
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 03 June 2015, 14:10:09
The joint invasion has been taking place in other threads.

I adopt a typical Kuritan stoic face in light of these tweets.  The future is not yet determined.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 03 June 2015, 20:48:22
Surprised no one is commenting on Ben's twitter teaser posts for TRO3150 it's full of little nuggets like this:-

Tai-i Nejem’s company of the Second Arkab Legion defended a Dominion raid by the Second Drakøn Cluster in 3146.


And this:-

Sao-wei Nilyavich worked beside DCMS counterparts during part of the recent Capellan-Combine joint invasion of Republic space

I wasn't aware before your post there were such things.

Assuming these aren't trollish/april fools type tweets, when the Combine attacks Remagen in 3148 it means one of two things:

The invasion is going fantastically well for House Kurita

or

They've taken their eye waaaaaay off the prize.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Ghostbear_Gurdel on 03 June 2015, 22:01:47
Assuming these aren't trollish/april fools type tweets, when the Combine attacks Remagen in 3148 it means one of two things:

The invasion is going fantastically well for House Kurita

or

They've taken their eye waaaaaay off the prize.
Probably a very deep raid, possibly a part of a larger effort, to pin down Davion defenders away from the Front-lines.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 16 June 2015, 18:40:42
Annoying question here:  is the Dead Tree version of HB: HK out yet?  My brother wants me to get it for him for his successful defense of his doctoral dissertation.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Moonsword on 16 June 2015, 19:37:37
Yes.

There's a product page linked on the front page of this very website:
http://bg.battletech.com/test/handbooks/handbook-house-kurita/

It, in turn, links here:
http://www.battlecorps.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=3435
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 16 June 2015, 21:00:41
Yes.

There's a product page linked on the front page of this very website:
http://bg.battletech.com/test/handbooks/handbook-house-kurita/

It, in turn, links here:
http://www.battlecorps.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=3435

Sweet!  Thanks Moonsword!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 17 July 2015, 07:03:45
Besides the First Sword of Light, does anyone know which DCMS units were involved in the final assault on Irece at the end of the failed Nova Cat rebellion?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 July 2015, 07:45:18
Besides the First Sword of Light, does anyone know which DCMS units involved in the final assault on Irece at the end of the failed Nova Cat rebellion?
The First Genyosha.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 17 July 2015, 08:23:13
The First Genyosha.

Any chance you have a source for that? Not that I don't believe you, I just prefer to have citations when I can get them.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 17 July 2015, 08:29:36
Any chance you have a source for that? Not that I don't believe you, I just prefer to have citations when I can get them.

" .... making for Irece and the deciding battle of the rebellion."
Era Report: 3145 (CAT 35223), p. 48, the right column
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 17 July 2015, 08:38:56
Fantastic, thank you!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Trevor on 17 July 2015, 18:54:22
Hello there Kuritans, working on a Drac force myself, currently have a Komodo, Wight, Nyx and Wolverine operating in a C3 lance which has been doing well even against my Lyran forces. Looking for ideas to expand, would the Kuritans make use of primarily cavalry style lances with mostly mediums/lights and maybe a heavy or two?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 17 July 2015, 21:12:30
Asking about good skirmisher choices for a Kurita force is actually challenging.. it'd be like asking "what are some good assaults for a Lyran force?"  There's just so many choices it's hard to narrow it down...

If you're looking to expand the C3 network:
The Naginata is about the best C3M around.  The new Mark II S-Tanks from TRO 3415 are excellent spotters, as well.

If you're looking to build some more cavalry forces:

The Grand Dragon is a Kurita staple and there are some good skirmisher models in the series.  The Daikyu is ugly as sin but it's a great addition to a  skirmish lance.  I'm a fan of the Wolf Trap, too.  At least in Alpha Strike anyway.  As for light mechs, there's a bunch of good choices.. the DCMS does love their lights.

If you have a time period in mind that'd narrow the focus.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Trevor on 17 July 2015, 23:02:12
Thinking post 3085 moving into current timeline really.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 21 July 2015, 14:03:17
There's already a thread (http://bg.battletech.com/forums/general-discussion/tro-3150/) for discussing the new lore for the BTU post 3145.  In the interest of promoting factionalism, I'm bringing mention of it here :)

Of particular interest is the possibility that New Avalon has already fallen.  I personally don't buy into it, but I'd be curious to continue to discuss it without being sidetracked over what counts as an IC or OCC quote from the book ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Flieger on 21 July 2015, 15:54:44
I buy it, actually. At the very least, New Avalon has become open for an invasion which the AFFS cannot/could not stop. New Syrtis is considered safer than New Avalon after all...
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 22 July 2015, 21:43:42
Just got my copy of Handbook House Kurita today.

My God, this book is awesome.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 22 July 2015, 23:50:11
I buy it, actually. At the very least, New Avalon has become open for an invasion which the AFFS cannot/could not stop. New Syrtis is considered safer than New Avalon after all...

It wasn't for Duchess Angela Hasek.   ^-^
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jayof9s on 23 July 2015, 14:58:50
I buy it, actually. At the very least, New Avalon has become open for an invasion which the AFFS cannot/could not stop. New Syrtis is considered safer than New Avalon after all...

Safer because the Capellans already captured it and won't invade again?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 23 July 2015, 15:03:03
Safer because the Capellans already captured it and won't invade again?

As of TRO: 3150 Julian and Task Force Navarre took it back.

Granted it's probably still precarious, but presumably it's less so than New Avalon.  Remagen was apparently a major C2 hub for the AFFS that merited a major DCMS raid including 2 regiments of Rykuen to deal with.  Remagen is significantly rimward of New Avalon, so there's oodles of room to read in what that means to New Avalon's current status.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 24 July 2015, 06:49:30
Soooo...holy shit, a 'Zuchi with ten SRM tubes? So a squad is basically like a mini-SRM carrier? Makes me wonder how many rounds it carries.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 24 July 2015, 12:27:28
Well, assuming I'm not doing the math wrong...swapping to advanced armor saves 150kg (assuming they're talking about literally Advanced armor in the description). Dropping all weaponry apart from the modular equipment adapter mounts saves you another 660 kg. So a total of 810kg for weaponry, which nets you two SRM5s and 2 shots each, with I think 10kg and 1 slot free, enough to put one of the AP mounts back. Of course, if the Cavalier II can be cranked out with Clantech then I don't see why the Kanazuchi can't, and using standard Clan armor would net another 200 free, which would give each SRM5 another 2 shots.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 24 July 2015, 22:09:49
Perhaps it uses DWPs to fit more ammo?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 25 July 2015, 03:41:43
Could I suppose. I can't remember the rules right off hand, but that might be a bad thing since you might have to fiddle with the movement if you wanted more than one DWP.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 26 July 2015, 14:59:45
Let's talk about Operation PERCEVAL.

