There were a lot of interesting things to glean from the story in Shrapnel. I hesitate to describe them in detail but it's a good read. Bidding practices of the trial were certainly one of these along with the formation used by Smythe-Jewel. If the Kindraa had justified its actions by that new grouping alone I might go for their creative excuse but other deceptive practices in the bid and during combat were beyond the pale for me. Final comment; the result of this story I will annoyingly say again by the letter of Clan law was not technically an annihilation but an absorption with a dash of reaving. Well maybe more than a dash.
I also found the Smythe-Jewel deception (I'll have to admit, my previous readings of the Death of the Kindraa suggested to me that their twisting of the formations was more subtle) far beyond what I thought any group of Clanners, especially in those Golden Century years, would stoop to. Sure, the swapping of "bidded" formations with Payne's I can see being tolerated, and the
business with the misidentification of solahma I can also see being allowed.
Especially when supported by the juicy exchange between Smythe and Jewel:
TJ: "Star Colonel...the bid. You told the Horse[']s Khan he would face two Trinaries of solahma. We have no such troops. That was a lie."
WS: "Hardly Tomas Jewel. You and your warriors have served the Kindraa for a few years, quiaff?. You yourself are nearly twenty-five. How many warriors have been decanted since you passed your Trial of Position? I believe your Trinaries should be called solahma
....
WS: "Perhaps the status of you and your warriors would rapidly change, were you to find victory here?" But the sheer gall of
doubling Trinaries feels farfetched. Then when you consider that apparently Smythe-Jewel used the same deceptive bidding practices against the Coyotes, even the in-story rationale - the fact that the horses field two-to-a-point vehicle Stars, and five-per-point Battle Armour - falls apart, as the Coyotes would (presumably) have fielded neither of these formations. Not sure about the vehicles, but certainly not the BA.
Maybe this sets us up for a truly heroic oral defence in the Grand Council by Smythe-Jewel where they managed to mongoose out of their predicament? Looking forward to the see how the author navigates the next steps.
While it was, the first move the Horses made post-Trial was to push for a Trial of Annihilation against the Mandrills as a whole; it's only after the Grand Council shut this down that they and the Coyotes went for the aggressive absorption instead.
Fascinatingly, the Grants are one of the few examples that can be pointed at for a post-founding, pre-Invasion Kindraa evolution. The very strong implication in FM:CC is that Grant Bloodheritages were originally exclusively held by Kindraa Smythe-Jewel; as such, during the time of the Kindraa's destruction, the Beyls were likely their own independent Kindraa.
The Beyl capture of multiple Grant Bloodheritages seems to have been the move that finally give the Bloodhouse room to gain power and influence. They could not have had much within Kindraa Smythe-Jewel---it was not Kindraa Smythe-Jewel-Grant, after all---but joining a Kindraa with mostly aerospace lineages could have allowed them to carve a strong place for themselves.
A little embarrassed to say that I'd never made the connection between the Grant legacies Smythe-Jewel lost and Beyl-Grant.
That's right, there was a third Kindraa that scooped up some remains, thank you for correcting that.
Yes, I had similar thoughts as I was reading the Beyl-Grant fluff last night -- internal dynamics like that are exactly what make the Fire Mandrills so fascinating.
Kindraa politics related to the Bloodhouses seems like it might be fertile ground for more Clan fiction, with the added benefit of getting us a deeper look in to culture of Bloodhouses. The sourcebooks don't seem to delve to deep into them. Are there particular novels/fiction you all are familiar with that get into them?
I wonder what the fourteen original Kindraa of the Mandrills was to begin with? We only know of eight... likely the remaining six were some of the remaining exclusive or more famous of the Mandrill Bloodnames. Jannik and Lynn have really not been expounded on too much. Other candidates out there??
If Jannik's ever been mentioned I've missed it entirely. If you all have found any references, I'd love to know where. Lynn, I
think has a little more support. Suu Lynn gifts us with an awesome, very "Mandrill" quote in Historical: Operation KLONDIKE:
"We will fight for honour and for glory, knowing that we may be mere mortal, but our legacy will last forever. We may perish, but our children will not be robbed of their very lives because of it" and I believe shows up in the Beyl-Grant TO&E, and Mattila-Carrol descriptions.
There definitely is an advantage to obscuring the precise composition of the earlier Kindraa and keeping a few lines more mysterious though. Great fodder for fan-created Kindraa!