@gyedid.
I don't have any problem with Smith's Doctor. I liked him, I think he is fantastic. Just like all of the ones before him. I just don't think he had many good stories to support him. That and I just got annoyed with Moffet bashing us over the head with melodrama. I mean, seriously, how many times did Amy or Rory die? A companions death should be a major thing. Look at Adric's. Or Donna's (I know, I know). But by the time they finally did leave, I have to be honest and say I was relieved to finally see them go.
I can't speak for anyone else, but it's not a problem with Smith for me...just with the writing of the stories he had during his tenure. I don't know...can't really explain how I feel about them. It's like...Moffet tried to make everything far too epic and every episode a blockbuster, and they simply collapsed from the weight. To me at least, the best stories of those series are the small ones.
Actually...I think that was a great way for Tennant to go out. Because that fit his character. He was petulant and immature. People forget that. But it does show though at times. One of the biggest is the way he treated Martha. He was basically just leading her on...
Though I will say Eccleston wouldn't have been so quick to fight and kill as Smith was.
(By the way, my favorite Doctor is Sylvester McCoy.
And your link doesn't work.