I'm actually feeling pretty good about what's presented in TRO: 3150.  It is the mandatory other shoe dropping to the events of 3145, and I don't think it's really harming the invasion that much.  And given the outcome of the Raid on Remagen, I think whether or not New Avalon has already fallen the AFFS may actually have a fork put in them by the DCMS.  (and thus the situation is set up for someone else to come into the war to save Davion.)

Consider the lore we're teased with:
PERCEVAL forces are suggested as being rather small and built to harry and raid rather than liberate.  Scaling up to larger efforts is something the AFFS higher echelons hopes to do in the future.. as opposed to already being done. (Fusilier pilot lore, J12A1 pilot lore further reinforces idea they are hit-and-run raiders rather than liberators)

The planet Franklin is mentioned several times as a problem for the DCMS. Most notably, the 1st DG hit Franklin in an apparent repeat of the Whirling Dervishes of New Rhodes event in the 1st SW in a strike on the 5th Ghost Regiment's supply depots.  PERCEVAL is also mentioned as "attempting" to link up with partisans on Franklin during the same year as the 1st DG raid, so it's possible the 1st DG are part of operation PERCEVAL.   Interestingly, the 1st DG are also retaking New Syrtis in this apparently eventful year.  It's probable that the Davion Guards operating with PERCEVAL are only elements of the regiment, or a psyop conducted by the AFFS to make the regiment look to be in two places at the same time (or by the TPTB to confuse people like me who like to delve into the weeds).

Remagen features heavily as well.  It was hit by Task Force TSUJIKIRI: a rather large force assembled to raid the PERCEVAL FOB on Remagen.  It included at least two Ryuken regiments, Hachi and Hikage (Saracen pilot lore) and an elite company of Narukamis (Narukami pilot lore), and enough aerospace support that a pilot could go ace shooting down incoming Kuritans and still have a negligible impact on the planetfall (Rondel pilot lore).    Erik Sandoval and the 1st Kestrel Grenadiers were caught on-planet (Sortek and Saracen pilot lores) and the prince's champion barely escaped to the 5th Avalon Hussars' dropships (sortek pilot lore)

Those two AFFS regiments being on Remagen at all is remarkable.  In 3145 the 1st Kestrel was on Markesan, and 5th Avalon on Cammal.  Is it possible those worlds have fallen?  Markesan would be particularly noteworthy if so.  And of all the places in the Federated Suns, why would a world 2 jumps rimward of New Avalon be chosen to coordinate PERCEVAL?  It certainly appears that the entire point of PERCEVAL is to make occupation as painful as possible.  It'd make sense to coordinate such raids and assistance to insurgencies within a few jumps of occupied space.

So does that mean Remagen IS now a couple jumps from occupied space?  I still think that if New Avalon had fallen that'd have been an event of such magnitude it'd have been said explicitly.  Yet what I call the Palmyra Thumb has been given a canonical name: The Dragon's Tongue and it appears to have expanded (if only because it's now formally named IC).  Coloma was attacked (Antlion pilot entry) but it's not clear if it was a conquest or raid.

Thoughts?








Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jayof9s on 26 July 2015, 16:25:19
Most notably, the 1st DG hit Franklin in an apparent repeat of the Whirling Dervishes of New Rhodes event in the 1st SW in a strike on the 5th Ghost Regiment's supply depots.

Interestingly, the 1st DG are also retaking New Syrtis in this apparently eventful year.  It's probable that the Davion Guards operating with PERCEVAL are only elements of the regiment, or a psyop conducted by the AFFS to make the regiment look to be in two places at the same time (or by the TPTB to confuse people like me who like to delve into the weeds).

I don't want to comment on the rest until I read what's in there but it is possible for them to get from Franklin to New Syrtis and have been in combat on both planets and still have it happen in the same year. Especially if PERCEVAL is mostly raids - you don't usually stick around for a very long time on raids. So, they got in, hit their targets, and then left. The AFFS is low on units, so they didn't get a lot of rest time and got sent almost straight to New Syrtis to join in retaking it. Now, if it said they did both within a month of each other or less, then I'd question if there was something else up.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: False Son on 27 July 2015, 08:37:57
Let's talk about Operation PERCEVAL.

I'm actually feeling pretty good about what's presented in TRO: 3150.  It is the mandatory other shoe dropping to the events of 3145, and I don't think it's really harming the invasion that much.  And given the outcome of the Raid on Remagen, I think whether or not New Avalon has already fallen the AFFS may actually have a fork put in them by the DCMS.  (and thus the situation is set up for someone else to come into the war to save Davion.)

Bearing in mind that logistics has always been a weak point for the DCMS.  PERCEVAL's attacks on the DCMS support train is right out of Alister Marsden's playbook. 

Quote
I still think that if New Avalon had fallen that'd have been an event of such magnitude it'd have been said explicitly.

That time will come.  In the meantime we can piece it together.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: sillybrit on 27 July 2015, 12:02:26
Perhaps it uses DWPs to fit more ammo?

DWPs can't be used with missile launchers
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 29 July 2015, 12:37:20
As I am reading up on the Combine (which is firmly cementing itself as my favorite Successor State), thoughts are brewing.  Now, keep in mind that I am ill as I type this, so they may not necessarily be the most coherent.

I notice that several elements of Black Dragon plans utilize resources and plans associated with Marcus Kurita.  For instance, Marcus Kurita was the one who hid Franklin Sakamoto away, as a tool to be used against Takashi later (which the Black Dragon did in the cartoon).  Likewise, Marcus (along with Hassid Ricol) was involved in the assassination plot against Takashi in the Rasalhague district, in an attempt to brew trouble which Marcus could then step in and take advantage of.  And wouldn't you know it, later Hassid Ricol turns out to be a Black Dragon.  And the Coordinator's Birthday Assassination plot (thwarted by Uncle Chandy's Favorite Merc Unit), the Kurita that the Black Dragon Society plans to put on the Chrysanthemum Throne is...Marcus Kurita's Grandson.

