***Before reading; my intent is not to offend or upset. This is just *MY* uneducated take on how I think the Clans might develop, set in my Der Tag AU.
This work deals with mature themes, but aims to do so respectfully of a reader's real lived experiences, at arm's length and without detail. The following subjects are mentioned, but not described:
-Various forms of abuse, particularly of children and subordinates
-Incest
-Sexuality
These themes are not the focus of the work, but are touched on briefly. This work was written with the rules of the forum and the standards of the setting in mind.
While the Clans are far from the focus of the events of Der Tag and what come after, they are important to the setting and the overall picture I'm painting.
With that in mind, I hope you enjoy. I've re-written this about four times so far and I hope that the effort shows through, if nothing else.
Contemporary Anthropology 301
Excerpts from Main Study Text by Professor Francesca Utewoman and Doctors H.J. Kern & K.K. Mutsu
This edition first published 3263, New Avalon Press
Chapter 4: The Clans; Later Development 3060 to the mid 3090s
In previous chapters, we have covered the unique conditions that created and shaped Clan culture, initially (Ch 2) and how that culture evolved up to the time of the invasion and beyond (Ch 3).
Here, we shall now discuss the development of the Clans from the later invasion-period up to the finalization of their balkanization, which was complete by the mid 3090s.
From the early 3060s, onwards, the previously well-insulated Clan society and culture were forced to begin to adapt to the influences of the Spheroid and to a much lesser extent; Periphery peoples they encountered or face increasing mal-adaptation to the realities of the wider human environment they now found themselves inextricably mired in. Though many would try; no Clan possessed the wherewithal to entirely realize an adaptation of their occupation zones to their own culture.
Expansion of Clan holdings relieved the real restrictions on resources which had done so much to shape Clan society to this point; although in many cases, these remained apparent for some time after they had been relieved, simply as a cultural milieu.
Increased contact by Warriors and lower castes with disparate cultures forced them to question many of the aspects of the Clan society which they had been born into.
In addition; it was during the 3060s that the results of internal pressures, left simmering for some time, came to the forefront with the inauguration of the Clan Civil War; consummate as it was with the revelation of the secret, multi-Clan "Society" controlled by a not insignificant faction of the combined Scientist Castes.
While the Invading Clans, the expatriate diaspora and the new class of "Petitioners" would react differently to these influences; members of the various Castes were faced with a similar set of pressures, even in the Home Worlds where second-hand contact through the Invaders had spread knowledge of human civilization beyond the Clans through the castes, despite the best efforts of their leaders to prevent this.
Proliferation of resources and the quite apparent need for expansion all but eliminated the artificial cultural taboos associated with expansion of the Touman and the general population which supported it. Far removed from the Pentagon Wars and faced with a hostile Inner Sphere, there remained little to argue against for expansion past the traditional limits enforced by the Grand Council to avoid arms races and wasted resources. Even those Clans without Occupation Zones to worry over, still had to contend with the greater assets the Invading Clans could potentially bring to bear in the homeworlds.
While the threat of destabilization remained, it was subject to open debate whether or not the state of the known galaxy in fact mandated a different approach to the founding ideals of competition and social Darwinism baked into the Clans by Nicholas Kerensky.
This left many to ask if the issue of an IlClan might not be decided as much by the simple metric of "last Clan standing", or even the less extreme recognition by the other Clans of an unquestioned leader amongst their people to direct them forward as an alternative to ultimate conquest. Certainly, the whole seemed to suffer from the lack a single pre-eminence to lead them.
This, in turn led to serious questions regarding the practicality of the Invasion itself and speculation amongst Warriors, Merchants and Labourers as to just what it might take to at least conquer Terra, if not the entire Inner Sphere, given the experiences of the invasion so-far and first-hand observations of Spheroid capabilities.
Warriors and the leaders amongst them were forced to ask questions far outside their expertise and purview; to ask these questions of other castes, even. For the first time in a century; it was becoming common for Clan Warriors to actively engage in *study* in order to understand principles of war, leadership, organization and empire long forgotten or discarded as "Un-clan-like" and not just hone their personal warrior's skills. Some argued there might even be a paradelle to the “Samurai-Bureaucrat” of ancient Japanese history on the horizon for the Warriors if they were to remain the true leaders of Clan society.
Critics rightly point out, however that in light of the stated goals of the Clans, pre-Operation: REVIVAL, this was almost certainly much too little and far too late.
