How about the Gürteltier Main Battle Tank or the ye old Challenger Main Battle Tanks?
Sure
Heavy Tanks – An Endangered Species or on the verge of Evolution?
Prepared by MI2 Station New Avalon for First Prince Peter Steiner Davion, 3072MI2 has completed its analysis of the lessons learned during the Jihad particularly those concerning the use of armored vehicles over sixty-five metric tons on the modern battlefield.
The Jihad saw the proliferation of numerous high-tech pieces of equipment to our adversaries particularly within the Trinity Alliance who have rapidly evolved to be our peers in conventional warfare. Our edge in Battlemech, Armored Infantry, and Aerospace technologies allow us to maintain an overmatch capacity. However, more and more reports appear on our desks concerning Word of Blake defectors working throughout the Trinity Alliance but particularly in the Shengli Arms facility. If the Capellan Confederation can deploy Blakist technology in quantity, they will pose an incredible danger to the AFFS.
Since they are our most pressing adversary, we will begin with a quick threat assessment of a modern Trinity Alliance Combined Forces. Although not the most mech heavy formation their infantry are without peer in the Inner Sphere heavily equipped with top notch armor or sneak suits and portable SRM launchers that can be loaded with either an Armor-Piercing Tandem or the Anti-Material Inferno warhead. Either of these can disable or destroy an armored vehicle if aimed properly and even the basic HE round is sufficient if used in enough quantity.
TACF deploys numerous organic AA Vehicles and Flak Artillery particularly in their mechanized regiments and deploys Anti-Air Arrow IV missiles with the Battlemech and Armored Corps. Kuan-Yin’s St Ives Compact has also given the TACF access to our own standard issue Federated Barrett rifle system which is now manufactured throughout Alliance territory. This serves to negate some of our current advantage and lessons learned from THUNDERSTRIKE have revealed severe deficiencies in our conventional units.
Although the Post-REVIVAL arms research spree enabled us to survive the Jihad well enough to stand on our we do so shakily. The Clans maintain the edge on Omnimech production as they always have but have now enlisted the Second Star League to provide support to their front-line elite Warrior caste. We have no such advantage, but we do have one of the most advanced and second largest standing army in the Inner Sphere after the SLDF.
These advances have been costly however and attrition has sapped our elite units of their premier equipment as surely as enemy fire. While the treasury didn’t burn down the economy will take time to recover from the war footing it had been on for the past five years. Nobles are restless and the enemy is biding their time to strike once more. We will have to be ready to counter the TACF rather than the Clans as we anticipated. Doing so will require a major reorganization of armored vehicle procurement.
Assessment of current Assault TanksAjax – Designed along the same paradigms of our own Challenger X the modern Ajax is a highly capable omni-vehicle that served as a frequent and persistent adversary in the hands of the Word of Blake. Modern versions drop some of the weapons to mount hardened armor to counter TC SRMs in the hands of TACF supported guerillas in the Border Territories. The inclusion of an Ultra AC/10 in the base model has been widely derided and we have begun to see more equipped with a PPC to support the Gauss Rifle with the medium pulse lasers often exchanged for an MML.
Alacorn – In the hands of a good gunner the Alacorn is a major threat to any adversary on the modern battlefield. With good range, decent mobility, and incredible firepower its biggest threat remains the same as any other armored vehicle. Snakes, Toras, and other fast medium mechs with LBX autocannons that might be able to close with and disable it with a side hit.
Carnivore – The standard Clan assault tank the Carnivore is a no-nonsense design spawned from the mind of a no nonsense late ilKhan. Its two Gauss Rifles and pair of cERMLs tear into enemy armor as it cruises along at a very fast speed for its size. Fortunately for us it is incredibly expensive and thus the line doesn’t produce many each year as the Council itself must judiciously balance their own resources against those they are willing to commit to the SLDF.
Challenger – Once the pride of the AFFS the Challenger X is beginning to show signs of its age. Although even the earliest are still viable designs improvements in the Silver Bullet Gauss Rifle have seen its inclusion in the latest XII model as the threat of enemy Aerospace grows with the Snow Ravens in the Outworlds Alliance.