So this got me thinking:  Are the Black Dragons a tool for Marcus' Branch of the Family?  Could that be one of the reasons they persist?  That they have a patron in the form of a cadet branch of the royal family?  Or is it perhaps the other way around?  Is that side of the Kurita Family tree merely puppets dancing on the strings of the Black Dragons?  What are your thoughts on the matter?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 29 July 2015, 17:01:02
I think it's the latter. The Black Dragons were apparently willing to back Kitsune Kurita for the throne right up until he revealed himself as Victor's son. Prior to that, they believed him to be Isoroku Kurita's grandson, and thus a direct descendant of Hohiro I (Takashi's father).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 30 July 2015, 11:20:26
I think it's the latter. The Black Dragons were apparently willing to back Kitsune Kurita for the throne right up until he revealed himself as Victor's son. Prior to that, they believed him to be Isoroku Kurita's grandson, and thus a direct descendant of Hohiro I (Takashi's father).

Actually, now I'm curious for more info on Marcus Kurita.  Keeping in mind that I STILL haven't eaten anything, and that therefore this might not be the most logical thought process...

We know Marcus Kurita was a cousin (of some sort) of Takashi.  Takashi viewed Marcus getting the Chrysanthemum Throne as a terrible, terrible thing for the Combine ("Heir to the Dragon".)  We know that Marcus was definitely pulling some strings in the Rasalhague Independence Movement (per the assassination attempt in "Heir to the Dragon") and other things that later became involved with the Black Dragons.  He kept Franklin Sakamoto safe to be used as a pawn later, and was one of the Warlords to rebel during the Ronin War.

I wonder if it's a question of "the chicken and the egg"?  Like, we know the Black Dragon Society existed for ages.  But what if Marcus manipulated their sentiments in an attempt to gain the throne for himself?  Then Marcus gets assassinated (sucks to be him).  But, whoops, his rhetoric lives on, and the Society is now trying to get less competent members of the family on the throne believing A) They can control them, and B) It's what good ol' Grandpa Marcus would've wanted.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 August 2015, 04:39:22
Does anyone else think it's odd that the Combine didn't invade the Outworlds Alliance at any point during the succession wars?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 01 August 2015, 05:04:43
Does anyone else think it's odd that the Combine didn't invade the Outworlds Alliance at any point during the succession wars?

Not alot for them to gain. The OA's population is pretty spread out, they have limited heavy infrastructure that would make the Kuritans interested in the OA's worlds. The limited military forces also would mean little honor for the Kuritans to win..these were the people that would stop attacking the Lyrans and go after the FedSuns because the Lyrans were too easy and the FedSuns made a fight of things.

So yeah, there might have been one or two planets that they might have wanted, but very little in the way of winnable resources or honor.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 August 2015, 05:45:56
True although the few industrial worlds would have been handy to have during the succession wars and if the invasion was successful it could potentially open a route into the back of the Federated Suns.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 01 August 2015, 06:19:53
The other little bit is opening up a third front. All the Successor States pretty much stalemated on what was effectively two fronts for them (sure, down by Terra you could easily attack another Successor State, but for the most part, they were two front wars). The DCMS would have to pull troops from the Lyran and Davion borders (or their interior) to the OA, and that could cause issues. Especially with how much aerospace (traditionally limited in scope by the Succession Wars, IIRC) they would have to pull to deal with the OA's units. Probably just easier to train with them and buy off of them than conquer.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 01 August 2015, 07:38:55
Outworlds was also pretty big on trying to play the FedSuns and Combine off of each other.

"Yeah, you COULD conquer us, but then you wouldn't have this handy neutral nation where you could ostensibly sneak spies through!"
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 August 2015, 12:41:00
True, mind you I am of the opinion that if the Combine invaded the Alliance the Suns would have done the same to protect their flank.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Archangel on 07 August 2015, 02:44:18
The Outworlds Alliance was nominally pro-FedSuns but maintain their neutral stance to avoid antagonizing the Draconis Combine.

In the past, the Draconis Combine was dissuaded from invading the Outworlds Alliance was the number of units that would have to be redeployed from more active fronts to not only seize the OA but secure it against resistance groups that would be sure to crop up and assuredly be actively supported by the FedSuns (the DC has no need for another district full of dissidents) and the amount of funding (which they can ill afford), not to mention time and effort, for developing the territory before it would start paying off.

True, mind you I am of the opinion that if the Combine invaded the Alliance the Suns would have done the same to protect their flank.

Highly unlikely.  More likely they would send some mercenaries to aid the OA defenders as well as provide some material support while they tried to take advantage of the DCMS' weakness by launching raids if not an outright invasion like the FWLM took advantage of the Lyrans' Operation Concentrated Weakness.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Savage Coyote on 26 August 2015, 09:01:34
Away from my books and needed an answer:  What is the DCMS's equivalent rank of a company commander as well as a lance commander?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: martian on 26 August 2015, 09:32:17
Away from my books and needed an answer:  What is the DCMS's equivalent rank of a company commander as well as a lance commander?
Tai-i (Captain)
- company commander
- sometimes Sho-sa (Major) commands company

Chu-i (Lieutenant)
- lance commander
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Savage Coyote on 26 August 2015, 11:11:39
Awesome, thanks martian!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 20 December 2015, 05:58:05
Hi, quick question for the DCMS experts here, does the combine have access to any mechs equipped with Plasma Rifles?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 20 December 2015, 08:20:27
Yes. They use the Panther PNT-13K, all three variants of the Peacekeeper, the Raptor RTX1-OG, and the Wight WGT-3SC.

There's also the SL-27 Samurai and MIK-OE Tatsu on the aerospace fighter side of things.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 20 December 2015, 08:41:16
Yes. They use the Panther PNT-13K, all three variants of the Peacekeeper, the Raptor RTX1-OG, and the Wight WGT-3SC

There's also the SL-27 Samurai and MIK-OE Tatsu on the aerospace fighter side of things.

Cracking, cheers for the reply.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 20 December 2015, 09:08:14
They get clan spec plamsa cannons, too.  Off the top of my head I know the Rifleman IIC 7 is a Kurita-available mech as of the Dark Age.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kojak on 20 December 2015, 13:39:05
They get clan spec plamsa cannons, too.  Off the top of my head I know the Rifleman IIC 7 is a Kurita-available mech as of the Dark Age.

