Feenix,
Try Chicago. Games Plus, in Mount Prospect, Illinois. It's like game shops were back in the 1980s, except it has playing areas too. I drooled.
Yes, a bit out of our usual way, but I also got the opportunity to meet and play with WolfReaper, GreyWolfActual, OrangeWoman, GreatSarcasmo, and a bunch of other forumites.
(Having a company office in Libertyville helps ... still angling for another junket ;) )