In dark corners, some even dared ask if any kind of final victory could be considered un-Clan-like? Or put another way; would a final victory and state of stability in and of itself be against or even a threat to the Way of The Clans?
An interconnected issue was that of agism.
As resources had become more available and the needs of the Touman greater, the pressures to clear the way for the Ristars and conserve resources by relegating older warriors to lesser and lesser responsibilities seemed, in direct contrast to earlier measures and mores; wasteful.
Increasingly during the fighting in the Inner Sphere, it had been coolly observed by all parties that the Clans discarded their many of their surviving warriors just as their skills and experience were reaching their apogee in order to clear the way for new, but less-accomplished generations. While the Trueborn, particularly started off their careers more capable than their Spheroid opponents; these gaps narrowed and then reversed when age and experience were counted. A Trueborn's advantage was when they faced a spheroid of comparable age and with as much prior experience prior to meeting their first spheroid combatant as possible to maximise the skill-advantage of the Clan breeding program.
Facing warriors of greater age and experience placed Clansmen at first a reduced advantage and then a deficit. As those same Clan Warriors grew older and accumulated additional combat experience, they would be discarded or relegated to less-active roles in the fighting. This while Spheroid combat experience created a feedback-loop that didn't begin to fall-off until the late 40s or early 50s in age.
The natural dichotomy in the Clan Warrior's ultimate goal of a glorious death in battle with the Spheroid goal of survival had its own part to play as well and only those Clan warriors with the greatest self-control could expect to live long enough to accumulate extensive combat experience.
A willingness to learn from the older and more experienced among them ensured an ongoing tutelage for the seasoning of the inferior Spheroid Warrior. This culminated in the survivors progressing as a battle-hardened, experienced and well-honed force which grew and improved over time if not destroyed to the last warrior or at least severely crippled.
In place of these factors; the Clans held true only to the principle of youth in command; prizing raw daring, aggression and bloody-mindedness over more-tempered virtues.
Over time, it had increasingly proven an uneven contest, especially when faced with equipment of peer or near-peer quality. As the invasion had worn on, particularly through the Coventry Offensive and then later in the Ghost Bear-Combine war, it was found that a Spheroid force that ought to have been easily overcome proved a more difficult opponent or even a fair match to a Clan force which ought to have been their masters in battle. Once the bidding process was factored in, the Clans typically fought at a self-imposed handicap and a measure aimed at conserving resources, instead came to waste them.
One noted exception to all this were Elementals, who have consistently remained the pound-for-pound masters of their opponents for the entirety of Clan warfare against non-Clan enemies. Note here, however; the vast comparative sink of resources of the entire Elemental program, their often-short active careers and typically rapid decline in health due to compounding medical issues later in life.
While many chose to cleave to the old ways, there were enough open and unconventional minds around at the time that the Chatterweb and even the Grand Councils of the 60s became a frequent host to debates on the status of Solahma troops and the necessity or wastefulness of the Clan's bedrock agist policies and culture.
By the early 60s there was already evident pressure and broad-based interest in change, with the strict traditionalists in the minority in the senior ranks of the Clans at that time.
This was then a very vulnerable time for Clan culture as a whole and while there can never said to be a "Good Time" to discover that your entire grand socio-political structure has been undermined and manipulated by a subservient underclass, the 3060s might arguably have been said to be the worst time for such to happen.
To attempt to summarize such a ground-shaking event as the Clan Civil War, let alone the Purity Wars that followed immediately after would be folly and is a subject best left to military historians and political scientists. As we in the study of anthropology are only distantly interested in these things as they relate to our own study, I shall touch on the subject only briefly.*
*Note, however that as we are treating as true a “Warrior” culture as has ever existed in human history, extensive digressions into military subjects may be unavoidable. Prospective scholars are advised to retain your dedication to higher pursuits and salve your minds with the promise of a speedy return to more important and interesting subject matter at the completion of this unit. Academic advisors best serve their charges by heeding faculty suggestions of a “padded” term wherever The Clans are concerned; a healthy add-mixture of such topics as Exituri Art appreciation and Neo-Mennonite cultural practices will be of aid to healthy, eager minds.
In short; a vast conspiracy had been discovered amongst the Scientist Castes of many Clans. Their goal was to over-throw the warriors and institute a technocratic rulership of the wise over the bombastic warriors who had been installed over them. They were in the process of building their own private army, including the use of proscribed techniques to do so and it was initially unclear to what extent the conspiracy involved the entire scientist caste of all the Clans.