They do indeed. They also get the Warhammer IIC 8, although in fairness so does everyone else.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Top Sergeant on 24 December 2015, 22:04:05
Merry Christmas! May you get a 'Mech under your tree!  8)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 January 2016, 16:44:30
Happy new year fellow warriors of the Dragon.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Armond on 18 January 2016, 16:10:31
Just saying konichiwa from Okinawa as a DC fan and player.  I built a Company for the 2nd Sword of Light for a small campaign I was running as well as a Command Lance for the Ryuken-Hachi.  We played in the Clan Invasion era, it was/is going well.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 18 January 2016, 16:44:58
Always great to hear about players honoring the Dragon!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Armond on 18 January 2016, 17:20:49
Is it permissible to post the pics of my 2nd Sword of Light as they are right now?  They aren't 100%, but at a happy place for play.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: worktroll on 24 January 2016, 21:58:12
Question if I may. I'm doing the prep-work for building a battalion of minis for one of the Ryuken regiments. The regiment is set during the Clan invasion period, and - from the bit of research I've done so far - it looks like the Ryuken largely sat out the initial phases of the Invasion, with only Ryoken-Roku playing a (significant) role in Operation Bulldog.

Now that's no problems - I'm comfortable with the idea of doing the Roku variation paintjob. It just seems odd that the other Ryoken regiments sat this period out. Can anyone shed any canon light on what they were up to? Is this related to their poor perception by other elements of the DCMS?

Thanks in advance,

W.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 24 January 2016, 22:09:51
Question if I may. I'm doing the prep-work for building a battalion of minis for one of the Ryuken regiments. The regiment is set during the Clan invasion period, and - from the bit of research I've done so far - it looks like the Ryuken largely sat out the initial phases of the Invasion, with only Ryoken-Roku playing a (significant) role in Operation Bulldog.

Now that's no problems - I'm comfortable with the idea of doing the Roku variation paintjob. It just seems odd that the other Ryoken regiments sat this period out. Can anyone shed any canon light on what they were up to? Is this related to their poor perception by other elements of the DCMS?

Thanks in advance,

W.

Page 10 of The Dragon Roars gives their deployment.  Some did indeed basically sit out the war as reinforcements on Wolcott that proved unnecessary.

EDIT: I didn't notice that you were asking about the entire era, not just Bird Dog/Bulldog.  Up until that point, they were basically living on Wolcott and playing Inglorious Basterds behind the front lines.  Whatever suffering the Jags endured from the Wolcott-based raids was largely courtesy of the Ryuken.  Their expertise in these raids paid off for Bird Dog, where the Ryuken company was one of only two recovered intact. (The 1st FS Armored Cavalry's company was the other).
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Dmon on 30 January 2016, 21:42:56
Just giving TRO:3150 a proper read for the first time. Anybody know what the Hikage is?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 30 January 2016, 23:23:13
Just giving TRO:3150 a proper read for the first time. Anybody know what the Hikage is?

We know they're new.  Contextually, it seems they're not part of any established legion.  At first I got the idea they were a newly raised regiment of Ryuken, but it never actually says that.  And the Saracen fluff implies there's significant differences in doctrine between the Hikage and the Ryuken.

I think it sounds like they're a kind of praetorian guard personnaly loyal to Toranaga.  Probably old-school hardline samurai types, if it's a "good thing" some Ryuken warriors didn't start drinking their kool-aid.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: jklantern on 30 January 2016, 23:24:32
Page 10 of The Dragon Roars gives their deployment.  Some did indeed basically sit out the war as reinforcements on Wolcott that proved unnecessary.

EDIT: I didn't notice that you were asking about the entire era, not just Bird Dog/Bulldog.  Up until that point, they were basically living on Wolcott and playing Inglorious Basterds behind the front lines.  Whatever suffering the Jags endured from the Wolcott-based raids was largely courtesy of the Ryuken.  Their expertise in these raids paid off for Bird Dog, where the Ryuken company was one of only two recovered intact. (The 1st FS Armored Cavalry's company was the other).

As if I needed another reason to like the Ryuken.

Seriously, the DC has a BUNCH of my favorite units in the setting.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 09 July 2016, 23:11:38
It's a good day to be a Kurita fan... CM:Best House Ever is available!

My sentimental favorite, the 18th Dieron Regulars, got a feature writeup.

It's a good day, indeed.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 10 July 2016, 02:03:30
Loving the new Combat Manual but am I missing something or does the PNT-9ALAG not list a PV?

EDIT: Confirmed that PV is missing and that is 20
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Klat on 10 July 2016, 13:52:01
So, if I'm reading this correctly I could field a reinforced company of nothing but PNT-9ALAGs in order lances. With all units at veteran skill level and lance commanders at elite that comes to 100PV per lance.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Bongfu on 19 July 2016, 01:18:54
So, if I'm reading this correctly I could field a reinforced company of nothing but PNT-9ALAGs in order lances. With all units at veteran skill level and lance commanders at elite that comes to 100PV per lance.

That is actually kind of terrifying.

Good day to be on your side, brother!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 24 July 2016, 05:05:10
So, if I'm reading this correctly I could field a reinforced company of nothing but PNT-9ALAGs in order lances. With all units at veteran skill level and lance commanders at elite that comes to 100PV per lance.

I know nothing of AS but that sounds really good/terrifying, my life for the Dragon!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: glitterboy2098 on 25 July 2016, 16:20:38
So, if I'm reading this correctly I could field a reinforced company of nothing but PNT-9ALAGs in order lances. With all units at veteran skill level and lance commanders at elite that comes to 100PV per lance.
Mercer Ravannion would love it.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 25 July 2016, 16:50:35
Mercer Ravannion would love it.

He'd love the Horde Lances even more ;)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 31 May 2017, 14:20:48
Been a while since this one has been posted in.

I'm looking for ideas for a 6k bv Lance for the DCMS in the late succession wars to take on the local FedRat.

Cheers in advance.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Frogfoot on 31 May 2017, 20:33:08


WVR-7K Wolverine (1331 BV)
BHKU-O Black Hawk-KU (1731 BV)
AV1-OB Avatar (1496 BV)
BL-7-KNT Black Knight (1443)

6001 BV
 
The Wolverine and Black Hawk are your jumping brawlers, the Black Knight is a zombie that presses in to support them, and the Avatar is the LRM fire support. It's not a fast lance but the mobile jumpers can pulse up fast enemies. Lorewise it's one older upgraded Kuritan mech, two cutting edge omnis, and one of the old downgraded SL mechs gifted by ComStar back in the '30s.