Gurtlier (Modified, -20 ton, only 12M CB vs 20M CB) – Built to compliment the Patton and Rommel tanks of the LCAF the Gurtlier (or Armadillo) is an 80 tonner that desperately wants to be an MBT, equipped with a Gauss Rifle, ERPPC, and MML/7 it has impressive firepower and like the Tedate manufactured in the DCMS comes stock with a bulldozer blade meant to protect its motive systems from damage. Unlike the Behemoth however it concentrates its heavy ferro fibrous armor into its turret rather than keeping it spread out.
Mars (Slightly modified 90 ton) – The Mars is what happens when a Behemoth and Sturmfeur have babies, 45 LRM tubes are arrayed along its back facing forward under the guidance control of an Artemis IV module while the turret is equipped with a cERLL, AMS, and LBX-10. Stream SRM6s are mounted alongside to catch fast movers while a ECM unit can provide some defense utilizing ghost targets or be swapped out for an Active Probe to search for ambushes. This lumbering engine of destruction is commonly used to break up enemy formations in support of Armored Infantry as it can move scarcely faster than an Elemental can jump.
Morrigu – Although not perfectly optimized as it mounts two cERLLs forcing additional mass to be devoted to heat sinks the Morrigu’s two LRM15s and in modern versions waist mounted AP Gauss Rifle are capable of severely damaging any foe unlucky enough to be in their long range.
Schreck – Much like the Morrigu the Schreck is a combat vehicle that has a deservedly stellar reputation. However, its inequities have been laid bare more than once over the Jihad as its weak armor made it susceptible to enemy attack and easy destruction. This has forced designers to replace the central PPC with a Rotary AC/2 and use the leftover mass to almost double its armor protection at a slight loss in throw weight.
Ontos – The modern Ontos comes in two varieties each of which serve principally in the FLWM and their SLDF allies. The first and newest is basically the Light Gauss equivalent of an Alacorn but unfortunately suffers from the same deficiency as the base Schreck as its 9.5 tons of HFF armor is not sturdy enough to take abuse. However, with the Light Gauss Rifle’s incredible range one could argue it can attack and possible fight off an enemy before they close within effective range. The second is the tank equivalent of a modern Longbow with 2xLRM20s and 2xLRM10s but much cheaper at a mere 3.1M CB as it uses an older ICE engine. Both are typically used to provide heavy firepower to the FLWMs slower Mechanized Infantry units rather than engage Battlemechs with their thin armor.
Partisan – The Partisan AA tank has been a mainstay of installation defense for decades and provides steady fire support when on the offensive. Modern Partisans use slightly lighter fuel cell engines to add two more tons of ammo, extra armor, and CASE to the design at the cost of the defensive machine guns. Doing so does add to their price however with the modern Partisan costing almost twice as much as its ICE powered predecessor. That said the extra armor, ammo, and CASE will likely improve survivability.
Tedate (Modified Behemoth)– The DCMS reconfigured the New Samarkand Metal’s Behemoth lines to produce the Tedate which might be the first sign of an evolution in assault tanks. Rather than pretend to be a MBT that can keep up with the faster Battlemechs of our modern era the Tedate is designed to use its frontal bulldozer blade to scratch out hull down positions where it can use its paired Gauss Rifles, Light PPCs, and AMS to best effect while protecting what little mobility it posesses. Smoke Grenades, Magshots, and B-Pods protect its flanks from hostile Armored Infantry attack.
Apparent Trends Post-JihadModern Assault tanks like MBTs have consolidated their unfocused weapons groupings to a more sensible arrangement. The added survivability of bulldozer made hull-down positions is certainly enticing for many crews and their ability to make trenches will support the infantry they often work with. The cost in mass and lost firepower are equally minimal particularly on these heavier vehicles. Like most other thanks they have lost their Anti-Personnel weapons trading out machine guns for Magshots that can more respectably damage the more numerous every year Armored Infantry at range. Mechanized Infantry those troops can take the Anti-Personnel role away from the heavier platform allowing more specialized and optimized designs more suited to anti-vehicle warfare. While the use of Heavy Ferro-Fibrous armored composites is more widespread in the MBT category Hardened armor is an increasingly popular option at this edge of the mass range as a single TC costing only a few thousand CB can disable a 90-ton 12M CB tank.
Final ThoughtsWhile there will always be a need for these assault tanks they will likely continue to be under pressure from improved munitions. That said I personally think that the assault tank is an endangered species costing to much money and resources that could be put toward more versatile MBTs just as the proliferation of Clantech distinctly threatens the Assault Mech more than a Medium.