It was ultimately by only the narrowest of possible margins that the Clans did not choose to collectively purge their scientist castes, but they did inaugurate a massive internecine conflict with the goal of rooting this "Society" out by whatever means necessary.
The Clan Civil War saw flags, loyalties and factions shifting almost daily and extended it's reach from the farthest-flung of the homeworld-colonies to the most distant extant enclaves of the Occupation Zones and indeed; well beyond.
The demarcation between the Clan Civil Wars and the Purity Wars that followed is fiercely debated in its exact position on the timeline of humanities countless conflicts. But it is generally agreed as being the point when the Society had ceased to function, both as an effective military force through attrition and a coherent cultural entity through ruinous pogroms. After this point; the war was reduced to an ever-tightening spiral of ideologically-driven xenophobic and Hobbesian war of all, against all.
This point is generally accepted today as having occurred sometime in early 3071. But Society holdouts were still being encountered twenty years later as well. And with the earliest clashes between non-Society-controlled or 'manipulated forces over issues of ideological purity having occurred the same day as the issue was first formally brought to the Grand Council by the Khans of the Steel Vipers, this marks any such distinction between the two conflicts as specious at best. This goes a long way to explaining why the two major internecine Clan conflicts of the era are often mentioned together or dealt with as a single topic.
Once one additionally factors in the upheaval of the Word of Blake Jihad, occurring concurrently for most of the conflicts mentioned, then one is tempted to simply throw up one's hands; proclaim that nothing is made, human conflict is a watch without a watchmaker and any such attempts at making sense of it are the errands of fools. Such moments of intellectual abandon however, are why we study the more logical, scientific discipline of Anthropology.
The above period of questioning and introspection led directly into the upheaval of the following wars, concurrent with other conflicts unfolding in the Inner Sphere and elsewhere at the same time. Returning to the subject at hand brings us to the controversial and oft over-romanticised, so-called "Household"-movement.
Many latter-day sources give unwarranted weight to the matter of the phenomena of the complex and oft-misunderstood "Household" movement. While it must be acknowledged that during the 70s and 80s certain Clans experienced a notable counter-cultural upsurge in antisocial rebellion, the form this took was rarely exemplified in the much-romanticized Warrior's Household or it's more common Scientist derivative.
This took the form of senior members of the Clan Caste/Social strata (Warriors most-famously, but the practice was even more common among scientists and Merchants) increasingly attracted to a "self-absorbed, un-Clan-like fantasy" whereby they maintained a more traditional family or household setting in the Spheroid or pre-Clan sense; complete with spouses and even freeborn or "Kindled" trueborn children. The argument being that a Warrior's true path should be theirs and theirs alone to forge and that as sole architects of their destiny; so long as the needs of the Clan were served, then a degree of latitude ought to be permissible.
For quite some time before Khan Vlad Ward of the Wolves appeared to whisk Katrina Steiner-Davion away from her vengeful brother Victor, it had been something of an open secret that many Trueborn members of the Scientist and Merchant Castes maintained family relationships and even secret marriages, which; while not expressly against Clan law, were considered distasteful enough that they were not spoken of openly. Marriage was not unknown in the Warrior Caste, but it was looked upon with open contempt and seen as a "Career-Limiting Decision" at best. Certainly; it was not an arrangement which was likely to shown much, if any respect as far as the Touman and postings were concerned.
Two noted exceptions were the Ghost Bears; whose founders had been a married couple and the Cloud Cobras, within whose cloisters, marriages were not only performed regularly for all castes, but honoured and even respected to the greatest degree possible in Touman assignments.
Conditions in other Clans varied from a "Don't ask, Don't Tell" policy, to relegation to lower-readiness units, such as Solahma and Garrison Clusters, to the extreme of the Jade Falcon practice of exiling married warriors to the Dark Caste and forced sterilization of their dwindling pool of “tame” scientists.
What was much more common and a much more nebulous issue were those Warriors who maintained unconventional interpersonal and semi-professional relationships skirting the boundaries of Clan Law. These warriors would in-turn defend their assumed prerogatives in the Circle of Equals as required. These were known as "Warrior Households" long before there was any such movement, per say and dated back to at least the late 2800s.
Warrior Households were a troubling open secret within the Clans and existed as the inseparable flaw in the Founder’s teachings; inherently, the way of the Clans permitted a warrior the right to do as they pleased, provided they possessed the skill and savvy to triumph in combat over those who would gainsay them. Once one accepted the fundamentals of Kerensky’s vision, it became difficult to argue conclusively that a warrior could *not* simply fight for what they saw as their right. And if you tried; you might earn yourself a circle of equals in the bargain.