If you have to come in under the 6K mark then you can swap the Black Knight for a CTPL-K3 Catapult (uncommon refit from the War of '39) or a Puma A (Smoke Jag salvage) which are both decent long ranged mechs.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 31 May 2017, 21:09:18
I would think the Late Succession War would be pre-Clan Invasion :)
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 01 June 2017, 00:11:48
I'm more of an Alpha Strike player than a Boardgame/CBT player these days, but I certainly support activity in the Kurita fandom thread!

Here's a crack at a <6KBV lance.  All introtech because I'm presuming when Rainbow 6 asked for Late SW era, he meant a pre-Helm/LosTech Renaissance force.

Archer ARC-2K (pilot 3/4) 1871 BV
Dragon DRG-1N (pilot 4/4) 1294 BV
Shadow Hawk SHD-2K (pilot 3/4) 1583 BV
Jenner JR7-D (Pilot 3/4) 1208 BV
Total: 5956 BV

That lance gives you a very Kurita feel.  Archer is your slowpoke at 4/6, but that's ok since Archers are LRM boats.  The -2K variant downgrades the LRMs to still-substantial -15 packs, but the short range firepower is dramatically improved with 2x Large Lasers.  The Dragon and Shadow Hawk are mobile skirmishers with good long range firepower (and in the case of the Dragon, a decent wingman for the Archer if the fight becomes a point blank slugfest).  Of course, the Jenner rounds out the force with a great backstabbing unit.  He can also/alternately be your spotter for the 45 LRM tubes in the rest of the lance!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: JadedFalcon on 01 June 2017, 00:17:51
How about this?

Crusader CRD-3K - 3/4 1780BV
Wolverine WVR-6K - 3/4 1722BV
Grand Dragon DRG-1G - 4/5 1300BV
Jenner JR-7D - 3/4 1207BV
Total: 6,009BV
(The lance is short on hard-hitting guns, but these are mechs I consider "fun" to play. Consider swapping a mech with a Warhammer 6K or a Catapult K2 for more firepower.)

Or how about an order lance?
Grand Dragon DRG-1G - 3/4 1793BV
Grand Dragon DRG-1G - 3/5 1560BV
Grand Dragon DRG-1G - 4/5 1300BV
Grand Dragon DRG-1G - 4/5 1300BV
Total: 5,953BV
(It's like a Lyran wall of steel, but faster! If you want more firepower instead of speed, make an order lance of four Warhammer 6Ks. The same skill values should keep it under 6k BV.)

And the Grand Dragons are void if the game is set before 3024.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kit deSummersville on 01 June 2017, 07:46:28
Here's one:

Akuma AKU-2XK - 4/4 2495 BV
Phoenix Hawk PXH-7K - 4/5 1241 BV
Panther PNT-12A - 3/5 1178 BV
Panther PNT-13K - 4/5 996 BV
Total: 5910

A nice beast in the middle of everything, a sniper to pick at them from the edges and two bouncers that will drive the enemy nuts.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 01 June 2017, 15:07:57
I would think the Late Succession War would be pre-Clan Invasion :)

Very true, here's the MUL list of available mechs http://www.masterunitlist.info/Era/FactionEraDetails?FactionId=27&EraId=256

Thanks for the ideas so far though, making for interesting reading.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kit deSummersville on 01 June 2017, 15:12:40
For some reason I thought it was about 3080. My bad.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Frogfoot on 01 June 2017, 17:44:33
I would think the Late Succession War would be pre-Clan Invasion :)

My mistake, I misread it as Late Civil War


In that case:

Hatamoto-Hi
Guillotine 4L
Grand Dragon 1G
Awesome 8Q

5932 BV

Two Assault bruisers, a jumping brawler and a cavalry skirmisher.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 02 June 2017, 10:24:39
Very true, here's the MUL list of available mechs http://www.masterunitlist.info/Era/FactionEraDetails?FactionId=27&EraId=256

Thanks for the ideas so far though, making for interesting reading.

Since you are interested in LosTech, I'll have to second the suggestion of including a Wolverine-7K.  I agree with those who consider that mech the gold standard for the Inner Sphere in the 3050 era.  Here's another lance built around "What else goes with a 3050 Wolverine?"

Wolverine WVR-7K (pilot 3/5) 1597BV
Charger CGR-3K (4/5) 1656BV
Grand Dragon DRG-5K (4/5) 1358BV
Phoenix Hawk PXH-3K (4/5) 1359BV

You've got a very fast lance where the 5/8/5 are your slowpokes.  You've got some decent LRM and ER Large Laser coverage for long range skirmishing, and oodles of potential when the fight gets close and personal.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 03 June 2017, 09:06:14
Since you are interested in LosTech, I'll have to second the suggestion of including a Wolverine-7K.  I agree with those who consider that mech the gold standard for the Inner Sphere in the 3050 era.  Here's another lance built around "What else goes with a 3050 Wolverine?"

Wolverine WVR-7K (pilot 3/5) 1597BV
Charger CGR-3K (4/5) 1656BV
Grand Dragon DRG-5K (4/5) 1358BV
Phoenix Hawk PXH-3K (4/5) 1359BV

You've got a very fast lance where the 5/8/5 are your slowpokes.  You've got some decent LRM and ER Large Laser coverage for long range skirmishing, and oodles of potential when the fight gets close and personal.

Nice Lance, shame none are available in that era on the MUL.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: VhenRa on 04 June 2017, 02:08:03
Been thinking on Ryuken regiments.

Namely. The destruction of four regiments at Misery... the listings we have of them are the same numbered regiments that exist post-4th SW in War of 3039, 3049, FM: House Kurita and such.

Yet we are missing the first numbered regiment as well.


Its bugging the hell out of me.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jaim Magnus on 04 June 2017, 05:25:55
The First Ryoken was disbanded because of the dishonourable behaviour of its commander, Jerry Akuma. I believe it wasn't reconstituted until the Dark Age.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 03 April 2018, 17:00:33
Hi all, has anyone got a list handy for the mechs we are building in the 3025-3040 period?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: (SMD)MadCow on 03 April 2018, 17:18:00
Here's a good start:

http://www.sarna.net/wiki/Category:Draconis_Combine_BattleMechs

Not era specific and probably needs updating though.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 03 April 2018, 17:29:16
Hi all, has anyone got a list handy for the mechs we are building in the 3025-3040 period?

