They had the 2nd largest in the Clans before the invasion after it well it kind of fell apart piece by piece
The Nova Cats biggest naval problem was 2 fold first it was a Cruiser navy (nothing bigger than a Black Lion)
2nd they didn't have a portable shipyard
The Trial of Possession for the Rasalhague ripped the heart out of the navy and then the Jihad finished it off
What the Nova Cats needed was to capture or trade for a Faslane and win the Rasalhague trial if they'd done those 2 things the Combine might have thought twice and the Nova Cats could have probably moved to the Republic
Unfortunately the Jihad sunk any such hope as WarShips were lined up and sunk in glorious fashion. Honestly I didn't mind that it was that the infrastructure was never rebuilt
Even post jihad a decent pocket warship would have been good for the Cats and stopped Irece from happening so easily
Yeah, it's really hard to say and I think we just don't have enough information, as in all things Nova Cat. First, we had a pretty large navy all things considered, even if they weren't McKenna class WarShips. But I would argue, second, the Nova Cats always prided aerospace assets, so high maneuverability WarShips may have been a good thing. (It has *always* baffled me that Khan Leroux, one of the greatest aerospace jockies the Clans ever produced, constantly bid away his aerospace).
Agreed on the portable shipyard - but as I have argued earlier - we really have no idea how much we lost once the Abjuration was declared. How much we couldn't bring with us to the IS. The Ghost Bears had WAAAAAAYYYY more time to relocate to the IS than we did, and under much less stressful conditions. Hence, orbital shipyards. And the Kuritans weren't about to give us anything. We were a speedbump for the Combine, as later proved out. (If I am not mistaken, Minoru complains to Omiko, who complains to Victor, about how the Nova Cats are being treated unfairly immediately after relocating).
To be honest, the descriptions of New Barcella in
Path of Glory kind of shocked me with how much the Cats were able to rescue and rebuild from the Homeworlds in so little time. Until I understood how much the Bears were able to bring with them to Rasalhague. Post-Abjuration, the Cats were always set up for failure. The fact that we were able to be as resilient and honorable as we were afterward is a testament to our people.
As usual - to put it in an old Terran dialect: "We done gots ourselves screwed". So I suppose we agree, although I think the Cats never had a chance, through no fault of our own to do what's right and be good at doing it.