Within a "Household", a given Warrior sat at the top of a self-proclaimed hierarchy which could include a romantic partner or partner(s), as well as one or more preferred Technicians, Warrior subordinates, Labourer-Caste servants and retainers and sometimes more esoteric attachments like pets or more significant items of property, all things normally considered unusual or even un-clan-like.
All of this could be expected to be maintained through a varied mixture of mutual respect, open denial (extended to self-delusion that the household did not exist), icy détente with fellow Warriors, networks of understanding with superiors and peers, willful ignorance and of course; adequate fighting skill to claim and maintain such arrangements as demonstrated through the circle of equals.
Romantic partners, married or not might be peers in the Warrior Caste or from subordinate Castes. This was a position (no pun intended), within the Household, which often overlapped with others, particularly Techs and Subordinates within a given Toumanic organization. While often considered decadent, overly sentimental or even un-clan-like, this was the aspect of the Household which was hardest to openly oppose. In Clan society; a Warrior could couple with whom they chose. If they preferred one partner over all others, who else's business was that? If there were quarrels between romantically-involved Warriors, it could be worked out in the Circle of Equals. Such disagreements between Warriors and lower castemen were ignored, deliberately overlooked or settled informally, but in most cases boiled down to the Warrior getting their way and the lower casteman be damned.
Part of the impetus for the Household-Movement was also a grudging acknowledgement that it could and often did serve as a counterweight to various socio-sexual issues, which had been growing in severity within Clan Society for the last 200 years and which were increasingly leading to discipline issues with Warriors and insubordination between the Castes. While Households did not eliminate sexual practices considered "deviant" by Clan society and Law, they did serve to codify them when they were present and provided an attractive alternative outlet for human urges not yet fully tamed by the Scientists or Clan Culture.
While this aspect of the Household could make the sexual power disparity between castes that much worse by putting it behind closed doors, it also offered a seemingly healthier alternative which made more violent and predatory practices, simply unnecessary.
Pregnancy is always possible in any sexual relationship, but is more likely to result from a situation with regular sexual contact between common partners. Thus, within a household, children were more likely to result, but also a "situation" easier to "take care of" one way or the other than in the very public light of normal Clan society. This even extended to the children of Trueborn parents. The structure of a Household, so long as it lasted also made it less difficult for Clansmen who wished to keep their children close, or at least to maintain contact with them to do this as well, if they so chose.
For a Warrior to have a proprietary attitude towards those individuals who serviced their equipment and upon whose efforts, their lives and legacies depended was such a common cultural artefact as to be almost not worth mentioning within the Clans by the turn of the millennium. A redacted Star Adder unit record of Trials of Grievance fought during the year 3055, records a stunning 123 such trials over lower castemen for a Galaxy of four Clusters. It must be noted this was considered a remarkably amiable and cooperative record for a unit of this size. Of those; 76 were over allocation and assignment of Technician-Caste staff. This example is but one of many.
Although lower castemen were officially looked at as a lower form of life; a tool to be used and discarded, Warriors often realized that not all of them were created equal, nor were they endlessly available on issue from the Touman's stores. Over-time, no-matter their relationship, working and otherwise; a Warrior with two braincells to rub together and a Tech good enough to avoid demotion to the Labour Caste would learn to communicate, learn how the other thought and functioned, or failed to function. To a credible Warrior; a skilled and effective Technician, with whom they could communicate; who *knew what they wanted and what they meant*, who could, as they say; “read their mind”, was not something to be casually discarded or allowed to slip away. Particularly when considering OmniPod-swaps between battles.
Certainly; it was the Star Colonel's prerogative to reassign their personnel as they saw fit, especially lower-castemen and this was especially common when part of a unit had suffered extensive battle damage and was in unusual need of Technician work-hours to get back into operation. But that didn't mean that a Warrior had to simply lamely accept a permanent reassignment. It certainly did not suggest that such a warrior tolerated abuse or "poaching" of "Their" Tech(s) by another Warrior or unit without reply. And it did not prevent trials of grievance even so.
Households did not officially regularize or codify these feelings and arrangements, but they did add an additional level of emotional attachment to the issue, which in turn added another layer of resistance to over-come for what was officially seen as matters of little consequence. While an individual Warrior who expected to live long enough to pass on their genes had to see the difference between one Tech and the next; by administrative practice and cultural demand; a senior officer could recognize no such significance to what were in effect "assets" under their control. Any such officer would need to carefully balance which figurative and literal battles they chose to fight and chose to overlook in order to remain alive, fit and in command. Thus, these understandings were strengthened and acquired customary legitimacy over-time.