Well the MUL is the modern tool for answering such questions, and the original sources on House Kurita were written before the House Books began including mech production numbers.  So the MUL is probably the best (indeed only, outside of fandom) resource to tackle that specific timeframe.

The MUL doesn't distinguish between domestic production and wide-spread imports and existing large fleets of chassis surviving from earlier eras when it covers "availability".  However, with some discernment you can fairly easily make an unofficial judgement over what's imported, although current production and historical survivals can be harder to parse.

I'd filter a search based on the Draconis Combine faction only, as opposed to including the general Inner Sphere availability as well.  This should cut out most of the battle salvage circulating back and forth between Houses.  That search for this timeframe can be viewed here (http://masterunitlist.info/Unit/Filter?Name=&HasBV=false&MinTons=&MaxTons=&MinBV=&MaxBV=&MinIntro=&MaxIntro=&MinCost=&MaxCost=&HasRole=&HasBFAbility=&MinPV=&MaxPV=&Role=None+Selected&Types=18&BookAuto=&FactionAuto=&Factions=27&AvailableEras=256).

Personally: on this list I'd say the Wasp-1K, Spider-5K (via retcon), Stinger LAM, all the Jenners, all the Panthers, Sentinel-3K, All the Dragons/Grand Dragons, Lancelot, Catapults, Chargers, Hatamotos, and Maulers are being domestically produced.  Probably lost from the IS general list would be Atlas (@ Altair) and maybe some others.  Post 3039 add Marduk's (http://www.sarna.net/wiki/Victory_Industries) and Quentin's (http://www.sarna.net/wiki/Independence_Weaponry) output.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 04 April 2018, 16:12:13
Cheers, er isn't the Atlas built on Al Na'ir? Along with the Catapult.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 04 April 2018, 18:12:26
Cheers, er isn't the Atlas built on Al Na'ir? Along with the Catapult.

Yeah.  That's why I said the Atlas' absence from the search return (other than the one unique variant) was probably an unintended casualty of subtracting "Inner Sphere General" from the list for availability.  And my bad.. you're right it's Al Na'ir not Altair :)

Anyway when you say you want "production", that's a tricky thing to parse out.  "Avaliability" is broader than that, and that's the currency in which the MUL deals.  Still, it's the best tool for the task at hand... it'd just need some massaging by hand to do exactly what you were asking.  I gave you my own take, and it was by memory.  If you sit down with the list and look at all the sourcebooks (or sarna) you might catch me in a few errors about what'd be domestically produced as opposed to better explained as imports/modified salvage or survivals from earlier Succession Wars.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 05 April 2018, 16:41:08
No worry's bud, think my Feddie buddy and I got it sorted, just need to order 6 more mechs for the full Battalion, choose a regiment and get painting before the first game in a while in a few weeks.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Tai Dai Cultist on 04 August 2018, 18:22:05
The Lair has been hibernating for a good long while, but I'll roust the thread now that Shattered Fortress is available.

I've been waiting for the other shoe to drop since FM/ER3145. 

Now that it has, we came through pretty damn well. Far better than I pessimistically expected.


I've also been waiting for more info about the Hikage regiment ever since the name was given to us with sparse context in TRO:3150.  I wasn't expecting a Kuritan version of the Death Commandos but was honestly kinda pleasantly surprised.  They certainly seem like a fun new unit to fanboi over.  Which is nice, since we've lost so many Legions in recent eras: Night Stalkers, Proserpina Hussars, An Ting, etc...

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 04 August 2018, 22:31:09
Hi all, has anyone got a list handy for the mechs we are building in the 3025-3040 period?

Probably a bit late of a response, but off the top of my head....

I think the following were in production
Locust-1V
Jenner-7D
Panther-9R
And maybe the Wasp-1K or Spider-5V?

Griffin-1N
Wolverine-6R
PhoenixHawk-1K?

Quickdraw-4G
Dragon-1N (+1G)
Archer-2K
Catapult-K2?

Atlas-7D
Charger-1A1


Possibly some others, but I think the above is mostly accurate.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: ThePW on 02 September 2019, 21:01:35
I do apologize for the necromancy, but I cannot find any answers elsewhere (wiki or the actual FM in question, which I lack):

1) What is the special ability (s) for the 1st sword of Light (reference: Field Manual Draconis Combine)

2) based on what is known to have happened to them during the Jihad, would it still be applicable in 3078, specifically during their actions on Terra/Operation SCOUR?

any help would be appreciated.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 02 September 2019, 21:39:40
According to page 147, the 1st Sword of Light (Only a B Equipment rating surprisingly) specialized in night missions, and during the nighttime, they receive +2 initiative modifiers, and do not suffer the +2 to-hit modifier for night fighting.

As to whether or not it would still apply during SCOUR...

FM:3085 on page 189 states that the 1st SOL's unit abilities are that when fighting at night they gain an +2 initiative modifier and ignore all to-hit modifiers for night combat.

Fortunately the 1st SOL was one of the few DCMS units with abilities mentioned in FM:3085, so it seems the nighttime abilities have stuck.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 15 December 2019, 22:03:59
I asked in the Writers section but figured maybe the DC fans could tell me.

Anyone know what happened to the 4th Ghost Regiment?

I can track them in 39 & 50, but they aren't in FM:DC in 3059.

Sarna has them as disbanded but with no source listed.

Any info you can point me to?

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: VhenRa on 16 December 2019, 04:16:39
Combat Manual Kurita says "Disbanded in 3040", presumably they got a big beating during the War of 3039.

Edit: Yeah, checked. 1st and 3rd Battalions listed as [Destroyed] while 2nd Battalion listed as [Heavy Damage]. So about 40% losses to 2nd Battalion and above 60% losses to 1st and 3rd Battalions.

So we have CM K and 20 Year Update saying different things.

Given how 20 Year Update lists a question mark after it's location... I suspect its a case that C* got it wrong and lost track of the unit. Or that the DCMS kept a HQ staff reporting things back that the 4th Ghost is there but its just for signals misinformation.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: TheEmptyRoad on 18 November 2020, 17:33:14
Hello all, brand new player here looking to get started with the Combine. Any recommendations for up-to-date sourcebooks and where I can find them? Anything with the Ryuken and/or Legion of Vega and what they use.

I really like Theodore Kurita and his story, his intrigues are what drew me to the Combine in the first place.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kitsune413 on 18 November 2020, 22:48:05
Hello all, brand new player here looking to get started with the Combine. Any recommendations for up-to-date sourcebooks and where I can find them? Anything with the Ryuken and/or Legion of Vega and what they use.

I really like Theodore Kurita and his story, his intrigues are what drew me to the Combine in the first place.

For up to date sourcebooks you'll probably want the Field Manual 3145. It'll tell you what the regiments are doing to trash the Federated Suns pretty quick and update you on what's going on, mostly. Era Report 3145 doesn't hurt either.

Sadly, Theodore Kurita passed 75 years ago. But if you want to avenge him you can look into the Jihad era sourcebooks.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Mecha82 on 19 November 2020, 10:51:12
Hello all, brand new player here looking to get started with the Combine. Any recommendations for up-to-date sourcebooks and where I can find them? Anything with the Ryuken and/or Legion of Vega and what they use.

I really like Theodore Kurita and his story, his intrigues are what drew me to the Combine in the first place.

Current Coordinator is Yori Kurita and way I have understood she is more like Coordinators before Theodore Kurita. Granted those who put her on throne thought that they could use her as puppet but turned out that she is more than they can handle.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Metallgewitter on 20 November 2020, 06:16:10
Yori doesn't seem to be like older Coordinators. I mean she kept the organisation of the actual DCMS which tries to balance the importance of Mechwarriors and the "lesser" branches and she also keeps the tolerance towards the Ghosts and Azami. Then again she belongs to Theodore's line (just a bastard branch) so I would assume she is smart enough to keep the reforms of Theodore. Let's just wait how her Gunjo no Kanrei acts in the Iclan era. Maybe he wants to rebel or gets booted
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jellico on 24 April 2021, 16:56:32
Trying to get info for a game.

When after 3145 did the 1st Genyosha leave Lambrecht?

Arigatō.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 25 April 2021, 04:29:36
Interesting that LAW are able to build the Griffin IIC 9 on Luthien.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 02 August 2021, 15:49:32
How widespread is C3 master/slave network usage within the DCMS by 3150?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: MarauderD on 02 August 2021, 15:54:11
How widespread is C3 master/slave network usage within the DCMS by 3150?

I always wondered if they were still using it at all or just using Boosted C3, if there are enough variants that use the newer system.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 02 August 2021, 15:59:21
I always wondered if they were still using it at all or just using Boosted C3, if there are enough variants that use the newer system.

Not even sure the DCMS makes use of the system any more, let alone Boosted C3, that seems more an AFFS thing to be honest.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Maelwys on 03 August 2021, 20:29:09
They've got some. Not alot mind you, but some designs are relatively recent (3140s) that have boosted c3 tech on them.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: bobthecoward on 12 August 2021, 08:09:10
Why did the people of the rasalhague planets dislike the Combine so much when the coordinator was Rasalhague nobility? Rasalhague nobility ruled the Combine for 500 years
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Elmoth on 12 August 2021, 17:35:51
Because, space Vikings supposedly do not fit with James Bond Evil-level space samurai.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 21 September 2022, 15:25:06
Wow, this thread has died.

Where are all the Samurai at?


So I have a question for the DC Fans.

I don't own FM:DC but I'm wondering about Conventional Forces for the DC.

Specifically, these Combat Orgs.

Sword of Light
Ryuken
Dieron Regulars

I'm wondering which of the 3 are larger users of attached Vees/Infantry/ASF.

Basically I'm just deciding what scheme to paint up my Combine NON-Mech forces.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Gorgon on 21 September 2022, 15:32:23
AFAIK most (all?) DCMS formations attach conventional forces more on an ad-hoc base and don't integrate them into the parent formations (at least pre-Dark Age). I think the Ryuken are an exception to that.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 21 September 2022, 16:01:17
Sword Of Light specifically doesnt have permanently attached support elements, aside from the 2nd.

Ryuken regiments do have permanently attatched combined arms support.

The Dieron Regulars also seem to have attatched support.

The Sarna Military Commands Page shows all kinds of unit breakdowns by year, with sources. Its my first look, and then I go into the sources if I have them
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: BrianDavion on 21 September 2022, 23:16:48
Why did the people of the rasalhague planets dislike the Combine so much when the coordinator was Rasalhague nobility? Rasalhague nobility ruled the Combine for 500 years

that doesn't mean they're going to support the central government
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: GoGo Yubari on 22 September 2022, 01:20:39
In the earlier books, the 'Mech units were noted as working in isolation from the other forces as they considered them beneath them. So in the early period truly mixed units might have been a true rarity, actually. As said the 2nd SOL is noted for its support elements (but is an exception that proves the rule). The Ryuken, however, are built on the Wolf's Dragoons combined arms model and represent a new (and successful) way of doing things. This then has an opportunity to spread around with Theodore's renovations and I don't think it's that rare for modern Kurita units to be combined arms or at least work closely with attached support elements. 
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 22 September 2022, 02:03:58
I’m looking at the CM:Kurita now.

SoL only have aero as listed support. The blurb on the all but the 2ndmentions conventional support is as needed. There is no mention of permanently attached in the ToE, only the blurb for the 2nd. I would assume it is drawn locally (which would only make them look down further on them, as local militas are not often well trained). Plus their roving, quick response nature makes it hard to keep vees around.

All the Dieron Regular regiments are listed with armor and infantry support along with aeros. The armored and/or infantry segments are mentioned in the blurbs, lending credence to the idea they are permanently attached. As kinda garrison/trooper regiments this makes sense.

The Ryuken as noted took the combined arms idea from the Dragoons. Their blurbs and ToEs both have armor/infantry/aero listed.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 22 September 2022, 22:01:18
Thanks all!

So big red tanks is a no-go for sure.

Which is fine by me, since I'm not actually a fan of that scheme.

Probably go Ryuken since the Dieron parade scheme is far too much like C* for me.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Kerfuffin(925) on 23 September 2022, 00:04:29
My Drac unit is Ryuken-roku also.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Hellraiser on 23 September 2022, 00:45:38
My Drac unit is Ryuken-roku also.

Oh for my whole "painting project" there are several lances.

SoL
Dir Reg
Ben Reg
Ryuken-Ni
SZ Academy Cadre

With more than 2 regiments of mechs, I have a project give each house a full company of mechs in 1 scheme & then several other lances.
And the Company will also get any other Conventional assets as well.
I just hadn't figured out who my DC "Company" will be.