Household relationships often formed based on or strengthened by the bonds of shared hardship and camaraderie found in the peculiarly sexualized Clan military structure. Thus, it was not uncommon at all for a Household to include one's subordinates, whether they shared a sexual relationship or not. This began to produce alternative bonds of loyalty in a pseudo-feudal fashion and was regularly remarked on in reports by the mid 3050s.
If the presence of customarily preferred individuals to maintain and repair the tools of war had been too subtle an indication, here the Household began to take on a martial imposition which was increasingly difficult to ignore.
While rarely regularized before the 3080s, it was not uncommon at all in the Clans for a pair of Warriors to demand to serve together, or for a mentor and mentee to wish to continue such a relationship. A Clan Warrior being promoted might often wish to bring along a trusted comrade or two to their new position. In some cases, whole Stars might come along as ready-made cronies through such demands, arrangements or petty trials. That these relationships might also contain romantic overtones would hardly be remarked on in Clan Society and it was only with the beginning of the movement as a force for change that it even came to be seen as a cachet of the Household concept.
At this point, it was only natural, especially for Senior Officers so inclined to retain various others in their household as servants, flunkies or functional staff. For example; Elementals in such positions usually sought out trusted and well-regarded MedTechs and Scientists in order to maintain themselves in effective physical condition for as long as possible.
Even before the 3060s, it was not unknown for "Householding" customs to be observed in the form of a Warrior's Last Will and Testament. Such documents would commonly see various personal items; particularly military equipment passed on from one Warrior to the next, but it was not unknown for a Will to include a disposition for certain members of a household; particularly Techs and servants. On rare occasion, it might even include instructions for a trusted and like-minded comrade to see to the children or former spouse of the departed.
Occasionally; one Warrior might even "Inherit" or have Willed to them a subordinate Caste romantic partner of the deceased and their accustomed sexual rights to them, as either a final gift to one or the other, a passing along of a person deemed treasured property or as a means to see a valued companion's welfare was looked after once they were gone.
Once the practice became normalized in the mid 3070s, it was even possible for one Warrior to declare, fight and win a Trial of Possession for the Household, entire of another Warrior. In this sense; the "Household" might also include particular items of major military equipment; typically, 'Mechs, Fighters or Battle Armour. This particular practice would be much-less common with crewed-equipment such as a combat vehicle (except, see below), though it might well include a crewed-dropship in some select cases.
Freeborn Warriors looked at Trueborn households with incredulity and an often-righteous anger; knowing that here was a closed structure, existing in contravention of the letter of Clan Law and it was being regularly overlooked in many cases. Often, they thought correctly; because the perpetuators were Trueborn Clan Warriors.
It was hard to argue the point: while Freebirths were openly viewed as second-class citizens, even in more liberal Clans, it was impossible to deny an allegation that this was a transgression which would *never* be tolerated among their kind. Rather, the Trueborn and even pragmatic Freeborn senior officers looking to retain their positions and the loyalty of the mass of their subordinates would close-ranks and deny the practice even existed.
A freeborn pursuing anything like a "Household" had no legitimate or lawful recourse to defend their actions. Since the separation of Clan Society into Trueborn and Freeborn, it had been forbidden for Freebirths to engage in what amounted to a barbaric parallel to the Clan eugenics program, one that would undermine it, devoid of the inherent virtue of the system of the Bloodhouses. A de-facto family-structure, especially one ostensibly formed along the lines of merit and mutual esteem would do just that.
For a Freeborn to become a Warrior meant forsaking the practices of romantic love, marriage and family. Even in the aforementioned Ghost Bears and Cloud Cobras, recognized marriages were not performed by any body or authority which the Clan as a whole or the Clans Society felt legally bound to respect.
Thus, it was maddening to know their Trueborn social superiors were engaging in practices which were specifically denied to themselves. It was further infuriating to observe the cases where Trueborn-led Households incorporated Freeborn romantic/sexual partners. Particularly when these relationships proved fruitful.
As difficult as it was to argue against, it was even more difficult to defend the “Householding” practice from a philosophical stand-point. To those denied access to such taboo practices, it was thus also a case of corruption of the way of life, they had sacrificed so much to uphold and take part in.
During this time, almost no Freebirth would have or even could have engaged in the concept of the "Platonic" or "Pure" household with any degree of credulity, either.