Fitting if it's Ryuken as that was the first DC Lance I ever did many eons ago.
So now I'm thinking I'll add to it & make it the main unit of my DC minis.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: tassa_kay on 23 September 2022, 11:07:37
Why did the people of the rasalhague planets dislike the Combine so much when the coordinator was Rasalhague nobility? Rasalhague nobility ruled the Combine for 500 years

Because the Combine ruthlessly repressed them like they do damn near everyone they conquer? Is this a trick question?!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 27 December 2022, 07:27:10
Because the Combine ruthlessly repressed them like they do damn near everyone they conquer? Is this a trick question?!

Makes you wonder if they should have treated Rasalhague like the Azami, might have led to a better outcome.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Metallgewitter on 27 December 2022, 07:53:23
Makes you wonder if they should have treated Rasalhague like the Azami, might have led to a better outcome.

Interesting that the Azami have more autonomy then the Rasalhaguerians despite the fact that the Azami have a way smaller part of the Combine. Or it was more the fact that the worlds of the now Rasalhague Republic / Dominion are more valuable then the Azami worlds
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Jellico on 27 December 2022, 08:39:06
Because the Combine ruthlessly repressed them like they do damn near everyone they conquer? Is this a trick question?!

Have you ever checked out just how big the Principality of Rasalhague was when the Combine vassaled em? "Rasalhague" expanded massively under the governorship of the Draconis Combine. When Martin McAllister came crawling to Blaine Sorenson in 2494 the, the Sorenson went full in supporting the Kuritas despite killing cadet branches fifty years before. After that Rasalhague was considered such a core part of the Combine that it provided spouses for Coordinators and was central to court intrigue.

All of which is to say, Rasalhague's relationship with the Combine is complicated. For every uprising there was corresponding wealth and power. There are times the lady protests too much.

Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: BrianDavion on 27 December 2022, 18:19:43
If you think you're oppressed thats all that matters, Rassalhuage would hardly be the first large minority region that recrived arguably preferential treatment, that decides they;re oppressed.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: tassa_kay on 27 December 2022, 18:57:11
If you think you're oppressed thats all that matters, Rassalhuage would hardly be the first large minority region that recrived arguably preferential treatment, that decides they;re oppressed.

I didn't realize that "receiving arguably preferential treatment" and "being oppressed by a larger majority" were mutually exclusive. It's like saying that it's okay to keep slaves as long as you treat them better than everyone else that keeps slaves. Ridiculous. This entire statement reads like a Breitbart comment.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Metallgewitter on 31 August 2023, 05:46:03
Sorry for necroing this thread but does anyone know what happened to Katana Tormark? Era report 3145 has her locked up on Luthien (at least that was the assumption from Republic intelligence). Do you think she might still be alive? Or was she as the book suggest quietly executed? And if she is alive you think she might get a return? Perhaps sending her on a suicide mission to "regain her honor"? Then again Yori probably doesn't want to elevate someone who was actively waging war against her again to any position of influence.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Church14 on 31 August 2023, 09:06:02
I haven’t read much about Yori, so I won’t be surprised if I have this wrong:

Given the combine, I’m inclined to say interrogated until she had nothing left, then dumped in unmarked grave. That fits that Yori Kurita seems to prefer her enemies dead in a way that stops the next fight before it occurs. The concerns about Katana becoming a martyr seem on point, so a quiet permanent solution feels in order.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Rainbow 6 on 11 November 2023, 12:04:43
If Yori's smart she's in an unmarked grave somewhere on Luthien, if not it wouldn't surprise me if she ended up leading the Legion of Vega (or at least a regiment of it) at some point given they are back to being the dumping ground for the DCMS.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: The Wobbly Guy on 22 March 2024, 09:55:23
Looks like I'm necro-ing this thread after it's been dormant for months.

I was reading an article which mentioned the Sanshu no Jingi/Mikusa no Kamudakara/Imperial Regalia of Japan and how important it was as a symbol of the ruling line's authority and lineage from Amaterasu, the sun goddess.

So... did the Kuritas (avid cosplayers that they were) ever consider trying to get their hands on the three sacred items, and get the blood of Amaterasu (some female scion of the Japanese Emperor) into their own House?

Heck, does the Japanese Royal Family still exist at all after the Exodus era?

All these can make for an intriguing RPG adventure. Throw in Nova Cats, Goliath Scorpions, Comstar, Word of Blake, and it can be a rollicking saga for the ages!
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: Metallgewitter on 23 March 2024, 06:02:56
Heck, does the Japanese Royal Family still exist at all after the Exodus era?

All these can make for an intriguing RPG adventure. Throw in Nova Cats, Goliath Scorpions, Comstar, Word of Blake, and it can be a rollicking saga for the ages!

The Royal family of Japan should have been alive when the Exodus happened. While amaris forces took them hostage to ensure a means of escape the SLDf didn't budge. According to Vol 2 of the Battle for Terra book the 19 year old daughter of the then current head was killed but the rest of the family was saved by the SLDF. Of course what happened then is anyones guess. I would bet that the royal family of Japan still lived when the Republic took over unless told otherwise. And not to forget the Clans didn't conquer Japan.
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: The Wobbly Guy on 23 March 2024, 11:56:26
Quote
According to Vol 2 of the Battle for Terra book the 19 year old daughter of the then current head was killed but the rest of the family was saved by the SLDF.

Hmm... the book stated 'Duke Naruhito, the noble leader of the Japanese District'. Would the Japanese Royals have willingly demoted their status down to Dukes in the face of the Director-General Camerons?

I also wonder if the Kuritas ever tried to bring in Japanese imperial blood into their own House, particularly during the Star League era when it was presumably easier to do so.

And, it would also add further legitimacy to their own status, because new money also sought out old money for the affirmation of status it brings.

Finally, the regalia themselves... did the Kuritas ever consider taking them?
Title: Re: The Dragon's Lair
Post by: tassa_kay on 23 March 2024, 14:29:36
Would it add legitimacy for the Kuritas? Would the Kuritas even care about the old imperial family? They aren't claiming to be descended from them, and most nobility in the Inner Sphere has a marked disinterest in pre-spaceflight Terra. At best, I can see them collecting those things as quaint trinkets/antiques, but I don't think they'd have any importance to them beyond that.